RFE responses
An EB-1B RFE on international recognition: what evidence answers it?
An EB-1B petition must show that the professor or researcher is recognized internationally as outstanding in the academic field. Meeting two of the six evidentiary criteria in 8 CFR 204.5(i)(3)(i) is only the first step. In three EB-1B appeals dismissed in 2024, the AAO accepted that at least two criteria were met and still found no international recognition. Among the reasons were citation counts and reviewing not compared with peers and letters without specific examples.

Why does an EB-1B RFE question international recognition?
Because the regulation asks for evidence that the beneficiary is recognized internationally as outstanding, and the officer weighs that evidence as a whole after checking the criteria. Two criteria met do not end the review.
Under 8 CFR 204.5(i)(3)(i), the petition must include "Evidence that the professor or researcher is recognized internationally as outstanding" in the academic field, consisting of at least two of six listed types of evidence.
The AAO reads this as a two-step review. In a decision of January 11, 2024, it wrote that "the successful submission of evidence meeting at least two criteria does not, in and of itself, establish eligibility for this classification," and that it would "weigh the totality of the evidence" to decide whether the beneficiary is "recognized internationally as outstanding." The decision cited Kazarian v. USCIS (9th Cir. 2010) for the two-part review and the USCIS Policy Manual, 6 USCIS-PM F.3, for the framework.
The standard of proof is a preponderance of the evidence. Citing Matter of Chawathe, the AAO asked whether the claim is "more likely than not" true. In the decision of March 22, 2024 it added that the controlling purpose of 8 CFR 204.5(i)(3)(i) is to establish a beneficiary's international recognition, so "any evidence submitted to meet these criteria must therefore be to some extent indicative of international recognition."
An RFE on international recognition therefore asks two things at once: whether each claimed criterion is documented, and whether the record as a whole proves that the field outside the beneficiary's own circle recognizes the work.
What must the petition prove besides international recognition?
At least three years of teaching or research in the academic field and a qualifying offer of employment: a tenured or tenure-track teaching position or a permanent research position. An RFE can question these points too.
Under 8 CFR 204.5(i)(3)(iii), the petition must show "at least three years of experience in teaching and/or research in the academic field." Teaching or research while working on an advanced degree counts only if the beneficiary has acquired the degree and either had full responsibility for the class taught or did research toward the degree that has been recognized within the academic field as outstanding. Employer letters document the experience, with the writer's name, address and title and a description of the duties.
Under (i)(3)(iv), no labor certification is required, but the petition needs an offer of employment from one of three employers: a U.S. university or institution of higher learning offering a tenured or tenure-track teaching position; such an institution offering a permanent research position; or a department, division or institute of a private employer offering a permanent research position. A private employer must show that it employs "at least three persons full-time in research positions" and has "achieved documented accomplishments in an academic field."
The definitions in 8 CFR 204.5(i)(2) control these terms. An academic field is "a body of specialized knowledge offered for study at an accredited United States university or institution of higher education." A permanent research position is "either tenured, tenure-track, or for a term of indefinite or unlimited duration," with an expectation of continued employment unless there is good cause for termination.
Which criteria can the response rely on?
The six types of evidence in 8 CFR 204.5(i)(3)(i), of which at least two are needed. If the standards do not readily apply, the petitioner may submit comparable evidence under 204.5(i)(3)(ii).
The regulation lists six types of evidence:
- Documentation of the beneficiary's receipt of major prizes or awards for outstanding achievement in the academic field.
- Documentation of membership in associations in the academic field that require outstanding achievements of their members.
- Published material in professional publications written by others about the beneficiary's work in the academic field, with the title, date and author and any necessary translation.
- Evidence of participation, individually or on a panel, as the judge of the work of others in the same or an allied academic field.
- Evidence of original scientific or scholarly research contributions to the academic field.
- Evidence of authorship of scholarly books or articles, in scholarly journals with international circulation, in the academic field.
When can comparable evidence be used?
Paragraph (i)(3)(ii) provides: "If the standards in paragraph (i)(3)(i) of this section do not readily apply," then "the petitioner may submit comparable evidence to establish the beneficiary's eligibility." The response has to explain why a standard does not readily apply before it offers a substitute.
