RFE responses

H-1B RFE on specialty occupation: what evidence answers it?

A specialty occupation RFE means the officer did not find that the offered job requires a bachelor's degree in a directly related specific specialty. Since January 17, 2025, the regulation defines "directly related" as a logical connection between the degree and the duties, accepts a range of degree fields and states that "normally does not mean always." The response has 12 weeks at most and answers the criteria one by one.

A diploma tube, a closed job folder and a face-down envelope rest on a desk

Why does USCIS issue a specialty occupation RFE?

Because the record did not establish that the position fits the regulatory definition and at least one of four criteria. USCIS may request evidence when the initial evidence is missing or does not establish eligibility.

Under 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(ii), a specialty occupation is "an occupation which requires theoretical and practical application of a body of highly specialized knowledge" in fields "including, but not limited to" architecture, engineering, mathematics, physical sciences, social sciences, medicine and health, education, business specialties, accounting, law, theology and the arts, "and which requires the attainment of a bachelor's degree or higher in a directly related specific specialty, or its equivalent, as a minimum for entry into the occupation in the United States."

The definition alone is not enough. Paragraph (h)(4)(iii)(A) says that a position does not meet it "unless it also satisfies at least one of the following criteria". The officer asks two questions: does the job fit the definition, and does the record prove at least one criterion?

Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(ii), USCIS may request evidence when required initial evidence is missing or does not establish eligibility. Under 103.2(b)(1), the petitioner must establish eligibility "at the time of filing". The response therefore proves the job as it was described in the petition. A response that rewrites the duties to fit the criteria describes a different job.

What changed in the specialty occupation rules in 2025?

The DHS final rule published on December 18, 2024 took effect 30 days later. It defined "directly related", accepted a range of degree fields, dropped the named examples of general degrees and added that "normally does not mean always."

The rule, RIN 1615-AC70, is titled "Modernizing H-1B Requirements, Providing Flexibility in the F-1 Program, and Program Improvements Affecting Other Nonimmigrant Workers." It was scheduled for publication in the Federal Register on December 18, 2024 and took effect 30 days after publication, on January 17, 2025.

The current definition says that a position "is not a specialty occupation if attainment of a general degree, without further specialization, is sufficient to qualify for the position." DHS removed the references to "business administration" and "liberal arts" from the final text and explained that "the title of the degree alone is not determinative and that degree titles may differ among schools and evolve over time." A position "may allow for a range of qualifying degree fields, provided that each of those fields is directly related to the duties of the position." The rule adds: "Directly related means there is a logical connection between the required degree, or its equivalent, and the duties of the position."

For the four criteria, the rule defines "normally" as "conforming to a type, standard, or regular pattern", that which is "considered usual, typical, common, or routine." The paragraph ends with one sentence: "Normally does not mean always." DHS tied this clarification to skills-based hiring and alternative training programs.

Which of the four criteria should the response argue?

Any one is enough, and the response can argue several: the occupation's normal entry requirement, the practice of similar employers, the employer's or client's own requirement, or duties so specialized, complex or unique that they need the degree.

The first criterion: a U.S. baccalaureate or higher degree in a directly related specific specialty, or its equivalent, "is normally the minimum requirement for entry into the particular occupation". The evidence is occupational data for the occupation the job belongs to, discussed in the next section.

The second criterion: such a degree "is normally required to perform job duties in parallel positions among similar organizations in the employer's industry in the United States". The evidence is about other employers: their job postings for the same role, statements from industry associations, and an expert's account of how organizations of the employer's type staff the role.

The third criterion: "The employer, or third party if the beneficiary will be staffed to that third party, normally requires" such a degree "to perform the job duties of the position". The evidence is the employer's own hiring record for the position: past postings, the degrees of the people who held it, and, for a client placement, the client's requirement.

The fourth criterion: "The specific duties of the proffered position are so specialized, complex, or unique that the knowledge required to perform them is normally associated with the attainment of a U.S. baccalaureate or higher degree in a directly related specific specialty, or its equivalent." The evidence is a duty-by-duty description that names, for each duty, the knowledge it draws on and the courses in which that knowledge is taught.

