Business plans

EB-5 business plan under Matter of Ho: what makes it comprehensive and credible?

An EB-5 petition for a business that does not yet employ 10 qualifying employees must include a comprehensive business plan showing the need for at least 10 such employees within the next two years. Matter of Ho, a 1998 precedent, lists what the plan should contain and adds: "Most importantly, the business plan must be credible." AAO decisions from 2024 and 2025 still turn on that sentence.

An open binder of turned-away charts sits beside a small building model

When does an EB-5 petition need a business plan?

When the new commercial enterprise has not yet hired 10 qualifying employees. Under 8 CFR 204.6(j)(4)(i)(B) the petition then includes a comprehensive business plan showing the need for them within the next two years.

The regulation gives two ways to show job creation. "To show that a new commercial enterprise will create not fewer than ten (10) full-time positions for qualifying employees, the petition must be accompanied by" either tax records, Forms I-9 or similar documents for ten qualifying employees already hired, or "A copy of a comprehensive business plan showing that," "due to the nature and projected size of the new commercial enterprise," "the need for not fewer than ten (10) qualifying employees will result," "including approximate dates, within the next two years, and when such employees will be hired."

The definitions in 204.6(e) set what counts. Full-time employment means a position "that requires a minimum of 35 working hours per week", and combinations of part-time positions do not count. A qualifying employee is a United States citizen, a lawful permanent resident or another immigrant authorized to work, and the definition "does not include the alien investor." In a November 21, 2024 decision on a for-hire vehicle business in New York with 99 investors, the AAO pointed to the rule that the definition of an employee "shall not include independent contractors" and found that the documents did not support the claim that the independent contractor positions qualified. It withdrew the denial and remanded the case on several grounds.

The plan sits beside other required evidence. Paragraph (j)(1) asks for the organizational documents of the enterprise and a certificate of authority to do business in a state or municipality. Paragraph (j)(5) asks for the investor's position title and a complete description of its duties, or evidence that the investor is a corporate officer, a board member or engaged in policy making.

What happened in Matter of Ho?

On July 31, 1998, the Associate Commissioner for Examinations reversed the approval of a petition for a wheel importer in Compton, California. The four-page business plan was wholly inadequate, and the capital was not shown to be at risk.

King's Wheel Corp. was incorporated in California on December 18, 1997, to import steel and aluminum automobile wheels from Taiwan and sell them wholesale from a leased office and warehouse in Compton, in Los Angeles County, a targeted employment area. On December 30, 1997, the petitioner moved $515,000 into a corporate money market account, and on January 5, 1998, he received 500,000 of the one million authorized shares for $500,000. He filed on January 12, 1998. The director approved the petition and certified the decision for review. The order reads: "The decision of the director is reversed. The petition is denied."

The plan projected sales within three to six months of filing, but the record showed no purchases of inventory or equipment, no negotiations with suppliers or buyers and no utility contracts. The lease had an escape clause for assignment or sublease. "This petitioner's de minimis action of signing a lease agreement, without more, is not enough."

On jobs, the petitioner offered two Forms I-9 completed three days before he signed the Form I-526. They did not show that the workers had started, which positions they held or whether the jobs were full-time and permanent. The plan called for eight more hires within 12 months: a secretary, an accounting clerk, a truck driver, two warehouse workers and three salespeople. The decision called the four-page 'business plan' "wholly inadequate".

What does Matter of Ho say the plan should contain?

At a minimum, a description of the business, its products or services and its objectives, then market analysis, permits, production and supply, contracts, marketing, organization, staffing with a hiring timetable, and projections with their bases.

The decision states that a comprehensive plan "should contain, at a minimum, a description of the business, its products and/or services, and its objectives." It then lists a market analysis with the names of competitors, their strengths and weaknesses, a comparison of prices and a description of the target customers; the permits and licenses obtained; manufacturing or production details, materials and sources of supply where they apply; and any contracts for supplies or distribution of products.

The list continues with the marketing strategy, covering pricing, advertising and service. "The plan should set forth the business's organizational structure and its personnel's experience." It should explain staffing requirements, contain a timetable for hiring and give job descriptions for all positions. "It should contain sales, cost, and income projections and detail the bases therefor."

The list uses "should", and the decision recognizes that each business is different. The Policy Manual repeats the point: "A business plan is not required to contain all of the detailed elements," and the more detail it has, the more likely USCIS is to find it comprehensive and credible.

What makes a business plan credible to USCIS?

Facts in the record that back its numbers. Matter of Ho says: "Most importantly, the business plan must be credible." The Policy Manual has the officer decide whether that is more likely than not.

The Policy Manual sets the test: the officer decides whether it is more likely than not that the business plan is comprehensive and credible. The general standard is a preponderance of the evidence, and evidence meets it if it "leads to the conclusion that the claim is more likely than not (that is, probably true)."

