Expert report review
Prior art dates in the opposing invalidity report: is each reference earlier than the claim's effective filing date?
An invalidity opinion compares each reference with a claim as of one date: the claim's effective filing date under 35 U.S.C. 100(i). A reviewer checks that date from both sides: is the claim entitled to the priority the expert gave it, and was each reference public or effectively filed before it? In Dynamic Drinkware (2015) a reference patent lost its provisional date without proof that the provisional supported its claims; Dental Monitoring (2026) applied that rule under the AIA.

Which date does an invalidity opinion measure the prior art against?
The effective filing date of each claimed invention: the actual filing date, or the filing date of the earliest application whose priority or benefit the claim is entitled to under 35 U.S.C. 100(i).
Section 100(i)(1) of the Patent Act defines the term. For a claimed invention it means the actual filing date of the patent or application containing the claim, unless the patent is entitled, "as to such invention," to a right of priority under section 119, 365(a), 365(b), 386(a) or 386(b), or to the benefit of an earlier filing date under section 120, 121, 365(c) or 386(c). In that case the date is the filing date of the earliest such application.
Section 100(j) defines the claimed invention as "the subject matter defined by a claim in a patent or an application for a patent." The date is attached to the claim, not to the patent as a whole. A patent with several asserted claims can carry several dates when the claims draw on matter added in a later application.
Under 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(1), a person is not entitled to a patent if "the claimed invention was patented, described in a printed publication, or in public use, on sale, or otherwise available to the public before the effective filing date of the claimed invention." Every reference in the opposing report is measured against that date. A wrong date moves references in or out of the prior art while the technical comparison stays the same, so the reviewer checks the date before the claim chart.
Is each asserted claim entitled to the priority date the expert used?
Only if the earlier application supports the claim. Its disclosure must convey with reasonable clarity to those skilled in the art that the inventor possessed the claimed invention as of the date sought.
Section 120 gives a later application the date of an earlier one for an invention disclosed in the earlier application "in the manner provided by section 112(a)," other than the best mode requirement. The later application must be filed "before the patenting or abandonment of or termination of proceedings on the first application" and must contain a specific reference to it. Section 112(a) requires "a written description of the invention."
PowerOasis, Inc. v. T-Mobile USA, Inc., decided by the Federal Circuit on April 11, 2008, concerned claims of U.S. Patents 6,466,658 and 6,721,400. The patents came from a continuation-in-part filed June 15, 2000, and PowerOasis sought the February 6, 1997 date of its original application. The MobileStar Network had been publicly used, sold and offered before June 15, 1999, more than a year before the continuation-in-part. With the later date, MobileStar was a statutory bar.
Judge Moore wrote that the district court "correctly placed the burden on PowerOasis to come forward with evidence to prove entitlement to claim priority" to the earlier date. The standard for that proof is the written description test: the earlier disclosure "must convey with reasonable clarity to those skilled in the art that, as of the filing date sought, [the inventor] was in possession of the invention."
The chain itself can also be at issue. In MOAEC, Inc. v. MusicIP Corp., decided June 30, 2008, Napster argued in the Western District of Wisconsin that the '283 patent anticipated the '886 and '471 patents. The '886 patent issued from a continuation-in-part of an application filed on May 15, 2001, the day that application's parent issued as the '539 patent. Judge Barbara Crabb held that "the same day filing satisfies the copendency requirement" of section 120 and denied summary judgment of invalidity.
A reviewer of the patent owner's report looks for the passages of the parent application that describe each element of each asserted claim. A reviewer of the challenger's report looks for the reason the claim falls back to a later date before the expert relies on art from the gap.
When is an earlier-filed patent or application prior art?
Under 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(2), a U.S. patent, a published U.S. application or a WIPO publication designating the United States counts if it names another inventor and was effectively filed before the claim's date.
Section 102(a)(2) covers a claimed invention that "was described in a patent issued under section 151, or in an application for patent published or deemed published under section 122(b), in which the patent or application, as the case may be, names another inventor and was effectively filed before the effective filing date of the claimed invention."
MPEP 2154.01 lists the three kinds of documents that qualify: U.S. patents, U.S. patent application publications and certain WIPO published applications. Such a document may be prior art even if it was published or issued after the effective filing date of the claim, provided it was effectively filed before that date. Under MPEP 2154.01(a), WIPO publications of PCT applications that designate the United States are treated as U.S. application publications regardless of the international filing date, the language of publication or entry into the U.S. national stage.
