Expert report review

Anticipation in the opposing invalidity report: does one reference really disclose every element as claimed?

A claim is anticipated only if a single prior art reference discloses every limitation, expressly or inherently, arranged as the claim arranges it. The Federal Circuit requires anticipation testimony to identify each claim element, state the witness's reading of it and explain in detail where the reference discloses it. A review of the opposing invalidity report checks those three things for every element, and the dates, the corroboration and the dependent claims.

Hands line one closed reference volume against a row of blank claim cards, only that single book on the desk.

What does anticipation require?

One prior art reference that discloses each and every limitation of the claim, expressly or inherently, before the effective filing date. If any limitation is missing from that reference, the claim is not anticipated by it.

Section 102(a)(1) of the Patent Act denies a patent if "the claimed invention was patented, described in a printed publication, or in public use, on sale, or otherwise available to the public before the effective filing date of the claimed invention." Section 102(a)(2) adds patents and published applications that name another inventor and were "effectively filed before the effective filing date of the claimed invention."

In Kapusta v. Gale Corp., 457 F. Supp. 2d 1051 (E.D. Cal. 2006), Senior District Judge Karlton restated the rule: a claim is anticipated when "each and every limitation is found either expressly or inherently in a single prior art reference," and a reference "must disclose 'each and every limitation' in order to anticipate a claim."

That rule separates anticipation from obviousness. An obviousness opinion may combine references and explain why a skilled person would have joined them. An anticipation opinion may not: it stands or falls with one reference. When the opposing report needs a second document to supply a missing element, the reviewer marks the opinion as obviousness presented under the wrong heading.

Must the elements appear in the reference arranged as in the claim?

Yes. In Net MoneyIN v. VeriSign (2008) the Federal Circuit held that the reference must disclose the limitations arranged or combined in the same way as the claim, and reversed a finding built by combining two protocols in one document.

Net MoneyIN, Inc. v. VeriSign, Inc. was decided on October 20, 2008, with Judge Linn writing for a panel of Judges Linn, Clevenger and Moore. The district court had granted summary judgment that claim 23 of the '737 patent was anticipated by the iKP reference, which described two payment protocols.

The Federal Circuit reversed. An anticipating reference must show the limitations "arranged or combined in the same way as recited in the claim." The court wrote that "it is not enough that the prior art reference discloses part of the claimed invention, which an ordinary artisan might supplement to make the whole," and that anticipation cannot rest on "picking, choosing, and combining various disclosures."

Neither protocol in the iKP reference disclosed all five links of the claim arranged as claimed, and the district court had erred by combining parts of the separate protocols. The court concluded: "we reverse the district court's grant of summary judgment of invalidity."

A reviewer therefore checks where each element comes from inside the reference. A report that cites page 3 for one element and page 12 for the next, where pages 3 and 12 describe different embodiments, presents a patchwork that Net MoneyIN rejected, even though every element appears somewhere in the same document.

What must expert testimony on anticipation contain?

Under Schumer v. Laboratory Computer Systems (2002), testimony from a person skilled in the art that identifies each claim element, states the witness's interpretation of it and explains in detail how the reference discloses it.

Schumer v. Laboratory Computer Systems, Inc., 308 F.3d 1304 (Fed. Cir. 2002), was written by Judge Dyk for a panel of Judges Newman, Michel and Dyk. The court wrote: "Typically, testimony concerning anticipation must be testimony from one skilled in the art and must identify each claim element, state the witnesses' interpretation of the claim element, and explain in detail how each claim element is disclosed in the prior art reference."

Each of the three requirements matches a part of a report. Identifying each claim element means the report breaks the claim into its limitations, one by one, as construed by the court. Stating the interpretation means the report says what the expert understands each limitation to require, so that the reader can check it against the claim construction order. Explaining in detail means a citation to the page, column, line or figure of the reference and an explanation of why that passage meets the limitation as interpreted.

The requirement of a witness skilled in the art connects anticipation to qualification. In Sundance, Inc. v. DeMonte Fabricating Ltd. (Fed. Cir. 2008), the court held it "an abuse of discretion to permit a witness to testify as an expert on the issues of noninfringement or invalidity unless that witness is qualified as an expert in the pertinent art."

What happens to general or conclusory anticipation testimony?

It does not prove invalidity. In Schumer the court said it is not the task of the courts to interpret confusing or general testimony and that testimony is insufficient if it is merely conclusory.

In Schumer the party challenging the patent relied on declarations of Robert Dezmelyk, identified as the programmer of the Seiko driver said to anticipate the claims and as the challenger's current president. The court found that he "merely sets forth his understanding of the operation and steps performed by the Seiko driver" without clearly describing the operative steps of claim 13 and how the driver performs them.

The court wrote: "It is not our task, nor is it the task of the district court, to attempt to interpret confusing or general testimony to determine whether a case of invalidity has been made out." It added: "The testimony is insufficient if it is merely conclusory."

The Federal Circuit held that the challenger had not proved invalidity of claim 13 by clear and convincing evidence on summary judgment, and it vacated and remanded. For a reviewer, the test is whether a reader who knows the claim and the reference, but not the expert, can follow each step of the opinion. If the report describes the reference in its own terms and then asserts that the claim is met, the step between the two is missing.

Does anticipation of the independent claim decide the dependent claims?

