Expert report review
Cell tower location evidence: how does a reviewer test the other side's cell-site analysis?
A cell-site report plots the towers a phone used and argues that the phone, and its owner, were near a place at a certain time. The records behind the report name a tower and a sector, never a street address. A review of the other side's report checks which records were used, how the sectors were drawn and whether the conclusion claims more precision than the data hold.

What do cell-site records record?
They record which cell site and sector handled a call, a text or a data session, and when. They do not record where inside the sector the phone was or who was holding it.
The Supreme Court described the technology in Carpenter v. United States, decided June 22, 2018. Cell sites typically have several directional antennas that divide the covered area into sectors, and each time a phone connects to a cell site it generates a time-stamped record. The precision of that record, the Court wrote, "depends on the size of the geographic area covered by the cell site."
The Scientific Working Group on Digital Evidence (SWGDE) states the limit in its Recommendations for Historical Cell Site Analysis, version 3.0, dated March 3, 2025. Section 4 says the analysis establishes only the specific cell site and sector that a device used at a date and time. The same section says call detail records "do not conclusively indicate who was using a device" and that sector data cannot be used to pinpoint the exact location of a device.
A reviewer starts by sorting the statements in the opposing report into two groups: what the records say and what the analyst inferred. A statement that a phone used a named sector at a named minute is a record. A statement that a person was at an address is an inference with at least two more steps in it: where in the sector the phone was, and who carried it.
How precise is a location taken from tower records?
It depends on the size of the sector. In Carpenter the government said the records placed the phone in a sector of between one-eighth of a square mile and four square miles. The Seventh Circuit speaks of a "general area."
In Carpenter the government obtained 12,898 location points cataloging the defendant's movements over 127 days. The government's own description, quoted in the opinion, was that the records placed him within a wedge-shaped sector of between one-eighth of a square mile and four square miles.
The Court added that "the greater the concentration of cell sites, the smaller the coverage area," and that the accuracy of cell-site location information "is rapidly approaching GPS-level precision." Density differs by place and by year. A reviewer therefore asks what the network around the relevant towers looked like on the date in question and does not accept a figure borrowed for another city or another decade.
In United States v. Hill, decided March 21, 2016, Chief Judge Diane Wood wrote for the Seventh Circuit that historical cell-site analysis "can show with sufficient reliability that a phone was in a general area." A report that names a building, an intersection or a parking lot has to explain what data carried it past a general area.
Does a phone always connect to the nearest tower?
No. The Seventh Circuit wrote in Hill that the user's proximity is a significant factor in which tower a phone connects to, but "it is not the only one." A report built on the nearest-tower assumption needs support.
The Hill opinion lists the other factors: the towers' technical aspects, including geography and topography; the angle, number and directions of the antennas on the sites; the technical characteristics of the relevant phone; and environmental and geographical factors.
The SWGDE recommendations add that neighboring cell sites "can affect the outer boundaries of a target cell site's coverage area" and that coverage "is not always uniform across all sectors" and differs between cell sites. Section 6.3 calls it necessary to have the neighboring cell site locations and information; with them, the section says, the analysis is conducted more thoroughly.
The reviewer checks whether the opposing analyst obtained the neighboring sites and used them, or drew each sector as if the tower stood alone. A call that the report assigns to the scene may sit in an area where two or three sectors of different towers overlap.
What do the wedges on the expert's map mean?
They are illustrations. SWGDE says a sector line is for illustration purposes only and is not the exact coverage area, and the half-power edge of a sector should not be treated as its absolute edge.
A shaded wedge that ends a few blocks past the scene can be read as a boundary the phone could not have crossed. SWGDE's definition of a sector line says otherwise: the line is "for illustration purposes only." Section 10.4 says the half-power edge "should not be considered the absolute edge of the sector coverage."
Section 10.5 says actual beamwidth should be used instead of optimal beamwidth, because actual beamwidth is closer to the true sector angle. Section 10.1 notes that orientation cannot be determined for an omni-directional cell site. Section 12 asks for legends and distance scales that present proportionally accurate maps.
The reviewer measures the wedges in the opposing exhibits: the azimuth, the angle and the drawn radius. If the radius has no source in the carrier's data or in a survey, the report should say that the length of the wedge is the analyst's choice.
Which records does the reviewer need?
The call detail records as the carrier produced them, the cell site list valid for the period, the neighboring sites, the carrier's key to the record fields, the time zone used and the analyst's working files.
