Membership
What happens when a member violates a professional association's code of ethics?
A professional association acts on its code of ethics through a committee of members: it receives a written complaint, asks the member to respond, investigates and votes. The sanctions differ by society. They include a letter that finds a violation, a public notice of the violation, a letter of admonition, required corrective action, suspension and expulsion. ASCE, ICMA, AICPA, ACM and IEEE publish their procedures, and some publish the sanctions as well.

Who enforces a professional association's code of ethics?
A standing committee of members. ASCE and ICMA each call it the Committee on Professional Conduct; at IEEE complaints go to the Ethics and Member Conduct Committee, and at AICPA an ethics committee and a Joint Trial Board decide.
ASCE has used the same body for more than a century. In a July 2008 article, ASCE general counsel Tara Hoke wrote that complaints go to the Committee on Professional Conduct, which has handled them since 1923. Since 1968 it has not been a committee of the Board of Direction. In 2008 it had "no fewer than four ASCE members," each a former Board member; ASCE's current ethics page describes it as an eight-person volunteer committee that reviews and investigates complaints under its rules of procedure. The society's history of discipline is older still: the 1878 constitution authorized removal of members "for cause," the first recorded disciplinary action, a requested resignation, came in 1899, and the first Code of Ethics was adopted in 1914.
At ICMA the Committee on Professional Conduct is a standing committee of the Executive Board. Under the ICMA Rules of Procedure for Enforcement, revised in May 2026, it consists of three or more Board members selected by the ICMA president and determines whether the member's conduct violated the Code, while the Board makes the final decision on enforcement matters. In an August 1, 2022 article in PM Magazine, ICMA ethics director Martha Perego wrote that the committee has "sole authority to determine when a violation of the Code occurs."
At AICPA the dispositions are split between bodies. The ethics committee dismisses complaints, closes them without further action or issues letters of required corrective action. The Joint Trial Board admonishes members publicly. Suspension and expulsion are imposed by the AICPA.
At IEEE a complaint goes to the Ethics and Member Conduct Committee. In the case described below, a hearing board appointed by the IEEE Board of Directors heard the matter, and the Board imposed the sanction.
Who can file an ethics complaint, and against whom?
At ACM anyone may file, member or not, and usually only members and awardees can be charged. ICMA opens proceedings only on a complete written complaint, submitted electronically and signed.
ACM's enforcement page states: "Note that you do not need to be a member to file a complaint." It also limits who can be charged: "Usually only ACM members, ACM SIG members, ACM awardees, and ACM SIG awardees can be charged with violating The Code." The complainant files the reporting form with a concise statement of the facts, an explanation of why these facts indicate a violation and, if possible, the principles of the Code that were violated. Knowingly filing a false allegation is itself a violation of the Code. The current policy was adopted by the ACM Council on March 28, 2024.
ICMA does not start cases on its own. Under the 2026 Rules the executive director/CEO may initiate proceedings after receiving a complete written complaint, submitted electronically and signed, with the submitter's current contact information. Perego wrote in 2022 that ICMA staff working on ethics issues "do not initiate a review."
At ASCE, according to the 2008 article, a staff liaison first confirms that the complaint names a current member and identifies the canons of the Code allegedly violated. The committee then decides whether the circumstances, if proven, "could constitute a violation of the Code of Ethics." The procedure starts only for a current member. ASCE's current page asks complainants to mail a printed complaint form to ASCE headquarters in Reston, Virginia.
How is an ethics complaint investigated?
The member receives the complaint in writing and answers it. A committee member or a fact-finding committee gathers documents and interviews, and the full committee votes on whether the code was violated.
At ASCE, as the 2008 article describes it, the committee "assigns a committee member to investigate the case." The committee sends a letter to the member under investigation. The investigator may interview the parties and witnesses and review records of judicial or other related proceedings, and the findings are presented at a meeting of the full committee. ASCE's current page adds that if the committee finds a violation and that discipline is appropriate, it forwards its recommendations to the Executive Committee or the Board of Direction for a formal hearing.
Perego wrote in 2022: "The process begins with the assumption of innocence." The member may submit a detailed written response, and the 2026 Rules give 30 days for it. If the facts are unclear, the Committee on Professional Conduct asks the state association president to appoint a fact-finding committee of ICMA members; the 2026 Rules set 15 days for the appointment and 60 days from the appointment for the report. That committee gathers facts and does not decide whether the Code was violated, and the member receives a copy of its report. If the member does not respond at all, a fact-finding committee gathers the documentation.
Confidentiality runs through both procedures. Perego wrote that the ICMA review is confidential "unless and until it results in a finding by the ICMA Executive Board that a member has violated the Code." The 2026 Rules bar the complainant and the members of the committee and the Board from discussing pending or completed cases, except where the sanction is made public. ACM's disclosure policy states that "information about the resolution of a complaint will be kept confidential," shared only on a need-to-know basis.
ICMA reported the volume in 2022: more than 12,000 members and 40-50 cases a year.
What sanctions can a professional association impose?
