Expert report review

How does a patent owner answer the petitioner's expert declaration in an IPR?

In an inter partes review the petitioner's technical expert testifies by declaration, and the patent owner answers in four places: the preliminary response, the cross-examination after institution, the patent owner response and the sur-reply. The PTAB rules set the limits of each step. Opinions without disclosed facts or data get little or no weight under 37 CFR 42.65, the cross-examination lasts up to seven hours, and objections survive only through a motion to exclude.

A person from behind holds a closed binder facing an empty witness chair

What is the petitioner's expert declaration in an IPR?

Direct testimony by affidavit. Under 37 CFR 42.53(a) uncompelled direct testimony is filed as an affidavit, the Federal Rules of Evidence generally apply, and opinions without disclosed facts or data get little or no weight.

Under 37 CFR 42.53 uncompelled direct testimony must be in the form of an affidavit, and other testimony, including testimony compelled under 35 U.S.C. 24, is taken as a deposition transcript. The parties may agree to video-recorded testimony but may not submit it without Board authorization. Uncompelled direct testimony may be taken at any time to support a petition, motion, opposition or reply. The petitioner's expert declaration is testimony of this kind.

Two sentences of 37 CFR 42.65(a) govern how the Board reads it: "Expert testimony that does not disclose the underlying facts or data on which the opinion is based is entitled to little or no weight," and "Testimony on United States patent law or patent examination practice will not be admitted." If a party relies on a technical test, 42.65(b) requires an affidavit explaining why the test or data is used, how the test was performed and the data generated, how the data is used to determine a value, how the test is regarded in the relevant art, and any other information the Board needs to evaluate the test and data.

The slides of a PTAB Boardside Chat on the use of expert witness testimony, held on September 15, 2022, list 37 CFR 42.62 among the governing rules, under which the Federal Rules of Evidence generally apply, including Rules 702 and 703. The slide on basic principles reads: "Opinions supported by underlying facts and data," "Testimony on U.S. Patent Law not admissible," "Subject to cross-examination," and "Depositions of experts are NOT discovery depositions." The closing slide adds, citing the Consolidated Trial Practice Guide at page 36: "Expert testimony does not take the place of disclosure in a reference."

Can the patent owner attack the declaration before institution?

Yes, in the preliminary response, which may include testimonial evidence. In Xerox v. Bytemark, designated precedential in 2023, the Board denied institution where the declaration repeated the petition's conclusory assertions verbatim.

The Consolidated Trial Practice Guide of November 2019 says the preliminary response "may present arguments and supporting evidence (including testimonial evidence)" to show that no review should be instituted, citing 37 CFR 42.107(a) and 42.207(a). Cross-examination of the petitioner's declarant comes later: according to the Guide, "the patent owner may begin deposing the petitioner's declarants once the proceeding is instituted."

In Xerox Corp. v. Bytemark, Inc., IPR2022-00624, Paper 9, decided on August 24, 2022, the Board denied institution. The USPTO announcement of February 10, 2023, by which the Director designated the decision precedential, states the holding: a declarant's testimony is "entitled to little weight" if it "merely repeats, verbatim, conclusory assertions from a petition," particularly when it cites no additional supporting evidence or technical reasoning. A Boardside Chat of July 20, 2023 paired Xerox with Equipmentshare.com Inc. v. Ahern Rentals, Inc., IPR2021-00834, Paper 33. The slides say that expert testimony closely mirroring a petition is "not necessarily deficient or entitled to no weight," that the Board evaluates "the specific testimony of an expert," and that under Xerox a declaration is "entitled to little weight when it contains an exact restatement of the petition's arguments."

A preliminary response built on this line compares the declaration with the petition paragraph by paragraph and marks each passage copied word for word, each statement with no citation, and each statement that cites a document, a figure or a test.

When and how long is the petitioner's expert cross-examined?

After institution, as routine discovery. 37 CFR 42.51(b)(1)(ii) authorizes cross-examination of affidavit testimony prepared for the proceeding, and 42.53(c) sets seven hours for it unless the parties stipulate or the Board orders otherwise.

Rule 42.51(b)(1)(ii) reads: "Cross examination of affidavit testimony prepared for the proceeding is authorized within such time period as the Board may set." The Trial Practice Guide lists cross-examination of the other side's declarants as routine discovery. For uncompelled direct testimony, 42.53(c) gives seven hours for cross-examination, four hours for redirect and two hours for re-cross, unless the parties stipulate or the Board orders otherwise.

