Examinations
Gift tax appraisal: what does adequate disclosure require, and what must the appraisal contain?
The IRS has three years after a gift tax return is filed to assess more tax, but only if the gift was adequately disclosed. If it was not, the period never starts, and a valuation from many years ago can be challenged today. The regulation on adequate disclosure lists what the return must say and lets a qualifying appraisal replace the detailed description of the valuation method. Below are both lists.

Why does adequate disclosure matter for a gift tax appraisal?
Because it starts the period for assessment. Under 26 U.S.C. 6501(a) tax is assessed within 3 years after the return is filed; under 6501(c)(9) a gift not adequately disclosed may be assessed at any time.
26 U.S.C. 6501(a) sets the general rule: "the amount of any tax imposed by this title shall be assessed within 3 years after the return was filed." For gifts, section 6501(c)(9) carves out an exception. If a gift of property required to be shown on a gift tax return "is not shown on such return, any tax imposed by chapter 12 on such gift may be assessed" at any time.
The exception has its own limit: "The preceding sentence shall not apply to any item which is disclosed in such return" "in a manner adequate to apprise the Secretary of the nature of such item." For a gift disclosed in that manner, the general three-year period applies.
The Treasury regulation, 26 CFR 301.6501(c)-1(f), turns the statutory phrase into a checklist. Under paragraph (f)(1), if a transfer "is not adequately disclosed on a gift tax return" for the calendar period in which it occurs, the gift tax on it may be assessed at any time.
For the donor, the value on the return is a position that can be challenged; adequate disclosure decides for how long. For the appraiser, the consequence is concrete: the appraisal attached to the return is the document the IRS reads to decide whether the disclosure was adequate, and gaps in it can keep the period open.
Which transfers need a gift tax valuation in the first place?
Gifts without consideration and also sales or exchanges for less than full value, to the extent the property's value exceeds what was received. A transaction in the ordinary course of business counts as made for full consideration.
Under 26 CFR 25.2512-8, transfers "reached by the gift tax are not confined to those only which, being without a valuable consideration" are gifts in the ordinary sense. The gift tax also reaches sales, exchanges and other dispositions for consideration, to the extent the value of the property transferred exceeds the money or money's worth received.
That rule turns family transactions for consideration into valuation questions: a sale of shares of a family company to a child, an exchange of a partnership interest for a note, a transfer of real estate to a trust in exchange for an annuity. If the value of what was given exceeds the value of what was received, the excess is a gift, and the measure of the excess is an appraisal.
The regulation gives a safe category: a sale, exchange or other transfer "made in the ordinary course of business," meaning bona fide, at arm's length and free of donative intent, is treated as made for full and adequate consideration. Consideration that cannot be reduced to money or money's worth, such as love and affection or a promise of marriage, is disregarded, and the entire value of the property counts as the gift.
Relinquishing dower, curtesy, a statutory estate in lieu of them or other marital rights is not consideration in money or money's worth under the same regulation; section 2516 and its regulations govern certain transfers incident to divorce. Sections 2701 through 2704 contain special valuation rules for business interests, transfers in trust and transfers under options and purchase agreements.
For the appraiser, this means an assignment for a transfer with consideration is the value of a property on a transfer date compared with the price or consideration actually received, and the report has to state both figures.
What must the gift tax return disclose for each transfer?
Under 301.6501(c)-1(f)(2): a description of the property and any consideration; the identity and relationship of transferor and transferee; trust information; a detailed description of the valuation method; and any contrary position taken.
Paragraph (f)(2) lists five elements. A transfer reported as a gift is considered adequately disclosed if the return, or a statement attached to it, provides all of them.
First, a description of the transferred property and any consideration the transferor received. Second, the identity of the transferor and each transferee and the relationship between them. Third, for property transferred in trust, the trust's tax identification number and either a brief description of the terms of the trust or a copy of the trust instrument.
Fourth, a detailed description of the method used to determine the fair market value of the property, including financial data used in determining the value, any restrictions on the transferred property considered in determining value, and a description of any discounts claimed. The regulation adds specific rules for interests in actively traded entities and for entities that are not actively traded, including lower-tier entities.
Fifth, a statement describing any position taken that is contrary to proposed, temporary or final Treasury regulations or revenue rulings published at the time of the transfer.