How does the Occupational Outlook Handbook figure in the RFE?

In Innova Solutions v. Baran USCIS denied a petition for a computer programmer after reading the Handbook entry, and the Ninth Circuit held that "typically" in the Handbook and "normally" in the regulation are synonyms.

Innova Solutions petitioned for a computer programmer who held a bachelor's degree. USCIS denied the petition, and the district court granted USCIS summary judgment. The Occupational Outlook Handbook (OOH) entry stated that "Most computer programmers have a bachelor's degree in computer science or a related subject". USCIS argued that some employers hire programmers with associate degrees and that the Handbook described "a wide range of educational credentials".

On December 16, 2020, the Ninth Circuit, in case No. 19-16849 and an opinion by Judge John B. Owens, reversed and remanded, holding the denial arbitrary and capricious. "There is no daylight between typically needed, per the OOH, and normally required, per the regulatory criteria," the court wrote, and "'Typically' and 'normally' are synonyms." Some hires without a bachelor's degree, it held, are consistent with a bachelor's degree being the normal minimum. It also found that USCIS had misstated the Handbook entry. The opinion contains the sentence that the final rule later added to the regulation: "Normally does not mean always."

A response under the first criterion quotes the Handbook entry, names the detailed occupation the job falls in and maps the job's duties to the duties in that entry. Where the entry lists several degree fields, the response ties each field the employer accepts to the duties, because each qualifying field must be directly related.

What if the degree field does not match the job title?

The regulation asks for a logical connection between the degree and the duties, not for a matching title. A range of fields qualifies if each one is directly related; a general degree without further specialization does not.

This RFE can raise two separate questions. One concerns the position: whether the requirement the employer sets is a degree in a directly related specific specialty. The other concerns the worker. Under 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(iii)(C), the beneficiary qualifies with a U.S. bachelor's or higher degree required by the specialty, a foreign degree found equivalent to it, an unrestricted state license, registration or certification that permits full practice of the specialty, or education, specialized training and progressively responsible experience equivalent to the degree, together with recognition of expertise.

If the employer's posting accepts a bachelor's degree in any field, or a general degree without specialization, the stated requirement itself fails the definition. The response then has to show the requirement the employer actually applies and why: which courses the duties draw on and which degree fields teach them.

A worker whose degree carries a different name from the job title is answered through the duties. The response lists the duties, the knowledge each one needs and where that knowledge sits in the worker's transcript.

What if the worker will be placed at a client's site?

Then the client's requirements count. Under 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(i)(B)(3), when the worker is staffed to a third party, "it is the requirements of that third party, and not the petitioner, that are most relevant."

The third criterion names the third party directly, and paragraph (h)(4)(iv)(C) lets USCIS ask for proof from the client. In accordance with 8 CFR 103.2(b) and paragraph (h)(9), USCIS "may request evidence such as contracts, work orders, or other similar evidence between all parties in a contractual relationship showing the bona fide nature of the beneficiary's position and the minimum educational requirements to perform the duties."

The final rule's preamble lists this provision under the heading "Third-Party Placement (Codifying Policy Based on Defensor v. Meissner (5th Cir. 2000))".

A response to a client-site RFE carries the end client's own description of the duties and of the degree it requires, signed by someone at the client, together with the contract chain that links the client to the petitioner. A letter from the petitioner alone states the petitioner's requirement, which the regulation treats as less relevant than the client's.

How much weight does an expert opinion letter carry?

Advisory weight. In Matter of Caron International the Commissioner held that expert statements may be used as advisory opinions, and that the agency may reject them or give them less weight when they conflict with other information or are questionable.

Matter of Caron International, Inc., Interim Decision 3085, decided by the Commissioner on October 28, 1988, concerned an H-1 petition for a yarn manufacturer's vice-president of manufacturing. The decision says the Service "may, in its discretion, use as advisory opinions statements from universities, professional organizations, or other sources". Where an opinion is "not in accord with other information" or "in any way questionable", the Service "is not required to accept or may give less weight to that evidence." The final determination of eligibility stays with the Service.