Letters of admonition or corrective action, a letter or a public notice that finds a violation, suspension and expulsion. ICMA can suspend for up to five years and revoke a credential; AICPA suspends for up to two years.
ASCE's Committee on Professional Conduct may recommend a "letter of admonition, suspension, or expulsion," in the words of the 2008 article, and the ASCE Bylaws approved in January 2026 list the outcomes of a professional conduct case as "exoneration, letter of admonition, suspension, or expulsion." The ICMA Rules list sanctions that may be imposed separately or together. The lightest is a letter to the member, the complainant and, as applicable, the state association president stating that the member's conduct violated the Code and that repeated conduct may be cause for more serious sanctions. The next is a public notice of the violation and the sanction, which may include suspension of membership and all related benefits for up to five years, expulsion or a permanent bar on reinstatement, and revocation of the ICMA Credentialed Manager or Credentialed Candidate designation. Every option beyond the letter requires approval by the ICMA Executive Board.
AICPA publishes definitions of each disposition. A letter of required corrective action may require continuing professional education, submission of reports and workpapers, or a pre-issuance review by an outside party. The Joint Trial Board "publicly admonished a member who has violated the Code of Professional Conduct" where the violation does not warrant suspension. The heaviest disposition reads: "The AICPA expelled or suspended a member for a period up to two years."
Suspension removes the rights of membership for its term. A suspended AICPA member may not identify as an AICPA member, vote, or hold committee positions or offices. Other dispositions close a case without a sanction: no prima facie evidence of a violation, dismissal because no provision of the Code applies, and no further action where the committee could not obtain sufficient evidence.
Sanctions can also follow up on the member's work. Under AICPA's "subsequent monitoring completed satisfactorily" disposition, the ethics committee accepted the work product that the member had to submit.
Are ethics sanctions made public?
Some are. AICPA must publish suspensions, expulsions and admonishments but not the terms of corrective action letters. ICMA sends public notices of violations to its membership and, as applicable, the media, and IEEE publishes notices to its membership.
AICPA marks publication as mandatory for expulsion or suspension and for admonishment. For the letter of required corrective action it states: "The AICPA does not publish the terms of the letter of required corrective action."
At ICMA the letter that finds a violation is not made public. A complainant who is not an ICMA member is told that the complaint was considered and resolved and that ICMA took no public action on it. A public notice goes to the member, the complainants, the ICMA membership, the state association president and the fact-finding committee members and, as applicable, to local governing bodies and the media; it states that the member's conduct violated the Code and the nature of the sanction. ASCE, according to the 2008 article, may publish disciplinary actions in ASCE News "with or without the accused member's name."
ACM keeps the resolution of individual complaints confidential but publishes cases in a general form. Its disclosure policy states that "ACM will make publicly available information describing representative policy violations and associated sanctions" and that it "shall collect and make publicly available aggregate data summarizing the number of complaints filed." Awards committees are told when a candidate is under investigation and when a candidate's prior conduct violated the Code.
IEEE publishes notices in IEEE Spectrum when its Board of Directors decides so. The notice of November 10, 2023 names the member and states: "The IEEE Board of Directors also determined that this notification to the IEEE membership should be made."
How did IEEE handle a recent ethics case?
A hearing board found Cause that a Senior Member violated Section II, Subsection 8 of the IEEE Code of Ethics. The Board of Directors sustained the finding and suspended the member for five years under Bylaw I-110.5.
The notice to membership dated November 10, 2023 describes the steps. The complaint went to the Ethics and Member Conduct Committee. A hearing board appointed by the IEEE Board of Directors "found Cause" that the member, "a member in the grade of Senior Member of the IEEE," violated Section II, Subsection 8 of the Code. The Board sustained the findings and "imposed the sanction of a five-year suspension from IEEE membership" "in accordance with IEEE Bylaw I-110.5."
The IEEE Code of Ethics has three parts. The first commits members "To uphold the highest standards of integrity, responsible behavior, and ethical conduct in professional activities." The second, which the 2023 case concerned, reads: "To treat all persons fairly and with respect, to not engage in harassment or discrimination, and to avoid injuring others." The third asks members to work for the code being upheld by colleagues and co-workers.
Can a member appeal an ethics decision?
At ICMA a member can contest a finding before the committee or the Executive Board. At ASCE a formal hearing comes before discipline, and expulsion needs a vote of at least 75% of the Board members present.
The ICMA Rules give the member 15 days after receiving the committee's letter. After a letter that finds a violation, the member may ask the committee to reconsider on new information or appeal to the Executive Board. After a preliminary recommendation of a public sanction, the member may ask for reconsideration or for a hearing before the committee. At a hearing the member may appear in person or online, be represented by an attorney, review the documents in advance, cross-examine a complainant who testifies and present evidence. Hearings take place in executive session, and neither side may record them. The Board may dismiss the case, adopt the committee's findings and sanctions, or amend and adopt them, and it may not increase the recommended sanction unless new documentation shows a more serious violation.
