Expert report review
Claim construction expert declarations: what may the opposing expert say about claim terms, and how is it answered?
The judge decides what a patent claim means, but the parties support their proposed constructions with expert declarations on how a person of ordinary skill reads the terms. Those declarations are disclosed on a fixed schedule, the experts can be deposed on them, and the Federal Circuit has warned that experts opining on claim construction before a jury risk confusing it. A review of the opposing declaration tests each proposed meaning against the claim, the specification and the prosecution history.

Who decides what a patent claim means?
The court. In InTouch v. VGo (2014) the Federal Circuit called claim construction a question of law, and in Sundance (2008) it held that testimony to the jury on claim construction would be improper.
In InTouch Technologies, Inc. v. VGo Communications, Inc., decided on May 9, 2014, the Federal Circuit wrote: "Claim construction is a question of law reviewed de novo." The court then construed the disputed terms itself and compared its constructions with those of the trial court.
In Sundance, Inc. v. DeMonte Fabricating Ltd., decided on December 24, 2008, the court explained why the jury does not hear experts argue about claim meaning. Quoting its earlier decision in CytoLogix, it wrote that "[t]he risk of confusing the jury is high when experts opine on claim construction," and it described "allowing a witness to testify before the jury on claim construction" as improper.
Expert evidence on claim meaning therefore goes to the judge, usually at the Markman stage, through declarations and, if the court permits, live testimony at the claim construction hearing. At trial, the experts apply the court's construction to the product or the prior art.
What evidence does the court use to construe a claim?
The claim language first, read with the ordinary and customary meaning a person of ordinary skill would give it, then the specification and the prosecution history. Expert testimony is extrinsic evidence offered alongside that record.
InTouch restated the framework of Phillips v. AWH Corp.: "To determine the scope and meaning of a claim, we examine the claim language," and "a claim term is given the ordinary and customary meaning as understood by a person of ordinary skill in the art." The specification is "the single best guide to the meaning of a disputed term," and "[a] court should also consider the patent's prosecution history, if it is in evidence." The prosecution history "consists of the complete record of the proceedings before the PTO."
Sundance put the same point in one sentence, citing Phillips: "Patent claims are construed from the perspective of one of ordinary skill in the art." That perspective is the reason expert declarations exist at this stage. The expert explains how a skilled person in the field at the relevant time would have read a term, what the technical vocabulary meant, and how the specification uses it.
The New Jersey Local Patent Rules label expert testimony for what it is. Rule 4.2(b) requires each party to identify its intrinsic evidence and to designate supporting extrinsic evidence, including "testimony of all witnesses including expert witnesses." The intrinsic record is the patent and its file history; the expert's declaration is offered beside it, not in place of it.
When does an expert declaration enter the claim construction schedule?
In New Jersey, the expert is identified when preliminary constructions are exchanged, summarized in the joint statement, and the declarations are filed with the opening Markman briefs, 45 days after that statement.
Under Rule 4.1 of the Local Patent Rules of the District of New Jersey, each party serves "a list of claim terms which that party contends should be construed by the Court," generally 14 days after service of the responses to invalidity contentions. Within 21 days after that exchange, Rule 4.2(a) requires the parties to "simultaneously exchange preliminary proposed constructions of each term identified."
At the same time, under Rule 4.2(b), a party relying on a witness gives "a description of the substance of that witness' proposed testimony." Within 14 days after the preliminary constructions, Rule 4.2(c) requires each party to identify the evidence it will use to oppose the other side's constructions.
The Joint Claim Construction and Prehearing Statement follows 30 days after the exchange of preliminary constructions (Rule 4.3). Opening Markman briefs, with supporting evidence including "experts' certifications or declarations," are due not later than 45 days after the joint statement (Rule 4.5(a)). Responding briefs, with "any responding experts' certifications or declarations," are due not later than 60 days after the opening submissions. For design patents, Rule 4.5(d) provides that subsections (a), (b) and (c) of Rule 4.5 do not apply and sets its own schedule.
What must be disclosed about the expert before the hearing?
