Expert report review
Does an IP address identify a person, and how does a reviewer test the other side's expert who ties an IP address to a defendant?
An IP address identifies a network connection at a moment in time. The internet service provider can name the subscriber who pays for that connection. Whether the subscriber is the person who acted is a separate fact. The Ninth Circuit held in 2018 that being the registered subscriber of an infringing IP address, standing alone, did not create a reasonable inference that the subscriber was the infringer.

Does an IP address identify a person?
No. It identifies a connection to the internet at a given time. The provider's records name the account holder for that connection, and many people and devices can use one connection.
A home router receives one public IP address from the provider. Every phone, laptop and television in the house reaches the internet through that address. So do guests on the Wi-Fi and, if the network is open, neighbors. The provider sees the router; the website sees the address.
The Ninth Circuit put it this way in Cobbler Nevada v. Gonzales: "multiple devices can access the internet under the same IP address," and "that connection does not mean that the internet subscriber is also the infringer."
An opposing expert who writes that "the defendant" downloaded a file or posted a message, when the data show only an address, has moved two steps beyond the evidence. The first step goes past the address to the account; the second goes past the account to a person.
What did the Ninth Circuit decide in Cobbler Nevada v. Gonzales?
That a bare allegation that a defendant is the registered subscriber of an IP address associated with infringing activity is not sufficient to state a claim for direct or contributory copyright infringement.
Thomas Gonzales ran an adult care home in Portland, Oregon. Its internet service was accessible to residents and visitors. Cobbler Nevada, the owner of the film The Cobbler, traced BitTorrent downloads to an IP address, and records from Comcast identified Gonzales as the subscriber for that address.
Gonzales declined to share resident and staff names without a court order. His deposition gave no new information about who downloaded the film; he testified that he and the staff had tried to find the person and told everyone to stop. Cobbler Nevada sued Gonzales for direct and contributory infringement.
The Ninth Circuit held that Gonzales's "status as the registered subscriber of an infringing IP address, standing alone, does not create a reasonable inference that he is also the infringer." A plaintiff must "plead factual allegations that create a reasonable inference that the defendant is the infringer." The court also affirmed the district court's award to Gonzales under 17 U.S.C. 505 of $17,222.40 in attorney's fees and $252.20 in costs.
Why does the time of each log entry matter so much?
Because addresses are reassigned. RFC 6302 recommends timestamps accurate to the second from a traceable source such as NTP, preferably in UTC, because a time zone offset can be lost in the reporting chain.
A provider assigns an address to a customer for a period and can then give it to someone else. If the website logged 23:59 in its own time zone and the provider read the time as UTC, the lookup may return the customer who held the address hours earlier or later.
RFC 6302 asks for a timestamp accurate to the second, taken from a traceable source such as the Network Time Protocol. It prefers UTC over local time with an offset, because the offset "can be lost in the reporting chain."
The reviewer reconstructs the chain: the time format in the original log, the time zone of the server, each conversion in the subpoena to the provider, the time zone of the provider's answer. A one-hour error on the day clocks change for daylight saving time can return a different customer.
What do the provider's subscriber records actually show?
The name and address on the account that held the IP address at the time asked about, and sometimes the period of the assignment. They do not show which device or which person in the household used the connection.
Under 18 U.S.C. 2702(c)(6) a provider may disclose a record or other information pertaining to a subscriber "to any person other than a governmental entity." In civil cases, subscriber records come in response to a subpoena, and in Cobbler the Comcast records named Gonzales.
The reviewer reads the subpoena and the answer side by side. Was the question for one timestamp or for a range? Did the answer give the assignment period or only a name? Did the provider state the time zone of its records?
The subscriber record is the end of what the provider knows. Everything that follows in an opposing report, the device, the user, the intent, comes from other evidence, and the report should name it.
What evidence can link an IP address to a specific person?
Evidence from inside the network and from the devices: router logs that tie the activity to a device, the device itself with traces of the activity, account logins, and testimony about who used the connection when.
A router may log which internal device used which connection at what time. A seized laptop may hold the downloaded file, the program that downloaded it or the browser history that matches the website's log. An account login from the same address at the same minute narrows the circle further.
