Peer letter

An O-1A RFE on the consultation letter: what must the new advisory opinion say?

Every O petition must include a written advisory opinion from a U.S. peer group, and an RFE on that opinion takes one of two forms. In the draft O-1A RFE template USCIS posted for comment in January 2013, the officer writes either that no consultation was submitted or that the one submitted "is insufficient," and adds: "A new consultation may be submitted." Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv), the response period cannot exceed twelve weeks.

Hands open a consultation folder beside a face-down photo and a petition binder

What does an O-1A RFE on the consultation say?

Either that the petition contains no consultation or that the consultation filed "is insufficient," followed by the officer's reasons. In both versions of the USCIS template, the petitioner may still submit a new consultation.

The wording comes from a document USCIS posted for public comment. On January 22, 2013, NAFSA reported that USCIS was asking for comments on a draft request for evidence template to be used by adjudicators in O-1A petitions, with comments accepted between January 2 and February 5, 2013. The template is marked "DRAFT TEMPLATE FOR COMMENT" and covers extraordinary ability in the sciences, education, business and athletics. The American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA) filed comments on the parallel O-1B and O-2 templates on February 5, 2013, and on a draft O-1B template on February 22, 2016.

The section titled "Evidence of Consultation" opens with the rule: "All petitions seeking O nonimmigrant classification must include a written advisory opinion from a U.S. peer group in the area of the beneficiary's ability." The officer then picks one of two paragraphs. The first reads: "You did not submit evidence for this requirement. You may still submit evidence to satisfy this requirement." The second begins "The consultation you submitted is insufficient," carries a note telling the officer to explain what was submitted and why it does not establish eligibility, and ends with "A new consultation may be submitted which meets the requirements specified below."

The two paragraphs call for different work. After the first, the petitioner obtains an opinion that was not in the file at filing. After the second, the petitioner reads the officer's reasons against the requirements listed in the template and decides whether to file a new opinion or to explain why the one in the record meets them. The template's introduction names that second route among the ways to answer any item: "Explain how the evidence in the record already establishes eligibility."

What must the new advisory opinion contain?

Three statements: the beneficiary's ability and achievements in the field, the nature of the duties to be performed, and whether the position requires a person of extraordinary ability, with supporting facts and an authorized signature.

The template defines the document: "A consultation is a written advisory opinion regarding the nature of the work and the beneficiary's qualifications." The advisory opinion must state "The beneficiary's ability and achievements in the field of endeavor," "The nature of the duties to be performed," and "Whether the position requires the services of an alien of extraordinary ability."

Two more requirements follow. "The written opinion should contain a statement of facts that support the conclusion reached in the opinion," and it "must be signed by an authorized official of the group or organization." The University of Arizona international office gives departments the same list for O-1 faculty: "An acceptable Advisory Opinion describes the alien's ability/achievements in the field, duties to be performed" and "whether the position requires someone of extraordinary ability."

Each statement can be checked against the petition. The achievements match the evidence filed under the O-1A criteria. The duties match the position title in Form I-129 and the contract filed with it. The third statement links the two: it says whether work of that description calls for someone at the level the O-1A standard sets.

An opinion that praises the beneficiary and never mentions the job covers one statement out of three. An opinion that describes the job in general terms of the industry, without the title and duties from the petition, gives the officer nothing to compare.

Who may write the consultation for an O-1A petition?

A U.S. peer group in the beneficiary's area. The USCIS template says it "may include a person or persons with expertise in the field, labor, or management organization." University offices ask for a union or professional association first.

The full sentence in the template reads: "The U.S. peer group may include a person or persons with expertise in the field, labor, or management organization." The University of Arizona page puts it in two parts: "A peer group is a person with expertise in the FN's field" or "a group/organization composed of practitioners in the FN's occupation/field of extraordinary ability," where FN stands for foreign national.

The Yale Office of International Students and Scholars tells O-1 applicants on its page on O-1 letters to "obtain a written consultation/advisory opinion from an appropriate union or professional association." If none exists, the office will "obtain letters of support from internationally recognized artists, faculty or scientists" to "represent the peer group," and adds: "As a general rule it is recommended you have at least 3 letters of endorsement."

The signature line was discussed during the comment period. In its comments of February 5, 2013 on the O-1B template (AILA Doc. No. 13020643), AILA wrote that the requirement that the opinion "must be signed by an authorized official of the group or organization" should apply only when the opinion comes from an organization, since as worded it did not cover a consultation from an individual with expertise in the field.

The words "in the area of the beneficiary's ability" narrow the choice. An organization whose members work in another field does not meet them, whatever its size. The field as the petition describes it, such as machine learning, cardiology or venture finance, is the reference point the officer uses.

Why would an officer find a consultation insufficient?

The template asks the officer to say what was submitted and why it fails. The grounds follow its requirements: a missing statement, no supporting facts, no authorized signature, a group outside the field or the wrong category standard.