Section 102(d) fixes the date of such a document. It is effectively filed as of its actual filing date or, if it is entitled to priority or benefit from earlier applications, "as of the filing date of the earliest such application that describes the subject matter." MPEP 2154.01(b) applies the rule to foreign applications "regardless of where filed."
In the opposing chart, a patent document cited by its publication date may in fact count from an earlier filing date, and a document cited by a foreign or provisional date needs a separate showing that the earlier application describes the subject matter relied on.
Can a prior art patent claim the date of its provisional application?
Only with proof that the provisional supports the reference patent's claims. In Dynamic Drinkware v. National Graphics (2015) the petitioner lost because it never showed that the provisional supported the reference's claims.
The patent in Dynamic Drinkware, LLC v. National Graphics, Inc., U.S. Patent 6,635,196, is directed to making molded plastic articles bearing a lenticular image. The Board instituted inter partes review of claims 1 and 12 on Dynamic's ground that they were anticipated by the Raymond patent, U.S. 7,153,555. Raymond was filed May 5, 2000, and claims a provisional filed February 15, 2000. The Board found that National Graphics reduced its invention to practice by March 28, 2000, so everything turned on whether Raymond could use the February date.
The Federal Circuit decided the appeal on September 4, 2015, in an opinion by Judge Lourie. It wrote that "(a) provisional application's effectiveness as prior art depends on its written description support for the claims of the issued patent of which it was a provisional." A reference patent "is only entitled to claim the benefit of the filing date of its provisional application if the disclosure of the provisional application provides support for the claims in the reference patent."
Dynamic had compared the claims of the '196 patent with Raymond. It had not shown that the provisional supported Raymond's own claims, and the court affirmed the Board's finding that Raymond was not entitled to the earlier date on this record.
The court also separated two burdens. The petitioner must prove "unpatentability by a preponderance of the evidence," and "that burden never shifts to the patentee." The burden of production shifts, "the allocation of which depends on where in the process of trial the issue arises." Once National Graphics produced evidence of an earlier reduction to practice, Dynamic had to produce evidence of Raymond's provisional support.
Did the America Invents Act change the rule for provisional dates?
No. In Dental Monitoring v. Align Technology, decided August 10, 2026, the Federal Circuit held that section 102(d) requires written description support for at least one published claim of the reference.
The appeal came from an inter partes review of claims 1-15 of U.S. Patent 10,755,409. The reference was the Carrier publication, U.S. 2021/0068923 A1. The effective filing date of the '409 patent fell between the filing dates of Carrier's provisional and non-provisional applications, so the provisional date decided whether Carrier was prior art.
Applying its precedential decision in Penumbra, the Board treated the priority requirements of sections 119 and 120 as "ministerial" for purposes of AIA section 102(d)(2). It read Dynamic Drinkware as limited to the pre-AIA version of section 102.
The Federal Circuit, in an opinion by Judge Lourie with Judges Schall and Taranto, rejected that reading. It read sections 102(d)(2) and 119(e)(1) as "conditioning entitlement to an earlier prior art date on compliance with § 112(a)" and held that "the statutory text requires § 112(a) support for at least one of the prior art patent's published claims" before the reference may take the earlier date. The requirement "is not merely 'ministerial.'" The Board had not determined whether Carrier's provisional provides that support, so the court vacated the decision and remanded.
For each reference dated by a provisional or a parent, a reviewer now looks for a claim-by-claim comparison of the reference's published claims with the earlier application. A report that cites only the benefit claim printed on the face of the reference lacks it.
Which disclosures within a year before filing are not prior art?
Under 35 U.S.C. 102(b)(1), a disclosure made one year or less before the effective filing date is not prior art if it came from the inventor or from someone who obtained the subject matter from the inventor.
Section 102(b)(1) excludes such a disclosure from 102(a)(1) prior art if "the disclosure was made by the inventor or joint inventor or by another who obtained the subject matter disclosed directly or indirectly from the inventor or a joint inventor," or if the subject matter had already been publicly disclosed by the inventor or by someone who obtained it from the inventor.