The letters in Caron came from three universities and the American Yarn Spinners Association. The Commissioner found that they did not establish that a specific academic degree was the minimum requirement, and one university letter stated: "To proceed without formal textile education is definitely possible." The petition was approved on another ground. A letter for a specialty occupation RFE states which degree fields the duties require and why, and it does not concede that the work can be learned without them.

An expert who knows the industry can address the second and fourth criteria directly. The letter describes how organizations of the employer's type staff the same role and goes through each duty with the knowledge it draws on. It names the author's background, the sources for each statement about hiring practice and the documents the author reviewed, so that the officer can check it against the rest of the record.

How long is there to respond, and how is the response filed?

No more than 12 weeks, with no extension. All requested materials go in together, and submitting only part of the evidence counts as a request for a decision on the record.

Under 8 CFR 103.2(b)(8)(iv), "in no case shall the maximum response period provided in a request for evidence exceed twelve weeks," and "Additional time to respond to a request for evidence or notice of intent to deny may not be granted." Under 103.2(b)(11), "All requested materials must be submitted together at one time," and "Submission of only some of the requested evidence will be considered a request for a decision on the record."

If the petitioner does not respond, 103.2(b)(13)(i) provides that the request "may be summarily denied as abandoned, denied based on the record, or denied for both reasons." If the decision will be adverse and based on derogatory information, 103.2(b)(16)(i) requires that the petitioner be advised of this fact and "offered an opportunity to rebut the information".

The expert letter goes into the same package, so it has to be signed before the attorney assembles the response. The expert needs the RFE, the petition, the job description, the Labor Condition Application and, for a client placement, the client documents.

Does a prior H-1B approval for the same worker help?

It can. The final rule wrote deference into 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5): with the same parties and underlying facts, adjudicators generally should defer to a prior USCIS eligibility determination unless it contained a material error or circumstances materially changed.

The rule codified the deference policy at 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5). When the same parties and the same underlying facts are involved, "adjudicators generally should defer to a prior USCIS determination on eligibility". Deference does not apply when the earlier approval involved a material error or when a material change affects eligibility.

An extension petition for the same worker, the same employer and the same duties can cite the earlier approval notice and show that the duties and the degree requirement have not changed. A new employer, a new client or a rewritten job description changes the parties or the facts, and the officer reviews the position again.

How does IAE prepare an expert letter for a specialty occupation RFE?

IAE prepares an expert opinion letter built on the text of the RFE, with a separate section for each finding in the expert's field. The standard turnaround is 5 business days, and the rush option takes 3.

On the RFE and NOID response page the H-1B finding is listed as "Specialty occupation not established", and the expert's part is "Analysis of the position's duties and industry hiring practice." The text of the request is split into separate findings. The expert takes the points within their field, and legal points stay with the attorney. The letter runs up to 15 pages, with point-by-point answers and references to the case file.

The request includes the text of the RFE or NOID, the petition and the supporting file. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day and checks the turnaround against the response deadline. Within one business day IAE confirms the fee, the turnaround and the expert in writing; the fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. The secretariat prepares the draft from the client's documents, and the expert checks it, makes changes and signs it. Revisions before signing are included, and the draft goes to the attorney. RFE and NOID orders go into a priority queue, and the 3-day rush counts from payment and receipt of all materials.

The client receives a signed PDF with the expert's CV and a declaration of independence. The expert's record can be checked by Member ID or QR code on the status check page. When the findings call for different specializations, a second expert joins at the assessment stage. IAE is not a law firm: the attorney prepares the response, the letter is one piece of evidence in it, and USCIS makes the decision.

Sources

Read also

All articles

RFE and NOID responses

Received an RFE? We count the days with you.

The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. We confirm the fee, the turnaround and the expert within one business day and check the turnaround against the response deadline.

Quote request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

DocumentRFE or NOID text
Timeline5 business days, rush 3
AuthorFrom the IAE registry