Awards

EB-1B major prizes or awards: which awards count under criterion (A)?

An EB-1B petition can count an award only if the professor or researcher personally received it and it is a major prize for outstanding achievement in the academic field. That is criterion (A) of 8 CFR 204.5(i)(3)(i), one of six criteria, of which the petition needs two. In AAO decisions of 2020 and 2022, university certificates and a $500 travel award failed the criterion, and a small dissertation prize counted only in the final merits review.

Hands set a small academic medal beside a face-down conference booklet on linen

What does the EB-1B awards criterion say?

Criterion (A) of 8 CFR 204.5(i)(3)(i) asks for documentation of the beneficiary's receipt of major prizes or awards for outstanding achievement in the academic field. It is one of six criteria, and the petition needs at least two.

The outstanding professor or researcher category, known as EB-1B, is set out in 8 CFR 204.5(i). A United States employer files Form I-140 for a professor or researcher "who is outstanding in an academic field under section 203(b)(1)(B) of the Act." The researcher does not file the petition: it comes from the university, the research institute or the company that offers the job.

The regulation defines an academic field as "a body of specialized knowledge offered for study at an accredited United States university or institution of higher education." The prize has to be for achievement in such a field, the one named in the petition.

Paragraph (i)(3)(i) asks for evidence that the professor or researcher "is recognized internationally as outstanding in the academic field specified in the petition," and adds: "Such evidence shall consist of at least two of the following." Criterion (A) comes first: "Documentation of the alien's receipt of major prizes or awards for outstanding achievement in the academic field." The other five criteria cover membership in associations that require outstanding achievements, published material by others about the researcher's work, judging the work of others, original research contributions, and authorship of scholarly books or articles in journals with international circulation.

The criteria are one part of the petition. Paragraph (i)(3)(iii) also requires evidence of "at least three years of experience in teaching and/or research in the academic field," and the employer offers a tenured, tenure-track or permanent research position. The regulation calls a research position permanent when it is "for a term of indefinite or unlimited duration" and the employee "will ordinarily have an expectation of continued employment unless there is good cause for termination."

How is it different from the EB-1A awards criterion?

EB-1A accepts lesser nationally or internationally recognized prizes for excellence in the field. EB-1B asks for major prizes for outstanding achievement in an academic field, and the whole petition must show international recognition.

For extraordinary ability, or EB-1A, paragraph (h)(3) asks for evidence that the person "has sustained national or international acclaim." The evidence may be "a one-time achievement (that is, a major, international recognized award), or at least three of the following" ten criteria. The first of the ten reads: "Documentation of the alien's receipt of lesser nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards for excellence in the field of endeavor."

Set side by side, the two texts differ in three places. EB-1B says "major" where EB-1A says "lesser nationally or internationally recognized." EB-1B says "outstanding achievement" where EB-1A says "excellence." EB-1B says "academic field" where EB-1A says "field of endeavor."

The level of recognition differs too. An EB-1A petition may rest on national acclaim, so a national prize can meet the EB-1A awards criterion. In EB-1B the introduction to paragraph (i)(3)(i) sets the standard for all the evidence: the researcher must be "recognized internationally as outstanding."

The count is different as well: two of six criteria for EB-1B, three of ten for EB-1A. Paragraph (i) has no one-time achievement option: even the largest prize enters an EB-1B petition as one criterion of the two required, and the final merits review follows.

How does USCIS check an award under criterion (A)?

With two questions. USCIS first decides whether the beneficiary personally received the prize or award, and then whether it is a major one given for outstanding achievement in the academic field.

Chapter 3 of volume 6, part F of the USCIS Policy Manual, on outstanding professors and researchers, describes the check. "First, USCIS determines if the beneficiary was the recipient of prizes or awards." The chapter explains that the wording of the regulation puts the focus on "the beneficiary's receipt of the major prizes or awards, as opposed to the employer's receipt of the prizes or awards."

"Second, USCIS determines whether the prizes or awards received are major ones and are for outstanding achievement in the academic field." Here the chapter gives a scale: "an award available only to persons within a single locality, employer, or school may have little international recognition, while an award open to members of an internationally known and respected institution (including an R1 or R2 doctoral university) or professional organization may be internationally recognized." R1 and R2 are classes of doctoral universities in the Carnegie Classification of Institutions of Higher Education, which the chapter cites in a footnote.