Is peer review enough to show international recognition?
Not by itself. The AAO wrote in 2024 that participation in peer review does not automatically show international recognition and that the record has to compare the beneficiary's reviewing with that of peers.
In the March 22, 2024 decision, the beneficiary, a software engineering researcher in computer vision and machine learning, had reviewed four papers for one conference and three for one journal and had been invited to review three papers for another conference. The AAO noted that the record did not show the invited reviews were completed and that the petitioner did not show how this activity compares with peers. It wrote that participation in peer review "does not automatically" establish international recognition.
In the March 4, 2024 decision, about a sociologist, the AAO called peer review "a routine part of the process" and observed that "possessing expertise in a given field is a considerably lower threshold" than international recognition. The judging criterion was met in both cases, and both appeals were dismissed.
A response on judging therefore documents more than the count of reviews. It names where the reviews were done, whether they were completed and how the beneficiary's role compares with that of others at the same career stage.
How do citations and publications have to be presented?
With a comparison. In 2024 the AAO rejected citation counts offered without statistical evidence or other objective metrics comparing them with others in the field, and held that a journal's impact factor speaks to the journal, not the author.
In the March 22, 2024 case, eight articles had 77 cumulative citations, and the top five had 24, 21, 11, 10 and 8. The AAO wrote that "Without statistical evidence or other objective metrics comparing the number of citations" with peers, the petitioner had not shown recognition. It added that a high journal or conference ranking or impact factor describes how often a publication is cited as a whole and does not show an individual author's influence.
In response to a notice of intent to deny, that petitioner submitted Google Scholar Metrics and a conference ranking list from Research.com. The AAO noted that one journal did not appear on the Google Scholar list, one conference ranked 23rd and another was not in the top 100, and the outcome did not change.
In the January 11, 2024 case, about research on Internet of Things systems for water management, the AAO found that the Google Scholar profile in the record appeared to belong to a different person with the same name. The petitioner did not address the point, and the inconsistency stayed unresolved. In the March 4, 2024 case, ten articles had five citations in total.
Which awards and memberships did the AAO reject?
An award given to the employer and not the beneficiary, a fellowship at the beneficiary's own university, honorary certificates, grant funding and IEEE Senior membership, which the record did not show requires outstanding achievement.
In the January 11, 2024 case, the petitioner relied on a 2023 Presidential Award for Export Achievements. The AAO wrote that "this award for increasing export sales was presented to the Petitioner and not the Beneficiary," and it noted that the award came after the petition was filed. Eligibility has to exist at the time of filing.
In the March 22, 2024 case, a 2016 mentored fellowship at the beneficiary's alma mater was not shown to be a major prize or award for outstanding achievement. For IEEE Senior membership the AAO wrote: "The record therefore does not indicate that the Beneficiary's IEEE Senior membership requires outstanding achievement."
In the March 4, 2024 case, the petitioner had not shown that the Armenian honorary certificates qualify as major prizes or awards, or that the grant funding required outstanding research achievements. Media articles in Armenian outlets about the beneficiary's books and research were considered in the final merits review, and the AAO found that this level of coverage had not been shown to rise to international recognition.
What did the AAO find missing in the recommendation letters?
Specific information. In all three 2024 decisions the AAO wrote that the letters did not contain sufficient information and explanation and did not show recognition by the academic field at large rather than by the references selected.
In the March 22, 2024 decision, a referee wrote that the beneficiary's findings "are unique and will gain tremendous recognition once quantum computing becomes mainstream." The AAO noted that he "did not provide specific examples" of impact. It held that the letters "do not contain sufficient information and explanation" and did not show recognition by the academic field at large, "rather than by the references he selected."
In the January 11, 2024 decision, a letter from an engineer in Nepal called the research "a significant resource internationally." The AAO found no corroborating evidence of influence and wrote that "not every research finding that broadens knowledge in a particular field renders an individual's work as outstanding."
In the March 4, 2024 decision, the letters described collaborations, syllabi, workshops and reviewing. One letter's claim about twenty papers was not corroborated. The AAO again found that the letters rested on the references the beneficiary selected.
How long is there to respond, and how is the response filed?
