Membership

Do professional memberships count toward an expert witness's qualifications?

Federal Rule of Evidence 702 lets a witness testify as an expert if qualified by knowledge, skill, experience, training or education. Membership in a professional association is not on that list. A court looks at what the membership required and what the expert did to earn it. In Austin v. American Association of Neurological Surgeons, the Seventh Circuit upheld a six-month suspension that the association imposed on a neurosurgeon after reviewing his testimony in a malpractice trial.

A blank lapel pin and a face-down card rest by an empty witness chair

What does Rule 702 say about an expert's qualifications?

Rule 702 lets a witness testify as an expert if qualified by knowledge, skill, experience, training or education. The rule does not mention memberships, so a membership counts only as evidence of one of those five bases.

Federal Rule of Evidence 702 opens with one sentence: "A witness who is qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education may testify in the form of an opinion or otherwise" if the party offering the witness shows the court that four conditions are more likely than not met. The testimony must assist the trier of fact, rest on sufficient facts or data, come from reliable principles and methods, and apply those methods reliably to the facts of the case.

The committee note to the 2023 amendment calls this "the preponderance of the evidence standard" and refers to Rule 104(a). The same note says that the other admissibility requirements of the rule, "such as that the expert must be qualified," are governed by the Rule 104(a) standard as well. The qualification question and the reliability questions are decided under one standard of proof.

Memberships are not among the five bases. The committee note to the 2000 amendment says that the text of the rule "expressly contemplates that an expert may be qualified on the basis of experience." A witness who relies solely or primarily on experience "must explain how that experience leads to the conclusion reached, why that experience is a sufficient basis for the opinion, and how that experience is reliably applied to the facts."

A membership therefore enters the analysis through the facts behind it. A grade that required years of practice, published work or case reports is evidence of experience or training. A membership that required only a fee records neither.

Where does a membership appear in the expert's disclosure?

In the written report. Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(iv) requires a retained expert's report to state the witness's qualifications, including all publications of the previous 10 years, and Rule 26(e)(2) requires updates to that information.

Rule 26(a)(2)(A) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires a party to disclose the identity of any witness it may use at trial to present evidence under Rules 702, 703 or 705 of the Federal Rules of Evidence. If the witness is retained or specially employed to give expert testimony in the case, or regularly gives such testimony as the party's employee, the disclosure comes with a written report prepared and signed by the witness, unless the parties stipulate or the court orders otherwise.

The report has six required parts. Item (iv) is "the witness's qualifications, including a list of all publications authored in the previous 10 years." Item (v) is a list of all other cases in which the witness testified as an expert at trial or by deposition during the previous 4 years. The other items are the opinions with their basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, the exhibits, and a statement of the compensation for the study and testimony in the case.

When an expert lists memberships and grades, they are part of the qualifications under item (iv). The duty to keep them accurate does not end when the report is served. Under Rule 26(e)(2), for an expert whose report must be disclosed, the duty to supplement "extends both to information included in the report and to information given during the expert's deposition." Additions or changes must be disclosed by the time the pretrial disclosures under Rule 26(a)(3) are due.

A membership that lapses after the report, a suspension or a change of grade is a change in information included in the report.

Can an association discipline a member for testimony in court?

Yes. In 2001 the Seventh Circuit upheld a six-month suspension that the American Association of Neurological Surgeons imposed on a neurosurgeon after a complaint about his testimony for a malpractice plaintiff.

Donald C. Austin, a neurosurgeon, testified as an expert for a malpractice plaintiff against Dr. Ditmore, a member of the American Association of Neurological Surgeons (AANS). The plaintiff claimed permanent damage to her recurrent laryngeal nerve after an anterior cervical fusion. In 1995 the jury returned a verdict for Ditmore.

Ditmore complained to the AANS, an Illinois not-for-profit voluntary association. After a hearing in 1997, at which Austin and Ditmore both testified, the AANS suspended Austin for six months, and he later resigned. He sued for damages for lost expert-witness income and for expungement of the suspension, without asking for reinstatement. The district court granted summary judgment for the AANS, and the Seventh Circuit affirmed in an opinion by Judge Posner, reported at 253 F.3d 967.

The opinion explains why the membership mattered in the courtroom. Austin had mentioned it in his testimony in the malpractice suit, "a fact he did not neglect to mention," and the court wrote: "Austin boosted his credibility as an expert witness." The court found that the AANS had an interest in stopping a member who would "use his membership to dazzle judges and juries and deflect the close and skeptical scrutiny" of his opinions.

On the merits the court saw "little doubt that his testimony was irresponsible" and that it violated "a number of sensible-seeming provisions of the Association's ethical code." It rejected the argument that such discipline is contrary to public policy: "this kind of professional self-regulation rather furthers than impedes the cause of justice." It added: "More policing of expert witnessing is required, not less." Findings of professional review, in the court's words, are "a datum that judges, jurors, and lawyers are entitled to weigh heavily."

The suspension did not end Austin's work as a witness. The court noted that he continued to practice neurosurgery and to testify "notwithstanding his suspension and subsequent voluntary resignation from the Association." His claim failed under Illinois law, which required that the association's action "jeopardize the principal source of the professional's livelihood."

What do association rules say about memberships and testimony?

Some codes address it directly. ACEP guidelines say experts should be chosen for their experience and not for society offices, and the AAFS bylaws forbid members to misrepresent their membership status in the Academy.