Deposition testimony in the United States may be taken at any reasonable time and place before a disinterested official authorized to administer oaths; uncompelled deposition testimony outside the United States requires the parties' agreement or the Board's direction. Under 42.53(g), unless the Board orders otherwise or the parties agree in writing, the proponent of direct testimony bears all associated costs, including the reasonable costs of making the witness available for cross-examination. The July 2023 Boardside Chat quoted the Guide: "a party presenting a witness's testimony by affidavit should arrange to make the witness available for cross-examination."

When the declarant cannot be cross-examined, the same presentation cited John's Lone Star Distribution, Inc. v. Thermolife International, Inc., IPR2014-01201, Paper 31, for the Board's power to strike the declaration under 37 CFR 42.12(a) and (b). The 2022 slides treat testimony from another proceeding separately: "Cross-examination of testimony from another proceeding is not new testimony subject to routine discovery," and they raise the hearsay question under Federal Rule of Evidence 804(b)(1).

What rules govern objections and coaching during the deposition?

The Board's Testimony Guidelines. Objections are limited to a word or term, counsel who offered the expert may not confer about the substance of the testimony during cross-examination, and instructions not to answer are narrow.

Under Appendix D of the Trial Practice Guide, objections must be "stated concisely in a non-argumentative and non-suggestive manner." The proper examples are "Objection, form," "Objection, hearsay," "Objection, relevance" and "Objection, foundation"; "Objection, vague" and "Objection, take your time answering the question" are given as improper. "Objections should be limited to a single word or term."

From the start of cross-examination until it ends, counsel who offered the witness on direct may not consult or confer with the witness about the substance of the testimony, except to decide whether to assert a privilege or how to comply with a Board order, and may not suggest how a question should be answered. "Counsel may instruct a witness not to answer only when necessary to preserve a privilege," to enforce a limit ordered by the Board or to present a motion to terminate or limit the testimony. The Board may allow more time than 42.53(c) gives if it is needed to examine the witness fairly.

Objections at the deposition have their own rule. Under 37 CFR 42.64(a), "An objection to the admissibility of deposition evidence must be made during the deposition," and evidence to cure the objection must be provided during the deposition unless the parties stipulate otherwise on the record. Under 42.53(f), objections not made on the record and preserved in a timely motion to exclude are waived.

What should the cross-examination of the petitioner's expert cover?

The facts or data behind each opinion, every element of a test under 42.65(b), passages copied from the petition, what each reference discloses on its face, and whether the expert's qualifications cover the full scope of the testimony.

Rule 42.65(a) gives the first line of questions: for each paragraph of the declaration, which document, page, figure or test supports it. Where the declaration relies on a test, the five items of 42.65(b) become five questions: why the test was used, how it was performed and the data generated, how the data was used to determine a value, how the test is regarded in the art, and what else the Board would need to evaluate it.

The 2022 slides add two more. "Expert testimony does not take the place of disclosure in a reference," so each statement about what a prior art reference teaches is checked against the reference, and the expert is asked to point to the column and line. The slides also list as an emerging issue whether the expert's qualifications match the scope of the testimony, which turns into questions about the expert's work in each field the declaration covers.

Paragraphs that the comparison with the petition marked as copied are put to the expert one by one: who drafted the text, what the expert reviewed before signing, and what independent basis the expert has for the statement. Testimony on United States patent law is not admitted under 42.65(a), so legal conclusions in the declaration are listed for an objection.

How are objections preserved, and what can a motion to exclude do?

Object within the 37 CFR 42.64 deadlines, let the petitioner serve supplemental evidence, then file a motion to exclude. The Trial Practice Guide says the motion is not a vehicle for weight or sufficiency.

Under 42.64(b)(1), an objection to evidence submitted during a preliminary proceeding must be filed within ten business days of institution, and once a trial is instituted any objection must be filed within five business days of service of the evidence. The objection must identify its grounds "with sufficient particularity to allow correction in the form of supplemental evidence." The party relying on the evidence may serve supplemental evidence within ten business days of service of the objection under 42.64(b)(2). Under 42.64(c) "A motion to exclude evidence must be filed to preserve any objection"; it must identify the objections in the record in order and explain them, and it may be filed without prior authorization.

The Guide adds that "Objections may be preserved only by filing a motion to exclude the evidence," and that the motion should "Identify where in the record the objection originally was made." It sets the limit of the motion: it "is not a vehicle for addressing the weight to be given evidence" and "may not be used to challenge the sufficiency of the evidence to prove a particular fact." Admissibility, according to the Guide, "is generally governed by the Federal Rules of Evidence."