The note in the second paragraph is a placeholder for the officer: "(ISO should explain what evidence was submitted and why it is insufficient to establish eligibility.)" The explanation the officer writes there is the text the response answers. The requirements in the same section give the possible grounds, and the list below follows them in order.

A last ground comes from the category. The Policy Manual chapter on O-1 beneficiaries sets two standards. For O-1A, extraordinary ability means "a level of expertise indicating that the person is one of the small percentage" "who have arisen to the very top of the field of endeavor." For O-1B in the arts, the standard is "distinction, defined as a high level of achievement in the field of arts," which the chapter explains as "a degree of skill and recognition substantially above that ordinarily encountered."

An opinion that calls an engineer or a founder "distinguished" answers the O-1B question. The O-1A template asks whether the position requires "the services of an alien of extraordinary ability," and a new opinion uses those words and that standard.

  • The opinion does not describe the beneficiary's ability and achievements in the field of endeavor.
  • The opinion does not describe the duties of the position named in the petition.
  • The opinion does not say whether the position requires the services of a person of extraordinary ability.
  • The opinion states a conclusion without the facts that support it.
  • The opinion from an organization is not signed by an authorized official of that organization.
  • The author or the organization is not a peer group in the area of the beneficiary's ability.

Can a letter of no objection answer the RFE?

Yes. The template says: "A consulting organization may submit a letter of no objection if it has no objection to the approval of the petition." It sets no separate content requirements for such a letter.

The Directors Guild of America describes the same three outcomes on its page about O-1 and O-2 visa consultation letters, which it calls "consultation letters, also called advisory opinions, from a designated U.S. peer group or labor organization." The DGA may endorse a petition, object to it or issue a no objection. According to the page, an objection letter states specific facts, and these often explain which evidentiary criteria the request did not meet.

The petitioner files what the organization issues. The DGA page says its letter "becomes part of the underlying petition and is submitted by the petitioner to the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services." A letter that arrives after the petition was filed goes into the RFE response.

An objection does not close the matter. The template asks every written opinion for "a statement of facts that support the conclusion," and its introduction lets the petitioner "submit other evidence to satisfy the request" or explain how the record already establishes eligibility. A response to an objection takes the facts it states one by one and answers each with a document from the record or a new one.

What if no appropriate peer group exists?

The draft O-1A template does not address that case. AILA asked USCIS in 2013 to let petitioners file letters or affidavits saying so, and Yale uses letters from internationally recognized faculty or scientists in place of a union.

In its comments of February 5, 2013 on the O-2 template (AILA Doc. No. 13020645), AILA wrote that the consultation requirement did not account for fields with no peer group and proposed this sentence: "If no appropriate peer group exists, you may submit letters or affidavits to that effect from individuals with expertise in the field."

In the O-1B comments of the same date, AILA proposed adding the words "unless waived" to the consultation requirement and gave as its basis "8 CFR §214.2(o)(5)(i)(E) and (ii)(B)." In its comments of February 22, 2016 on the draft O-1B template (AILA Doc. No. 16022302), AILA again asked that the bullet refer to a written advisory opinion "from the appropriate consulting entity unless waived."

For research fields without a union, Yale's office collects at least three letters from internationally recognized faculty or scientists to stand for the peer group. In an RFE response, a statement that no peer group exists is a factual claim like any other, and it goes in with the documents that support it: a description of the field, the organizations that exist in it and why none of them covers the beneficiary's area.

Does the stricter motion picture and television rule apply to an O-1A?

No. The Policy Manual ties the more stringent consultation requirements to persons "seeking entry for a motion picture or television production," which is an O-1B category. Petitions in science, education, business and athletics are O-1A.

Section A of Policy Manual Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 4 says the statute "includes more stringent consultation requirements for persons 'seeking entry for a motion picture or television production,'" and its footnote cites INA 101(a)(15)(O)(i) and INA 214(c)(3). The chapter then treats O-1A in the sciences, education, business or athletics, O-1B in the arts and O-1B in motion picture or television in separate sections.

The motion picture organizations draw the same line. The Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers says on its O-1/O-2 advisory opinions page that it "is not the appropriate management-side organization to issue a letter" for roles outside the industry and asks not to send "Submissions for anyone working outside the motion picture and television industry." The DGA issues letters for directors, assistant directors, unit production managers, associate directors and stage managers.

An O-1A RFE for an engineer, a researcher or a company founder is answered by a peer group in that person's field. A letter from a film union in such a case is a consultation from a group outside the area of the beneficiary's ability.

How long is the response period, and how is the answer filed?

The RFE states the due date, and 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv) caps the period at twelve weeks. Under 103.2(b)(11), all requested materials go in together, at one time, with the original request for evidence.

Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iii), when the initial evidence is in the file but does not establish eligibility, USCIS may deny the petition, ask for more evidence "within a specified period of time as determined by USCIS," or issue a notice of intent to deny. Paragraph (b)(8)(iv) adds that "in no case shall the maximum response period provided in a request for evidence exceed twelve weeks," and that the response time in a notice of intent to deny cannot exceed thirty days.

Paragraph (b)(11) gives three options: a complete response with all requested information, a partial response with a request for a decision on the record, or withdrawal of the petition. "All requested materials must be submitted together at one time, along with the original USCIS request for evidence or notice of intent to deny." The next sentence reads: "Submission of only some of the requested evidence will be considered a request for a decision on the record."

An RFE often covers the consultation and some of the O-1A criteria at once. The new advisory opinion then waits for the rest of the package, because sending it alone would count as a partial response. Under paragraph (b)(13)(i), if the petitioner does not respond by the required date, the petition "may be summarily denied as abandoned, denied based on the record, or denied for both reasons."

The template's introduction lists four ways to answer an item: "Submit one, some, or all of these items," submit other evidence instead, "Explain how the evidence in the record already establishes eligibility," or "Request a decision based on the record."

Can a consultation dated after filing answer the RFE?

Yes, the template invites a new consultation. Its content has to fit the petition as filed: under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(12), a petition is denied when evidence in the response does not establish eligibility at the time of filing.

Paragraph (b)(12) reads: "A benefit request shall be denied where evidence submitted in response to a request for evidence does not establish filing eligibility at the time the benefit request was filed." Paragraph (b)(1) requires the petitioner to be eligible at the time of filing and to remain eligible through adjudication. The template's introduction says the same in plain words: "Evidence must show that both you and the beneficiary were eligible for the requested benefit when you filed Form I-129."

The new opinion carries the date of its signature, which falls after filing. What it discusses is fixed by the petition: the position and duties as stated in the Form I-129 and the contract, and the achievements documented in the file on the filing date. An award or a publication dated after filing does not establish eligibility at the time of filing under paragraph (b)(12), and an opinion that rests on it gives the officer a ground to deny.

The same applies to the position. If the job changed after filing, the opinion still addresses the duties described in the petition. A different job is a matter for a new or amended petition, and the attorney decides how to handle it.

How much time do consulting organizations take?

Each sets its own schedule. The DGA aims to issue a letter within seven to ten business days of a fully documented request and has no expedited process. AMPTP asks for the packet at least one week ahead.

The DGA page says the guild "attempts to issue a consultation letter within seven to ten business days of receiving a fully documented request," that some petitions need more time and that there is no expedited process. The DGA charges $250 per petition and does not issue an opinion for a petition submitted without payment.

AMPTP asks petitioners to "Send packet at least one week in advance" and notes that the "O-1 Packet should be less than 50 pages." Its list of required documents includes the signed Form I-129, the signed petitioner's letter on company letterhead, the signed deal memo or contract, the beneficiary's background and any previous AMPTP and guild or union advisory opinion.

The twelve weeks run for the whole response, and the opinion is one part of it. The request to the organization goes out in the first days after the RFE arrives, so that the attorney receives the signed opinion with time left to assemble the package and file it at one time, as paragraph (b)(11) requires.

How does IAE prepare an association letter for an O-1A RFE response?

IAE issues the letter as the advisory opinion of a professional association. At least two members in the applicant's field assess the dossier, and the signed letter takes 5 business days, or 2 on the rush option.

The request on the association letter page includes a CV, a list of achievements, publications and awards, and a description of the petition. For an RFE response, the description includes the RFE itself, so that the draft can be read against the officer's reasons. The secretariat confirms receipt, the fee and the turnaround within one business day, and the fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials.

At least two registry members in the applicant's field review the materials against the IAE Certification Criteria Matrix. The letter is issued on IAE letterhead with references to the charter, the Criteria Matrix and the association's public policies, and the IAE leadership signs it. Before signing, the draft goes to the applicant and the attorney. Factual revisions are included, and the conclusions remain with the association. The draft review is the point to check the three statements the USCIS template lists against the petition.

The signed letter comes as a PDF, with a paper original on request. The 5 business days, or 2 on the rush option, run from payment and receipt of all materials. The letter, the signatory's authority and the association are verified by Member ID on the status check page.

IAE is not a labor organization. Where the law requires a consultation with a labor organization, as in motion picture and television petitions, the letter does not replace it and says so. IAE is not a law firm, and the response strategy stays with a licensed immigration attorney. USCIS evaluates the letter together with the rest of the response and makes the decision.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Association letter

Need recognition from the professional community?

The standard turnaround is 5 business days, the rush option 2 business days. The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials; we confirm the fee and the turnaround within one business day.

Association letter

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

ReviewersAt least 2 IAE members
Timeline5 business days, rush 2
LetterheadIAE, signed by leadership