Officers answer both questions under the preponderance of the evidence standard. The chapter tells them to "apply a preponderance of the evidence standard when making these determinations." At this stage the officer only decides whether the award fits the regulatory description. Whether the researcher is outstanding is decided later, in the final merits determination.

Do awards from a university, an employer or a postdoc association count?

An award limited to one school or employer may have little international recognition. In an April 29, 2020 decision the AAO did not accept university certificates of honor and a $500 postdoctoral travel award under criterion (A).

The case, In Re: 7584818, concerned a research associate in cell biology and neuroscience at the petitioning university. He had earlier been a postdoctoral fellow at another university. The Nebraska Service Center denied the petition, and the Administrative Appeals Office dismissed the appeal.

Three kinds of awards were claimed under criterion (A). The first were certificates of honor from a university where he had earned his degree, for academic achievements and research projects there. The second was a $500 travel award granted in 2015 by the petitioner's Postdoctoral Association as a "Career Development fund" for conference expenses. The third was a 2012 award from a university for young postdoctoral investigators. A professor's letter of June 2019 said it was given to "not more than 5" exceptional researchers and called it "very prestigious and highly selective."

The AAO wrote that "the Petitioner has not offered sufficient information about these awards" and had not shown "their stature in the Beneficiary's field." It found that the awards were recognition from the beneficiary's alma maters and his employer and did not show international recognition in the field. For the 2012 award the record held the professor's praise and no evidence of the award's international significance.

The current Policy Manual text gives both ends of the scale. An award limited to one locality, employer or school sits at one end. An award open to members of an internationally known institution or professional organization sits at the other. The circle of people who could compete for the award is one of the facts the petition has to prove.

What if the prize went to the employer or came after filing?

A prize received by the employer does not count for the researcher under the Policy Manual. A prize received after filing does not count either: eligibility must exist on the date the petition is filed.

The Policy Manual sentence on the employer is short. The focus must be on "the beneficiary's receipt of the major prizes or awards, as opposed to the employer's receipt of the prizes or awards." A certificate made out to the university, the department or the company is the employer's receipt of an award in the words of the chapter, even when the researcher's work earned it.

Timing is set by 8 CFR 103.2(b)(1): "An applicant or petitioner must establish that he or she is eligible for the requested benefit at the time of filing the benefit request and must continue to be eligible through adjudication." A prize announced after the I-140 was filed is not evidence of eligibility on the filing date.

Can a smaller prize still count in the final merits review?

Yes. In a February 24, 2022 decision the AAO called a dissertation prize lightly contested, with a small cash amount, but wrote that it added to the evidence of recognition, and sustained the appeal.

The case, In Re: 19897654, concerned an assistant scientist at a research institution. She had a 2016 PhD in biomedical engineering, had joined the petitioner as a postdoctoral researcher in 2017 and worked in biomicroscopy. The Nebraska Service Center found that she met four of the six criteria but denied the petition because the evidence did not show international recognition.

Her prize was awarded "every three years for research related to a doctoral dissertation." The AAO did not analyze it as a major prize under criterion (A). In the final merits review it described the prize as "lightly contested and including a relatively small cash prize," and wrote that "it adds to the evidence of recognition of her work in the field."

The rest of the record carried the case. Several review articles discussed her published work, and two of them included figures from her paper. Her 2016 paper in Scientific Reports had been cited in the published work of hundreds of researchers. The editor of the Journal of Biomedical Optics wrote that the citations of her 2020 paper there placed it in the top 1% for the journal. She had completed 22 reviews for four Optical Society journals and had chaired two sessions at a 2020 conference.

The AAO's finding: "the Petitioner has established that she is internationally recognized as outstanding in her field." The prize was a small part of that finding. The AAO counted it with the facts the record gave about it: what it was for and how often it was awarded.

Is meeting criterion (A) enough for an EB-1B approval?

No. Two criteria are only the first step. USCIS then weighs all the evidence together and decides whether the researcher is recognized internationally as outstanding in a specific academic area.

Chapter 3 of the Policy Manual states: "Meeting the minimum requirement by providing at least two types of initial evidence does not, in itself, establish that the beneficiary in fact meets the requirements for classification as an outstanding professor or researcher." In the second step officers evaluate the evidence together and decide whether the petitioner has proven, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the beneficiary "is recognized internationally as outstanding in a specific academic area."

The chapter cites Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010), and notes that "USCIS has interpreted Kazarian as applicable to outstanding professor and researcher petitions." It also cites Matter of Chawathe, 25 I&N Dec. 369 (AAO 2010): "truth is to be determined not by the quantity of evidence alone but by its quality."

