Expert opinion letters
Does USCIS verify recommendation letters, and what happens when an author does not confirm a letter?
No rule says that every recommendation letter is checked, and no rule says that letters are taken on trust. The statute makes approval depend on an investigation of the facts, the regulations permit USCIS to direct any investigation it needs, and a consular officer may telephone the author years after the petition was approved. In one AAO case a single call by the U.S. Embassy in Seoul ended an approved NIW petition.

Does USCIS check every recommendation letter?
No published rule requires it, and none forbids it. Officers first read each letter against the documents in the file. Contact with the author is an investigation step that USCIS or a consulate may take in any case.
The first check takes place on the officer's desk. In Matter of Chawathe, a precedent decision of October 20, 2010, the AAO wrote that the director "must examine each piece of evidence for relevance, probative value, and credibility, both individually and within the context of the totality of the evidence." A recommendation letter is one of those pieces.
That reading needs no phone call. A letter that states a fact the record does not support loses weight, and a letter that contradicts the record raises a question about the rest of the file.
The second kind of check is external: an officer or a consular post asks the author whether the letter is his. Published decisions of the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) record such checks by U.S. posts abroad.
Are letters that nobody verifies taken at face value?
No. Matter of Caron International treats an expert statement as an advisory opinion that may receive less weight when it conflicts with other information or is questionable. Under Matter of Chawathe every piece of evidence is examined for credibility.
Two precedent decisions set the place of letters in a petition. In Matter of Caron International, decided on October 28, 1988, the Commissioner wrote that the Service "may, in its discretion, use as advisory opinions statements from universities, professional organizations, or other sources submitted in evidence as expert testimony." The decision continues: because the Service makes the final determination of eligibility, "where an opinion is not in accord with other information or is in any way questionable, the Service is not required to accept or may give less weight to that evidence."
Matter of Chawathe sets the standard of proof. The petitioner meets it when relevant, probative and credible evidence leads the director to believe that the claim is "more likely than not" or "probably" true. If the director can articulate a material doubt, the decision says, it is appropriate to request additional evidence or, if the doubt leads the director to believe that the claim is probably not true, to deny the petition.
A letter is therefore weighed twice: on its own terms and against the rest of the record. In the AAO decisions discussed below, letters lost weight when the other documents in the file did not support what they said or contradicted it.
Who does the checking: the officer, the fraud unit or a consulate?
All three can. The adjudicating officer reads the file, the Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate runs verification programs, and consular posts make their own inquiries when the case reaches the visa stage.
The Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate (FDNS) describes two programs on the USCIS site. The Administrative Site Visit and Verification Program began in 2009 and selects petitions at random: religious worker, H-1B, L-1 and EB-5 petitions. The Targeted Site Visit and Verification Program began in 2017 and uses a data-driven selection for H-1B, L-1A, H-2A, H-2B and certain spousal petitions.
In those programs officers verify the information in the petition and the supporting documents, confirm that the petitioning organization exists, review public records and make "unannounced site visits." They make telephone or electronic inquiries when necessary and, in the words of the page, "will request to speak with individuals who may have knowledge of the petition." After a visit the officer writes a report, and USCIS adjudicators review it for indicators of fraud or noncompliance. Where FDNS finds such indicators, it may refer the case to U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement for criminal investigation. EB-1A and NIW petitions are not on the two lists. The page adds that failure to comply with a site visit, telephone interview or electronic inquiry "could lead to adverse adjudicative actions," and that in certain cases a refusal to participate may result in denial or revocation, which it says is true in particular of H-1B petitions.
The State Department is the third checker. In both AAO decisions discussed below the doubt came from a U.S. post abroad: the Embassy in Seoul telephoned the author of a letter, and a post in Guangzhou returned an approved petition to USCIS with a recommendation to revoke it.
What happened when a consular officer phoned a letter's author?
In a decision of December 1, 2021 the AAO upheld the revocation of an approved NIW petition. A professor told the U.S. Embassy in Seoul that he had never written the reference letter filed under his name.
The petitioner was an industrial designer of exhibition booths who filed Form I-140 on January 20, 2015 and received an approval. One of her letters came under the name of a university professor. It described her exhibition projects in detail and ranked her among the top talents in South Korea.
