Expert report review
Building in a utility easement: how does the survey prove the encroachment, and when must the structure come down?
A structure built inside an easement stays or goes on two things: the words of the easement and the measurements on the ground. In a 2011 case against Georgia Power Co. the Georgia Court of Appeals upheld an order to remove a garage built in a 100-foot power line easement. In Halbrooks v. Durieux the Tennessee Court of Appeals in 2014 let a building in an access easement stay because it did not unreasonably interfere.

Can the landowner build anything inside an easement?
Only what is consistent with the easement. The servient owner may use the land in any way that does not unreasonably interfere with the holder's rights, unless the easement's own terms set a stricter rule.
In Halbrooks v. Durieux, decided by the Tennessee Court of Appeals on June 30, 2014 (No. M2013-00958-COA-R3-CV), the court restated the general rule: the owner of the servient estate may use his property in any manner consistent with the existence of the easement, but may not unreasonably interfere with the easement holder's rights. The holder bears the burden of proving unreasonable interference, and reasonableness depends on all the circumstances. The court relied on decisions under which a gate across an access easement should not be enjoined as long as the dominant estate has reasonable access, and it noted that it knew of no Tennessee case addressing a building on an easement.
The easement document can change that test. In the Georgia Power case, decided by the Georgia Court of Appeals on February 17, 2011 (No. A10A2184, 308 Ga. App. 341), the court treated the easement as a contract, read it under contract rules and held that its construction was a question of law. Under the opinion, the landowner may use the land under the easement only to the extent the use does not violate the easement's terms, and a use that violates them is a trespass on the easement.
A review therefore starts with the instrument: who holds the easement, how it was created, how wide it is, what the holder may build and clear, and what words limit the owner's use. Only then do the measurements mean anything.
Why did the court order the garage removed in the Georgia Power case?
Because the recorded easement let the utility clear obstructions, objects and structures. A 20-by-20-foot garage between two poles violated those terms, so the court affirmed summary judgment for trespass and an injunction requiring removal.
Georgia Power acquired a 100-foot-wide easement by condemnation in 1955, and the easement was recorded. It granted the rights to construct, operate and maintain towers, frames and poles and to clear undergrowth, trees and other obstructions, objects and structures. A 115,000-volt transmission line ran through it.
The landowner bought the property in 2006 and began building a 20-by-20-foot garage within the easement under a building permit. Georgia Power asked him to remove it before it was finished, and he refused. An affidavit of the utility's right-of-way specialist placed the garage 70 feet from one pole and 25 feet from another.
The court did not decide whether the garage actually interfered with the operation or maintenance of the line. It held that the utility's right to keep the right of way clear of obstructions, objects and structures allowed removal, and noted that the easement barred any use that interferes, whether or not the interference is substantial. It also rejected the argument that the trial court had banned every encroachment: the ruling concerned this particular structure between two poles. The trial court had denied summary judgment on Georgia Power's claim for attorney fees under OCGA 13-6-11 because of disputed facts, and the appeal concerned only the encroachment.
Why did the building stay in Halbrooks v. Durieux?
The trial court found that the easement holder still had reasonable access, so the building did not unreasonably interfere. The court of appeals affirmed, but the owner was ordered to remove the part that crossed onto the neighbor's land.
The easement was an express ingress, egress and utility line easement over a 50-foot strip created by deed. The servient owner built a concrete block building with retaining walls on the strip between 1993 and 1995 and added to it in 2008 and 2009; by April 2010 the roof reached about ten inches further, onto the easement holder's land.
Surveyor Boyd Gibbs surveyed the property in October 2009 and April 2010, and the parties agreed that the April survey accurately showed the property and easement lines. He testified that the building was entirely within the easement and partly across the holder's boundary, an encroachment of about 112 square feet, and recommended a driveway site 150 to 200 feet north of the house. Witnesses disagreed about whether vehicles could pass along the strip: Gibbs said two cars could pass, while others said a parked car or the house blocked the way.
The trial court found that the holder had reasonable access through Pike Lane and several hundred feet of unobstructed strip, so the building did not currently interfere unreasonably. It warned that the building would have to go if the easement became more burdensome or the holder needed full access, and it ordered the owner to remove either the portion outside the strip or the whole building, and to restore the land. The Court of Appeals affirmed.
What does the survey have to show in an easement encroachment case?
The easement's location and width from the recorded instrument, the structure's footprint including roof overhangs, distances to utility poles or lines, the property boundary and the access that remains around the structure.
