RFE responses

An EB-1A RFE on judging the work of others: what evidence answers it?

The judging criterion of 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(iv) counts participation as a judge of the work of others in the same or an allied field. The Policy Manual requires proof that the applicant actually judged, and an invitation does not meet it. In AAO decisions of 2023 and 2024 the criterion was met by an editor's thank-you email, a lead researcher's letter and a gallery owner's letter, and the final merits step weighed volume and venue.

A reviewer from behind sorts anonymous manuscripts into two stacks, an opened petition envelope at the side.

What does an RFE on the judging criterion question?

Usually one of three things: whether the applicant actually judged or was only invited, whether the judged work belongs to the same or an allied field, and whether the activity was judging at all.

8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(iv) asks for evidence of the alien's "participation, either individually or on a panel, as a judge of the work of others" in the same or an allied field. The criterion is about acts of evaluation: reviewing manuscripts, scoring entries, sitting on a jury or a committee.

Chapter 2 of Volume 6, Part F of the USCIS Policy Manual says that the petitioner must show that the person was invited to judge the work of others and also "actually participated in the judging of the work of others." Each of the decisions below turned on proof of that participation, on the field of the judged work or on the nature of the task.

An RFE on this criterion names the gap. The response answers it with documents for each judging activity claimed, because the officer counts the criterion only if at least one activity is proven.

Is an invitation to review enough?

No. In 2023 the AAO wrote that evidence of an invitation to participate as a judge does not meet the requirement. An email from a journal editor thanking the applicant for a completed review did meet it.

In a decision of August 1, 2023 (In Re: 27573483), a technical program manager in data storage submitted emailed invitations to review manuscripts for journals, invitations to serve on advisory boards of start-up companies and two invitations from IEEE Potentials. The AAO wrote that "evidence of an invitation to participate as a judge does not meet that requirement."

The same record held an email from the editor of the International Journal of Information Management thanking the petitioner for reviewing an article. The AAO treated that email as proof of actual participation and found the criterion met. The AAO withdrew the director's decision and remanded the case for a final merits determination.

The Policy Manual describes the evidence the same way: peer reviewing for a scholarly journal is proven by the journal's request to the person, "accompanied by proof that the review was actually completed." In an EB-1B decision of March 22, 2024 (In Re: 30518950), three invitations from ICPR were not counted because the record did not show that the reviews were completed, while reviews for ACMMM and KISJ were counted.

Which activities count as judging the work of others?

The Policy Manual lists peer review for a scholarly journal with proof of completion, peer review of abstracts or papers for conferences, service on a Ph.D. dissertation committee shown by departmental records, and peer review for government research funding programs.

These four examples come from Chapter 2. Each is an evaluation of another person's work by the applicant, and each has a typical document: the journal's request and confirmation, the conference's review record, the department's records of the committee and the funding agency's reviewer records.

The list is not closed. In a decision of December 12, 2024 (In Re: 35563226), the AAO accepted judging by an artist and designer on the strength of a gallery owner's letter, which stated that she "has helped to develop and judge Sculptural works created by me and other partnered Artists."

Activity that resembles judging may not count. In the same case newspaper articles described the artist as a go-to person for those still learning the ropes. The AAO found that the articles did not show that she had judged the work of others.

Does the judged work have to be in the applicant's field?

It has to be in the same or an allied field. In 2023 the AAO found that two review invitations from IEEE Potentials did not appear related to data storage, the petitioner's field.

The regulation limits the criterion to judging the work of others "in the same or an allied field." In the August 1, 2023 case the AAO noted that the IEEE Potentials invitations did not appear related to data storage and that the petitioner had not shown that the advisory board invitations, even if accepted, involved judging work in his field or an allied field.

The response to an RFE that raises the field question explains the link: the topic of the reviewed manuscript, the scope of the journal or competition and its relation to the field named in the petition. The journal's own description of its scope and the title of the reviewed paper are the usual documents.

The field is the one named in the petition. Judging in an earlier field of work counts only if that field is the same or allied.

What if the officer calls the review editing or proofreading?

The response proves that the applicant evaluated the substance on the basis of subject matter expertise. In 2024 the AAO rejected a director's finding that a research fellow had only proofread articles.

In a decision of December 18, 2024 (In Re: 35116908), the petitioner claimed peer review as a fellow at a research center. The record held a letter from the center's lead researcher confirming his participation in peer review of scholarly articles, emails from an organizing committee asking him to review several articles, and confirmation that he completed at least two of those reviews.

The director concluded that the petitioner had only proofread the articles. The AAO acknowledged that he corrected typographical and grammatical errors but found that the organization gave him "license to edit and revise the content" based on his subject matter expertise and did not engage him "to act as a proofreader." It found the activities consistent with the Policy Manual's examples of judging, withdrew the director's conclusion and remanded the case for a final merits determination.

The evidence that decided this point described the task: who asked the petitioner to review, what he was allowed to change and on what expertise the assignment rested. A response to a proofreading finding needs the same description from the organization that assigned the review.

Can a letter prove that the applicant judged?

Yes, if it describes the judging. In 2024 the AAO said it does not generally require corroboration of letters from non-parties and accepted a gallery owner's letter, while noting that it would prefer a more detailed one.