The two sentences of 42.65(a) fall on different sides of that line. The first concerns weight, and an argument that the declaration discloses no facts or data belongs in the patent owner response. The second says testimony on patent law "will not be admitted," which is an admissibility ground for an objection and a motion to exclude, as are objections under Federal Rule of Evidence 702 and the hearsay rules.

Does the patent owner need its own expert declaration?

No rule requires one. In FanDuel v. Interactive Games, decided in 2020, the Federal Circuit held that the burden of proving unpatentability stays on the petitioner throughout the proceeding and that no expert submissions are required.

In FanDuel, Inc. v. Interactive Games LLC, decided on July 29, 2020, Judge Hughes wrote that "the burden of proving invalidity in an IPR remains on the petitioner throughout the proceeding," that "the IPR regulations do not require a patent owner to submit any response to the petition," and that "a patent owner's response, alone, does not define the universe of issues the Board may address." The opinion states that "no expert submissions are required" and quotes Belden v. Berk-Tek on the absence of any rule requiring an expert to guide the Board on how to read prior art.

If the patent owner files a response, Rule 42.6(a)(3) applies to it: "Arguments must not be incorporated by reference from one document into another document." The Trial Practice Guide warns that parties that incorporate expert testimony by reference in their petitions, motions or replies risk having that testimony not considered. Admissions obtained at the cross-examination therefore go into the response itself, with page and line of the transcript.

A declaration from the patent owner's own expert is subject to the same rules in the other direction: cross-examination by the petitioner under 42.51(b)(1)(ii), costs of making the witness available under 42.53(g), and the weight rule of 42.65(a), which applies to its opinions in the same way.

What if the petitioner answers with a new declaration in reply?

A reply may respond only to arguments in the patent owner response, the preliminary response or the institution decision. The patent owner can cross-examine the reply declarant, object and move to exclude, and answer in a sur-reply.

Under 37 CFR 42.23(b), as amended in December 2020, "All arguments for the relief requested in a motion must be made in the motion." A reply may respond only to arguments raised in the opposition, the patent owner preliminary response, the patent owner response or the decision on institution. A sur-reply may respond only to arguments raised in the reply and may not be accompanied by new evidence other than deposition transcripts of the cross-examination of any reply witness.

The Trial Practice Guide states that the petitioner "may not submit new evidence or argument in reply that it could have presented earlier," that "Generally, a reply or sur-reply may only respond to arguments raised in the preceding brief," and that "a reply or sur-reply that raises a new issue or belatedly presents evidence may not be considered." Sur-replies may comment on reply declaration testimony and point to cross-examination testimony, and "This sur-reply practice essentially replaces the previous practice of filing observations on cross-examination testimony."

The Federal Circuit addressed a reply declaration in Belden Inc. v. Berk-Tek LLC, decided on November 5, 2015 in an opinion by Judge Taranto. It held that the Board did not abuse its discretion in concluding that the declaration of the petitioner's expert, Mr. Baxter, "fairly responds only to arguments made in Mr. Clark's declaration and Belden's response," and that the declaration "was not necessary for the prima facie case of obviousness." The court listed what a patent owner can do: "It can cross-examine the expert and move to file observations on the cross-examination." "It can move to exclude the declaration." "It can move for permission to submit a surreply responding to the declaration's contents." "The options are not mutually exclusive." Belden used cross-examination, a motion to exclude and observations, did not seek a surreply, and the court held it had not established that it was denied its procedural rights.

What does IAE do when a patent owner faces the petitioner's expert declaration?

An IAE expert reviews the opposing technical expert's report for district court or PTAB proceedings and prepares a review, a rebuttal expert report or deposition questions. The document is issued in up to 5 business days.

IAE's page on reviewing the opposing technical expert's report is written for patent litigators facing the other side's technical report on infringement or validity, in district court or before the PTAB. The reviewer checks whether every opinion is tied to the claim language and the evidence: whether each element is mapped, whether the claim construction is applied and whether the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data under Rule 702(b). Each finding is tied to a claim element, a page of the opposing report and a rule or decision.

The page names three formats: a review of the opposing technical report, a rebuttal expert report and deposition questions. Before work starts IAE confirms the patent, the asserted claims and the questions for the reviewer. The reviewer works from the opposing report with its exhibits and from the source code, samples or test data the expert relied on.

The document is issued in up to 5 business days. The decision on patentability belongs to the Board.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member