Business plans

E-2 visa franchise business plan: what does the franchise disclosure document give the plan, and what must the plan add?

A franchise buyer who applies for an E-2 visa meets the same tests as any other investor: a real and operating enterprise, a substantial investment at risk and a business that is not marginal within five years. The franchisor's disclosure document, required by the FTC Franchise Rule at 16 CFR part 436, supplies much of the plan's data. Item 7 gives the investment budget, Items 5 and 6 the fees, Items 19 and 20 the performance of other outlets.

Hands open a thick franchise binder beside a shop key and a rolled plan

Can a franchise qualify for an E-2 visa?

The E-2 rules set no separate requirements for franchises. A franchise has to meet the tests that apply to every enterprise: real and operating, a substantial investment at risk and income above a minimal living within five years.

Under 8 CFR 214.2(e)(2) a treaty investor "has invested or is actively in the process of investing a substantial amount of capital" in a bona fide enterprise in the United States and seeks entry "solely to develop and direct the enterprise." Paragraph (e)(13) defines a bona fide enterprise as "a real, active, and operating commercial or entrepreneurial undertaking."

The State Department's Foreign Affairs Manual, which consular officers apply, adds detail at 9 FAM 402.9-6(C). For a new enterprise the officer "must be convinced that it will be a real and active commercial or entrepreneurial undertaking that will produce some service or commodity if the visa is issued." It cannot be "a paper organization or an idle speculative investment," and it must be for profit. 9 FAM 402.9 contains no separate rules for franchises.

A franchise, as 16 CFR 436.1 defines it, has three elements: the franchisee operates a business associated with the franchisor's trademark, the franchisor exerts significant control or provides significant assistance, and the franchisee pays or commits to pay the franchisor or an affiliate as a condition of obtaining or starting the franchise. None of these elements answers the E-2 questions. A franchise unit is tested on its own investment, its own location and its own projected income.

What a franchise changes is the source of the numbers. An independent startup builds its budget and forecast from quotes and market data. A franchise buyer receives a disclosure document with a prescribed structure, and the plan can cite it item by item.

What is the franchise disclosure document, and when does the buyer receive it?

The Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD) is the disclosure the FTC Franchise Rule requires. The franchisor must furnish it at least 14 calendar days before the buyer signs a binding agreement or pays any money.

Under 16 CFR 436.2 the franchisor furnishes the disclosure document "at least 14 calendar-days before the prospective franchisee signs a binding agreement" with the franchisor or an affiliate, or makes any payment to them. If the franchisor makes material changes to the agreement on its own, it gives a copy of each revised agreement "at least seven calendar-days before the prospective franchisee signs the revised agreement." Changes that result from the buyer's own negotiation do not trigger the seven-day period.

Section 436.3 requires a cover page titled "FRANCHISE DISCLOSURE DOCUMENT" in capital letters and bold type, with the franchisor's name and contact details, a sample of its primary trademark, a short description of the business and the issuance date. The FTC's consumer guide "Buying a Franchise" (September 2020) tells buyers to get the FDD before investing and to read all 23 Items.

For an E-2 plan the timing has a practical side. The plan for a franchise is written from the FDD the buyer actually received, and the plan names its issuance date. The FTC guide tells buyers that they have the right to ask for a copy of any updated information before they sign the franchise agreement, and the plan's figures are checked against the updated document.

The sections below take the Items in the order a plan uses them: the investment budget, the fees, the earnings data, the outlet history, the franchisor's finances and the opening timeline.

How does Item 7 feed the investment table of an E-2 plan?

Item 7 is the franchisor's table of the estimated initial investment, with additional funds for an initial period of at least three months. The E-2 plan turns that estimate into the amounts actually paid or committed, with documents.