The embassy called the professor. According to the officer's report he said that the petitioner had never asked him for a recommendation letter and that he had never written one. He did not know of her plan to immigrate, which the letter mentioned, or of the projects it described, and he said the two had "only briefly worked together" in the 1990s.
The Director issued a notice of intent to revoke. The petitioner answered with a new statement by the professor: he had written the letter after all, the call had caught him off guard, he could not recall the letter because of the time that had passed, and the officer must have misunderstood him.
The AAO did not accept the second statement and found that "the Petitioner knowingly submitted a false document, and therefore willfully misrepresented a fact." The fact was material because the letter was offered as an expert's confirmation of her record of success, which is part of the second Dhanasar test. The appeal was dismissed.
Can the author take back what he said on the phone?
In the Seoul case he could not. The AAO presumed that the State Department officer had recorded the call accurately and found that the later statement contradicted the report without explaining the contradictions.
The AAO relied on the presumption of regularity, citing United States v. Chemical Foundation, 272 U.S. 1 (1926): the State Department officer was presumed to have performed his duties properly and to have recorded the call accurately. Citing Felzcerek v. INS, a Second Circuit decision of 1996, the AAO added that official records generally carry "strong indicia of reliability."
The later statement did not overcome that presumption. The professor did not dispute the other things the officer had written down, namely that he knew nothing of the petitioner's plan to immigrate or of her projects. He did not confirm the project details in the letter. And he did not explain how the two had "only briefly worked together" if, as he now wrote, he had let her teach the students at a university between 2006 and 2011.
The professor's answers on the phone covered three points: whether he wrote the letter, whether he knew the projects and how he knew the petitioner. An author who cannot confirm those three points leaves the officer with a report like the one sent by the embassy in Seoul.
Can a letter or a document be questioned years after approval?
Yes. Under 8 U.S.C. 1155 the approval of a petition may be revoked at any time for good and sufficient cause. In one EB-1A case the notice came seven years after the approval.
The statute reads that the Secretary of Homeland Security "may, at any time, for what he deems to be good and sufficient cause, revoke the approval of any petition." A revocation takes effect as of the date of the approval.
Matter of Ho adds three points. The approval of a petition vests no rights in the beneficiary. The realization that a petition was approved in error may itself be good and sufficient cause for revocation, if the record supports the revised opinion. And the evidence behind a notice of intent to revoke need not have been unavailable earlier.
In a decision of December 13, 2023 the AAO described the timeline of a research geophysicist. He filed an EB-1A petition in December 2015, received the approval in January 2016 and became a lawful permanent resident on April 18, 2016. In November 2020 the U.S. post in Guangzhou returned the petition and recommended revocation. On March 30, 2023 the Director issued a notice of intent to revoke that cited a memorandum of the National Visa Center Fraud Prevention Unit dated November 18, 2020, according to which the beneficiary had submitted fraudulent documents. The Director then revoked the approval.
The AAO withdrew that decision. The notice spoke of "fraudulent documents" without naming them and did not explain why fewer than three criteria were met, and the revocation did not answer the rebuttal. The case went back to the Director for a new notice.
What must USCIS do before it uses the results of a check against you?
It must tell you and let you answer. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(16)(i) an adverse decision based on derogatory information unknown to the petitioner requires notice and a chance to rebut it before the decision.
Paragraph (b)(16)(i) covers derogatory information "considered by the Service and of which the applicant or petitioner is unaware": the person is advised of it and offered an opportunity to rebut. Paragraph (b)(16)(ii) adds that a determination of statutory eligibility is based only on information in the record that has been disclosed.
For an approved petition the vehicle is the notice of intent to revoke. Under 8 CFR 205.2(b) the petitioner or self-petitioner must be given the opportunity to offer evidence in support of the petition and in opposition to the grounds alleged for revocation.
The Board of Immigration Appeals set the standard for the notice in Matter of Estime in 1987. The notice has to state specifically both the facts underlying the proposed action and the supporting evidence. A revocation cannot be sustained when the notice rests on "an unsupported statement or an unstated presumption," or when the petitioner was not told of the derogatory evidence. The 2023 geophysicist case was sent back on that ground.
