Examinations
Eminent domain appraisal: what must the government's appraisal contain, and how does the owner test it?
In an eminent domain case the owner is paid just compensation, which the Supreme Court in United States v. Miller defined through market value: what a willing buyer would pay in cash to a willing seller. Federal law requires the agency to appraise before negotiating and to offer at least its approved appraisal. In Florida the owner can obtain the appraisal behind the offer, and the condemning authority pays the owner's reasonable appraisal fees.

What does just compensation mean in an eminent domain case?
The full and perfect equivalent in money of the property taken, measured by market value: what a willing buyer would pay in cash to a willing seller. Value that is special to the government is excluded.
United States v. Miller, 317 U.S. 369, decided January 4, 1943, with the opinion by Justice Roberts, concerned land condemned for the relocation of some thirty miles of a railroad line. The old right of way would be flooded by water impounded for the Central Valley Reclamation Project in California, with the dam at Shasta. Before Congress authorized the project in August 1937, the land was largely uncleared brush. Afterward it was subdivided and developed into a settlement called Boomtown.
The Court held that the Fifth Amendment requires "the full and perfect equivalent in money of the property taken," and that market value is what "a willing buyer would pay in cash to a willing seller." Where the property has no market, courts may need other data, and value that is special to the condemnor is excluded. Federal courts follow local forms of procedure, but the measure of compensation is governed by the Federal Constitution, not by local law.
The Court was frank about the limits of the method. Where neither the property nor nearby land has recently sold in significant amounts, "the application of this concept involves, at best, a guess by informed persons." The federal appraisal rules below require the appraiser to describe the comparable sales and the approaches used, which gives the owner something to check.
Can the owner be paid for value the project itself created?
No, if the land was probably within the scope of the project from the time it was authorized. Federal appraisal rules also tell the appraiser to disregard any increase or decrease in value caused by the project.
In Miller the owners claimed the higher value their land had gained after the project was announced. The Court refused it where the land was probably within the project's scope from its authorization: "the owners ought not to gain by speculating on probable increase in value due to the Government's activities." Land merely adjacent to the project keeps the value added by its proximity, and the same exclusion applies to severance damages.
The federal acquisition regulation applies the same idea in both directions. Under 49 CFR 24.103(b), "The appraiser shall disregard any decrease or increase in the fair market value" of the property caused by the project, except physical deterioration within the reasonable control of the owner.
For an owner this rule cuts both ways. Neighborhood decline after a highway announcement does not reduce the value, and a price boom caused by the project does not raise it. A review of the government's appraisal checks whether the comparable sales were affected by the project and how the appraiser treated them.
What must the government's appraisal contain?
Under 49 CFR 24.103 it follows USPAP and contains the property description, a highest and best use analysis, a sales history of at least 5 years, the approaches to value, comparable sales and the effective date.
The Uniform Relocation Assistance and Real Property Acquisition Policies Act sets the federal acquisition rules. Under 42 U.S.C. 4651(2), real property is appraised before negotiations begin, and "the owner or his designated representative shall be given an opportunity to accompany the appraiser" during the inspection. The head of the lead agency may prescribe a procedure to waive the appraisal for low-value property acquired by sale or donation.
The regulation that carries out the Act, 49 CFR Part 24, sets the content. Section 24.103(a) states: "Appraisals are to be performed according to this section, which is intended to be consistent with the USPAP." Agencies may add their own requirements, such as the Uniform Appraisal Standards for Federal Land Acquisition. Each appraisal includes a description of the property's physical characteristics, encumbrances, title, location, zoning, present use, a highest and best use analysis and at least a 5-year sales history; all relevant and reliable approaches to value, reconciled if more than one is used; a description of the comparable sales; a statement of value, with damages and benefits to the remainder in a partial acquisition; and the effective date of valuation, the date of the appraisal, a signature and the appraiser's certification.
Under 24.103(d) the agency sets minimum qualifications for appraisers and review appraisers and uses only those it finds qualified, and contract appraisers must be State licensed or certified under title XI of FIRREA.
How is the offer set, and can it be lower than the appraisal?
It cannot be lower. Under 42 U.S.C. 4651(3) the agency sets the amount it believes to be just compensation, and "in no event shall such amount be less than the agency's approved appraisal."
Before negotiations start, the agency sets the amount it believes to be just compensation, makes a prompt offer and gives the owner a written statement summarizing the basis for that amount (42 U.S.C. 4651(3)). The agency head "shall make every reasonable effort to acquire expeditiously real property by negotiation" (4651(1)), may not "take any other action coercive in nature, in order to compel an agreement on the price to be paid" (4651(7)), and, if eminent domain is used, "shall institute formal condemnation proceedings" (4651(8)). The owner cannot be required to surrender possession before the agency pays the agreed price or deposits with the court an amount not less than the approved appraisal or the award of compensation (4651(4)).
The approved appraisal comes out of a review. Under 49 CFR 24.104 a qualified review appraiser examines the presentation and analysis of market information in all appraisals. If an appraisal cannot be approved and another appraisal is not practical, the review appraiser may present and analyze market information to support a recommended or approved value. The review appraiser writes a report listing the appraisals reviewed and the findings, and the signed certification states the approved value and, if the agency authorizes it, the amount believed to be just compensation.
The owner who disagrees has two documents to test: the appraisal itself and the review appraiser's report, which shows what the agency accepted and why.