The American College of Emergency Physicians (ACEP) approved its Expert Witness Guidelines for the Specialty of Emergency Medicine in September 1990, revised them in 1995, 2000, 2010 and 2015, and reaffirmed them in June 2021. They list three qualifications for an emergency physician expert: a current license in a U.S. jurisdiction, certification by a recognized certifying body in emergency medicine, and at least three years of active clinical practice of emergency medicine, exclusive of training, "immediately preceding the date of the occurrence giving rise to the case."

One guideline deals with titles held in societies. Expert witnesses "should be chosen on the basis of their experience in the area in which they are providing testimony" and "not on the basis of offices or positions held in medical specialty societies, unless such positions are material to the expertise of the witness." Other guidelines bar testimony that is "false, misleading, or without medical foundation," bar advertising that contains false or deceptive representations about the physician's qualifications, ask the expert to be willing to submit transcripts of depositions and testimony to peer review, and rule out any compensation contingent on the outcome of litigation.

The American Academy of Forensic Sciences (AAFS) puts its Code of Ethics and Conduct in Article II of its bylaws; the version on its website is marked revised March 2024. Section 1(b) reads: "No Member or Affiliate of the Academy shall materially misrepresent his or her education, training, experience, area of expertise, or membership status within the Academy." Section 1(c) forbids material misrepresentation of the data or scientific principles on which an opinion is based. Section 1(d) forbids public statements that appear to represent the position of the Academy without authority from the Board of Directors.

AAFS sanctions follow the gravity of the violation. A member who violated the code within the preceding five years is liable to formal or informal discipline imposed by the Board of Directors. A minor violation can lead to a confidential Letter of Reprimand or to a letter that is not confidential, a serious one to suspension for a specific period, and an egregious one to expulsion. The Ethics Committee orders or conducts investigations, holds hearings when needed and, at a member's request, gives an advisory opinion on conduct the member is only contemplating.

Do all memberships carry the same weight?

No. Grades differ in what they require. At AAFS, advancement to Member or Fellow requires meetings and service and, in many sections, years in the grade, case reports, publications, presentations or recommendations.

The AAFS publishes promotion requirements by section. For promotion of an Associate Member to the Member grade the AAFS lists attendance at a minimum of one meeting, service in forensic science research and service in forensic science education or training. The Anthropology, Criminalistics, Forensic Nursing Science and Toxicology sections require at least two years as an Associate Member. Anthropology asks for any two items among case reports from the last five years, first- or second-authored publications and evidence of teaching or other contributions to applied anthropology. Digital and Multimedia Sciences asks for one letter of reference from a full Member, Fellow, Retired Member or Retired Fellow of the section, and Jurisprudence for one recommendation from a Member or Fellow of the AAFS.

The Fellow grade asks for more. Criminalistics requires at least two years as a full Member, attendance at two annual conferences and three points from listed activities within ten consecutive years; an oral, poster or webinar presentation as presenting author earns one point. Psychiatry and Behavioral Science requires three years as a Member, or one year in the event of participation in a joint session, and board certification or its equivalent. Questioned Documents requires four points from listed activities, such as papers and section presentations, within ten consecutive years and attendance at two annual conferences of the section. Jurisprudence requires two recommendations by Fellows of the section and a law license in good standing or a full-time law professorship.

Under Rule 702 these requirements are the content of a grade. A Fellow grade that required years in the grade, conference attendance and points for papers or presentations is evidence of training and experience in the field. Opposing counsel can ask what the grade required, when the expert received it and whether the membership was current on the date of the report. The AAFS publishes these requirements on its website, so the answers can be checked against the association's own text.

What does an IAE registry record tell a court?

The member's current status and category, the attested specialization, the admission date and the record number. The record page states that a record is not a recommendation for a particular case and does not confirm admissibility.

The IAE public registry is open to courts, agencies, employers and private individuals. A status is checked free of charge and without registration by surname and first name, by a registration number in the format IAE-YYYY-XXXXX or by the QR code on the certificate, which leads to the permanent record page with the same number. If the record is missing or the data differ, the Secretariat checks manually. On request it issues a membership letter with the record number and the verification date.

A record confirms the member's current status and category, the attested specialization, the admission date and registration ID, and the permanent record address with its QR code. The record page states that a record "is not a recommendation for a particular case and does not confirm the admissibility of an opinion in court." Under the IAE Bylaws, IAE statuses and designations are not a court appointment, and IAE may not represent any credential as accepted by a court unless such recognition has been expressly obtained and publicly documented.

Each status has published requirements. Senior Member (SM) requires at least 3 years of documented experience in a recognized field and an education document. Certified International Expert (CIE) requires at least 4 of 6 points under the Criteria Matrix; two Council members assess the application independently, and then the Council votes. F.IAE is conferred by the Council only, without an application.

The IAE Code of Ethics reminds experts that the duty of an expert witness is to assist the court, not the party that retained the expert, and requires them to remain within the limits of their expertise when giving testimony. False or misleading claims about qualifications, experience, academic degrees or professional memberships are a serious violation that will generally result in immediate suspension and disciplinary proceedings, and so is use of SM, CIE, F.IAE or Prof.IAE, h.c. after membership has ended. Membership starts with an online application, and the Council usually decides within 3 business days of receiving the complete set of documents.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Membership

Ready to apply for membership?

The Secretariat confirms receipt of the application within one business day. The Council usually decides within 3 business days of receiving the complete set of documents, and no later than 30 days under the Charter.

Membership application

Received

Confirmation within one business day

CategorySenior Member
Documents7 files
Council decisionup to 3 business days