RFE responses

An EB-1A RFE on original contributions of major significance: what evidence answers it?

The original contributions criterion of 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(v) has two parts, and an RFE usually accepts the first and questions the second: the work is original, but its major significance to the field is not shown. In AAO decisions of 2024 the evidence failed when the letters described value to one employer, repeated the regulation or listed no specific contribution. The response has to show how others in the field used the work, within a deadline that cannot be extended.

Hands set a small prototype and face-down journal offprints beside an opened petition envelope

What does an RFE on original contributions question?

Usually the second half of the criterion. The Policy Manual applies two tests: whether the contributions are original and whether they are of major significance to the field. Officers often accept originality and find significance unproven.

8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(v) asks for evidence of the alien's "original scientific, scholarly, artistic, athletic, or business-related contributions of major significance" in the field. Chapter 2 of Volume 6, Part F of the USCIS Policy Manual splits the review: first, USCIS determines whether the person has made original contributions in the field; second, whether those contributions are of major significance to the field.

In a decision of June 11, 2024 (In Re: 31160572), a television producer received two requests for evidence. The director found that her contributions were original and valued by the organizations where she worked, but not of major significance. The AAO agreed that originality alone does not satisfy the criterion and dismissed the appeal.

An RFE on this criterion therefore rarely asks whether the applicant did the work. It asks what the work changed outside the applicant's own projects, and the response is built around that question.

What does major significance mean for the officer?

Influence on the field beyond the applicant's own work. The Policy Manual says that funding, patents or publication alone will not necessarily establish it, and points to research that provoked widespread commentary from others in the field.

Chapter 2 says that evidence that the person's work was funded, patented or published may show originality but "will not necessarily establish, on its own, that the work is of major significance to the field." Pending patents generally need additional support, such as detailed letters.

The chapter gives an example of strong evidence: published research that "has provoked widespread commentary on its importance from others working in the field," together with citations at a level high relative to others in the field. It lists the types of evidence an officer may consider: published materials about the significance of the work, testimonials, letters and affidavits, citations, and patents, licenses or commercial use.

Every item on this list comes from outside the applicant. The officer looks for people and organizations who used, cited, licensed or wrote about the work.

Why did contribution letters fail in AAO decisions of 2024?

Because they praised skills, described value to one employer, repeated the regulatory language or listed no specific contribution. The AAO wrote that USCIS need not accept primarily conclusory statements.

In a decision of May 13, 2024 (In Re: 30728339), a mountain climber who also worked as a scout counselor received a request for evidence. His letters "primarily contain attestations of the Petitioner's status in the field." The AAO wrote that letters that repeat the regulatory language without explaining how the contributions influenced the field are insufficient, citing Kazarian v. USCIS, and added: "Having a diverse skill set is not a contribution" of major significance.

In a decision of December 16, 2024 (In Re: 35163329), an integration architect in energy efficiency relied on four letters. The AAO found that they "limit the relevance" of his contributions "to his employers" and lacked "specific, detailed information explaining how the Petitioner has made original contributions." It cited the 1756, Inc. decision for the point that USCIS "need not accept primarily conclusory statements."

In the June 11, 2024 producer case, a letter from a studio executive credited her "active engagement" with many television projects. The AAO noted that the letter "does not list the Petitioner's specific contributions." A government list of approved television and radio channels did not recognize her specific work and contributions.

Does a large impact inside one company count?

Not by itself. In 2024 the AAO rejected savings of over a million dollars a year at one employer and over $1 million per well at another, because the record did not prove influence on the wider field.

In the December 16, 2024 case one letter described an employer system with an "annual saving of over a million USD," and another described software rolled out to a bank's ATM fleet. The AAO said that neither letter explained how the work influenced the field and cited the Visinscaia decision for the requirement to corroborate impact on the field as a whole.

In a decision of November 22, 2024 (In Re: 35432503), a drilling engineer in oil and gas relied on colleagues' letters about safety measures, drilling efficiencies and savings of over $1 million per well. The AAO wrote that acclaim is generally expected to be recognized "well beyond the circle of their personal and professional acquaintances" and that the record did not show that his work had been widely implemented.

In a decision of December 12, 2024 (In Re: 34693081), a retail manager's former employer described her curation of product collections and a new sales technique for her team. The AAO accepted that these roles had assisted the company and found no evidence that they were original contributions to the field.

Can an economic impact study answer the RFE?

It did not in the 2024 drilling engineer case. The AAO considered an economist's estimate of 64 non-direct jobs and $1.7 million in federal taxes and found that it did not establish national or international acclaim.

In the November 22, 2024 case the AAO reopened the matter on its own motion under 8 CFR 103.5(a)(5)(ii) and requested additional evidence. The petitioner argued that the AAO had wrongly disregarded his expert letters and submitted an economist's economic impact analysis. It estimated 64 non-direct jobs and $1.7 million in federal taxes connected with his pay, and he added articles on safety in the industry.

The AAO acknowledged the materials and found that the economic analysis did not show national or international acclaim and that the safety articles did not show that his work had won widespread recognition in the field. It also found that the documentation of his technical publications "does not discuss the merits of the Petitioner's work."