Can the owner see the appraisal behind the offer?
In Florida, yes. Before filing suit the condemning authority makes a written offer and, if the owner requests it, provides the appraisal on which the offer is based within 15 business days.
Section 73.015(1) of the Florida Statutes requires the condemning authority to negotiate in good faith and to give the owner a written offer and, "if requested, a copy of the appraisal upon which the offer is based." Under 73.015(1)(a)3 the appraisal is provided "within 15 business days after receipt of a request by the fee owner." Under 73.015(1)(b) the owner has at least 30 days after receiving the notice to respond before the authority files a condemnation proceeding.
That window is when an owner's appraiser can review the authority's appraisal against 49 CFR 24.103 where federal funds are involved, against USPAP in any case, and against the owner's own knowledge of the property.
Under federal law the owner or a representative may also accompany the government's appraiser during the inspection (42 U.S.C. 4651(2)) and show the property in person.
As of which date is the property valued in Florida?
As of the date of trial or the date title passes, whichever occurs first. A jury of 12 decides the compensation under section 73.071 of the Florida Statutes.
Section 73.071(1) provides that a jury of 12 decides "the issue of compensation." Under 73.071(2) compensation is "determined as of the date of trial, or the date upon which title passes, whichever shall occur first." If title passes before trial, the earlier date controls.
The date matters for the comparable sales. An appraisal prepared months before that date relies on sales that may be stale by trial, and a review of the authority's appraisal checks whether its effective date is the date the statute requires.
Are business losses compensated in a Florida taking?
Only under section 73.071(3)(b): the taking is less than the entire property, an established business of the required standing sits on adjoining land of the same owner, and a public body takes a right of way.
Under 73.071(3)(b), business damages apply only when the taking is of "less than the entire property." The business must be an established business of more than 5 years' standing under the version of the rule that applies on or after January 1, 2005, located on land adjoining the part taken and owned by the same party, and the action must be by a public body condemning a right of way.
The claim has its own deadline. Under 73.015(2)(c) the business owner must, "within 180 days after either receipt of the notice," submit "a good faith written offer to settle any claims of business damage." Without good faith justification for a late offer, "the court must strike the business owner's claim."
The loss to the business is a different question from the value of the land taken, and it is measured from the business's own financial records.
Who pays the owner's appraisal and attorney's fees in Florida?
The condemning authority. Under section 73.091 it pays all reasonable costs of the defense, including reasonable appraisal fees, and under 73.092 attorney's fees are based solely on the benefits achieved for the owner.
Section 73.091(1) requires the petitioner to pay "all reasonable costs incurred in the defense of the proceedings in the circuit court, including, but not limited to, reasonable appraisal fees." An owner in Florida can therefore retain an appraiser to rebut the authority's appraisal, and the reasonable fee is part of the costs the authority pays.
Attorney's fees follow a formula. Under 73.092(1) the court "shall award attorney's fees based solely on the benefits achieved for the client." Benefits are the difference, exclusive of interest, between the final judgment or settlement and the last written offer the authority made before the owner hired an attorney. The fee is 33 percent of benefits up to $250,000, 25 percent of the portion between $250,000 and $1 million and 20 percent of the portion above $1 million.
The formula ties the attorney's fee to the gap between the last written offer and the result, so the appraisal behind that offer is the figure the owner's appraiser tests first.
What does IAE do in a condemnation case?
An IAE appraiser prepares an expert report on the market value of the property taken or a review of the condemning authority's appraisal against USPAP, in up to 5 business days. The property and the valuation date are confirmed first.
The IAE valuation page covers the market value of a house, building or land on the date of a sale, a divorce or a taking, for estate and gift tax disputes, divorce, condemnation and shareholder cases. Development follows USPAP Standard 1, and each comparable sale and adjustment is traced to its source. A review under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 gives an opinion on the quality of the opposing appraisal: comparables, adjustments, the effective date and the support for each conclusion.
IAE confirms the questions, the property and the valuation date with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt of materials the same day and, within one business day, the format, cost, deadline and the appraiser from the registry; the client approves the candidate and the CV. Cases with tight deadlines can use a 48-hour rush.
Appraisers are listed in the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The appraiser confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. IAE is not a law firm, and neither IAE nor the appraiser guarantees the outcome of the negotiation or the verdict.
Sources
- United States v. Miller, 317 U.S. 369 (1943) (U.S. Reports, govinfo.gov)
- 42 U.S.C. 4651, Uniform policy on real property acquisition practices (govinfo.gov, 2023 edition)
- 49 CFR 24.103, Criteria for appraisals (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 49 CFR 24.104, Review of appraisals (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Florida Statutes 2025, chapter 73, Eminent domain (sections 73.015, 73.071, 73.091, 73.092)
Read also
All articles
House owned before the marriage: how is the marital share of its appreciation valued in a Florida divorce?
A house one spouse owned before the wedding is that spouse's nonmarital property in Florida. The marriage can still give the other spouse a claim
Qualified appraisal for a noncash charitable contribution: who may sign it, what must it contain and when is the deduction lost?
A deduction of more than $5,000 for donated property requires a qualified appraisal under section 170(f)(11) of the Internal Revenue Code
Gift tax appraisal: what does adequate disclosure require, and what must the appraisal contain?
The IRS has three years after a gift tax return is filed to assess more tax, but only if the gift was adequately disclosed. If it was not, the periodExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

