Expert report review
Rebutting secondary considerations: how is a commercial success opinion tested in an obviousness dispute?
Commercial success, long-felt need and failure of others entered obviousness law through Graham v. John Deere in 1966, where the Supreme Court said such secondary considerations "might be utilized to give light to the circumstances surrounding the origin" of the invention. The Federal Circuit gives this evidence weight only when the patent owner shows a nexus between it and the claimed invention. A rebuttal expert tests that link, claim element by claim element.

Where do secondary considerations come from in an obviousness analysis?
From Graham v. John Deere (1966). After the scope and content of the prior art, the differences from the claims and the level of ordinary skill are resolved, commercial success, long-felt need and failure of others may be considered.
Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1, was decided on February 21, 1966. The Court set out three factual inquiries: "the scope and content of the prior art are to be determined; differences between the prior art and the claims at issue are to be ascertained; and the level of ordinary skill in the pertinent art resolved." It added that "such secondary considerations as commercial success, long felt but unsolved needs, failure of others, etc.," might shed light on the origin of the subject matter and "may have relevancy" as indicia of obviousness or nonobviousness. In the same opinion, on the sprayer patent in the companion cases, the Court wrote that commercial success and long-felt need "do not, in the circumstances of this case, tip the scales of patentability."
KSR International Co. v. Teleflex Inc., decided on April 30, 2007, kept that framework. Justice Kennedy wrote that the Graham factors "continue to define the inquiry that controls," held that the teaching, suggestion or motivation test, when applied as a rigid and mandatory formula, "is incompatible with our precedents," and said that a combination of familiar elements according to known methods "is likely to be obvious when it does no more than yield predictable results." On the record before it, the Court found that "Teleflex has shown no secondary factors to dislodge the determination that claim 4 is obvious."
KSR also warned that "a factfinder should be aware, of course, of the distortion caused by hindsight bias."
What is nexus, and how does the patent owner prove it?
Nexus is the link between the evidence of success and the claimed invention. The proponent shows it through a rebuttable presumption, when the product is coextensive with the claims, or by direct proof that the success comes from the invention.
In Fox Factory, Inc. v. SRAM, LLC, Nos. 2018-2024 and 2018-2025, decided on December 18, 2019, Chief Judge Prost wrote for the Federal Circuit in an appeal from two inter partes reviews. A patentee is entitled to a rebuttable presumption of nexus when the evidence is tied to a specific product that embodies the claimed features and is coextensive with them. The court traced the presumption to the requirement that the product be "the invention disclosed and claimed," and it treated coextensiveness as a question of fact.
Without the presumption, the patentee can still prove nexus. Fox Factory requires a showing that "the product is essentially the claimed invention" and that the evidence of success is a "direct result of the unique characteristics of the claimed invention." In Manufacturing Resources International, Inc. v. Squires, a nonprecedential decision of March 31, 2026, Judge Taranto summarized the rule: "the proponent must show a nexus between the evidence and the claimed invention in one of two ways."
The rebuttal expert's work follows those two routes. Against the presumption, the expert proves that the product is not coextensive with the asserted claim. Against direct proof, the expert traces the sales, the praise or the copying to something other than the claimed invention.
Do unclaimed features in the product defeat the presumption of nexus?
They can. In Fox Factory the X-Sync chainrings had features that SRAM itself called critical but did not claim in the patent at issue, and the court held that no reasonable fact finder could find them coextensive with the claims.
SRAM's U.S. Patent No. 9,182,027 claimed a bicycle chainring with alternating narrow and wide teeth. Its X-Sync chainrings also had a feature claimed only in the continuation, U.S. Patent No. 9,291,250: wide teeth with more than 80% gap filling, which SRAM itself had called critical. The court also identified forwardly protruding tooth tips, hook features and mud-clearing recesses. Because the unclaimed gap-filling feature "materially impacts the product's functionality," the Board erred in presuming nexus, and the court vacated the obviousness determinations and remanded with SRAM bearing the burden of proving nexus.
Fox Factory also rejected two shortcuts. Coextensiveness is not met whenever a claim broadly covers the product, because that approach would turn on "minor variations in patent claim language." And a continuation patent does not share the presumption automatically, since the two patents claimed different combinations of features. The existence of an unclaimed feature alone does not defeat the presumption; the question is how much it matters.
In Campbell Soup Co. v. Gamon Plus, Inc., decided on August 19, 2021, Chief Judge Moore restated the test: "The question is instead whether unclaimed features are 'insignificant,' period." The court held that the Board erred in finding the iQ Maximizer product coextensive with the design claims. In Manufacturing Resources International the evidence concerned Samsung products that included electronic displays the claims did not cover, and the court wrote that showing those features were insignificant "was a prerequisite to a presumption of nexus."