Matter of Ho explains why conclusions alone fail: "Mere conclusory assertions do not enable the Service to determine whether" the job creation is likely. In Ho the four-page plan projected eight hires within 12 months and sales within three to six months, and the record held no purchases, negotiations or contracts behind those figures.

Recent AAO decisions apply the same sentence from Ho. In three decisions issued between January 15 and February 3, 2025, the AAO relied on Matter of Ho and dismissed the appeals because the plans were not both comprehensive and credible. The facts behind those findings are set out below.

How must the plan show 10 jobs within two years?

With positions, approximate dates and hiring times tied to the nature and projected size of the business. The Policy Manual starts the two-year period 6 months after the Form I-526 is adjudicated.

Matter of Ho requires the plan to be "sufficiently detailed to permit the Service to draw reasonable inferences about the job-creation potential." Ho asks for staffing requirements, a timetable for hiring and job descriptions for all positions.

The Policy Manual restates the regulation: the plan must establish that "the need for not fewer than 10 qualifying employees will result within the next 2 years." It adds that the 2-year period "is deemed to begin 6 months after adjudication of Form I-526", and that the plan should give reasons why the jobs will exist by the end of that period.

Temporary work does not count. Under the Policy Manual, intermittent, temporary, seasonal or transient jobs do not qualify as permanent full-time jobs, but jobs expected to last at least 2 years are generally not placed in that category.

Are jobs counted differently in regional center projects?

Yes. Outside a regional center, only direct jobs count. Regional center investors may count indirect jobs shown by reasonable economic methodologies, up to 90 percent of the jobs for petitions filed on or after March 15, 2022.

The Policy Manual defines the two kinds. Direct jobs establish an employer-employee relationship with the new commercial enterprise. Indirect jobs are held outside it but are created as a result of it. A standalone investor counts only direct jobs, which must be created by the new commercial enterprise itself.

For regional center petitions filed on or after March 15, 2022, "up to 90 percent of full-time positions may be created indirectly." Investors must rely on reasonable methodologies to establish the number of indirect jobs, and USCIS reviews the multipliers and the geographic assumptions behind the economic model.

Economic models take their inputs from the plan. In the January 15, 2025 senior care decision, the AAO found the model unreliable because it was built on job figures taken from a business plan that was neither comprehensive nor credible.

Is a signed lease and money in the company account enough?

No. Matter of Ho held that forming a company, funding its account and signing a lease do not show capital at risk. The petitioner must show meaningful concrete business activity.

The first headnote of Ho reads in part: "The petitioner must present, instead, evidence that he has actually undertaken meaningful concrete business activity." King's Wheel had a lease, an account with $515,000 and a plan, but no inventory, equipment, suppliers or customers.

The regulation says the same about investment. Under 204.6(j)(2) the petitioner must establish that the required capital has been placed at risk for the purpose of generating a return, and "Evidence of mere intent to invest, or of prospective investment arrangements entailing no present commitment, will not suffice."

The Policy Manual adds that capital is at risk only if there is a risk of loss and a chance for gain, and that a guaranteed return is not at risk. Merely establishing the enterprise and signing a commercial lease, it says, are not sufficient.

What happens when the project timeline keeps moving?

The plan loses credibility. On January 15, 2025, the AAO dismissed an appeal for a California senior care project whose completion date moved three times and whose construction financing was never obtained.

The investor in In Re: 26766714 put $500,000 into a new commercial enterprise in 2016, which was to lend its whole raise to a job-creating entity building a senior care facility in California. The 2015 plan called for $42 million in EB-5 capital from 84 investors. A 2017 addendum lowered that to $36 million from 72 investors and added $30.84 million of construction financing. A June 2020 update lowered it again to $10 million from 20 investors and $66.84 million of construction financing through a proposed joint venture.

The dates moved with each version. Construction completion was planned for May 2019, then March 2023, then December 2023, and the grand opening for January 2020, then March 2025, then December 2025. The AAO relied on the finding that the only financing obtained was the $10 million of EB-5 capital, and the record held no evidence that the joint venture had been formed. The developer cut its land value estimate, $27,500,000 in 2017, down to $17,500,000 in 2020, with no appraisal, settlement statement or tax bills in support.

The AAO wrote that "the JCE has modified its project development timeline, including completion dates, multiple times," and pointed to "the inability of the JCE to obtain the required construction financing to fund the project". It held that the facts had materially changed since the 2018 approval of the exemplar petition, so no deference was owed, and dismissed the appeal.

What happens when actual results fall short of the projections?

USCIS compares them. In January and February 2025 the AAO rejected job projections of 800.3 for a security technology project that had 76 jobs through September 30, 2023, where revenue lagged the forecasts.