Can a court overturn a revocation that rests on a disputed letter?
In Bouarfa v. Mayorkas (2024) the Supreme Court held that a revocation under 8 U.S.C. 1155, there based on a sham-marriage finding, is a discretionary decision that federal courts do not review. The letter is defended before the agency.
The Court decided the case on December 10, 2024. It concerned a petition that a U.S. citizen had filed for her husband and that the agency revoked after finding that he had earlier entered a marriage to evade the immigration laws. The Court held unanimously that the revocation fell under 8 U.S.C. 1252(a)(2)(B)(ii), which takes discretionary decisions out of judicial review. Its reasoning rested on the text of section 1155, the provision under which employment-based approvals are revoked as well: "the word 'may' clearly connotes discretion," and the grant of authority, in words the Court quoted from Webster v. Doe, "fairly exudes deference" to the Secretary.
The Court noted one remaining path. The petitioner may file a new petition, and if that petition is denied on the same finding, the denial can be taken to court.
Inside the agency the time limit is short. Under 8 CFR 205.2(d) the petitioner or self-petitioner may appeal within 15 days after service of the notice of revocation. The response to the notice of intent is the stage at which new evidence about the letter enters the record.
How is a doubt about a letter rebutted?
With independent objective evidence. Matter of Ho places the burden on the petitioner and says that explanations alone, without competent objective evidence of where the truth lies, do not resolve an inconsistency.
The Board decided Matter of Ho on March 17, 1988. Two of its sentences set the method. The first: "Doubt cast on any aspect of the petitioner's proof may, of course, lead to a reevaluation" of the reliability and sufficiency of the remaining evidence. The second: "it is incumbent upon the petitioner to resolve the inconsistencies by independent objective evidence."
The Seoul file went the same way. The rebuttal was a second statement by the same author, which is not independent of the first. Once the letter fell, the AAO reread the rest of the file and found it thin. The employment certificate came from a company led by the petitioner's husband. Her articles of 2012 had no independent confirmation that the clients were satisfied. A reference letter by a chief executive gave no employment dates and did not say whether the projects had succeeded.
Matter of Ho does not list such evidence. Records that existed before the dispute and that the petitioner does not control are independent in the ordinary sense of the word: contracts and publications that match the facts in the letter, or a statement by a third person who saw the work.
Which defects in a letter do officers catch without calling anyone?
Contradictions with the rest of the file. In recent AAO decisions letters lost weight because they misstated a title, made a claim the record disproved, or left out dates and results.
In a decision of February 2, 2023 a publisher's letter about the petitioner's editorial role had errors of grammar and capitalization and called her "Dr." nearly a year before she received the degree. The AAO concluded that her association with the publisher was not strong evidence in her favor.
In a decision of April 4, 2024 the petitioner stated that only top researchers are invited to review manuscripts. The record showed that he had reviewed papers in 2010, as a first-year graduate student with no publications, and the AAO noted the conflict.
In the Seoul case the chief executive's letter failed on missing facts: no dates of employment and no word on the outcome of the projects.
The 2023 decision adds a fourth defect. Letters from the petitioner's faculty did not explain how her earlier work was relevant to the endeavor she proposed, and the AAO held that the second part of the Dhanasar test was not met.
What do verifiers ask about a letter?
In the cases above the questions went to four points: who wrote the letter, whether the author knows the facts in it, how the author knows the petitioner, and whether other documents confirm what it says.
Authorship was the first question in Seoul, and the professor's answer that he never wrote such a letter decided the case.
Knowledge of the content was the second. The professor did not know the projects the letter described or the petitioner's plan to immigrate, which the letter mentioned.
The relationship was the third. His words on the phone, a brief acquaintance in the 1990s, did not fit a letter written in the voice of someone who had followed her projects.
Corroboration was the fourth. Once the letter fell, the AAO looked for independent verification of the projects' success and found none in the record. When every fact in a letter also appears in a contract, a publication or a public record, the author is asked to confirm what the file already proves.
What does a false letter cost the petitioner?
Denial or revocation, the loss of the priority date, a finding of willful misrepresentation that makes the person inadmissible, and exposure to prosecution for a false statement in an immigration document.