Does success that comes from features already in the prior art count?
No. In Asyst v. Emtrak (2008) and Campbell Soup v. Gamon (2021) the Federal Circuit gave the evidence no weight because the success and the praise traced to features the prior art already disclosed.
In Asyst Technologies, Inc. v. Emtrak, Inc., No. 2007-1554, decided on October 10, 2008, Judge Bryson affirmed judgment as a matter of law that claims of Asyst's patent were invalid for obviousness. Asyst offered commercial success, long-felt need and industry praise. The court pointed to "Asyst's failure to link that commercial success to the features of its invention that were not disclosed in Hesser," the prior art reference. The praise addressed the system as a whole, and the problems the evidence described were problems Hesser had already solved.
Campbell Soup reached the same result for a design patent. The evidence of commercial success and praise "merely ties commercial success and praise to aspects of the label area that were already present in the prior art," and the court held that objective indicia "must be linked to a design patent claim's unique characteristics," as in the utility patent context.
Fox Factory applied the rule to combination claims. When a claim combines features each known in the prior art, the evidence must be attributable to the claimed combination, and not to unclaimed features or to one of the known features alone. The same evidence cannot be attributed to two different feature combinations.
Can secondary considerations overcome a strong prima facie case of obviousness?
Not always. The Federal Circuit wrote in Asyst that such evidence "does not always overcome a strong prima facie showing of obviousness," and in Campbell Soup it assumed copying and still held the designs obvious.
In Asyst the court concluded that the secondary-considerations evidence did not overcome the strong case of obviousness built on Hesser. In Campbell Soup the court assumed that substantial evidence supported copying but held that "this alone does not overcome the strong evidence of obviousness that Linz provides." It reversed the Board and held the claimed designs obvious over Linz.
Manufacturing Resources International shows how the weighing goes on the facts. The patent owner argued that Samsung bought its displays, tore them down and copied the cooling system. The Board found that Samsung's displays "were completely designed before the teardown" and, relying on "credible deposition testimony by a witness with relevant personal knowledge," found no copying; the Federal Circuit saw no error. It also upheld the Board's finding of "insufficient nexus" between a Samsung employee's "vague praise" and the claimed features, and it affirmed the Board's decision to give the objective indicia "little weight."
A rebuttal that removes the nexus for one category of evidence leaves the others standing. The challenger's expert therefore addresses each category the patent owner raises: sales, licensing, praise, copying and long-felt need.
What does a rebuttal expert check in a commercial success opinion?
Whether the product practices every element of the asserted claim, which unclaimed features the product has and how significant they are, which claimed features were in the prior art, and whether the sales or praise trace to the novel features.
The first check is the mapping of the product to the claim. The presumption requires a product that embodies the claimed features and is coextensive with them, so the rebuttal expert reads each element of each asserted claim against the product's documentation, and does so separately for each patent when continuations are asserted, as in Fox Factory.
The second check is an inventory of what the product has beyond the claim. Fox Factory listed gap filling, tooth tips, hooks and recesses; Manufacturing Resources International turned on electronic displays. For each feature the expert states what it does in the product and how the patent owner's own documents describe it, because SRAM's description of the gap-filling feature as critical weighed against the presumption.
The third check is the prior art. Asyst and Campbell Soup gave no weight to success traced to features the prior art already disclosed. The rebuttal expert identifies, for each feature the patent owner credits for the success, whether that feature appears in the references of record.
The fourth check is the data. Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(ii) requires the opening report to list "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming" the opinions, and Rule 26(b)(4)(C) leaves discoverable the facts, data and assumptions that the party's attorney provided and that the expert considered or relied on. Sales figures, market reports and the dates of any alleged copying are requested on that basis, and the timeline of alleged copying is checked against evidence of when the accused product was designed, as in Manufacturing Resources International, where the Board found that Samsung's displays were designed before the teardown.
When is the rebuttal report due, and what must it contain?
Unless a stipulation or court order sets another date, within 30 days after the other party's disclosure, when the evidence is intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter (Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii)).
Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure covers evidence "intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter identified by another party under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) or (C)." Such a disclosure is due "within 30 days after the other party's disclosure." A stipulation or a court order can set other dates, and then those dates govern.
A retained expert's rebuttal report contains the same six parts as any other report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B): a complete statement of all opinions and the basis and reasons for them; the facts or data considered; exhibits; the witness's qualifications, including publications authored in the previous 10 years; a list of cases in which the witness testified as an expert at trial or by deposition during the previous 4 years; and a statement of compensation.