MPEP 2151 measures the grace year from the earliest U.S. or foreign application to which a proper benefit or priority claim is made, provided that application supports the claimed invention under 35 U.S.C. 112(a). A period that ends on a weekend or a federal holiday runs to the next business day.
Section 102(b)(2) sets three exceptions for 102(a)(2) patent documents: the subject matter was obtained from the inventor, the inventor publicly disclosed it before the document was effectively filed, or the subject matter and the claimed invention, "not later than the effective filing date of the claimed invention, were owned by the same person or subject to an obligation of assignment to the same person." MPEP 2151 states that the common ownership exception "only removes disclosures as prior art under AIA 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(2)" and does not reach the same subject matter available under 102(a)(1).
When the opposing report relies on a paper, a talk or a product release within the year before filing, the reviewer asks who made the disclosure and where the subject matter came from. When it relies on a patent document of a related company, the reviewer checks ownership and assignment obligations on the effective filing date.
Which rules apply to a patent filed before March 16, 2013?
Pre-AIA section 102, unless the application ever contained a claim with an effective filing date on or after March 16, 2013. Under the old law the date of invention matters, and a patent owner may prove an earlier one.
MPEP 2159.02 says the AIA provisions "apply to any patent application that contains or contained at any time a claim to a claimed invention that has an effective filing date that is on or after March 16, 2013." When an application has claims on both sides of that date, MPEP 2159.03 requires each claim to be patentable under AIA sections 102 and 103 "as well as pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102(g)."
Pre-AIA section 102(a) measured the art against "the invention thereof by the applicant for patent," and 102(e) counted an application or patent by another "filed in the United States before the invention by the applicant." A patent owner can answer such a reference with proof of an earlier conception and reduction to practice. In Dynamic Drinkware the Board found that National Graphics reduced its invention to practice by March 28, 2000, before Raymond's own filing date, which is why the provisional date mattered.
Pre-AIA section 102(b) works differently. It barred a patent if the invention was patented, published, in public use or on sale "more than one year prior to the date of the application for patent in the United States." No proof of an earlier invention date removes that bar. In PowerOasis the MobileStar network fell under 102(b) once the claims were held to the continuation-in-part date.
The reviewer therefore records which version of section 102 the opposing expert applied and whether the patent owner has, or has disclosed, evidence of an earlier invention date.
Who has to prove the dates, in court and at the PTAB?
The challenger. In district court invalidity must be proved by clear and convincing evidence; at the PTAB the petitioner proves unpatentability by a preponderance. The patent owner produces evidence of the priority it claims.
In Microsoft Corp. v. i4i Ltd. Partnership, decided June 9, 2011, the Supreme Court considered "whether §282 requires an invalidity defense to be proved by clear and convincing evidence" and held that it does. Justice Sotomayor wrote for the Court that when the evidence was not before the Patent and Trademark Office, "the jury may be instructed to consider that it has heard evidence that the PTO had no opportunity to evaluate."
PowerOasis sets the order of proof in court. The party asserting invalidity first presents its prima facie case, and "the party relying on validity is then obligated to come forward with evidence to the contrary." The court added that the MobileStar art never having been before the PTO "does not change the presumption of validity or who has the burden of proof with respect to the prima facie case of invalidity."
Before the Board, Dynamic Drinkware places the burden of persuasion on the petitioner throughout, and Dental Monitoring sent the provisional question back to the Board for a finding on the evidence.
In district court the date analysis is part of the expert's opinion. Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(i) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires "a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them," and Rule 702(b) of the Federal Rules of Evidence requires testimony "based on sufficient facts or data." A reference date given without a source is a gap in the basis of the opinion.
What does the reviewer record for each reference in the opposing report?
Its type, the date the report gives it, the document behind that date, the subsection of section 102 it falls under, and whether it predates the effective filing date of each claim it is cited against.
The table is built claim by claim, because the effective filing date belongs to the claim (35 U.S.C. 100(i) and (j)). Its rows follow the order in which a court or the Board reaches the dates.
- The reviewer fixes the effective filing date the opposing expert used for each asserted claim and checks it against the priority chain printed on the patent.
- For each claim given a parent, provisional or foreign date, the reviewer looks for the passages of the earlier application that describe every element of that claim.
- For each reference the reviewer records whether the report offers it under 102(a)(1) or 102(a)(2) and which date the report assigns to it.
