RFE responses

An EB-1A RFE on commercial success in the performing arts: what evidence answers it?

The tenth EB-1A criterion counts commercial successes in the performing arts, shown by box office receipts or record, cassette, compact disk or video sales. The Policy Manual reads it as a measure of sales volume compared with others, and recording and releasing music is not enough by itself. In 2021 the AAO accepted a producer's audited Gold and Platinum certifications, and in 2023 it rejected an actor's claims of millions of views without viewership or sales data.

Hands set blank-labeled records and ticket stubs beside an opened petition envelope

What does the commercial success criterion require?

Evidence of commercial successes in the performing arts, as shown by box office receipts or record, cassette, compact disk or video sales. The Policy Manual reads it as sales volume measured against others.

8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(x) asks for "Evidence of commercial successes in the performing arts," "as shown by box office receipts or record, cassette, compact disk, or video sales." It is the last of the ten EB-1A criteria, and the petition needs at least three of them or a one-time major international award.

Chapter 2 of Volume 6, Part F of the USCIS Policy Manual says that the criterion "focuses on volume of sales and box office receipts as a measure of the person's commercial success in the performing arts." It adds that "the mere fact that a person has recorded and released musical compilations" is "insufficient, in and of itself": the figures have to establish the person's commercial success relative to others.

An RFE on this criterion therefore asks for numbers and for a comparison. A release, a performance or a role is a fact about the work; the criterion asks what the market did with it.

Why do officers question this criterion in an RFE?

Because the record shows activity but no sales figures, offers chart positions without independent proof, or does not connect the applicant's own role to the commercial result.

In a decision of July 18, 2023 (In Re: 20617300), an actor who also worked as a singer, songwriter and music therapist relied on commercials he had acted in. A producer's letter spoke of "millions of views," and a public service announcement he appeared in was described as raising more than eight million dollars. The AAO found that the record lacked "details of the online viewership, or the videos' product sales," and without further evidence that his acting contributed to the commercials' successes the record did not show national or international acclaim.

The same record claimed that a 2015 song was voted number one on an Indie Dance/Disco chart. The AAO found no independent, objective evidence of that ranking. It also gave little weight to letters with identical wording, which suggested that the language was not the writers' own.

In a decision of August 26, 2021 (In Re: 17773598), the director had found that a petitioner claimed the criterion as a producer and not as a performing artist, gave no sales or box office evidence and did not show that he was featured in any promotional material. The AAO reversed on the evidence described below.

Can a producer or composer meet a criterion written for the performing arts?

In 2021 the AAO said yes for a music producer who proved his own contribution to an album's certified sales. The decision turned on documents tying him to the album, not on his title.

In the August 26, 2021 case the petitioner was a singer-songwriter, producer and composer. He relied on a 2007 album by another artist that was certified Gold in 2009 for sales of more than 500,000 units in the United States and Double Platinum for more than 200,000 units in Canada. A record label gave him a plaque for his contributions to the album, and reviews and media articles named him as a close collaborator.

The AAO described the criterion as focusing on "volume of sales and box office receipts in relation to others" and concluded that "the Petitioner established his contributions to the album's commercial success." It found the criterion met, found that the petitioner met at least three criteria and sustained the appeal on the final merits as well.

Where the criterion does not readily apply to an occupation, the petitioner may offer comparable evidence under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(4). Chapter 2 requires a detailed, specific and credible explanation of why the criterion does not readily apply and treats a general unsupported assertion as not probative.

What sales evidence did the AAO accept?

Industry certifications that rest on audited sales. In 2021 the AAO noted that the certification bodies require labels to submit proof of commercial sales that is subject to audit, and that the certifications are recognized across the industry.

In the August 26, 2021 decision the AAO relied on the Gold and Double Platinum certifications because the certifying organizations require record labels to submit "proof of commercial sales that is subject to audit." The certifications carried figures, a country and a year: more than 500,000 units in the United States in 2009 and more than 200,000 in Canada.

The certification proved the sales. The plaque from the label and the media reviews naming the petitioner proved his part in them. The AAO needed both.

The same logic applies to box office receipts. Figures that come from a source that counts tickets, with the production, the period and the venue, give the officer numbers to compare. A letter that calls a project a success gave the officer no such numbers in the 2023 actor case.

How do you prove success relative to others?

With figures that the officer can compare: certified sales thresholds, box office data for the same market and period, and documents on what such figures mean in that market.

Chapter 2 asks for figures that establish commercial success relative to others, and the 2021 decision repeated the phrase "in relation to others." A certification threshold works as a built-in comparison, because the certifying body grants it only above a set sales level.

Raw counts need context. A number of views, tickets or downloads says little without the standing of that number in the same market and period, and the 2023 actor case failed on the lack of such details. A document that explains the measure, its source and where the applicant's figure stands gives the officer the comparison the criterion asks for.

Self-reported rankings carry little weight. In the 2023 case the claimed number one chart position lacked independent, objective evidence, and the AAO did not credit it.

Can sales certificates count under another criterion?

Yes. In 2024 the AAO discussed RIAA and BPI certificates under the leading or critical role criterion, as evidence of an organization's distinguished reputation. The commercial success claim had been waived on appeal.