The substance of the proposed testimony when preliminary constructions are exchanged, and in the joint statement whether any party will call witnesses, with a summary of each expert opinion on claim construction. Undisclosed evidence is excluded.
Rule 4.3 lists the contents of the joint statement, among them "The construction of those terms on which the parties agree," the anticipated length of the hearing and, under Rule 4.3(e), "Whether any party proposes to call one or more witnesses at the Claim Construction Hearing." For each expert, the statement gives a summary of the testimony, including "each opinion to be offered related to claim construction."
The rule closes the record: "Any evidence that is not identified under L. Pat. R. 4.2(a) through 4.2(c) inclusive shall not be included" in the joint statement. A declaration that introduces a new meaning or new evidence at the briefing stage is exposed to that sentence.
For the reviewer, the disclosures are the first checklist. The opposing declaration is compared with the summary given under Rule 4.3 and with the evidence identified under Rule 4.2. An opinion that was never summarized, or that rests on a dictionary or article never identified, is the first point of the response.
Can the opposing expert be deposed on a claim construction declaration?
Yes. Under New Jersey Rule 4.5(b), unless the court orders otherwise, expert discovery on claim construction must be concluded within 30 days after the opening Markman submissions are filed.
Rule 4.4 requires the parties to "complete all discovery relating to claim construction" within 30 days after the joint statement is served and filed, but that rule covers witnesses other than experts. Expert witnesses are handled by Rule 4.5(b): their discovery ends 30 days after the opening Markman submissions unless the court orders otherwise.
The window is short. The opening declarations arrive with the opening briefs, the deposition must be taken within 30 days, and the responding declaration and brief are due within 60 days after the opening submissions. A review of the opposing declaration is most useful at the start of that window, because it gives counsel the deposition questions and gives the responding expert the points to answer.
The usual questions follow the Phillips order. Where in the claim does the proposed meaning come from? Which passages of the specification support it, and which contradict it? What did the applicant say about the term during prosecution? On what basis does the expert define the person of ordinary skill, and does the expert's own background fit that definition?
What does a review of the opposing claim construction declaration check?
Whether each proposed meaning is tied to the claim language, the specification and the prosecution history, whether the declarant reads terms as a person of ordinary skill, and whether the declaration offers technical meaning or legal conclusions.
The first check is the source of each meaning. A declaration that defines a term by a general dictionary or by the declarant's experience, without addressing how the specification uses the term, inverts the order InTouch described, where the specification is "the single best guide to the meaning of a disputed term."
The second check is the skilled person. Sundance requires claims to be construed "from the perspective of one of ordinary skill in the art." The reviewer compares the declarant's definition of that person with the one the other side proposes and with the field of the patent, and notes where the proposed meaning depends on a higher or lower level of skill.
The third check is the line between technical meaning and law. Sundance criticized patent lawyers who give "their opinion regarding the proper interpretation of a claim as a matter of law." A declaration that argues claim differentiation, canons of construction or the effect of prosecution disclaimer is making legal arguments that belong in the brief, and the response can say so.
The fourth check is the general standard. Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence requires the proponent to show that it is more likely than not that the testimony rests on sufficient facts or data and reliable methods reliably applied. A claim construction declaration that cites no passage of the patent for its key opinion is weak on Rule 702(b).
Can a patent lawyer give testimony about what claim terms mean?
Not as a substitute for the court. In Sundance the Federal Circuit criticized patent lawyers who interpret claims as a matter of law and rejected the claim that it had let patent law experts explain technical terms.
In Sundance, DeMonte called Mr. Bliss, a patent attorney with no experience in the field of tarps or covers. The court held that it is "an abuse of discretion to permit a witness to testify as an expert on the issues of noninfringement or invalidity unless that witness is qualified as an expert in the pertinent art."
On claim meaning, the court quoted Endress + Hauser in criticizing patent lawyers who give "their opinion regarding the proper interpretation of a claim as a matter of law." DeMonte relied on Snellman for the proposition "that we previously allowed patent law experts to testify on the meaning of technical terms in claims." The court found that Snellman did not analyze that issue.
For the review, the qualification of the declarant matters as much at claim construction as at trial. A declarant without training or experience in the pertinent art can describe the prosecution history, but the opinion about how a person of ordinary skill reads a technical term comes from someone who is, or has trained and worked with, such a person.