Paragraph (f)(3) offers an alternative to the fourth element: the donor may submit an appraisal that meets the requirements of that paragraph instead of the detailed description of method. The remaining elements stay on the return.
What does the detailed description of the valuation method have to include?
The financial data used, the restrictions on the property considered in the value, and each discount claimed. Interests in entities not actively traded carry additional requirements, including for lower-tier entities.
The fourth element is where a disclosure succeeds or fails. The regulation asks for a description detailed enough to show how the value was reached: the method, the financial data, the restrictions and the discounts.
Financial data means the figures the valuation rests on. For an interest in a closely held company, the appraiser lists the balance sheet and income statement figures used, the normalization adjustments made to them, the earnings or cash flow base, the capitalization or discount rate and the source of each. A description that says "income approach" without the numbers does not tell the IRS how the value was determined.
Restrictions are the terms that limit what the holder of the transferred interest can do: transfer restrictions in a partnership agreement, a right of first refusal, a buy-sell agreement, limits on withdrawal. The regulation asks which restrictions were considered in the value. If a restriction affected the discount, the description says so and how.
Discounts are described one by one. If the valuation applied a discount for lack of control and a discount for lack of marketability, each is named, sized and supported. Combining them into one figure without saying what each is and why hides the reasoning the regulation asks to see.
The regulation's special rules for entities that are not actively traded also mention lower-tier entities. Where the value of a holding company interest depends on the value of a subsidiary, the appraiser checks those rules with counsel and describes the subsidiary's valuation in the same detail.
Who qualifies as an appraiser for adequate disclosure?
An individual who holds out to the public as an appraiser or appraises regularly, is qualified for the property type, and is not the donor, the donee, a family member of either or their employee.
Paragraph (f)(3)(i) sets three conditions. The appraiser must be an individual who "holds himself or herself out to the public as an appraiser" or "performs appraisals on a regular basis."
The appraiser must also be qualified to appraise the type of property being valued. A business appraiser valuing a family limited partnership that holds real estate and a real property appraiser valuing the underlying buildings may both be needed, and each one's qualifications are stated in his or her own report.
Finally, the appraiser cannot be the donor or the donee, a member of the family of the donor or donee, or a person employed by the donor, the donee or a family member of either. An appraisal prepared by an employee of the donor, or by a relative of the donee who holds appraisal credentials, fails this condition regardless of its quality.
A report that states the appraiser's credentials, experience with the property type and independence from the parties lets the IRS check all three conditions from the return as filed, without a request for more information.
What must the appraisal itself contain?
Dates and purpose, property and process, assumptions and limiting conditions, information detailed enough to replicate the process, procedures and reasoning, the method and its rationale, and the specific basis for the valuation.
Paragraph (f)(3)(ii) lists the contents. The appraisal states the date of the transfer, the date of the appraisal and the purpose of the appraisal.
It describes the property and the appraisal process employed, and it states the assumptions, hypothetical conditions and limiting conditions.
It sets out the information considered in determining the value, including all financial data used "sufficiently detailed so that another person can replicate the process." This is the test for the whole document: a second appraiser with the report and the data should be able to reach the same figure by following the same steps.
It describes the appraisal procedures followed and the reasoning that supports the analyses, opinions and conclusions; the valuation method used, the rationale for it and the procedure used in determining the fair market value of the asset transferred.
Finally it states "the specific basis for the valuation," such as comparable sales or asset-based approaches. A conclusion that rests on unnamed comparables does not meet this element.
Why do the transfer date and the appraisal date both appear in the report?
Because the value is measured as of the transfer date, while the appraisal is prepared on a later date. The regulation requires both, and the report explains what information was known on the transfer date.
Paragraph (f)(3)(ii) lists the date of the transfer and the date of the appraisal as separate items. The gift is valued as of the transfer, and the appraisal can be prepared afterwards, when the return is being prepared.
The gap creates a question the report answers: which information about the company or the property existed on the transfer date and which came later. A valuation of a closely held company as of a December gift, prepared in March, may have access to year-end financial statements that were not final in December. The report states which figures were used and when each became available.
The purpose of the appraisal also appears in the report. A valuation prepared for a gift tax return answers the fair market value question under the gift tax rules, and the report says so. An appraisal prepared earlier for a bank loan or an internal plan has a different purpose, and attaching it to the return without a new appraisal for the transfer leaves the purpose element and the date element unanswered.