8 U.S.C. 1182(a)(6)(C)(i) makes inadmissible any alien who "by fraud or willfully misrepresenting a material fact" seeks or has sought to procure a visa, other documentation, admission or another immigration benefit. The waiver provision is subsection (i) of the same section. The AAO cited this provision in the Seoul decision, together with the warning printed on the form that USCIS "may deny any other immigration benefit."
The queue position goes too. Under 8 CFR 204.5(e)(2) a priority date is not retained when USCIS revokes the approval because of "Fraud, or a willful misrepresentation of a material fact."
The criminal provision is 18 U.S.C. 1546(a). It covers a person who knowingly subscribes as true, under penalty of perjury, a false statement of a material fact in a document required by the immigration laws, or who knowingly presents such a document. The penalty is a fine, imprisonment, or both, with a maximum of 10 years for a first or second offense unconnected with terrorism or drug trafficking.
How does IAE prepare letters whose authors can be checked?
Each letter is signed by an expert whose record is open in the public IAE registry, after the expert has checked and corrected the draft prepared from the applicant's documents. The CV and a declaration of independence are attached.
The expert opinion letters page describes the order of work. You send the applicant's CV, a description of the achievements and the draft petition. The secretariat names an expert in the subject area, and you approve the candidate and the CV before work starts. The secretariat prepares the draft from your documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs. The applicant and the attorney see the draft before signing and make factual clarifications in one included round, while the conclusions remain the expert's own.
The letter runs up to 15 pages on letterhead. Anyone who receives it can enter the Member ID on the status check page or scan the QR code and see the expert's category, specialization, attestation date and record status.
The standard turnaround is 10 business days and the rush option 5. IAE is not a law firm, the letter does not guarantee approval, and USCIS weighs it together with the other materials of the petition.
Sources
- 8 CFR 103.2, Submission and adjudication of benefit requests (eCFR)
- 8 U.S.C. 1154, Procedure for granting immigrant status, subsection (b) (govinfo)
- USCIS, Administrative Site Visit and Verification Program (Fraud Detection and National Security Directorate)
- AAO non-precedent decision of December 1, 2021, In Re: 14759499 (EB-2 national interest waiver, revocation after an embassy call to the author of a letter)
- AAO non-precedent decision of December 13, 2023, In Re: 28805817 (EB-1A, notice of intent to revoke)
- AAO non-precedent decision of February 2, 2023 (EB-2 national interest waiver)
- AAO non-precedent decision of April 4, 2024 (EB-2 national interest waiver)
- 8 U.S.C. 1155, Revocation of approval of petitions; effective date (govinfo)
- 8 CFR part 205, Revocation of approval of petitions (eCFR)
- Bouarfa v. Mayorkas, 604 U.S. 6 (2024), Supreme Court of the United States, No. 23-583
- Matter of Estime, 19 I&N Dec. 450 (BIA 1987), Interim Decision 3029
- Matter of Ho, 19 I&N Dec. 582 (BIA 1988), Interim Decision 3051
- Matter of Chawathe, 25 I&N Dec. 369 (AAO 2010), Interim Decision 3700
- Matter of Caron International, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791 (Comm'r 1988), Interim Decision 3085
- 8 U.S.C. 1182, Inadmissible aliens, subsection (a)(6)(C) (govinfo)
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants, paragraph (e) (eCFR)
- 18 U.S.C. 1546, Fraud and misuse of visas, permits, and other documents (govinfo)
Read also
All articles
EB-1A for athletes and coaches: which criteria fit a sports career, and what should expert letters say?
Athletics is one of the five fields named in the EB-1A definition, and the regulation lists athletic contributions among its criteria. AAO decisions
Comparable evidence in EB-1A and O-1A: what must a letter explain when a criterion does not fit?
When an EB-1A or O-1A criterion does not readily apply to an occupation, the rules allow comparable evidence in its place. USCIS first asks
Expert opinion letter or recommendation letter: what is the difference for a USCIS petition?
A recommendation letter reports what the writer saw while working with the applicant. An expert opinion letter is written by a specialist who reviewsExpert opinion letters
Ready to strengthen your petition with an expert opinion letter?
Send the applicant's CV and the petition category: the expert, cost and timeline within one business day.