What happens when trial testimony departs from the court's construction?
The court's construction governs. In InTouch the patent owner's expert read the call back limitation as met by a message to all users; the Federal Circuit construed it as a message to specific previously denied users.
In InTouch, the Federal Circuit construed two terms of InTouch's robot patents. It held that "arbitrator" and "arbitrating" "require a determination of which user among multiple users has exclusive control of the robot," and that the "call back mechanism" "requires a device that sends a message to a specific user or users who previously were denied access to a particular mobile robot." It noted that its construction "differs slightly from the trial court's construction" but "does not do so in a way that materially impacts the infringement verdicts."
InTouch's expert, Dr. Hackwood, took the position that VGo's status indicator met the call back limitation by sending a message to all users. Under the court's construction, the message had to go to a specific user or users who previously were denied access, and the Federal Circuit affirmed the verdict that VGo did not infringe the asserted patents. On the doctrine of equivalents, where Dr. Hackwood had testified that VGo's arbitration system differed insubstantially from the claimed arbitrator, the court wrote: "While this testimony was proffered, the jury was free to reject it."
The point for a review is the link between the construction stage and the expert reports that follow. An infringement or invalidity report that reads a construed term more broadly or more narrowly than the order says, or that never states which construction it applies, becomes the subject of a motion and of cross-examination. The review lists each such term with the page of the report and the words of the order.
What does the expert's report have to say about the construction it applies?
Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires every opinion with its basis and reasons and the facts or data considered. When counsel supplies the construction as an assumption, the communication is discoverable under Rule 26(b)(4)(C).
Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires "a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them" and "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them." For a technical report after a Markman order, the basis includes the construction the expert applied to each disputed term.
Communications between counsel and the expert are protected, except to the extent they "identify facts or data that the party's attorney provided and that the expert considered" or "identify assumptions that the party's attorney provided and that the expert relied on" (Rule 26(b)(4)(C)). A construction supplied by counsel before the court rules is such an assumption, and the deposition will ask about it.
A rebuttal report on the same subject is due within 30 days after the other side's disclosure under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii), unless a stipulation or court order sets another schedule. In New Jersey the local patent rules and the scheduling order set those dates, and the reviewer works to them.
What does IAE do when the other side files an expert declaration on claim construction?
An IAE reviewer checks the opposing technical expert's declaration or report against the claim language and the evidence and prepares the points for the response and the deposition, in up to 5 business days.
The patent report review page describes the review as a check of whether every opinion is tied to the claim language and the evidence: each element mapped, the court's claim construction applied, sufficient facts or data under Rule 702(b). One of the listed problems is an expert who reads a term with a meaning the court rejected or never says which construction he used.
The reviewer needs the opposing declaration or report with its exhibits, the facts or data it lists as considered, the claim construction order or the joint claim construction statement, and both sides' contentions. Before work starts IAE confirms the patent, the asserted claims and the questions for the reviewer. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day; within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the reviewer from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every reviewer is a member of the public IAE registry, verifiable by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. A review is material that the court weighs with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- InTouch Technologies, Inc. v. VGo Communications, Inc., No. 13-1201 (Fed. Cir. May 9, 2014) (Justia)
- Sundance, Inc. v. DeMonte Fabricating Ltd., Nos. 2008-1068, -1115 (Fed. Cir. Dec. 24, 2008), slip opinion
- Local Patent Rules, United States District Court for the District of New Jersey
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, with committee notes (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Enablement and written description in the opposing invalidity report: what does a reviewer check after Amgen v. Sanofi?
An invalidity report under 35 U.S.C. 112 says that the patent's specification does not describe the invention or does not teach a skilled person
Is the opposing patent expert a person of ordinary skill in the art, and what follows if not?
Claim construction, obviousness and infringement are all judged through the eyes of a person having ordinary skill in the art. In Kyocera Senco
Amended, reissued or published claims: which version must the opposing expert compare with the product?
An infringement comparison is only as good as the claim it uses. Claims change after filing: they are published in an application, allowedExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