Under 16 CFR 436.5(g) the franchisor presents a table titled "YOUR ESTIMATED INITIAL INVESTMENT" with five columns: type of expenditure, amount, method of payment, when due and to whom payment is made. The table includes a line for additional funds for the initial period. The rule states: "A reasonable initial period is at least three months or a reasonable period for the industry." The franchisor also explains how it arrived at the additional funds figure.

The E-2 rules measure the investment against the cost of the enterprise. 9 FAM 402.9-6(D) states that the cost of a newly created business "is the actual cost needed to establish such a business to the point of being operational," and that the cost of an established business is generally its purchase price, normally its fair market value. A new franchise unit falls under the first rule, and Item 7 is the franchisor's estimate of that cost.

The plan's investment table follows the Item 7 lines and adds what Item 7 cannot contain: the amount the investor has paid, the date, the payee and the document. Under 9 FAM 402.9-6(B), the amount spent on equipment and on inventory on hand may be counted in the investment total. Rent and lease payments count only up to the funds devoted to that item in one month; annual rent is not counted unless it has been paid in advance.

Item 7 usually gives a range for each line. The plan states where the actual figure falls within that range and why, for example a smaller space than the franchisor's typical unit or used equipment the franchisor has approved. A plan that copies the upper end of the range without invoices presents an estimate as an investment.

Which franchise fees go into the financial model?

The initial fees from Item 5 and every recurring fee from the Item 6 table, such as royalties and advertising fees, with the formula used to compute them. Each becomes a separate line of the five-year model.

Under 16 CFR 436.5(e) Item 5 discloses the initial fees and the conditions under which they are refundable. Initial fees cover all fees and commitments to pay for goods or services from the franchisor or an affiliate before the business opens, whether paid in a lump sum or in installments. If the fees vary, the franchisor gives the range or the formula and the factors that determined the amount.

Item 6, under 436.5(f), is a table titled "OTHER FEES" with the type of fee, the amount, the due date and remarks, including any formula. Royalties and advertising fees appear here. A royalty stated as a percentage of gross sales goes into the model as a percentage of each month's revenue; a fixed weekly or monthly fee goes in as a fixed cost.

These lines change the E-2 marginality picture. Revenue that looks sufficient before fees may leave little for the owner after a royalty and an advertising contribution are taken out of every month's sales. The model shows revenue, the fees from Item 6, the operating costs and the remaining net income as separate lines, so the reader sees the income left for the investor and the staff after the franchisor is paid.

Refund terms from Item 5 belong in the plan as well. They are stated next to each initial payment, so that the attorney can see which payments the franchisor may return and decide how to present them.

Can the plan use the franchisor's earnings figures from Item 19?

Only figures that the franchisor actually discloses in Item 19, cited with their bases and assumptions. A franchisor is not required to make such a representation, and if it makes none, the plan builds its forecast from local data.

Item 19 under 16 CFR 436.5(s) covers financial performance representations. Section 436.1 defines one as any representation that states "a specific level or range of actual or potential sales, income, gross profits, or net profits." The franchisor is not required to make one. If it does, it must have a reasonable basis and written substantiation at the time it makes the representation, and it must say whether the figures are historic or a forecast, disclose the material bases and assumptions, warn that individual results may differ and state that substantiation is available on reasonable request.

A franchisor that makes no representation says so in Item 19. The prescribed statement begins: "We do not make any representations about a franchisee's future financial performance." The FTC guide adds that no other spoken or written financial performance claim may be made if it does not appear in Item 19, with two exceptions it describes: the actual records of an existing outlet and information about particular locations or circumstances. It tells buyers to ask for written substantiation of any claim.

The guide also warns about averages: an average figure "tells you very little about how individual franchises performed." For an E-2 plan this matters at the level of one unit. If Item 19 publishes average sales for all outlets, the plan states how many outlets the average covers, how long they have operated and how the planned location compares with them.

If Item 19 contains no figures, the forecast is built from the bottom up: the price list, the expected number of customers or orders per day, the market data for the county and the interviews with existing franchisees described below. The plan states each assumption so that the reader can change it and see the effect.