The study measured the economic effect of one person's employment. The criterion asks about the effect of the contribution on the field, and the response has to document that effect.

Which evidence answers an RFE on major significance?

Evidence that others in the field used the work: citations compared with the field, commentary by others, licenses, commercial use or adoption, with detailed letters that describe the contribution and the writer's basis of knowledge.

Chapter 2 asks that letters "specifically describe the person's contribution and its significance to the field" and "set forth the basis of the writer's knowledge and expertise." A letter that answers an RFE names the contribution, the date, who used it and how, and refers to the exhibits that prove each use.

Citation evidence needs a comparison. The final merits section of Chapter 2 treats a citation rate that is high relative to others in the field as a positive factor and asks petitioners who rely on tools such as the h-index to explain the methodology and its significance with supporting documentation.

In a decision of January 23, 2023 (In Re: 23372913), a biochemist's work had received two early-stage commercialization grants, and a letter from the grant program explained that the funding was meant to bring his research to clinical application and commercial use. The AAO found that the director had not adequately addressed the original contributions criterion, withdrew the decision and remanded the case for a new decision.

  • Collect citation data for the specific work and a comparison with others in the same field, with the method explained.
  • Add articles, reviews or other publications by independent authors that discuss the work and its importance.
  • Document use by others: licenses, contracts, adoption by other organizations, products built on the work.
  • Obtain letters from writers outside the applicant's employers that name the contribution and the basis of their knowledge.
  • Translate every foreign-language document in full and attach the translator's certification.

Can the response rely on results that came after the petition was filed?

No. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) eligibility is established at the time of filing, and under 103.2(b)(12) a request is denied where the RFE evidence does not establish eligibility as of the filing date.

8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) requires the petitioner to be eligible "at the time of filing" and to remain eligible through adjudication. Paragraph (b)(12) states that a benefit request shall be denied where evidence submitted in response to a request for evidence does not establish filing eligibility.

The response can therefore document contributions that existed on the filing date: earlier citations, earlier licenses, earlier adoption. A contribution made after filing belongs to a new petition with its own filing date.

Translations follow the same rule as any other evidence. In the June 11, 2024 case a university website printout listed video tutorials in a foreign language without a certified English translation, and the AAO could not determine whether it supported the claim. 8 CFR 103.2(b)(3) requires a full English translation that the translator certifies as complete and accurate.

How long is the response period, and how is the response filed?

The period printed in the RFE, which may not exceed 12 weeks and cannot be extended. All materials go together, with the original RFE, and a partial response is treated as a request for a decision on the record.

Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv), an RFE response period may not exceed twelve weeks, and "Additional time to respond to a request for evidence or notice of intent to deny may not be granted." Under paragraph (b)(11), all requested materials must be submitted together at one time, along with the original request. A partial response is treated as a request for a decision on the record.

The deadline is the date to plan from. Letters, citation reports and translations are ordered so that the whole package is ready before that date, because no second submission is possible.

Does meeting the criterion after the RFE decide the petition?

No. The criterion counts toward the three required at the first step, and the officer then weighs the whole record in the final merits determination for sustained acclaim and a place at the very top of the field.

Chapter 2 describes the final merits determination as the second step: the officer considers the petition in its entirety and decides whether the evidence establishes sustained national or international acclaim and a place among the small percentage at the top. "The totality of the evidence must establish that the person is extraordinary."

In the December 16, 2024 case the AAO found the contributions criterion unmet, did not reach the remaining claimed criteria and reserved the final merits determination. In the January 23, 2023 case it remanded and directed the director to consider the totality of the record if the criterion was met.

Evidence filed for the contributions criterion counts twice: once for the criterion and again at the final merits step, where citations, adoption and independent commentary help place the applicant in the field.

How does IAE prepare an expert letter for an RFE on original contributions?

IAE prepares an expert opinion letter built on the text of the RFE, with a separate section for each finding within the expert's field. The standard turnaround is 5 business days, and the rush option takes 3.

On the RFE and NOID response page, the EB-1A and O-1 finding is listed as "Criteria and the significance of achievements," with an assessment of publications, awards, memberships and original contributions. The text of the request is split into separate findings. The expert takes the points within their field, and legal points stay with the attorney. The letter runs up to 15 pages, with point-by-point answers and references to the case file.

The request includes the text of the RFE or NOID, the petition and the supporting file. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day and checks the turnaround against the response deadline. Within one business day IAE confirms the fee, the turnaround and the expert in writing; the fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. The secretariat prepares the draft from the client's documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs it. Revisions before signing are included, and the draft goes to the attorney.

The client receives a signed PDF with the expert's CV and a declaration of independence. The expert's record can be checked by Member ID or QR code on the status check page. When the findings call for different specializations, a second expert joins at the assessment stage. IAE is not a law firm: the attorney prepares the response, the letter is one piece of evidence in it, and USCIS makes the decision.

Sources

Read also

All articles

RFE and NOID responses

Received an RFE? We count the days with you.

The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. We confirm the fee, the turnaround and the expert within one business day and check the turnaround against the response deadline.

Quote request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

DocumentRFE or NOID text
Timeline5 business days, rush 3
AuthorFrom the IAE registry