The 2020 case ended at this step. The AAO agreed with the Director that the researcher met three criteria: judging the work of others, original research contributions and authorship of scholarly articles. It wrote that "the evidence indicates that the Beneficiary is a skilled researcher," but found that the petitioner had not shown that he "stands apart in the academic community." The appeal was dismissed on the final merits, after the criteria count had been met.

What if criterion (A) does not fit the field?

Paragraph (i)(3)(ii) lets the petitioner submit comparable evidence if the standards do not readily apply. The Policy Manual says the petitioner need not prove that a criterion is inapplicable to the occupation.

The regulation reads: "If the standards in paragraph (i)(3)(i) of this section do not readily apply, the petitioner may submit comparable evidence to establish the beneficiary's eligibility." The EB-1A rule in paragraph (h)(4) is worded differently and speaks of standards that "do not readily apply to the beneficiary's occupation."

The Policy Manual draws the consequence for EB-1B: "A petitioner for an outstanding professor or researcher does not need to establish that a particular standard is not readily applicable to the beneficiary's occupation." The petitioner may instead submit "alternative, but qualitatively comparable evidence," if it establishes that the standards do not readily apply to that evidence.

The chapter also sets the measure for such evidence: "The existing evidentiary standards serve as a roadmap for determining, among other things, the quantity and types of evidence that should be submitted in order for such evidence to be considered 'comparable.'" Evidence offered in place of a major prize is measured against what criterion (A) asks for: personal receipt, a major distinction and outstanding achievement in the academic field.

What does the record need to say about an award?

Who received it, who gave it, who could compete for it and why it is major in the academic field. In the 2020 case the AAO found too little information about the awards and their stature.

The two questions of the Policy Manual turn into facts about each award: the name on the certificate, the body that gives the award, the circle of eligible candidates, and whether the award is given for outstanding achievement in the academic field named in the petition. The reference to R1 and R2 universities makes the pool of candidates part of the analysis.

The 2020 decision lists what was missing. For the certificates of honor and the travel award the AAO found that the petitioner "has not offered sufficient information about these awards." For the 2012 award the record had a professor's letter that called it "very prestigious and highly selective," and no evidence of its international significance. A letter that praised the prize did not replace documents about the prize itself.

The 2022 decision gives the other side. The record told the AAO how often the prize was awarded, every three years, what it was given for, dissertation research, and that the cash amount was small. With those facts the AAO could place the prize in the final merits review and count it toward the recognition of her work.

How does the IAE Award select its laureates?

Active IAE members at Senior Member, CIE or Fellow level nominate a colleague, the secretariat checks the stated achievements against primary sources, and the Council votes in a closed session with written reasoning.

The IAE Award is the annual award of the International Association of Experts for contribution to the expert profession and its standards. It has five nominations: Methodological Innovation, Expert Practice, Academic Excellence, Rising Expert and the Grand Prix. Academic Excellence is given "For contribution to the academic literature on professional verification: peer-reviewed publications and their citation." The Grand Prix is not nominated: the Council initiates its consideration, and it has not yet been awarded.

A nomination comes from an active member at Senior Member, CIE or Fellow of the Association level who is personally familiar with the candidate's work. Self-nomination is not considered, and nominators' names are not disclosed to candidates. The candidate is an active IAE member of any level with a record in the registry. The nomination gives the candidate's full name and Member ID, the category, a description of achievements of 500-1,000 words and links to verifiable sources.

Nominations are accepted between September 1 and October 31. In November the secretariat checks every stated achievement against the registry and primary sources and excludes anything it cannot verify. The Council votes in a closed session in the first week of December, with written reasoning for each decision. In December the laureates' names are published, and each laureate is entered in the public registry and receives the Council's certificate. The award procedure has no quotas and is independent of the application process and IAE services.

Nominations for 2026 closed on October 31. Only active members nominate colleagues and receive awards, so taking part starts with an application for membership; the decision comes within 30 days. Members at Senior Member, CIE or Fellow level can submit a nomination when nominations open on September 1. Whether any award, the IAE Award included, meets criterion (A) in an EB-1B petition is decided by USCIS.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Awards

Become part of the IAE community

IAE membership is the first step to taking part in the award: only active members nominate colleagues and receive awards. A decision on the application within 30 days.

Nomination

Accepted

IAE Award 2026 season

CategoryExpert practice
CandidateIAE registry member
LaureatesIn December