Under Rule 26(b)(4)(A), a party may depose any person identified as an expert whose opinions may be presented at trial, and when a report is required the deposition may be taken only after the report is provided. Drafts of the report are protected under Rule 26(b)(4)(B). Communications between the attorney and the expert are protected under Rule 26(b)(4)(C), except those about compensation and those that identify facts, data or assumptions the attorney provided.
How does the court test a commercial success opinion under Rule 702?
Since December 1, 2023, the proponent must show the court it is more likely than not that the opinion is based on sufficient facts or data, comes from reliable principles and methods, and applies them reliably to the case.
Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, as amended effective December 1, 2023, admits expert opinion if the proponent establishes that it is more likely than not that the expert's knowledge will help the trier of fact, that "the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data," that it "is the product of reliable principles and methods," and that the opinion applies those principles and methods reliably to the facts of the case (subparagraph (d)).
The 2023 committee note addressed courts that had treated the sufficiency of an expert's basis as a question of weight: "These rulings are an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a)." A commercial success opinion that counts total sales of a product with significant unclaimed features, without attributing the sales to the claimed features, gives the opposing party a ground to argue under subparagraphs (b) and (d).
In KSR the Supreme Court described the role of expert testimony on obviousness as testimony "which may resolve or keep open certain questions of fact," and held summary judgment appropriate where the relevant facts "are not in material dispute, and the obviousness of the claim is apparent."
Do the same nexus rules apply before the PTAB?
Yes. Fox Factory, Campbell Soup and Manufacturing Resources International were appeals from inter partes reviews, and the Federal Circuit reviewed the Board's nexus findings under the same presumption and the same linking requirement.
In Fox Factory the Board had presumed nexus for SRAM's chainrings. The Federal Circuit vacated, affirmed the Board's finding that a skilled artisan would have been motivated to combine the prior art references, and remanded so that SRAM could try to prove nexus to the claimed combination without the presumption. It also remanded one review so that the Board could consider grounds it had not instituted.
In Campbell Soup the Federal Circuit found no substantial evidence of nexus for commercial success and praise and reversed the Board's decisions that the petitioners had failed to prove unpatentability. In Manufacturing Resources International the court affirmed the Board's decisions holding all challenged claims of U.S. Patent Nos. 8,854,595 and 9,173,322 unpatentable as obvious, and held that the Board's explanation of the "little weight" it gave the objective indicia enabled meaningful review.
What does IAE do when the other side relies on commercial success?
An IAE expert reviews the opposing technical expert's report or prepares a report on validity over the prior art and obviousness, for district court cases and PTAB proceedings, in up to 5 business days.
The reviewer checks whether every opinion is tied to the claim language and the evidence: each element mapped, the court's claim construction applied, sufficient facts or data under Rule 702(b). Each finding is tied to a claim element, a page of the opposing report and a rule or decision. For validity, an IAE expert searches the prior art before the effective filing date and addresses obviousness: the differences between the claim and the prior art, for a person of ordinary skill.
IAE chooses the expert by the technical field of the patent and confirms the patent, the asserted claims and the questions before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the expert from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every expert is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix; the Member ID or QR code in the document opens the record. The expert confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case, and materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. A review is evidence that the court or the Board weighs with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1 (1966) (LII)
- KSR International Co. v. Teleflex Inc., 550 U.S. 398 (2007), opinion of the Court (LII)
- Fox Factory, Inc. v. SRAM, LLC, Nos. 2018-2024, 2018-2025 (Fed. Cir. Dec. 18, 2019)
- Campbell Soup Co. v. Gamon Plus, Inc., Nos. 2020-2344, 2021-1019 (Fed. Cir. Aug. 19, 2021)
- Manufacturing Resources International, Inc. v. Squires, Nos. 2024-2228, 2024-2229 (Fed. Cir. Mar. 31, 2026) (nonprecedential)
- Asyst Technologies, Inc. v. Emtrak, Inc., No. 2007-1554 (Fed. Cir. Oct. 10, 2008)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with committee notes (LII)
Read also
All articles
Enablement and written description in the opposing invalidity report: what does a reviewer check after Amgen v. Sanofi?
An invalidity report under 35 U.S.C. 112 says that the patent's specification does not describe the invention or does not teach a skilled person
Is the opposing patent expert a person of ordinary skill in the art, and what follows if not?
Claim construction, obviousness and infringement are all judged through the eyes of a person having ordinary skill in the art. In Kyocera Senco
Amended, reissued or published claims: which version must the opposing expert compare with the product?
An infringement comparison is only as good as the claim it uses. Claims change after filing: they are published in an application, allowedExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