ASCE builds the review into the procedure. Its current ethics page states that the Committee on Professional Conduct forwards its recommendations to the Executive Committee or the Board of Direction for a formal hearing. The 2008 article described that hearing: the member may present a defense in writing or in person and have an attorney present, or accept the committee's recommendation through a consent procedure, and the Executive Committee votes by "secret ballot." Expulsion is decided by the Board. Under the January 2026 Bylaws, 75% of the Board members form a quorum for disciplinary action against a member, and expulsion requires "the affirmative vote of not less than seventy-five percent (75%) of the Board present."
Each association writes these rules into its own documents. ICMA has the Rules of Procedure for Enforcement adopted by its Executive Board. The ASCE Bylaws send professional conduct cases to the Society's Rules of Policy and Procedure. ACM's enforcement policy was adopted by the ACM Council.
Does an association's sanction affect a professional license?
An association acts on membership, a state board on the license. AICPA can suspend or expel a member without a hearing after a CPA license is suspended or revoked, and ASCE may report findings to licensing boards.
AICPA lists the causes for which it may expel or suspend a member "without a hearing," and one of them is the suspension or revocation of a CPA certificate or license to practice. A state action against a CPA license can thus lead to suspension or expulsion from AICPA without a separate hearing.
The connection runs in the other direction too. The 2008 ASCE article states that findings may be reported to state licensing boards or to other engineering organizations.
The IAE Code of Ethics links the two from the member's side: it requires a member to promptly notify the IAE Secretariat of any criminal conviction or professional disciplinary sanction.
How does the IAE Code of Ethics handle violations?
The Superior Credentialing Council decides after written charges, 15 days' notice and a hearing. Sanctions are a corrective order, a warning, suspension or termination, and the member may appeal within 30 days to a panel of the Board.
The IAE Code of Ethics sets standards of conduct binding on all IAE members: Senior Members, CIEs, F.IAE members and Prof.IAE, h.c. titleholders, in every jurisdiction where they practice. By accepting membership, a professional agrees to comply with it, and a violation is grounds for disciplinary proceedings. False expert opinions, concealing a conflict of interest, misrepresenting qualifications or professional memberships, using IAE post-nominals after membership has ended, breaching confidentiality and discrediting colleagues without documented grounds will generally result in immediate suspension and the start of proceedings.
The Council chooses among four sanctions after considering the nature of the violation, its seriousness, its consequences and the member's conduct during the proceedings: a corrective order, which may include additional training; a formal written warning recorded in the member's file; suspension of membership and of the right to use IAE post-nominals for a period set by the Council; and termination of membership with removal from the IAE Registry, for serious or repeated violations.
The Code lists ten procedural safeguards. Proceedings begin only on written charges that state the conduct and the provisions allegedly violated. The member receives notice at least 15 days before the hearing, with copies of all materials relied on, and may respond in writing, present evidence and be heard in person or remotely. Council members with a conflict of interest recuse themselves. Findings rest on the preponderance of the evidence, and every decision is written, with findings, reasons and any sanction. The member may appeal within 30 days to an appellate panel of the Board of Directors, from which conflicted directors are excluded, and the panel's decision is final. Disciplinary records are confidential: IAE may publish only the existence and the nature of a final sanction.
Current members and third parties may report a possible violation to the Secretariat, which normally confirms receipt within one business day; anonymous reports are accepted. The public registry shows the status of each record: valid until a stated date, Suspended or Terminated. Under the IAE Membership Guide, each IAE designation is valid only while the member remains in good standing. Membership starts with an online application, and the Council decides on Senior Member and CIE applications collegially, in writing and with reasons.
Sources
- ASCE, Tara Hoke, ASCE's ethics enforcement process, Civil Engineering, July 2008
- ASCE, Ethics reporting and enforcement
- ASCE Bylaws, approved by the Board of Direction, January 2026
- ICMA, Martha Perego, Ethics Matter! Professional Standards Matter, PM Magazine, August 1, 2022
- ICMA Code of Ethics: Rules of Procedure for Enforcement, revised May 2026
- AICPA and CIMA, Definitions of ethics sanctions and dispositions
- ACM, Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct Enforcement Policy and Procedure
- ACM, Policy on Complaint Process Disclosure
- IEEE Spectrum, Notice to Membership, November 10, 2023
- IEEE Circuits and Systems Society, IEEE Code of Ethics
Read also
All articles
What does "member in good standing" mean in a professional association?
A member in good standing is defined by each association's own bylaws, and the definitions share two elements: dues are paid and the member is not
Professional association, trade association or union: what is the difference?
A professional association enrolls people who practice a profession and sets standards for their work. A trade association speaks for an industry
Are professional association dues tax deductible?
For most employees the answer is no. Federal law has disallowed miscellaneous itemized deductions for every tax year beginning after December 31Membership
Ready to apply for membership?
The Secretariat confirms receipt of the application within one business day. The Council usually decides within 3 business days of receiving the complete set of documents, and no later than 30 days under the Charter.

