Business plans

The E-2 marginal enterprise test: what must the five-year business plan show?

Under 8 CFR 214.2(e)(15), an E-2 enterprise may not be marginal. It must have the present or future capacity to generate more than enough income to provide a minimal living for the treaty investor and his or her family, or to make a significant economic contribution. Projected income-generating capacity should generally be realizable within 5 years from the start of normal business activity, and the State Department checklist asks a new business for projections supported by a business plan.

A small-cafe owner works at the counter with a laptop and a folder, a barista blurred behind.

What is a marginal enterprise under the E-2 rules?

An enterprise without the present or future capacity to generate more than enough income for a minimal living for the investor and family. An enterprise that lacks that capacity but can make a significant economic contribution is not marginal.

The E-2 classification comes from section 101(a)(15)(E)(ii) of the Immigration and Nationality Act. Under 8 CFR 214.2(e)(2)(i), a treaty investor must have invested, or be actively in the process of investing, "a substantial amount of capital in a bona fide enterprise in the United States, as distinct from a relatively small amount of capital in a marginal enterprise solely for the purpose of earning a living." The investor must also seek entry solely to develop and direct the enterprise and must intend to depart when E-2 status ends.

Paragraph (e)(15) defines the term: "For purposes of this section, an enterprise may not be marginal. A marginal enterprise is an enterprise that does not have the present or future capacity to generate more than enough income to provide a minimal living for the treaty investor and his or her family." The next sentence adds a second way to meet the test: "An enterprise that does not have the capacity to generate such income, but that has a present or future capacity to make a significant economic contribution is not a marginal enterprise."

Consular officers apply the same test under 9 FAM 402.9-6(E), titled "Enterprise Must Be More Than Marginal," which repeats both routes and the five-year period. Paragraph (e)(13) of the regulation adds a separate condition: the enterprise must be "a real, active, and operating commercial or entrepreneurial undertaking which produces services or goods for profit."

Where does the five-year period come from, and when does it start?

From the last sentence of 8 CFR 214.2(e)(15): projected future income-generating capacity should generally be realizable within 5 years from the date the investor commences the normal business activity of the enterprise.

The definition was adopted by the Immigration and Naturalization Service (INS) in a final rule published at 62 Fed. Reg. 48138 on September 12, 1997, and effective November 12, 1997. On page 48143, in the part on marginal enterprise, INS wrote that the burden is on the alien to prove the enterprise's capacity to become a viable commercial entity "by presenting a business plan showing that the business will provide more than a subsistence living for the investor, within 5 years from the onset date of normal business activities."

On the same page INS named the purpose of the marginality requirement: "to weed out commercial enterprises, regardless of size, which will fail to become viable, that is to grow and become profitable."

For an enterprise that has not opened yet, the plan names the date on which normal business activity is to begin and counts each of the five years from that date. A first year that starts on the filing date covers a different period from the one in the regulation.

The State Department uses the same period. In the suggested document checklist for applicants in 9 FAM 402.9-11(B), Part V on marginality lists for a new business "Financial projections for next 5 years, supported by a thorough business plan." The FAM sections are marked CT:VISA-2190 and dated February 17, 2026.

How much income is more than a minimal living?

Neither 8 CFR 214.2(e)(15) nor 9 FAM 402.9-6(E) gives a dollar amount. The yardstick is a minimal living for the investor and his or her family, so the plan compares the investor's projected income with that family's living costs.

The regulation ties the test to "the treaty investor and his or her family." The size of that family is part of the calculation, and the plan states it next to the income the investor will draw from the enterprise in each year.

In Matter of Lee, decided by the Regional Commissioner on February 26, 1975 (Interim Decision 2348), the applicant gave no figure for the income he expected from the enterprise. He was a Korean national who applied for a change to treaty investor status to buy a one-third interest in The Korean Garden Restaurant in San Francisco for not less than $30,000, with $8,500 deposited in escrow. On appeal counsel said that $10,000 was now in escrow and that the applicant was prepared to invest a total of $85,000. Counsel also put the value of the enterprise at about $64,000, while an earlier figure had been over $90,000.

The Regional Commissioner wrote that "in the absence of any indication of the income the applicant could reasonably expect to derive from the enterprise," the applicant had failed to establish that his investment was not a "small amount of capital" in a marginal enterprise solely for earning a living, as 22 CFR 41.41(a)(2) then required. The decision also found no evidence that he could make the further investment he planned. The appeal was dismissed.

Can an enterprise that pays the owner little still qualify?

Yes, if it has a present or future capacity to make a significant economic contribution. INS wrote that route into the final rule in 1997, after comments that the old marginality test inhibited small business investors.

On page 48143 of the 1997 rule, INS summarized comments that the marginality test "historically used by State and the Service" kept small business investors from investing in the United States. One commenter argued that whether the investor is primarily employed as a skilled or unskilled laborer "bears no relationship to the question of an enterprise's marginality."

INS agreed with that comment. In its words, "the final rule deletes references to skilled and unskilled labor, and provides that the capacity of an enterprise to make a significant economic contribution is an appropriate consideration in a marginality determination." Paragraph (e)(15) now says that an enterprise with that capacity "is not a marginal enterprise."

Neither the regulation nor 9 FAM 402.9-6(E) puts a number on a significant economic contribution.

Does an E-2 enterprise have to hire employees?

8 CFR 214.2(e) sets no minimum number of employees. Form DS-156E asks for staff this year and next year by category, and its instructions ask an enterprise that is not fully operational for projections of job creation.

Form DS-156E, the Nonimmigrant Treaty Trader/Investor Application, and the online Form DS-160 together constitute the application for an E-1 or E-2 visa. All first-time applicants seeking treaty trader or treaty investor status complete Parts I and II.