What do the outlet tables and franchisee lists in Item 20 add?

Three fiscal years of data on opened, transferred and closed outlets, projected openings and contact details of current franchisees and of those who left. The plan uses them to test its forecast against units that already operate.

Under 16 CFR 436.5(t) Item 20 contains tables for the last three fiscal years: a systemwide summary of franchised and company-owned outlets, transfers by state and the status of franchised and company-owned outlets. A separate table shows projected openings for the next fiscal year. The status table shows how many outlets opened, changed hands or closed in each year.

Item 20 also lists current franchisees with the addresses and telephone numbers of their outlets. If the state has fewer than 100 franchised outlets, the list extends to contiguous states and then to the next closest states until at least 100 are listed. Franchisees who left the system during the latest fiscal year, or who have not communicated with the franchisor within 10 weeks of the issuance date, are listed with name, city, state and telephone number.

The FTC guide recommends talking to franchisees directly "rather than relying on information from the broker alone" and notes that "It's worth tracking down former franchisees (using contact information from Item 20)." For the plan, conversations with several current owners give the time to break even, the actual staff count and the cost lines that ran over the Item 7 estimate. The plan records whom it contacted and when, and states figures from these conversations as reported by named owners.

Closures and transfers from the status table go into the risk section. A system where a noticeable share of units changed hands in the last three years is a fact the reader will find in the FDD; the plan names it and states how the investor's unit differs, for example in location or in the owner's experience.

Why does the franchisor's own financial condition appear in the plan?

Because the unit depends on the franchisor's support and brand. Item 21 gives the franchisor's audited financial statements, and the FTC guide calls investing in a financially unstable franchisor a significant risk.

Under 16 CFR 436.5(u) the financial statements in Item 21 follow U.S. generally accepted accounting principles and, except during a start-up phase-in, are audited by an independent certified public accountant. They include balance sheets for the previous two fiscal year-ends and statements of operations, stockholders' equity and cash flows for the previous three fiscal years. A franchisor in its first years may phase in audited statements, beginning with an unaudited opening balance sheet.

The FTC guide tells buyers to check Item 21 and to consider an accountant's review, because "Investing in a financially unstable franchisor is a significant risk." It also suggests checking complaints with the local Better Business Bureau and, if the FDD does not mention state registration or disclosure laws, checking with the state Attorney General's office, office of consumer affairs or securities division.

In the plan this goes into the risks section with its source: the franchisor's revenue and equity over the years Item 21 covers, and any state registration that applies. A plan for a unit of a young franchisor with unaudited statements says so and names what the investor did about it, such as an accountant's review.

When will the franchise open, and how does that affect the five-year projection?

Item 11 discloses the typical time between signing and opening and the factors that can delay it. The E-2 five-year period runs from the date the investor starts normal business activity, so the projection starts at opening.

Under 16 CFR 436.5(k) Item 11 states the typical length of time between signing the franchise agreement, or the first payment if earlier, and the opening of the business. It also lists factors that can affect the timing, such as obtaining a lease, financing, permits, zoning, weather, shortages and delayed installation of equipment.

The E-2 regulation ties the income test to that date. Under 8 CFR 214.2(e)(15) the projected income is measured "within 5 years from the date the alien commences the normal business activity of the enterprise." 9 FAM 402.9-6(E) says the projected future capacity "should generally be realizable within five years from the date" normal business activity begins.

The model therefore shows the pre-opening months separately: build-out, training, hiring and the payments due before the doors open. Year one of the projection starts with the planned opening month. If the investor applies before the unit opens, the plan states what is complete on the filing date, for example a signed lease, paid fees and ordered equipment, and what remains, with the Item 11 timeline as the reference.

How does a franchise plan show that the business is not marginal?

With a five-year projection in which net income after franchise fees exceeds a minimal living for the investor and family, supported by the plan's assumptions. The State Department's checklist asks for projections supported by a thorough business plan.

