Expert opinion letters

Comparable evidence in EB-1A and O-1A: what must a letter explain when a criterion does not fit?

When an EB-1A or O-1A criterion does not readily apply to an occupation, the rules allow comparable evidence in its place. USCIS first asks for a detailed, specific and credible explanation of why the criterion does not fit, and only then weighs the substitute. In 2024 the AAO rejected a blanket statement backed by letters from athletes and trainers, and the Policy Manual says that witness letters offered as comparable evidence are not persuasive.

Hands slide one letter into a petition binder beside a second closed letter

What is comparable evidence?

Evidence that takes the place of a listed criterion when that criterion does not readily apply to the person's occupation. EB-1A, EB-1B and O-1A each have a rule for it. There is none for the one-time major award.

8 CFR 204.5(h)(4) provides that if the EB-1A criteria do not readily apply to the beneficiary's occupation, the petitioner may submit comparable evidence to establish eligibility. For outstanding professors and researchers, 204.5(i)(3)(ii) states: "If the standards in paragraph (i)(3)(i) of this section do not readily apply, the petitioner may submit comparable evidence to establish the beneficiary's eligibility." For O-1A, 8 CFR 214.2(o)(3)(iii)(C) permits comparable evidence when the criteria of paragraph (B) do not readily apply, and the USCIS O-1 page confirms that comparable evidence is allowed in certain circumstances.

The substitute replaces one criterion at a time. It does not replace the one-time achievement route: in a decision of November 1, 2023 (In Re: 28821261) the AAO wrote that "There is no comparable evidence for the one-time achievement of a major, internationally recognized award."

Comparable evidence is a way to meet the first step, not a lower standard. The sections below show what the petitioner has to explain and where the letters fit.

When does a criterion "not readily apply"?

When it is not easily applicable to the occupation. Chapter 2 of the Policy Manual does not require the criterion to be wholly inapplicable, and the O-1 chapter does not require that all or most criteria fail to fit.

Chapter 2 of Volume 6, Part F of the USCIS Policy Manual says that a criterion "need not be entirely inapplicable" to the person's occupation: the officer considers comparable evidence if the petitioner proves that the criterion is not easily applicable to the person's job or profession.

Chapter 4 of Volume 2, Part M, on O-1, adds that the petitioner does not have to show that all or most of the criteria do not apply. The analysis goes criterion by criterion: a petitioner may meet two criteria directly and offer comparable evidence for a third.

The question is about the occupation, not about the person's record. A criterion that fits the profession but that this applicant has not met does not open the door to comparable evidence. In a decision of February 3, 2025 (In Re: 34878316), a business consultant argued that comparable evidence should replace the scholarly articles criterion, because an author in her position would publish professional findings in professional publications and not in the public domain. The AAO answered in one sentence: "The regulatory language already takes professional publications into account."

What explanation does USCIS accept?

A detailed, specific and credible statement of why the criterion does not readily apply. The Policy Manual says that a general unsupported assertion is not probative, and the AAO rejected a blanket statement in 2024.

Chapter 2 states that a statement from the petitioner can be sufficient to establish whether a criterion is readily applicable if it is "detailed, specific, and credible." It also states that "A general unsupported assertion that the listed evidentiary criterion does not readily apply" to the occupation is not probative.

In a decision of April 17, 2024 (In Re: 29849078), an athlete argued that "several of the criteria simply don't apply to his occupation," because his sport "is not popular in the United States." He offered "several letters of reference from expert athletes and trainers." The director found that he had not explained why the criteria do not readily apply or specified how the letters were comparable. The AAO called the argument a "blanket statement" and was "not persuaded by the Petitioner's comparable evidence arguments."

A detailed statement names the criterion, describes how the occupation works and explains why the evidence that the criterion expects does not exist in that occupation. Then it names the substitute and explains why it carries comparable weight.

Can recommendation letters themselves be the comparable evidence?

Not as a general substitute. The Policy Manual says that general claims that USCIS should accept witness letters as comparable evidence are not persuasive. Letters can support the explanation and describe the substitute evidence.

Chapter 2 of the Policy Manual says that "general claims that USCIS should accept witness letters as comparable evidence are not persuasive." Chapter 5, on EB-2, makes the same point for exceptional ability: "Claims that USCIS should accept witness letters as comparable evidence are not persuasive."

The April 17, 2024 athlete case shows the pattern. The letters from athletes and trainers were offered in place of the criteria, and nothing in the record explained which criterion each letter replaced or why the sport made the criterion unavailable.

A letter has a different role when it explains facts. A specialist in the field can describe how the occupation recognizes achievement, why a listed form of evidence is not used in it and what the field uses instead. The officer then looks at the documents for the substitute itself, as Chapter 5 requires corroborating evidence for claims: "Claims lacking corroborating evidence are not sufficient to meet the petitioner's burden of proof."

