Awards

How do you write an award nomination, and what do IEEE, ACM, NSF and the UK honours system ask a nominator to prove?

Selection committees ask the same three things in different forms: what the nominee did, what changed because of it, and who can confirm it. The published rules of IEEE, ACM, the National Science Foundation and the UK honours system set word limits, numbers of endorsers and deadlines. They also say in plain words what a nomination should leave out: the extended CV, the job description and praise without evidence.

Hands write a nomination on cream paper, a sealed envelope and a fountain pen beside a closed blank card

What does a selection committee look for in a nomination?

Committees look for a specific contribution, proof that it belongs to the nominee and its effect on other people or on the field. The UK Cabinet Office tells nominators to describe the situation before and after.

The Cabinet Office guidance "How to write a nomination" asks for evidence of what the nominee did and how it improved things for others. It tells the nominator to show the difference the contribution made: the situation before, the situation now, and what sets the nominee apart from others doing similar work. Superlatives are acceptable if they are accurate, and assertions have to be supported with hard evidence: the nominator describes what the effect has been and why it has been important.

The National Science Foundation gives nominators for the Alan T. Waterman Award a similar instruction. The nomination should help reviewers "get to know the candidate and their work," explain the nominee's own contributions and not those of a group or an institution, and be written for readers outside the nominee's field. The NSF tips compare two versions of a statement. The stronger one names an outcome, such as a measured growth in participation or a process "widely adopted" in industry. The weaker one lists counts of papers or committees.

A guide prepared in January 2025 by the awards department of the IEEE Industry Applications Society for IEEE Fellow nominations asks for two specific, completed contributions, each supported by verifiable evidence of the nominee's individual work and of its impact.

Why does a CV or a job description fail as a nomination?

The UK guidance records a frequent complaint of honours committees: the person recommended is doing no more than the job. It names the extended CV, lists of posts and awards and the job description as things to avoid.

The Cabinet Office puts it directly: do not submit an extended CV, a list of educational achievements, a list of appointments, awards or posts, or a job description. Poor citations often list such things, the guidance says, and a frequent complaint from committees is that the person recommended is "doing no more than their job." The nomination guidance on the Cabinet Office honours site makes the same point: "Don't just list jobs or posts held: try instead to explain what their actual contribution or impact has been."

The IEEE guide warns against the same failure in Fellow nominations: describing an entire technical career instead of two contributions, abusing bibliometric indexes, and presenting potential in place of contributions that are already done. It adds that organizational positions cannot be the sole evidence of technical leadership, and that many years of teaching or an administrative role are not sufficient for an educator.

The CV still has a place. The ACM Prize in Computing asks for one as a separate part of the package, listing publications, patents, honors and service. The nomination statement is a different document with a different task: it argues why these contributions deserve this award.

How long should an award nomination be?

As long as the rules permit and no longer. ACM limits the nomination statement for its Prize in Computing to 200-500 words and the citation to 25 words, and the IEEE Fellow form caps every field.

For the ACM Prize in Computing the nomination statement runs 200 to 500 words and the suggested citation has a "maximum of 25 words." For ACM Fellows the citation is 15 words or fewer, the description of the candidate's main accomplishments is up to 750 words, a list of up to 8 specific contributions takes 300 words, leadership and service take 300, formal recognition takes 300, and each endorsement is limited to 400 words.

The IEEE Fellow form, as described in the 2025 guide, splits each of the two contributions into four fields: identification in 200 words, verifiable evidence in 400, impact in 200 and evidence of impact in 200. The proposed citation is limited to 15 words, and the guide states: "No attachments are allowed as support material for the nomination form."

The UK honours form is the exception. The Cabinet Office says there is "no right length" and accepts typed or handwritten forms.

What is a citation, and how do you write one in 15-25 words?

A citation is the short sentence that states what the award is for. ACM asks for a concise statement of the main accomplishment, and the committee, not the nominator, decides the final wording.

ACM describes the suggested citation for its Prize as a concise statement of the candidate's main accomplishment in no more than 25 words. The limit is 15 words for ACM Fellows and for the proposed citation of an IEEE Fellow.

Fifteen words hold the contribution and the area it changed. The other fields of the form carry the proof: dates, names and figures.

Who should write the supporting letters, and how many are needed?

The rules differ. ACM asks for 3-5 endorsers for its Prize and exactly 5 for Fellows, IEEE asks for 3-5, and the UK honours system asks for at least two letters. All require first-hand knowledge.

For the ACM Prize in Computing a nomination needs "at least 3, and not more than 5" endorsers. Each letter should cover accomplishments the endorser can personally attest to, and the endorsers should represent a range of perspectives and institutions. The nominator collects the letters and supplies a valid email address for each endorser.

ACM Fellows nominations need 5 endorsers who "must have personal knowledge of the candidate's work," preferably ACM Fellows or people of comparable distinction. One person may endorse no more than 4 candidates a year and nominate no more than 2.

For IEEE Medals, Recognitions and Technical Field Awards the FAQ sets a minimum of 3 and a maximum of 5 endorsers. Members of the IEEE Board of Directors, the Awards Board, the relevant council and the selection committee cannot endorse, and "IEEE Staff are not eligible to endorse a candidate." A Fellow nomination needs at least three and no more than five references, who must be IEEE Fellows or Life Fellows.

The UK honours system requires at least two letters of support, each about one page, from people who know the nominee's work at first hand. The nominator cannot write one, the letters must have been written within two years of submission, and letters repeating the same information are not accepted.

NSF asks for letter writers who are "widely recognized leaders in their discipline," come from different institutions and roles, give specific examples and add to the nomination without repeating it. Its tips tell the nominator to share the draft nomination with the letter writers at least two weeks before the portal closes.