Section 6.3 of the SWGDE recommendations tells the analyst to obtain "a cell site list for the appropriate time period." The document gives an example: a 2016 list is not used to analyze 2011 records. The same section says the appropriate time zone must be determined for the location of the device.
Section 7.1 says providers produce records in various formats and recommends requesting a CDR reference document, also known as a carrier key, from each provider when legal process is served. Section 6.5 asks the analyst to document "where, how, when, and by whom the data was obtained," and section 7.1.1 says to retain any hash values the provider supplies.
In a federal criminal case, Rule 16(a)(1)(G) of the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure requires the government, on the defendant's request, to disclose in writing a complete statement of all opinions it will elicit, the bases and reasons for them, the witness's qualifications with publications of the previous 10 years, and a list of cases in the previous 4 years in which the witness testified as an expert. The witness must approve and sign the disclosure, with narrow exceptions stated in the rule.
Rule 16(a)(1)(F) separately covers the results or reports of any scientific test or experiment in the government's possession that are material to preparing the defense. Counsel can cite that provision when requesting the data of a drive test and its raw log.
Does a drive test or an RF survey settle where the coverage reached?
Only for the day it was run. SWGDE says a survey is a sample of cellular coverage as it existed when the survey was undertaken and may or may not match conditions at the time of the event.
Some reports add a radio frequency survey: an analyst drives the area with measuring equipment and records which sector serves each point. SWGDE section 4 says a survey represents "a sample of cellular coverage as it existed at the time the survey was undertaken." Its results, the section continues, may or may not match the RF conditions that existed at the time of an event.
The same section says RF estimates "are theoretical in nature and differ from a radio frequency survey." A coverage plot generated by software is an estimate, and the report should label it as one.
Many reports have neither a survey nor an estimate. In Hill the agent acknowledged that he did not know the tower's power or the direction of its antennas and had not tested its coverage area. The Seventh Circuit affirmed the admission of his testimony. The agent had emphasized to the jury that the phone's use of a cell site did not mean the defendant was right at that tower or at any particular spot near it.
What do timing advance and similar distance records add?
They give an estimated distance between the antenna and the phone, drawn as an arc inside the sector. SWGDE says provider coordinates in such records are not intended to give an exact location of a device.
The SWGDE recommendations define what they call specialized historic location data: round trip time or delay, per call measurement data, timing advance and other ranging data. The definition says such data provide "distance from cell site antenna estimates along an arc within sectors." Section 10.6 adds that providers keep these records for a relatively short time and that preservation requests should be made as soon as possible after an incident.
Section 10.6 recommends mapping such data at the listed approximate distance from the cell site within the provided sector. Where a provider's record includes latitude and longitude, the coordinates are generated from a proprietary algorithm and "are not intended to provide an exact location of a device." Confidence levels are provided in some cases.
A reviewer checks three things in a report that uses these records: whether the arc was drawn at the distance the record lists, whether a point was plotted where the record supports only an arc, and whether the confidence value the provider supplied appears in the report.
Must the witness who presents the tower records be an expert?
Maryland's highest court said yes in 2014: a detective who interpreted call detail records and plotted tower locations should have been qualified as an expert. SWGDE notes that courts generally require expert qualification.
In State v. Payne and Bond, filed December 11, 2014, Detective Brian Edwards of the Baltimore County Police Department testified without being qualified as an expert. He trimmed Sprint Nextel call detail records to the relevant calls, used cell tower IDs to derive tower locations and plotted them on maps relative to the crime scene.
Judge Battaglia wrote for the Court of Appeals of Maryland that the detective "should have been qualified as an expert witness under Maryland Rule 5-702." A call detail record, the court said, "contains a string of data unfamiliar to a layperson." The court vacated the judgment of the Court of Special Appeals and directed that the case be remanded to the circuit court for a new trial.
Expert status has consequences for the review. An expert must disclose opinions and their bases, can be questioned on method and error, and has to meet the reliability rule of the jurisdiction. If the other side offers its analyst as a lay witness, the reviewer's list of what the witness did with the records supports the objection.
How have federal courts ruled on challenges to cell-site testimony?
The Seventh Circuit affirmed admission of historical cell-site analysis in Hill in 2016 but cautioned the government to state the level of precision. It noted that a district court had rejected one agent's "granulization" theory.