- For a patent document dated by its provisional or parent, the reviewer compares the earlier application with the reference's published claims, as Dental Monitoring requires.
- For a disclosure made within one year before the effective filing date, the reviewer checks its source and the ownership facts under section 102(b).
- For a patent with an effective filing date before March 16, 2013, the reviewer checks that the report applies pre-AIA law and whether an earlier invention date is in the record.
How does the date review reach the court?
As part of a rebuttal report served within 30 days after the other side's disclosure, unless the court sets another schedule, or as questions for the opposing expert's deposition after the report is served.
Under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii), evidence "intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party" is disclosed within 30 days after the other party's disclosure. A date analysis that answers the opposing invalidity report stays on the same subject matter.
Rule 26(b)(4)(A) permits the deposition of an expert whose report is required "only after the report is provided." The date table gives counsel the questions: which claim, which date, which page of the parent application, which document proves the date of each reference. Rule 26(e)(2) extends the duty to supplement to information given at the expert's deposition, and additions are due by the time pretrial disclosures under Rule 26(a)(3) are due.
What does IAE do when the dates in the opposing invalidity report are in question?
An IAE technical expert reviews the opposing report on infringement or validity, for district court or PTAB proceedings, and prepares a review, a rebuttal expert report or deposition questions in up to 5 business days.
IAE's page on reviewing the opposing technical expert's report is written for patent litigators facing the other side's report on infringement or validity, in district court or before the PTAB. The reviewer checks whether every opinion is tied to the claim language and the evidence: whether each element is mapped, whether the court's claim construction is applied and whether the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data under Rule 702(b). Each finding is tied to a claim element, a page of the opposing report and a rule or decision.
The IAE patent page describes validity work as a prior art search before the effective filing date and an obviousness analysis under 35 U.S.C. 103. The review page names three formats: a review of the opposing technical report, a rebuttal expert report and deposition questions. Before work starts IAE confirms the patent, the asserted claims and the questions for the reviewer.
The client sends the opposing report or the case materials and describes the task, and the secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry; the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
The specialist is a member of the public IAE registry who passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID or QR code on the document opens the record. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. The review is evidence that the court or the Board weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.
Sources
- 35 U.S. Code 100, Definitions (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 35 U.S. Code 102, Conditions for patentability; novelty (LII, Cornell Law School)
- United States Code, Title 35, Part II, 2022 edition: sections 103, 112, 120 (GovInfo)
- United States Code, 2011 edition, 35 U.S.C. 102 before the America Invents Act (GovInfo)
- MPEP 2151, Overview of the changes to 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103 in the AIA (USPTO)
- MPEP 2154, Provisions pertaining to subject matter in a U.S. patent or application effectively filed before the effective filing date (USPTO)
- MPEP 2159, Applicability date provisions and determining whether an application is subject to the first inventor to file provisions (USPTO)
- PowerOasis, Inc. v. T-Mobile USA, Inc., No. 2007-1265 (Fed. Cir. Apr. 11, 2008) (Justia)
- MOAEC, Inc. v. MusicIP Corp., No. 07-cv-654-bbc (W.D. Wis. June 30, 2008)
- Dynamic Drinkware, LLC v. National Graphics, Inc., No. 15-1214 (Fed. Cir. Sept. 4, 2015) (Justia)
- Dental Monitoring SAS v. Align Technology, Inc., No. 2025-1752 (Fed. Cir. Aug. 10, 2026), opinion text
- Dental Monitoring SAS v. Align Technology, Inc., 184 F.4th 1376 (Fed. Cir. 2026) (Leagle)
- Microsoft Corp. v. i4i Ltd. Partnership, 564 U.S. 91 (2011), opinion of the Court (ChanRobles)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702 (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Enablement and written description in the opposing invalidity report: what does a reviewer check after Amgen v. Sanofi?
An invalidity report under 35 U.S.C. 112 says that the patent's specification does not describe the invention or does not teach a skilled person
Is the opposing patent expert a person of ordinary skill in the art, and what follows if not?
Claim construction, obviousness and infringement are all judged through the eyes of a person having ordinary skill in the art. In Kyocera Senco
Amended, reissued or published claims: which version must the opposing expert compare with the product?
An infringement comparison is only as good as the claim it uses. Claims change after filing: they are published in an application, allowedExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