Which examples of comparable evidence does USCIS give?

Chapter 2 gives non-exhaustive examples: an Olympic coach whose athlete wins a medal, election to a national all-star or Olympic team, and a presentation at a major trade show for a person in industry.

Chapter 2 introduces them as "other non-exhaustive examples of where the comparable evidence provision might apply." An Olympic coach whose athlete wins an Olympic medal "while under the person's principal tutelage" would likely have evidence comparable to the original contributions criterion of 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(v). Election to "a national all-star or Olympic team" might serve as comparable evidence for the membership criterion of 204.5(h)(3)(ii).

For a person in industry rather than academia, Chapter 2 says that the person's presentation of work at a major trade show may be of comparable significance to the scholarly articles criterion of 204.5(h)(3)(vi). The O-1 chapter uses the same example: if publication of articles does not readily apply to an industry role, a presentation at a major trade show may be of comparable significance.

The chapter hedges each example with "would likely" or "might." Each has the same structure: the listed form of evidence does not fit the occupation, and the substitute is a recognized event in that occupation with documents of its own, such as results, selection records, programs and coverage.

What if the officer ignores the comparable evidence argument?

The AAO can send the case back. In 2023 it withdrew a denial for a horse trainer because the director's decision did not address the comparable evidence arguments made at filing and in the RFE response.

In the November 1, 2023 decision the petitioner had claimed four criteria for a horse trainer: awards, memberships, published material and a leading or critical role. The director found only the leading or critical role met. The petitioner had argued for comparable evidence at filing and in response to a request for evidence, and on appeal it argued that the director had not considered that request.

The AAO agreed, withdrew the decision and remanded the case. It set the order of review for the new decision: first whether the petitioner established that any claimed criterion does not readily apply, then whether the evidence is "truly comparable," and, if at least three criteria are met, a final merits determination under Kazarian.

The argument has to be in the record to be considered. A comparable evidence claim made for the first time on appeal comes after the director's decision, and the response to a request for evidence is the last chance to add it before that decision.

Does accepted comparable evidence lower the standard?

No. The O-1 chapter says that the use of comparable evidence does not change the standard, and that the petitioner must still meet at least three separate criteria. The final merits step follows as usual.

Chapter 4 of Volume 2, Part M states that even with comparable evidence the petitioner "must still meet at least three separate evidentiary criteria" and that "the use of comparable evidence does not change the standard for the classification."

Chapter 2 treats EB-1A the same way in practice: comparable evidence is part of the first step, and at the final merits step the officer asks whether the whole record places the person among that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field.

The officer weighs the substitute again at that step, together with the rest of the record.

What should a letter supporting comparable evidence contain?

The writer's expertise, the criterion in question, how the occupation works, why the listed evidence does not exist in it, what the field uses instead and why the applicant's substitute is of comparable significance.

Chapter 2 asks letters to set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise, and Chapter 5 lets officers weigh the experts' credentials when they assign weight. A letter about comparable evidence follows the same rule and adds the facts about the occupation.

  • State the writer's position, experience and how the writer knows the practice of the occupation.
  • Name the criterion that does not readily apply and describe how the occupation records achievement.
  • Explain why the listed form of evidence is not used in the occupation, with facts and not a general assertion.
  • Name the substitute, describe the selection or competition behind it and why the field treats it as comparable.
  • Refer to the exhibits that document the substitute, such as results, programs, selection records and coverage.

How does IAE prepare an expert letter that addresses comparable evidence?

An expert from the public IAE registry in the applicant's field signs a letter of up to 15 pages with an analysis under the criteria of the category. You approve the expert first. The standard turnaround is 10 business days.

The expert opinion letters page lists EB-1A, EB-2 NIW, EB-1B, O-1A and O-1B, H-1B and L-1B. For extraordinary ability categories the letter assesses contribution, originality and recognition against the level of the field, based on measurable results and industry recognition in science, business, technology or the arts.

Send the applicant's CV, a description of the achievements and the draft petition. The secretariat confirms the expert from the registry, the price and the turnaround; the price depends on the category and the volume of materials. You approve the candidate and the CV before work starts. The secretariat prepares the draft from your documents, the expert checks it, makes changes and signs, and the applicant and the attorney make factual corrections in one included round.

The letter comes on letterhead with the expert's CV and a declaration of independence, as a signed PDF. The standard turnaround is 10 business days and the rush option 5. Whether a criterion readily applies and whether the substitute is comparable is decided by USCIS; IAE is not a law firm, and the attorney decides how the petition argues comparable evidence.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert opinion letters

Ready to strengthen your petition with an expert opinion letter?

Send the applicant's CV and the petition category: the expert, cost and timeline within one business day.

Quote request

Received

Expert, cost and timeline within one business day

CategoryEB‑1A
ExpertIn the applicant's field
Timeline10 business days