Cobbler shows the opposite case. The plaintiff deposed the subscriber, learned that many residents and visitors used the network and got nothing more. The court found that the address and the subscriber's name were all the plaintiff had.
When the opposing report attributes activity to a named person, the reviewer lists each link in the chain and the evidence for it: address to account, account to device, device to person. A link without its own evidence is a gap in the report.
What if the address belongs to a VPN, a proxy or a public network?
Then the provider's subscriber is the VPN service, the business or the hotspot operator, and the trail to a person depends on that operator's own records. The opposing report should say who holds the address.
Public registries list which organization an address block is assigned to. If the address belongs to a hosting company or a VPN service, a subpoena to the access provider leads to that company, and what it can tell depends on what it logged.
A café, a hotel, a library or an office network gives one address to many users. The operator may know which device connected, by hardware address or login, if it kept those logs and if they cover the minute in question.
An opposing expert who looked up the address and found a residential account should say how the lookup was done and on what date. Registry data change over time, and the reviewer checks whether the lookup matched the date of the activity.
How do these points fit a Rule 702 challenge?
Rule 702 requires sufficient facts or data and a reliable application of the method to the case. An attribution that skips a link, misreads a time zone or ignores address sharing fails one of those conditions.
Since the amendment effective December 1, 2023, Rule 702 requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods, and applies those methods reliably to the facts of the case.
Each point of the review goes to one condition. A conclusion about a person based on a subscriber record alone goes to sufficient facts or data. A lookup without the source port on a shared address goes to reliable application. A time conversion that is not documented cannot be checked.
Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(ii) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires the report to list the facts or data the expert considered. The reviewer asks for the original server logs, the subpoena and the provider's answer, so that each step can be repeated.
What should a client send for a review of an IP attribution report?
The opposing report, the server logs it relies on, the subpoenas and the provider's answers, any router or device data, and a description of who had access to the network at the relevant time.
The reviewer needs the raw logs as the server wrote them, with their time zone and format. Screenshots of a log viewer or a summary table prepared for the report do not show what the server recorded.
The subpoena and the provider's answer show what was asked and what was returned. If the provider gave an assignment period, the reviewer checks the activity against that period, in a single time zone.
The client describes the household or the office: who lived or worked there, which devices were on the network, whether the Wi-Fi was open or protected, which guests had the password. Those facts decide what the alternative explanations are.
What does IAE do when the opposing expert ties an IP address to a client?
IAE reviews the opposing digital forensics report and can prepare a rebuttal expert report. Format, cost, deadline and specialist are confirmed before work starts; the review takes up to 5 business days.
The reviewer checks whether another examiner could repeat the work from the report: matching hash values, the tool and version that extracted the data, the time zone of each timestamp and whether each conclusion follows from the data. Each finding is linked to a page of the opposing report and to a rule or a published practice. Before work starts IAE confirms the review questions, the devices or logs involved and how the data reach the reviewer.
The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. IAE then confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- Cobbler Nevada, LLC v. Gonzales, No. 17-35041 (9th Cir. Aug. 27, 2018) (Justia)
- Cobbler Nevada, LLC v. Gonzales, No. 17-35041 (9th Cir. Aug. 27, 2018), opinion (Justia, PDF)
- RFC 6302, Logging Recommendations for Internet-Facing Servers, BCP 162 (IETF, June 2011)
- 18 U.S.C. 2702, Voluntary disclosure of customer communications or records (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with Committee Notes (LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (LII)
- Rule 702 as amended, effective in the Federal Rules of Evidence on December 1, 2023 (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces, conference handout, PDF)
Read also
All articles
Cell tower location evidence: how does a reviewer test the other side's cell-site analysis?
A cell-site report plots the towers a phone used and argues that the phone, and its owner, were near a place at a certain time. The records behind
Who pays for a review of the opposing digital forensics report, and can the fee be recovered?
The party that retains a reviewer of the opposing digital forensics report pays the reviewer. The other side pays only for the time it spends
Who is qualified to review a digital forensics report, and how are the opposing examiner's qualifications tested?
A digital forensics expert is qualified for an opinion when knowledge, skill, experience, training or education supports that opinion in the field itExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