In In Re: 33195781, decided January 17, 2025, the job-creating entity was developing security sensors, integration software and video analytics. Its 2016 plan claimed 257.7 jobs from $8 million raised from 16 investors. The parties later determined that 12 investors and $6 million were sufficient, which required at least 120 jobs. The 2020 plan projected 63.8 jobs in fiscal year 2021, 103.1 in 2022, 266.2 in 2023 and 367.1 in 2024, for a total of 800.3. The record showed 68.1 jobs at the end of fiscal year 2020, 74.4 at the end of 2021, the same through 2023, and 76 through September 30, 2023.

Revenue told the same story. The plan projected $2.5 million in fiscal year 2021, rising to $14.5 million in 2024. Actual revenue was about $1.8 million in fiscal year 2021, and cumulative revenue since inception stayed at about $3.7 million from the end of fiscal year 2021 through fiscal year 2023. About $3.2 million of EB-5 money had been paid to contractors who did not perform, with no showing that it was recovered. The AAO noted that "the 2020 business plan is silent on the amount of needed EB-5 funds" and wrote: "The record, however, is insufficient to support these projected job creation figures."

The appeal was dismissed. On February 3, 2025, in In Re: 33204056, the AAO dismissed the appeal of another investor in the same project on the same findings.

Can USCIS deny a petition on facts outside the record?

Not a finding of ineligibility. On January 15, 2025, the AAO withdrew a denial that relied on public sources about the construction which the notice of intent to deny had not identified, and sent the case back.

In In Re: 31260755 the Chief of the Immigrant Investor Program Office had found the business plan not compliant with Matter of Ho and cited publicly available sources indicating that construction of the project's hotel and casino had not started. The notice of intent to deny did not identify those sources or the specific derogatory information, so the petitioner had no meaningful chance to rebut it.

The AAO quoted 8 CFR 103.2(b)(16)(ii): "a determination of statutory ineligibility shall be based only on information contained in the record of proceeding." It withdrew the decision and directed the Chief to review the new evidence filed on appeal, including an amusement park reportedly operating since 2023 and a revised business plan, and to reconsider whether the capital was at risk.

The same decision restated two points from Ho. Where the 10 jobs do not yet exist, the petition must include a comprehensive business plan showing the need for at least 10 employees, and the record must give enough evidence for USCIS to judge whether the methodologies used are reasonable.

How much capital does the plan have to account for?

For petitions filed on or after March 15, 2022, the Policy Manual sets $1,050,000, or $800,000 in a targeted employment area or for an infrastructure project. The amounts rise automatically on January 1, 2027, and every 5 years after that.

Before March 15, 2022, the Policy Manual notes, petitions required at least $1,000,000, or $500,000 in a targeted employment area. Matter of Ho itself involved $500,000 in a targeted employment area.

The plan has to show where the money goes. In the security technology decisions the AAO criticized the 2020 plan because it did not specifically discuss how the job-creating entity had used or would use the $6 million of EB-5 funds, and did not explain how the smaller raise affected planned costs for acquisition, construction, systems development and operations.

How does IAE prepare a business plan for an EB-5 petition?

The IAE Secretariat drafts the plan from the client's materials and open sources, and a registry expert in economics and management checks it against 15 points, corrects and signs it. The plan is delivered in 7 business days.

The IAE page on business plans for petitions lists the EB-5 requirement as a comprehensive business plan showing the need for not fewer than 10 qualifying employees within the next two years under 8 CFR 204.6(j)(4)(i)(B), with contents as described in Matter of Ho, 22 I&N Dec. 206. Where the plan answers it: the market and competitors, positions and hiring dates, sales and cost projections, licenses. The plan runs 25-35 pages in the 11 sections of the IAE-BP-001 standard, with a five-year financial model in Excel: assumptions listed, a profit and loss statement, monthly cash flow for 24 months, a balance sheet, the break-even point and the use of funds.

Each figure on market size and growth carries the name of its source, the year and a link, for example to a government statistics release, and sources older than three years are replaced or qualified. The section for the visa category is written to the list the client's attorney names and contains no legal conclusions. The client sends a one-page description of the business, the owner's CV, the stage and the purpose. Within one business day the Secretariat replies which plan the purpose requires, which registry expert will check and sign it, the cost and the timeline. The timeline runs from payment and a full set of documents: 7 business days, or 4 in rush mode, with one round of edits on the attorney's comments included.

An existing plan can be sent for review. A registry expert checks it against the same 15-point checklist in 3 business days and writes what USCIS, a bank or an investor will ask: a table of points met, partly met and not met with the page of the plan, three main risks and a list of edits by priority. The decision on a petition is made by USCIS or the consulate, and the plan does not guarantee a visa.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Business plans for petitions, banks and investors

Send a description of the business

A page about the business, a CV, the stage and the purpose. The expert, the cost and the timeline within one business day, free of charge.

Plan assessment

Received

Reply in 1 business day

PurposeE‑2, L‑1A, EB‑5 and others
Timeline7 business days
SignatureRegistry expert