Under 8 CFR 214.2(e)(15) a marginal enterprise does not have the present or future capacity to "generate more than enough income to provide a minimal living" for the treaty investor and family. 9 FAM 402.9-6(E) describes a marginal enterprise by its "present or future capacity" to generate income and uses the same five-year horizon. The applicant checklist at 9 FAM 402.9-11(B), for a new business, lists "Financial projections for next 5 years, supported by a thorough business plan."

For a franchise the projection carries the fees from Items 5 and 6 and the investment from Item 7, so the net income line already includes what the franchisor takes. The plan states the owner's compensation separately and the number and pay of employees by year, with wages from public wage data for the area.

The assumptions behind the revenue line come from Item 19 where the franchisor discloses figures, from conversations with Item 20 franchisees and from market data for the location. A consular officer who doubts a figure can open the FDD at the cited Item and page. The plan does not draw legal conclusions on marginality; it presents the figures that the attorney uses.

When are the franchise fee and other payments at risk?

When they are committed to the enterprise and subject to loss if the business fails. 8 CFR 214.2(e)(12) requires capital at risk and irrevocably committed and permits escrow pending the visa decision.

Paragraph (e)(12) defines investment as the placing of capital, including funds and other assets, "at risk in the commercial sense with the objective of generating a profit." The capital must be "irrevocably committed to the enterprise," and the regulation permits "the placement of invested funds in escrow pending admission in, or approval of, E classification."

9 FAM 402.9-6(B) adds that funds which are not subject to partial or total loss if business fortunes reverse are not an investment in this sense. Commercial loans secured by the assets of the enterprise cannot count toward the investment; loans secured by the investor's own personal assets may count. The source of funds may include savings, gifts, inheritance and other lawful sources, and the applicant must show possession and control of the invested funds.

For a franchise this produces a list for the plan: the initial fee paid and its refund terms under Item 5, the deposits and equipment payments with their payees, any escrow arrangement and the source of each sum. The attorney decides how these facts are argued; the plan states them with documents.

How does IAE prepare a business plan for an E-2 franchise?

The IAE Secretariat drafts the plan from the FDD, the franchise agreement and your documents, and a registry expert in economics and management checks it against 15 points and signs it. The E-2 section follows your attorney's list.

Under the IAE-BP-001 standard the plan runs 25-35 pages in 11 sections, with a five-year financial model in Excel: assumptions listed, a profit and loss statement, monthly cash flow for 24 months, a balance sheet, the break-even point and the use of funds. For a franchise the use-of-funds table follows the Item 7 lines, and the fee lines follow Items 5 and 6. Market data come from government statistics and dated sources with the name, year and link; sources older than three years are replaced or qualified, and the plan names three competitors.

The section for the purpose of the plan covers investment and non-marginality for E-2 as facts, without legal conclusions, to the list your attorney names. There are no figures without a source and no data you have not confirmed.

Send a one-page description of the business, your CV, the stage and the purpose through the business plans page; for a franchise, add the FDD and the franchise agreement. Within one business day the Secretariat replies, free of charge, which plan is needed, which registry expert will check and sign it, the cost and the timeline. The plan takes 7 business days from payment and a full set of documents, 4 on rush, and one round of edits on the attorney's comments is included.

An existing plan can be sent for review: a registry expert checks it against the same 15 points in 3 business days and writes what USCIS will ask, with a table of points met, partly met and not met, three main risks and a list of edits by priority. The plan does not guarantee a visa. The consulate or USCIS decides, and the plan is responsible for confirmed figures and a model that adds up.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Business plans for petitions, banks and investors

Send a description of the business

A page about the business, a CV, the stage and the purpose. The expert, the cost and the timeline within one business day, free of charge.

Plan assessment

Received

Reply in 1 business day

PurposeE‑2, L‑1A, EB‑5 and others
Timeline7 business days
SignatureRegistry expert