Business plans

L-1A new office business plan: what must it show for the one-year test and the extension?

A new office petition asks USCIS to approve an L-1A manager or executive for a U.S. operation that is less than a year old. The regulation requires secured premises, a year of managerial or executive work in the three years before filing and evidence that within one year the office will support a managerial or executive position. The business plan carries that evidence, and at the extension USCIS receives the actual staff, wages and financial status of the office.

A person from behind looks over an empty new office and a rolled floor plan

What is a new office for an L-1A petition?

An organization that has been doing business in the United States through a parent, branch, affiliate or subsidiary for less than one year, under the definition in 8 CFR 214.2(l)(1)(ii)(F).

The definition in 8 CFR 214.2(l)(1)(ii)(F) reads: "New office means an organization which has been doing business in the United States through a parent, branch, affiliate, or subsidiary for less than one year." Doing business has its own definition in paragraph (l)(1)(ii)(H): "the regular, systematic, and continuous provision of goods and/or services by a qualifying organization", which "does not include the mere presence of an agent or office of the qualifying organization in the United States and abroad."

A U.S. company that has not yet sold anything files as a new office. An office that consists of a registered agent or a mailing address is not doing business under paragraph (H), and at the extension the petitioner files evidence "that the United States entity has been doing business as defined in paragraph (l)(1)(ii)(H) of this section for the previous year" (paragraph (l)(14)(ii)(B)).

What must a new office petition prove?

Three things under 8 CFR 214.2(l)(3)(v): the premises are secured, the beneficiary worked one continuous year as a manager or executive in the three years before filing, and the office will support such a position within one year.

When the beneficiary is coming "as a manager or executive to open or to be employed in a new office", paragraph (l)(3)(v) requires evidence that "(A) Sufficient physical premises to house the new office have been secured" and that "(B) The beneficiary has been employed for one continuous year in the three year period preceding the filing of the petition in an executive or managerial capacity and that the proposed employment involved executive or managerial authority over the new operation".

Part (C) is the one a business plan answers. The petitioner submits evidence that "The intended United States operation, within one year of the approval of the petition, will support an executive or managerial position", supported by information on three subjects: "(1) The proposed nature of the office describing the scope of the entity, its organizational structure, and its financial goals"; "(2) The size of the United States investment and the financial ability of the foreign entity to remunerate the beneficiary and to commence doing business in the United States"; and "(3) The organizational structure of the foreign entity."

The regulation does not use the words "business plan" and sets no minimum investment, revenue or headcount. It names subjects: scope, structure, financial goals, the size of the investment and the parent's ability to pay. The plan states each of them in numbers and dates.

How long is a new office L-1A approved for?

Up to one year. Then the petitioner files for an extension with the evidence listed in 8 CFR 214.2(l)(14)(ii), including a year of doing business, staffing, wages and the financial status of the U.S. operation.

Paragraph (l)(7)(i)(A)(3) provides that if the beneficiary is coming to open or be employed in a new office, "the petition may be approved for a period not to exceed one year". The validity is extended under paragraph (l)(14)(ii), once the petitioner proves that it is doing business as defined in paragraph (l)(1)(ii)(H).

After the first year, "An extension of stay may be authorized in increments of up to two years for beneficiaries of individual and blanket petitions" (paragraph (l)(15)(ii)). The total is capped by paragraph (l)(12)(i): a person who has spent "seven years in the United States in a managerial or executive capacity" in L or H status may not be readmitted in L or H status until he or she has resided and been physically present outside the United States for the immediate prior year, except for brief visits for business or pleasure.

The extension petition asks for the duties the beneficiary "will perform under the extended petition" (paragraph (l)(14)(ii)(C)). The plan therefore describes the second year of the office as well as the first.

What counts as managerial or executive capacity in a small office?

The person must primarily manage or direct, and not primarily do the work. 8 CFR 214.2(l)(1)(ii)(B) and (C) define both roles, and a first-line supervisor of non-professional staff is not a manager on that ground alone.