The RFE states the deadline, which cannot exceed twelve weeks, and no additional time may be granted. All requested materials are filed together at one time with the original request.
Under the current text of 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv), the request indicates the deadline, but "in no case shall the maximum response period provided in a request for evidence exceed twelve weeks," and a notice of intent to deny may give no more than thirty days. "Additional time to respond to a request for evidence or notice of intent to deny may not be granted." USCIS introduced this wording in a rule published in the Federal Register on April 17, 2007, effective June 18, 2007.
Under the current 103.2(b)(11), which the same 2007 rule amended, "All requested materials must be submitted together at one time, along with the original USCIS request for evidence or notice of intent to deny." "Submission of only some of the requested evidence will be considered a request for a decision on the record."
A response cannot move the date on which eligibility is judged. In the January 11, 2024 decision, the award received after filing did not count, because eligibility must be shown at the time of filing. Evidence in the response documents facts that already existed when the petition was filed.
What can an expert letter add to an EB-1B response?
Analysis of the points the officer raised, with references to documents in the record: how the beneficiary's citations, reviewing and contributions compare with the field, and who outside the beneficiary's circle uses the work.
The 2024 decisions name what the records lacked. The letters gave no specific examples of impact, the citation counts had no comparison with peers, and the reviewing was not compared with the activity of others. An expert letter written for the response can take each of these findings in turn and point to the exhibits that answer it.
The weight of a letter depends on its content and on the documents behind it. The AAO dismissed all three appeals after finding that the letters rested on references the beneficiary selected and lacked corroborating evidence.
How does IAE prepare an expert letter for an EB-1B RFE?
IAE prepares an expert opinion letter built on the text of the RFE, with a separate section for each finding in the expert's field. The standard turnaround is 5 business days, and the rush option takes 3.
On the RFE and NOID response page, the text of the request is split into separate findings. The expert takes the points within their field, and legal points stay with the attorney. For EB-1A and O-1 cases the page names the assessment of publications, awards, memberships and original contributions, the same kinds of evidence an EB-1B RFE questions. The letter runs up to 15 pages, with point-by-point answers and references to the case file.
The request includes the text of the RFE or NOID, the petition and the supporting file. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day and checks the turnaround against the response deadline. Within one business day IAE confirms the fee, the turnaround and the expert in writing; the fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. The secretariat prepares the draft from the client's documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs it. Revisions before signing are included, and the draft goes to the attorney. RFE and NOID orders go into a priority queue, and the 3-day rush counts from payment and receipt of all materials.
The client receives a signed PDF with the expert's CV and a declaration of independence. The expert's record can be checked by Member ID or QR code on the status check page. When the findings call for different specializations, a second expert joins at the assessment stage. IAE is not a law firm: the attorney prepares the response, the letter is one piece of evidence in it, and USCIS makes the decision.
Sources
- 8 CFR 204.5, Petitions for employment-based immigrants, including (i) Outstanding professors and researchers (LII, Cornell Law School)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 29024063, January 11, 2024 (outstanding professors and researchers)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 30240228, March 4, 2024 (outstanding professors and researchers)
- AAO non-precedent decision, In Re: 30518950, March 22, 2024 (outstanding professors and researchers)
- USCIS, Removal of the Standardized Request for Evidence Processing Timeframe, 72 FR 19100 (April 17, 2007)
- 8 CFR 103.2, Submission and adjudication of benefit requests, including (b)(8) and (b)(11) (eCFR, current text)
Read also
All articles
A second RFE after you responded: why does USCIS ask again, and how do you answer?
USCIS can send a second request for evidence on the same petition. Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8) it may deny, request more evidence or give notice of its
An H-1B RFE on a Level I wage: why does the wage level put the specialty occupation in question, and what evidence answers it?
A Level I wage on the labor condition application tells USCIS that the employer is paying an entry-level worker who performs routine tasks under
An EB-1A RFE on commercial success in the performing arts: what evidence answers it?
The tenth EB-1A criterion counts commercial successes in the performing arts, shown by box office receipts or record, cassette, compact disk or videoRFE and NOID responses
Received an RFE? We count the days with you.
The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. We confirm the fee, the turnaround and the expert within one business day and check the turnaround against the response deadline.