No. Each dependent claim adds limitations that the reference must also disclose. In Schumer the Federal Circuit held that the district court erred by not separately analyzing dependent claim 14.

A dependent claim includes every limitation of the claim it depends on plus its own. A reference that anticipates the independent claim anticipates a dependent claim only if it also discloses the added limitation, arranged as claimed.

Schumer applied that rule: besides vacating the ruling on claim 13, the court held that the district court erred by not analyzing claim 14 separately. A report that treats a group of dependent claims in one paragraph, saying that the reference discloses them "as well," leaves the same gap.

The review lists each dependent claim the report addresses and the place in the reference cited for its added limitation. Claims with no specific citation are the first candidates for a motion or for cross-examination.

How does the reviewer check that the reference is prior art at all?

By its date against the effective filing date of the claim. Section 102(a) counts disclosures before that date and patents or published applications of other inventors effectively filed before it, subject to the exceptions in 102(b).

The report has to establish two dates: the effective filing date of the challenged claim and the date on which the reference became prior art. Under 102(a)(1), the disclosure must have been patented, published, in public use, on sale or otherwise available to the public before the effective filing date. Under 102(a)(2), a patent or published application counts if it names another inventor and was effectively filed before that date; section 102(d) governs when such documents are effective as prior art.

Section 102(b)(1)(A) excludes certain disclosures made 1 year or less before the effective filing date, including a disclosure "made by the inventor or joint inventor or by another who obtained the subject matter disclosed directly or indirectly from the inventor or a joint inventor." A reference dated within that year needs a check of who made the disclosure.

Each of these questions is a separate line in the review: the date the report gives for the reference, the source of that date, the effective filing date it assumes for each claim, and whether a 102(b) exception applies.

Does testimony about an earlier device need corroboration?

Yes. When anticipation rests on a witness's account of a prior device or prior invention, the Federal Circuit has required corroboration, and testimony of an interested witness carries that requirement in particular.

In Schumer the court noted that Mr. Dezmelyk was an interested party and that his testimony about prior invention needed corroboration. In Rosco, Inc. v. Mirror Lite Co., No. 03-1562 (Fed. Cir. Jan. 19, 2005), a nonprecedential decision by Judge Dyk, the court wrote: "Testimonial evidence of invalidity must be corroborated." It found that the corroborating evidence relied on by the district court was insufficient and reversed the ruling that the claims were invalid over the alleged anticipating mirror.

For a review, the question is what besides the witness's memory supports the existence, date and design of the prior device: drawings, invoices, catalogs, the device itself. A report that describes a device from the recollection of its maker, with no dated document, is open to the corroboration objection.

What standard of proof does the review hold the opposing expert to?

Clear and convincing evidence. In Microsoft v. i4i (2011) the Supreme Court held that section 282 requires an invalidity defense to be proved by that standard, including anticipation by prior art the PTO never considered.

On June 9, 2011, Justice Sotomayor stated the question for the Court as "whether §282 requires an invalidity defense to be proved by clear and convincing evidence" and answered: "We hold that it does." The Court allowed an instruction that "the jury may be instructed to consider that it has heard evidence that the PTO had no opportunity to evaluate before granting the patent," but did not lower the standard.

The standard explains why Schumer and Net MoneyIN ended as they did. A report that leaves an element unexplained or assembles a claim from separate embodiments cannot carry the challenger to clear and convincing evidence, and the court can rule on that gap on summary judgment or after the verdict.

Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence adds the admissibility side: since the 2023 amendment the proponent must show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony rests on sufficient facts or data and applies reliable methods reliably to the case. An element with no citation to the reference fails the first of those conditions for that element.

What does a review of the opposing anticipation opinion check?

For each claim and element: one reference, a citation to its passage, the expert's interpretation set against the claim construction, the arrangement, the date, corroboration for devices, and a separate analysis for each dependent claim.

The review is a table built over the opposing report. For each asserted claim it lists the limitations, the page of the report addressing each one, the passage of the reference the expert cites, and whether the expert stated an interpretation of the limitation. It then marks each row: disclosed expressly, said to be inherent, cited from another embodiment or another document, or not addressed.

Inherency gets its own note. Kapusta restated that the limitation may be found "either expressly or inherently," and an expert who relies on inherency must explain why the reference necessarily includes the missing feature. A statement that the feature would be there "in practice" is the general testimony Schumer rejected.

The review also states what the rebuttal can answer. A rebuttal report on the same subject is due within 30 days after the other side's disclosure under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii), unless the court sets another schedule, so the review is timed to leave the rebuttal expert time to write.

What does IAE do when the other side argues that a reference anticipates the patent?

An IAE reviewer checks the opposing invalidity report element by element against the claim language and the reference and prepares the points for the rebuttal and the deposition, in up to 5 business days.

The patent report review page describes the review as a check of whether every opinion is tied to the claim language and the evidence: each element mapped, the court's claim construction applied, sufficient facts or data under Rule 702(b). Among the listed problems is an element marked as met with no document, code or test cited, and a theory that rests on a reference or combination never disclosed.

The reviewer needs the opposing report with its exhibits, the references it relies on, the claim construction order and both sides' invalidity contentions. Before work starts IAE confirms the patent, the asserted claims and the questions for the reviewer. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day; within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the reviewer from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every reviewer is a member of the public IAE registry, verifiable by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. A review is material that the court weighs with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member