Under paragraph (l)(1)(ii)(B), managerial capacity is an assignment in which the employee primarily manages the organization or a department, subdivision, function or component; supervises and controls the work of other supervisory, professional or managerial employees, or manages an essential function; has the authority to hire and fire or recommend those actions if other employees are directly supervised; and exercises discretion over the day-to-day operations of the activity or function. The paragraph ends: "A first-line supervisor is not considered to be acting in a managerial capacity merely by virtue of the supervisor's supervisory duties unless the employees supervised are professional."

Under paragraph (l)(1)(ii)(C), executive capacity means that the employee primarily directs the management of the organization or a major component or function, establishes its goals and policies, "Exercises wide latitude in discretionary decision-making" and "Receives only general supervision or direction from higher level executives, the board of directors, or stockholders of the organization."

In Brazil Quality Stones, Inc. v. Chertoff, 531 F.3d 1063, decided on July 10, 2008, the Ninth Circuit wrote that the president of a granite importer "cannot qualify for an L-1A visa simply because he performs managerial tasks"; "such tasks must encompass his primary responsibilities." The company had to show that he was "primarily engaged in overseeing essential functions of BQS's business rather than performing them himself."

How many employees must the new office have after one year?

No number is set. The statute requires USCIS to weigh staffing against the reasonable needs and stage of development of the organization, and the Ninth Circuit held that small size alone cannot defeat a petition.

8 U.S.C. 1101(a)(44)(C) provides that when staffing levels are used as a factor in determining managerial or executive capacity, the Attorney General "shall take into account the reasonable needs of the organization, component, or function" in light of its purpose and stage of development. The same subparagraph adds: "An individual shall not be considered to be acting in a managerial or executive capacity (as previously defined) merely on the basis of the number of employees that the individual supervises or has supervised or directs or has directed."

Brazil Quality Stones, the U.S. affiliate of a Brazilian exporter of granite and decorative stone, was a new office, so the first approval for its president ran for one year. When it sought the extension, it had paid only three employees other than him in the quarter before the petition. The Ninth Circuit held that "an organization's small size, standing alone, cannot support a finding that its employee is not acting in a managerial capacity", and that size is still a relevant "factor in assessing whether [an organization's] operations are substantial enough to support a manager." It upheld the denial, because the record did not compel a finding that the managerial tasks were his primary responsibilities.

At the extension, paragraph (l)(14)(ii)(D) asks for staffing "including the number of employees and types of positions held", with evidence of wages paid. A hiring schedule in the plan lists the same items by quarter: positions, number of employees and wages.

What evidence does USCIS require to extend a new office L-1A?

Five items under 8 CFR 214.2(l)(14)(ii): a continuing qualifying relationship, a year of doing business, the beneficiary's past and future duties, staffing with evidence of wages, and the financial status of the U.S. operation.

Paragraph (l)(14)(ii) lists the evidence filed with the extension: "(A) Evidence that the United States and foreign entities are still qualifying organizations"; "(B) Evidence that the United States entity has been doing business as defined in paragraph (l)(1)(ii)(H) of this section for the previous year"; "(C) A statement of the duties performed by the beneficiary for the previous year and the duties the beneficiary will perform under the extended petition"; "(D) A statement describing the staffing of the new operation, including the number of employees and types of positions held accompanied by evidence of wages paid to employees when the beneficiary will be employed in a managerial or executive capacity"; and "(E) Evidence of the financial status of the United States operation."

Each item has a counterpart in the original plan. The organizational chart for month 12 corresponds to item (D), the projected profit and loss statement and cash flow to item (E), the description of the beneficiary's role to item (C), and the sales forecast to item (B). If the plan forecast five hires and the payroll records show two, both numbers are in the file.

In ScotlandShop USA, Inc. v. USCIS, the court noted that the deference policy of the USCIS Policy Manual for a prior approval "explicitly applies to extensions". ScotlandShop had filed "a new and separate L-1A petition" after its new office approval, so "this policy does not apply in this situation."

What happens when the office stays smaller than the plan said?

USCIS can find that the beneficiary would have to do the operational work herself. In ScotlandShop USA v. USCIS (N.D.N.Y. 2024) the U.S. branch had two employees, both managers, and the court upheld the denial.