Can you nominate yourself for an award?

Often not. IEEE states that self-nominations are not permitted for its awards or for Fellow elevation, and ACM advises that the nominator for its Prize come from a different organization than the candidate.

The IEEE awards FAQ reads: "Self nominations are not permitted for IEEE-level awards. You must be nominated by someone." The Fellow guide repeats the ban and adds that any person, including a non-member, may serve as a nominator, with the exception of IEEE Board members, members of the Fellow Committee, evaluators and staff.

ACM describes the suitable nominator for its Prize as a recognized member of the community who works in a different organization than the candidate and can speak to the candidate's broader impact. For ACM Fellows the nominator must be a professional ACM member and senior enough to make a credible case.

The UK guidance says that anyone can nominate somebody for an honour.

Should the nominee know about the nomination?

It depends on the award. The UK Cabinet Office says the nominee should not be told, because it is not fair to raise their expectations. ACM does not tell candidates who nominated or endorsed them.

Under the Cabinet Office guidance a nominator may talk about the nomination to anyone except the person nominated, and personal information has to be held safely and securely.

ACM takes a narrower position for its Prize: the nomination form asks for the candidate's address and email, and ACM does not tell candidates who nominated or endorsed them.

A nominator who cannot ask the nominee for facts works with published work, public records and the people who write the supporting letters.

When should you start, and how long does a decision take?

Start months before the deadline. The NSF timeline for the Waterman Award begins four months before the portal closes. IEEE deadlines fall on January 15 and June 15, and a UK honours nomination is considered for 12-18 months or longer.

The NSF tips set out a calendar for a portal that is open between mid-July and mid-September. Four months before the deadline the nominator identifies a candidate, checks eligibility and outlines the accomplishments. Three months before, the nominator contacts letter writers and drafts the statement. Two months before, the draft goes out for feedback. One week before, the nominator confirms that the letters have been submitted.

IEEE gives fixed dates in its FAQ: "15 June (annually)" for Medals and Recognitions and "15 January (annually)" for Technical Field Awards. The 2025 guide for Fellow nominations names February 7, 2025 and adds: "Hard deadline, no flexibility allowed." References and endorsers must also submit on time. For the cycles shown on the ACM pages the deadlines were December 15, 2025 for the Prize in Computing and September 7, 2026 for Fellows.

UK honours have no deadline. The Cabinet Office says that consideration is likely to take at least 12 to 18 months because of the background work needed to assess a nomination, asks for nominations while the nominee is still active, at least 12 months before the nominee is expected to retire or stand down, and treats a nomination as lapsed if it has not succeeded after two years.

A failed nomination does not roll over. An unsuccessful ACM Fellows candidate may be nominated again after two review cycles, and an IEEE Fellow nomination must be submitted again as a new one with new forms, references and endorsements.

What do organizers check after you submit?

They check the claims and the person. The UK honours process runs probity checks with government departments, ACM asks nominators and endorsers to disclose known ethics violations, and IEEE bars a second award for the same contributions.

The Cabinet Office guidance describes probity checks with a number of government departments. The secretariat may ask HMRC to advise on potential risk with a low, medium or high rating, and the Main Honours Committee takes that rating into account.

ACM asks the nominator to state whether he or she knows of any action by the candidate that violates the ACM Code of Ethics or Core Values. Each endorser receives a link to the same attestation, and the ACM conflict-of-interest guidelines apply to every nomination. For Fellows the accomplishments must be backed by publicly recognized artifacts such as publications, products or awards, and the candidate must show "clear and compelling evidence" of influence beyond the employer.

The IEEE FAQ adds two limits. A candidate cannot be serving on the boards and committees that decide the award, and "a candidate also cannot be a previous recipient of another IEEE-level award for the same contributions."

How is a nomination for the IAE Award written and submitted?

An active IAE member at Senior Member, CIE or Fellow level nominates a colleague through a three-step form with a 500-1,000 word description of achievements and links to verifiable sources. The 2026 window closed on October 31.

The IAE Award is the association's annual award for contribution to the expert profession. Members nominate colleagues in four categories: Methodological Innovation, Expert Practice, Academic Excellence and Rising Expert, the last for a specialist with no more than seven years of practice. The fifth award, the Grand Prix, is not nominated: the Council initiates its consideration.

The nominator is an active member at Senior Member, CIE or Fellow level who is personally familiar with the candidate's work, and the candidate is an active IAE member of any level. Self-nomination is not considered, and the form does not accept a candidate's Member ID that matches the nominator's.

The form asks for both Member IDs, a note on how the nominator knows the candidate's work, and a description of achievements: what the candidate did, when and with what result, with dates, names and figures. It does not accept fewer than 500 or more than 1,000 words. Links to publications, decisions, registries and organization pages go one per line, and up to five PDF files may be attached. The Council does not take unverifiable information into account.

Nominations are accepted between September 1 and October 31. The 2026 window has closed, later nominations go to the 2027 cycle, and the site gives September 1, 2027 as the day nominations for IAE Award 2027 open. In November the secretariat checks the stated achievements against the registry and primary sources. The Council votes in a closed session with written reasoning in the first week of December, and the laureates are announced in December and entered in the public registry. Nominators' names and the content of nominations are not disclosed to candidates or third parties.

Only active members nominate and receive the award, so taking part begins with an application for membership. The Council decides on a membership application within 30 days, and the nomination page names August 1, 2027 as the date to apply by in order to take part in the 2027 cycle.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Awards

Become part of the IAE community

IAE membership is the first step to taking part in the award: only active members nominate colleagues and receive awards. A decision on the application within 30 days.

Nomination

Accepted

IAE Award 2026 season

CategoryExpert practice
CandidateIAE registry member
LaureatesIn December