In a decision of July 5, 2024 (In Re: 31112406), an artist manager's record included RIAA and BPI certificates, among them a BPI certificate for sales of more than 600,000 copies of a single. The AAO discussed them under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(viii), the leading or critical role criterion, in connection with the distinguished reputation of the organization.

The director had found the commercial success evidence insufficient, and the petitioner did not contest that finding on appeal. The AAO wrote: "On appeal, the Petitioner has not specifically challenged these findings, he has therefore waived these claims."

Two points follow from the decision. A sales certificate can serve more than one criterion if the petition explains how. And a finding that is not challenged on appeal stays in place, so the response to an RFE and any later appeal have to address each criterion the officer rejected.

Can the response rely on sales that came after filing?

No. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) eligibility is set at the time of filing, and under 103.2(b)(12) a petition is denied where the RFE evidence does not establish eligibility on that date.

8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) requires eligibility "at the time of filing" and through adjudication. Paragraph (b)(12) states that a request shall be denied where evidence submitted in response to a request for evidence does not establish filing eligibility.

A certification granted after filing, or box office receipts of a later season, does not count for the pending petition. Sales that occurred before filing can be documented after it: a certification issued later for sales completed before the filing date documents an earlier fact, and the response explains the dates.

Every foreign-language document needs a full English translation that the translator certifies as complete and accurate, under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3).

How long is the response period, and how is the response filed?

The period stated in the RFE, which may not exceed twelve weeks, with no extension. All requested materials are filed together with the original request, and a partial response is treated as a request for a decision on the record.

Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv), the period to respond to a request for evidence may not exceed twelve weeks, and "Additional time to respond to a request for evidence or notice of intent to deny may not be granted." The deadline printed in the request governs.

Under paragraph (b)(11), all requested materials must be submitted together at one time, along with the original request. Submitting only part of the requested evidence is treated as a request for a decision on the record.

Sales data and certifications come from labels, distributors, venues and certifying bodies. The requests to them go out first, so that the figures arrive before the package is assembled.

How does the O-1B criterion on commercial success differ?

The O-1B arts criterion speaks of a record of major commercial or critically acclaimed successes, shown by indicators such as ratings, standing in the field and box office receipts. Critical acclaim counts there as well as sales.

8 CFR 214.2(o)(3)(iv)(B)(4), one of the criteria for extraordinary ability in the arts, asks for evidence of "a record of major commercial or critically acclaimed successes," shown by indicators such as ratings, standing in the field and box office receipts.

The EB-1A criterion is narrower in one way: it names box office receipts and sales of records, cassettes, compact disks and videos, and the Policy Manual reads it as sales volume against others. Critical acclaim in an EB-1A petition goes to other criteria, such as published material about the person.

An artist who holds O-1B status and files an EB-1A petition prepares the commercial success evidence again under the EB-1A wording, and each petition is decided on its own record.

Does meeting the criterion after an RFE decide the petition?

No. The criterion counts toward the three required at the first step. In the 2023 actor case the AAO cited the Policy Manual: meeting the criteria in part one alone does not establish eligibility.

In the July 18, 2023 decision the AAO cited Chapter 2 for the rule that "objectively meeting the regulatory criteria in part one alone does not establish" eligibility for the classification. The officer then weighs the whole record for sustained national or international acclaim and a place among the small percentage at the very top of the field.

In a decision of June 29, 2023 (In Re: 27416381), a vocal coach and singer had received a request for evidence and claimed the commercial success criterion. The AAO found the judging and artistic display criteria met, withdrew the director's decision and remanded the case for a final merits determination.

In the 2021 producer case the AAO went through both steps: it found the criterion met, found that the petitioner met at least three criteria and then found that he met the final merits standard.

How does IAE prepare an expert letter for an RFE on commercial success?

IAE prepares an expert opinion letter built on the text of the RFE, with a separate section for each finding within the expert's field. The standard turnaround is 5 business days, and the rush option takes 3.

On the RFE and NOID response page, the EB-1A and O-1 finding is listed as "Criteria and the significance of achievements." The text of the request is split into separate findings. The expert takes the points within their field, and legal points stay with the attorney. The letter runs up to 15 pages, with point-by-point answers and references to the case file.

The request includes the text of the RFE or NOID, the petition and the supporting file. The secretariat confirms receipt and checks the turnaround against the response deadline. IAE confirms the fee, the turnaround and the expert in writing; the fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. The secretariat prepares the draft from the client's documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs it. Revisions before signing are included, and the draft goes to the attorney.

The client receives a signed PDF with the expert's CV and a declaration of independence. The expert's record can be checked by Member ID or QR code on the status check page. When the findings call for different specializations, a second expert joins at the assessment stage. IAE is not a law firm: the attorney prepares the response, the letter is one piece of evidence in it, and USCIS makes the decision.

Sources

Read also

All articles

RFE and NOID responses

Received an RFE? We count the days with you.

The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. We confirm the fee, the turnaround and the expert within one business day and check the turnaround against the response deadline.

Quote request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

DocumentRFE or NOID text
Timeline5 business days, rush 3
AuthorFrom the IAE registry