In the December 12, 2024 case the director had discounted the gallery letters. The AAO withdrew that finding, said that it does not generally require corroboration of non-party letters, and wrote: "We would prefer a more detailed letter." The letter stated that the artist's knowledge, skill and expertise were engaged in determining the final outcome, and the AAO found that this showed actual participation.

A letter works when the writer ran or observed the judging. The lead researcher in the December 18, 2024 case confirmed the fellow's participation in peer review, and the organizing committee's emails and the confirmation of completed reviews stood next to that letter.

Letters cannot replace records that exist. Where a journal system, a conference platform or a funding agency keeps review records, the response attaches them, and a letter explains what they show.

How much judging is enough at the final merits step?

Meeting the criterion is only the first step. At the second step officers asked how much the applicant judged, for which venues and whether the venues reserve that role for recognized experts.

Chapter 2 says that the second step requires the officer to evaluate the person's participation as a judge to determine whether it was indicative of the person being among the small percentage at the very top of the field and of sustained acclaim.

In the March 22, 2024 EB-1B case the AAO counted the reviews for ACMMM and KISJ under the criterion and then found no evidence that the level or frequency of the reviewing set the beneficiary apart, and no evidence that the venues reserve review invitations for internationally recognized experts. In an EB-1B decision of March 4, 2024 (In Re: 30240228), a sociologist had reviewed three articles for one bulletin and was listed on master's thesis committee orders, and the AAO found no evidence of her actual participation in specific theses. A letter said she had reviewed more than 20 conference papers, and the record did not corroborate that figure. The AAO wrote that participation in the peer review process does not automatically prove that a person is internationally recognized.

In an EB-1A decision of April 15, 2024 (In Re: 30470568), a jiu-jitsu competitor and coach had judged at one IBJJF event in 2019. The AAO noted that the record did not establish the event's prestige and questioned why his resume listed all of his judging experience as volunteer work. In a filmmaker case of August 30, 2021 (In Re: 18851417), a 2010 appointment as head juror at a 10-day festival was treated as a single appointment.

Which evidence answers an RFE on judging?

For each claimed activity, the request to judge and the proof that the judging was done, with documents that tie the judged work to the applicant's field and describe the standing of the venue.

The list follows the gaps that the AAO found in the decisions above. Each item is a document an RFE response can contain.

  • Attach each journal's or conference's request to review together with the confirmation that the review was completed, such as a thank-you email or a review record.
  • Add the scope statement of each journal or competition and the title or topic of the reviewed work, to tie it to the same or an allied field.
  • Include departmental records for dissertation committees and agency records for grant reviews.
  • Give a count of completed reviews by venue and year, with the documents behind the count.
  • Document the standing of each venue, such as how reviewers or jurors are selected.
  • Obtain a letter from the person who assigned the review that describes the task and why the applicant was chosen.

Can reviews completed after filing go into the response?

No. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) the applicant must be eligible at the time of filing, and under 103.2(b)(12) a petition is denied where the RFE evidence does not establish eligibility on that date.

8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) requires eligibility "at the time of filing" and through adjudication. Paragraph (b)(12) states that a benefit request shall be denied where evidence submitted in response to a request for evidence does not establish filing eligibility.

A review completed after the filing date can still serve later. It does not count for the petition already pending, and it counts for a new petition with a later filing date.

The documents of earlier reviews can be obtained after filing. A confirmation email that a journal sends now about a review completed before the filing date documents a fact that existed on that date.

How long is the response period, and how is the response filed?

The period stated in the RFE, which may not exceed 12 weeks and cannot be extended. All materials go in together with the original RFE, and a partial response is treated as a request for a decision on the record.

Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv), an RFE response period may not exceed twelve weeks, and "Additional time to respond to a request for evidence or notice of intent to deny may not be granted." Under paragraph (b)(11), all requested materials are submitted together at one time, along with the original request, and a partial response is treated as a request for a decision on the record.

Confirmations come from third parties: journals, committees and funding agencies. The requests for them go out first, as soon as the RFE comes in.

How does IAE prepare an expert letter for an RFE response?

IAE prepares an expert opinion letter built on the text of the RFE, with a separate section for each finding within the expert's field. The standard turnaround is 5 business days, and the rush option takes 3.

On the RFE and NOID response page, the EB-1A and O-1 finding is listed as "Criteria and the significance of achievements." The text of the request is split into separate findings. The expert takes the points within their field, and legal points stay with the attorney. The letter runs up to 15 pages, with point-by-point answers and references to the case file.

The request includes the text of the RFE or NOID, the petition and the supporting file. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day and checks the turnaround against the response deadline. Within one business day IAE confirms the fee, the turnaround and the expert in writing; the fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. The secretariat prepares the draft from the client's documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs it. Revisions before signing are included, and the draft goes to the attorney.

The client receives a signed PDF with the expert's CV and a declaration of independence. The expert's record can be checked by Member ID or QR code on the status check page. When the findings call for different specializations, a second expert joins at the assessment stage. IAE is not a law firm: the attorney prepares the response, the letter is one piece of evidence in it, and USCIS makes the decision.

Sources

Read also

All articles

RFE and NOID responses

Received an RFE? We count the days with you.

The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. We confirm the fee, the turnaround and the expert within one business day and check the turnaround against the response deadline.

Quote request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

DocumentRFE or NOID text
Timeline5 business days, rush 3
AuthorFrom the IAE registry