In Hill the court found that the science and methods behind the technique "are understood and well documented" and that the technique "has been subjected to publication and peer criticism, if not peer review." It also recorded a gap: "A mathematical error rate has not been calculated."
Then came the caution. The court told the government not to present historical cell-site evidence "without clearly indicating" the level of precision or imprecision with which the evidence pinpoints a person's location at a given time. Evidence that overpromises on the technique's precision, or fails to account adequately for its potential flaws, "may well be an abuse of discretion."
The court also pointed to United States v. Evans, 892 F. Supp. 2d 949 (N.D. Ill. 2012). As the Seventh Circuit recounts that decision, the district court admitted traditional historical cell-site analysis but rejected the same agent's theory of "granulization," which the Hill opinion describes as "novel" and "wholly untested."
Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, as amended effective December 1, 2023, puts the burden on the proponent to show that it is more likely than not that the testimony rests on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods, and applies them reliably to the facts of the case. The committee note says the judge should, where possible, receive an estimate of the known or potential rate of error.
Does it matter how the records were obtained?
Yes, for counsel. Carpenter held that the government's acquisition of historical cell-site records was a Fourth Amendment search and that the government must generally obtain a warrant supported by probable cause.
The Court held that "an individual maintains a legitimate expectation of privacy in the record of his physical movements" as captured through cell-site location information. Whether a particular order or warrant met that standard is a legal question for the attorney, and the reviewer does not answer it.
The reviewer's part is factual. The legal process fixes which numbers, which dates and which record types the carrier was asked for. The reviewer compares that scope with the records the analyst used and notes any record that falls outside the dates or the account named in the process, and any requested record type that the report never mentions.
Can another analyst repeat the mapping?
SWGDE says the approach should be well documented and reproducible, the analysis should undergo technical review, and analysts must be able to verify software results by manual mapping of sampled data.
Mapping software turns thousands of rows into wedges in seconds. Section 11 of the SWGDE recommendations says analysts "must be able to verify results by manual mapping of sampled data," that the analysis "should undergo technical review" and that approaches "should be well documented and reproducible."
A reviewer runs the same check as an outsider. A sample of calls is taken, each tower ID is looked up in the cell site list for the period, the azimuth is read and the sector is drawn by hand. A mismatch between that drawing and the opposing exhibit points to a wrong tower list, a wrong time zone or a setting in the software.
Section 8 adds that preliminary reports should carry a disclaimer that the product is in draft form. Where the file contains several versions of a map, the reviewer lists what changed between them.
What does IAE do when the other side relies on a cell-site report?
IAE reviews the opposing digital forensics report and can prepare a rebuttal expert report. Format, cost, deadline and specialist are confirmed before work starts; the review takes up to 5 business days.
The IAE service page is addressed to attorneys who received the other side's digital forensics report on messages, files, phones or computers. The reviewer checks whether another examiner could repeat the work: matching hash values, the tool and version that extracted the data, the time zone of each timestamp and whether each conclusion follows from the data. The reviewer ties each finding to a page of the opposing report and to a rule or a published practice. A party with a cell-site report sends the report or the case materials and describes what to check. Before work starts IAE confirms the review questions, the devices or images involved and how the data reach the reviewer.
The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. IAE then confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist chosen in its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- Carpenter v. United States, No. 16-402 (U.S. June 22, 2018), opinion of the Court (LII)
- United States v. Hill, No. 14-2019 (7th Cir. March 21, 2016) (Justia)
- State v. Payne and Bond, No. 85, September Term 2013 (Court of Appeals of Maryland, December 11, 2014)
- SWGDE 17-F-001, Recommendations for Historical Cell Site Analysis, Version 3.0 (March 3, 2025)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with Committee Notes (LII)
- Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, Rule 16, Discovery and Inspection (LII)
Read also
All articles
Does an IP address identify a person, and how does a reviewer test the other side's expert who ties an IP address to a defendant?
An IP address identifies a network connection at a moment in time. The internet service provider can name the subscriber who pays for that
Who pays for a review of the opposing digital forensics report, and can the fee be recovered?
The party that retains a reviewer of the opposing digital forensics report pays the reviewer. The other side pays only for the time it spends
Who is qualified to review a digital forensics report, and how are the opposing examiner's qualifications tested?
A digital forensics expert is qualified for an opinion when knowledge, skill, experience, training or education supports that opinion in the field itExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