ScotlandShop USA, Inc. v. USCIS, No. 1:23-CV-0703, was decided by the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of New York on December 17, 2024. ScotlandShop sells Scottish clothing online and through stores in Duns, Scotland, and Latham, New York; Anna White founded it in 2002 and is its owner and Managing Director. USCIS approved a new office L-1A petition for her on January 5, 2022. A new I-129 petition followed on November 29, 2022, USCIS issued a request for evidence on December 8, 2022, and denied the petition on March 9, 2023.

The decision records that "at the time the application was filed, the United States branch had only two employees, both of whom were listed as 'managers' with no subordinate staff." USCIS concluded that "it is likely that [Plaintiff White] would have to compensate for those staffing deficiencies in order to meet the company's immediate operational needs", and called the listed duties "general, repetitive, and appear to simply paraphrase the statutory definition of executive capacity."

The court reviewed the denial under the Administrative Procedure Act and found that USCIS had not relied on size alone: its concern was the lack of evidence of who would do the operational and administrative work. The order reads: "Defendants' cross-motion for summary judgment (Dkt. No. 22) is GRANTED", and the complaint was dismissed.

What should the business plan for a new office contain?

Numbers for each subject in 8 CFR 214.2(l)(3)(v)(C): the office's scope, organizational structure and financial goals, the size of the U.S. investment, the parent's ability to pay, and the structure of the foreign entity.

For the scope of the entity the plan states what the office will sell, to whom and in which premises, and the lease is the evidence for paragraph (l)(3)(v)(A). For the organizational structure it gives a chart for the first month and for month 12, with each position, its duties and its hiring date, so that the people under the beneficiary can be read against the definitions in paragraph (l)(1)(ii)(B) or (C). For the financial goals it gives revenue and costs by month for the first year and by year after that.

For the size of the U.S. investment the plan states the amount transferred or committed and its use by item, and the parent's financial statements back the beneficiary's salary. For the structure of the foreign entity it gives the parent's chart with the beneficiary's current position, which also supports the year of managerial or executive work required by paragraph (l)(3)(v)(B).

In Brazil Quality Stones and in ScotlandShop the courts looked at the number of U.S. employees and at who did the day-to-day work. The plan answers the same question with positions, hiring dates and wages.

How does IAE prepare a business plan for an L-1A new office?

The IAE Secretariat drafts the plan from the client's materials and open sources, and a registry expert in economics and management checks it against 15 points, corrects and signs it. The plan is delivered in 7 business days.

The IAE page on business plans for petitions lists, for an L-1A new office, the requirement of 8 CFR 214.2(l)(3)(v)(C) and where the plan answers it: structure for 12 months, a hiring schedule and financial goals. The plan runs 25-35 pages in the 11 sections of the IAE-BP-001 standard, with a five-year financial model in Excel: assumptions listed, a profit and loss statement, monthly cash flow for 24 months, a balance sheet, the break-even point and the use of funds. Each figure on market size and growth carries the name of its source, the year and a link, for example to a government statistics release; sources older than three years are replaced or qualified.

The section for the visa category is written to the list the client's attorney names and contains no legal conclusions. The client sends a one-page description of the business, the owner's CV, the stage and the purpose. Within one business day the Secretariat replies which plan the purpose requires, which registry expert will check and sign it, the cost and the timeline. The timeline runs from payment and a full set of documents (registration, lease, contracts, investment statements): 7 business days, or 4 in rush mode. One round of edits on the attorney's comments is included.

An existing plan can be sent for review through the business plans page. A registry expert checks it against the same 15-point checklist in 3 business days and writes what USCIS, the bank or the investor will ask: a table of points met, partly met and not met with the page of the plan, three main risks and a list of edits by priority. The decision on a petition is made by USCIS or the consulate, and the plan does not guarantee a visa.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Business plans for petitions, banks and investors

Send a description of the business

A page about the business, a CV, the stage and the purpose. The expert, the cost and the timeline within one business day, free of charge.

Plan assessment

Received

Reply in 1 business day

PurposeE‑2, L‑1A, EB‑5 and others
Timeline7 business days
SignatureRegistry expert