Item 14 asks for the type of personnel in the United States, with a staffing chart attached, in two columns, "This Year" and "Next Year." The rows are nationals of the treaty country on E, H and L visas, U.S. citizens and legal permanent residents, and third-country nationals. The instructions add: "If an enterprise is not yet fully operational, estimates and projections should be made concerning potential income, job creation, volume of sales, etc."

Item 9 asks for total assets, total liabilities, owner's equity and total annual operating income before and after taxes. Item 11 asks for the total start-up costs of a new business or the purchase price of an existing one, and item 12 for the investment made from abroad by type: cash, inventory, equipment, premises and other. A business plan filed with the form describes the same enterprise, and its start-up cost, investment by type and headcount use the figures entered in items 11, 12 and 14.

Which documents does the State Department list for marginality?

For a new business, 9 FAM 402.9-11(B) lists payroll records if any, financial projections for the next 5 years supported by a business plan, and business tax returns with proof of registration and ownership.

The checklist in 9 FAM 402.9-11(B) is a suggested list for applicants, and Part V of it covers marginality. For a new business it names a payroll register and records of salaries paid to employees, if any, with employee names, pay rates and copies of W-2 forms; financial projections for the next 5 years, supported by a thorough business plan; and business income and corporate tax returns, with proof of registration and ownership, audited financial statements and review engagements.

For an existing business the list is built on records: U.S. corporate tax returns, the latest audited financial statement or non-review statements, annual reports, a payroll register, W-2 and W-4 forms, and canceled checks for salaries paid or the corresponding payroll account.

9 FAM 402.9-6 has two more rules for an enterprise that is just starting. Under 9 FAM 402.9-6(C), for a new enterprise the officer "must be convinced that it will be a real and active commercial or entrepreneurial undertaking that will produce some service or commodity if the visa is issued." Under 9 FAM 402.9-6(D), the cost of a newly created business "is the actual cost needed to establish such a business to the point of being operational."

Is marginality checked again when E-2 status is extended?

Yes. INS wrote in 1997 that it must assess marginality "at every E adjudication, even after the initial 5-year period is completed." Admission and each extension of stay last up to 2 years.

The full sentence on page 48143 of the 1997 rule reads: "The Service must continue to assess whether the investor's enterprise is marginal at every E adjudication, even after the initial 5-year period is completed." Under 8 CFR 214.2(e)(19)(i), a treaty investor "may be admitted for an initial period of not more than 2 years," and under (e)(20) extensions of stay "may be granted in increments of not more than 2 years."

Under 9 FAM 402.9-6(D), once the officer determines that the applicant has invested a substantial sum, the applicant "generally does not need to be evaluated under this criterion again" unless ownership has changed, usually through a business acquisition. 9 FAM 402.9-6(E) contains no such sentence for marginality.

The checklist in 9 FAM 402.9-11(B) for an existing business has no item for financial projections.

What must the five-year projection contain?

The start date of normal business activity, the investment and start-up cost, the investor's income against the family's minimal living, payroll and headcount by year, and a source for each assumption.

The list uses the provisions cited above: the five-year period of 8 CFR 214.2(e)(15), the cost rule of 9 FAM 402.9-6(D), items 11, 12 and 14 of Form DS-156E and the checklist of 9 FAM 402.9-11(B).

  • State the date on which normal business activity begins and count the five years of 8 CFR 214.2(e)(15) from that date.
  • Show the investment by type, as in item 12 of Form DS-156E, and the total start-up cost of item 11, which 9 FAM 402.9-6(D) measures up to the point of being operational.
  • Show for each year the income the investor will draw from the enterprise and the size of the investor's family.
  • Show for each year the payroll and the number of employees in the three categories of item 14 of Form DS-156E.
  • If the case rests on a significant economic contribution, state that contribution in figures for each year.
  • Give a source for every assumption about prices, sales volumes and wages, and attach the documents that 9 FAM 402.9-11(B) lists for a new business.

How does IAE prepare a business plan for an E-2 petition?

The IAE Secretariat drafts the plan from the client's materials and open sources, and a registry expert in economics and management checks, corrects and signs it. The plan runs 25-35 pages with a five-year Excel model.

For E-2, the IAE business plans page names substantial investment and a non-marginal business as the facts the plan covers, under the requirements named by the client's attorney. The section for the purpose of the plan states those requirements as facts, without legal conclusions, and lists risks with responses.

The five-year financial model in Excel lists its assumptions and contains a profit and loss statement, monthly cash flow for 24 months, a balance sheet, the break-even point and the use of funds. Market size and growth come from government statistics and published reports cited with name, year and link, and sources older than three years are replaced or qualified. The team section gives positions, market salaries with a source, a hiring schedule by quarter and the owner's role. The plan contains no figures without a source and no data the client has not confirmed.

To start, send a one-page description of the business, the owner's CV, the stage (idea or operating business, with revenue over 12 months) and the purpose, which for a visa means the category and the attorney. Within one business day the Secretariat replies with the plan the purpose requires, the registry expert who will check and sign it, the cost and the timeline. The assessment is free. The invoice comes with a document list: registration, lease, contracts, investment statements.

The plan is ready in 7 business days from payment and the full set of documents, or 4 on the rush option. The expert checks it against 15 points, corrects it and signs the title page and the declaration of independence, and one round of edits on the attorney's or bank's comments is included. An existing plan can be reviewed against the same checklist in 3 business days. The decision on the visa is made by USCIS or the consulate.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Business plans for petitions, banks and investors

Send a description of the business

A page about the business, a CV, the stage and the purpose. The expert, the cost and the timeline within one business day, free of charge.

Plan assessment

Received

Reply in 1 business day

PurposeE‑2, L‑1A, EB‑5 and others
Timeline7 business days
SignatureRegistry expert