Each of the two cases rested on measured facts. In the Georgia Power case the garage's distances to the two poles, 70 and 25 feet, came from a right-of-way specialist's affidavit. In Halbrooks the agreed April 2010 survey located the building inside the easement and its roof ten inches over the boundary, and the area of the encroachment, about 112 square feet, came from the surveyor.
The survey therefore has to tie the easement to the record and the structure to the ground in the same coordinate frame. The easement width is taken from the instrument, not from the fence or the edge of a gravel drive. The structure is located at its furthest points, which for a building with eaves is the roof line, not the foundation. Utility poles, towers and lines are located with their distances to the structure.
Where the test is unreasonable interference, the survey also has to show what access remains: the width of the passable strip, the grades and the alternative routes. In Halbrooks the witnesses disagreed about whether vehicles could pass, and the trial court found reasonable access through Pike Lane and several hundred feet of unobstructed strip.
Does a building permit protect a structure in an easement?
Not in the Georgia Power case. The garage was being built under a building permit, and the court still affirmed the injunction requiring its removal, because the easement's terms gave the utility the right to clear structures.
The landowner began building his garage under a building permit, and the utility's recorded easement still controlled. The opinion's reasoning rests on the easement's terms, and the permit did not change them.
For a review this means that a permit, a certificate of occupancy or an approved site plan does not answer the question of whether the structure is inside the easement. The answer comes from the easement document and the survey.
Which test applies: any interference or unreasonable interference?
It depends on the easement's wording. The Georgia Power easement barred any use that interferes, while the general rule applied in Halbrooks asks whether the servient owner's use unreasonably interferes with the holder's rights.
In the Georgia Power case the court noted that the easement barred any use that interferes, substantial or not, and that the utility's right to clear structures was enough without proof of actual interference with the line. In Halbrooks there was no such clause, so the holder had to prove that the building unreasonably interfered with access, and the trial court found that it did not.
The difference changes what the surveyor measures. Under a clearing clause the key fact is the presence of the structure inside the easement. Under a reasonableness test the key facts are the remaining access and the burden the structure places on the holder's use, and the review checks whether the opposing survey measured them at all.
What does a review of the opposing encroachment survey check?
Whether the easement is plotted from the recorded instrument, whether the structure is located at its outermost points, whether distances and areas follow from the measurements, and whether the survey shows the access that remains.
First the record: which deed or condemnation order created the easement, whether it was recorded, its stated width and the reference line from which the width runs. A strip drawn from the centerline of a power line and a strip drawn from a property line give different results, and the review states which one the instrument requires.
Then the structure. The review checks whether the survey located the foundation or the roof line, whether additions built later were included, as the 2008 and 2009 additions were in Halbrooks, and whether the area of encroachment computes from the coordinates shown. Then the boundary: if part of the structure crosses onto the neighbor's land, as in Halbrooks, that is a separate encroachment with its own remedy.
Last, the access. Where the case turns on unreasonable interference, the review checks whether the survey shows the width of the remaining passage, the grades and the alternative routes, and whether those figures come from measurement or from estimate.
What does IAE do when the other side's survey places a structure in an easement?
IAE prepares a review of the opposing surveyor's report, deposition questions and a rebuttal survey report for boundary, quiet title and encroachment cases. Delivery takes up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
The reviewer reads the opposing survey with its field notes, plats and record documents and checks which records the survey used, which monuments it found and how its measurements compare with the record. For an easement encroachment this includes the instrument that created the easement, the reference line of its width and the measured outline of the structure. A rebuttal survey report is due within 30 days after the opposing disclosure unless the court sets other dates.
For an expert report on the client's questions, the surveyor collects the deeds, recorded plats and original field notes for the parcel and its neighbors, searches for the original monuments, measures with GNSS and a total station and compares measured bearings and distances with the calls in each deed. Fences, driveways and buildings are located relative to the line. Send the deeds, plats and any prior surveys with your request.
The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush. Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, verified by Member ID or QR code. The court weighs a review together with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the surveyor guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
Read also
All articles
The other side relies on a county GIS map: is it evidence of the boundary, and what does a reviewing surveyor check?
County GIS parcel lines are drawn for assessment, and the counties that publish them say so. Sedgwick County, Kansas, describes its boundaries as
Adverse possession survey: what does a reviewer check in the opposing surveyor's map of the claimed strip?
An adverse possession claim to a strip of a neighbor's land stands on two maps: the record line and the area actually possessed. The opposing
Partition in kind: how is the surveyor's division of co-owned land reviewed?
In a partition in kind the court divides co-owned land into separate parcels instead of selling it. In Florida three commissioners make the divisionExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