Where a series of gifts of the same interest is made over several years, each gift has its own transfer date. One appraisal can cover several dates only if it values the interest on each of them.
When must the return disclose a position contrary to regulations or rulings?
When the valuation or the reporting takes a position contrary to a proposed, temporary or final Treasury regulation or a revenue ruling published at the time of the transfer: paragraph (f)(2)(v) requires a statement describing it.
The fifth element of paragraph (f)(2) is a statement describing any position taken that is contrary to any proposed, temporary or final Treasury regulations or revenue rulings published at the time of the transfer.
For the appraiser, this element can arise when the valuation applies an approach that departs from a published ruling or a regulation on the type of interest. The appraiser does not decide whether a position is contrary; that is a legal question for the donor's tax counsel. The appraiser's task is to state clearly in the report which approach was taken and why, so that counsel can decide whether a statement under (f)(2)(v) is needed.
A report that is explicit about its method, its assumptions and its discounts gives counsel the material to make that decision. A report that is vague about them leaves both the method element and the contrary-position element uncertain.
How can an appraisal be checked against the regulation before the return is filed?
Item by item against paragraphs (f)(2) and (f)(3): appraiser qualifications and independence, both dates, purpose, property and process, assumptions, data detailed enough to replicate, reasoning, method and rationale, and the specific basis of value.
A pre-filing review reads the appraisal with the regulation open and marks each required item as present, incomplete or absent. The appraiser's qualifications and independence under (f)(3)(i) are checked first, because a failure there cannot be cured by the content of the report.
The review then follows (f)(3)(ii) in order: transfer date, appraisal date, purpose; description of the property and the process; assumptions and limiting conditions; information considered with financial data; procedures and reasoning; method, rationale and procedure; specific basis for the value. For each item the reviewer cites the page of the report where it appears.
The replication test is applied by recomputing the value from the data in the report. If a step cannot be reproduced because a figure, a rate or a comparable is missing, the reviewer lists what is missing.
The review also checks the return elements that the appraisal does not replace: the description of the property and consideration, the identity and relationship of the parties, trust information, and the contrary-position statement where counsel decides one is needed.
For a transfer for consideration, such as a sale to a family member, the review confirms that the report states both the value of the property and the value of what was received, so that the excess reported as a gift can be traced to the appraisal.
What does IAE do when a gift or estate valuation is at issue?
An IAE registry appraiser prepares an expert report on the fair market value of a business, an ownership interest or real property as of the needed date, or reviews the opposing appraisal against USPAP.
The IAE valuation page covers the market value of real property and the fair market value of a business or an ownership interest as of the date the case needs, for estate and gift tax disputes, divorce, condemnation and shareholder cases. For closely held stock the page names the factors of 26 CFR 20.2031-2(f)(2): net worth, earning power, dividend-paying capacity and the control the block carries, with USPAP Standard 9 for business appraisal.
A review of the opposing appraisal under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 gives an opinion on the quality of the other appraiser's work: comparables, adjustments, discount and capitalization rates, the effective date and the support for each conclusion. The questions, the property and the valuation date are confirmed before work starts, and the document is delivered in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
Every appraiser is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms no interest in the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on tax or case strategy; an appraisal is evidence that the IRS or the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the appraiser guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- 26 CFR 301.6501(c)-1, Exceptions to general period of limitations on assessment and collection, paragraph (f) (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 26 CFR 25.2512-8, Transfers for insufficient consideration (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 26 U.S.C. 6501, Limitations on assessment and collection (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
House owned before the marriage: how is the marital share of its appreciation valued in a Florida divorce?
A house one spouse owned before the wedding is that spouse's nonmarital property in Florida. The marriage can still give the other spouse a claim
Qualified appraisal for a noncash charitable contribution: who may sign it, what must it contain and when is the deduction lost?
A deduction of more than $5,000 for donated property requires a qualified appraisal under section 170(f)(11) of the Internal Revenue Code
Appraisal expert witness fees: who pays the appraiser, and when can the cost be recovered?
The party that hires an appraiser pays the appraiser, and the other side pays only for the time it takes in a deposition. Two federal statutes moveExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

