Membership

Who can sponsor your membership application, and how many current members do you need?

Many professional societies admit a new member only after current members vouch for the applicant. The American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons ask for up to two sponsors depending on the membership category, the Society for Neuroscience asks for one, and the American Association for Thoracic Surgery asks for three. Each society sets its own rules on who may sponsor, what the sponsor signs and what an applicant with no contacts in the society can do.

From behind, one member slides a closed folder across a cafe table

What does it mean to be sponsored by a current member?

A current member in good standing confirms, in a form, a letter or the online application, that he or she supports the candidate. The society's membership committee then decides on the application.

The American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons (ASES) state the rule in one sentence on the ASES sponsorship page: applicants "must be properly sponsored by current members of the Society." The page then lists "the minimum number of sponsors each applicant must have prior to receiving an application." At ASES the sponsors come first. The application form comes after them.

The Society of Forensic Toxicologists (SOFT) sets the same order: "Applicants must secure all required sponsors before submitting their application." Each sponsor completes a sponsorship form online, a copy goes to the applicant automatically, and the applicant uploads it with the application.

The Society for Neuroscience (SfN) uses a shorter version. A new member types the sponsor's last name and SfN member ID number into the application. Member ID numbers are not public, so the applicant gets the number from the sponsor directly.

How many sponsors or references do societies require?

Up to three in the societies reviewed here. SfN and ASGE ask for one sponsor, SOFT asks for two for Full Membership, and AATS and the IEEE Senior Member grade need three.

At ASES the number depends on the category. Active and Associate applicants need two current Active Members, a General applicant needs one, and a Corresponding applicant needs two Corresponding or two Active members, or one of each. Fellows in an ASES-recognized fellowship program need no sponsor. A fellow outside such a program needs one ASES member, Active or Associate.

SOFT asks for two Full Members in good standing for Full Membership and one for Associate Membership. A student may bring one Full Member or an academic advisor. Retired and Emeritus applicants need no sponsor.

The ASGE sponsor endorsement form for international applicants reads: "To apply for active membership, the candidate must be sponsored by one current ASGE member (Senior, Active or International)." The American Association for Thoracic Surgery (AATS) requires "Three Sponsors who are currently members of the Association." IEEE asks a Senior Member candidate for three references.

Who can act as a sponsor?

Usually a current member of a set grade. IEEE accepts Fellows, Senior Members and Honorary Members, ACP asks for a Fellow or a Master, and SfN accepts postdoctoral, regular, emeritus and graduate student members.

The IEEE Geoscience and Remote Sensing Society page states that "candidates for Senior Member grade must supply three references from current IEEE members holding the grade of Fellow, Senior Member, or Honorary Member." An IEEE Member below Senior Member grade cannot be one of the three.

The ACP Membership Sponsoring Form applies to member applicants outside ACP chapters who are not board certified in internal medicine or neurology. Their sponsor must be "a current recipient of ACP Fellowship (FACP) or Mastership (MACP)."

SfN accepts "Any postdoc, regular or emeritus SfN member with an active membership for the current year." Graduate students may sponsor as well, and SfN sets no limit on how many new members one existing member sponsors.

AATS adds a rule about who reviews. The primary sponsor must be a current Active, Senior or Honorary member and starts the application in the Nominate a Candidate area, and sponsors may not sit on the Membership Committee. At the Central Surgical Association (CSA) the sponsor must be an Active or Senior member, and one more Active or Senior member endorses the application.

What does a sponsor confirm or write?

It depends on the society's form. An ACP sponsor ticks a statement on personal knowledge or on the accuracy of the application, while an AATS sponsor writes a letter covering eight qualifications.

The ACP form offers three statements. The first confirms that "the applicant has met the customary and nationally accepted years of training in internal medicine or neurology." The second reads: "I know the applicant personally and recommend them for membership." The third reads: "I do not know the applicant but can attest to the accuracy of the information on the application." The form also has a signature block for the applicant's Departmental Director or Chair of Medicine.

On the ASGE form the sponsor states the basis for the evaluation, for example as director of the applicant's endoscopic training program or as an ASGE member familiar with the applicant's clinical and endoscopic skills. The sponsor then marks "I recommend" or "I do not recommend for ASGE membership" and signs.

AATS sponsors write letters on eight qualifications, among them personal knowledge of the candidate, academic appointments, clinical performance and professional conduct. The AATS application page states that "confirmatory evidence of qualities rather than emotional appeal is expected."

At CSA a letter of support from the sponsor or the endorser is optional and must be in the online application by the deadline. The CSA page warns: "Submission of the same letter which accompanied the first application may have a detrimental effect on the candidate's chances of selection."

How does the sponsor's form reach the society?

Most societies collect it online. The applicant enters the sponsor's email address or member ID, the society sends the sponsor a link, and the completed form joins the application file.

At ASES "Each applicant will enter their sponsors email address which will automatically send that sponsor a link" to complete the form on the applicant's behalf. The forms are collected through the membership application.

CFA Institute uses a reference submission tool. The CFA Society Houston instructions list the order. The applicant prepares a resume with the current job title and the candidate or ID number, registers and applies on the CFA Institute website, receives an email with a link to the tool and forwards it to the reference together with the resume. The reference signs in, identifies the applicant by email address and answers four reference questions.

The same page asks applicants not to contact potential references until the first two steps are done.

ACP takes the recommendation with the application, or directly from the sponsor by fax or email. SOFT sends the applicant a copy of the completed sponsorship form, and the applicant uploads it.

What if you do not know any current members?

Some societies publish a route. SfN points to its member directory and lets a committee review an application without a sponsor, and ACP accepts a letter from a local internal medicine society president.

SfN tells applicants to "Use the SfN member directory to find a sponsor," to narrow the search to a zip code or a city, and to write to potential sponsors with the reasons for joining, a note on the current position or research and a CV. The page warns that "there is no guarantee that every person you contact will respond" and advises contacting several people.

Applicants who find no sponsor may have the application reviewed by members of the SfN Global Membership Committee or the Early Career Advisory Committee. The applicant asks for this review by email to the SfN membership office, and SfN states that it can take up to 30 days.

On the ACP form, "A form or letter from the President or Past President of the local internal medicine society" may be substituted if necessary.

IEEE societies send applicants to their own members. The GRSS page says "Your professional colleagues are your best source of these references" and gives an email address for help in finding them. The IEEE Signal Processing Society offers to connect applicants with Chapter Chairs or technical mentors who can "review your work and serve as your professional references." CFA Society Houston publishes the names of two members who volunteered to act as professional references for new members.

Does a membership that required sponsors count for EB-1A?

Only where the petition proves that recognized experts judged the person's achievements for that membership level. USCIS writes that general membership in an international engineering organization may not meet the criterion.

The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 describes the membership criterion as membership in associations "that require outstanding achievement of their members," as judged by recognized national or international experts. Where an association has several levels, the level the person holds must be one that experts granted on the basis of the person's achievements.

The Policy Manual gives two examples. General membership in an international organization for engineering and technology professionals "may not meet the requirements of the criterion." The fellow level of the same organization may qualify where it requires accomplishments that contributed importantly to the field and where a council of experts and a committee of current fellows judge the nominations.

The IAE guide on association membership as an EB-1A and O-1 criterion lists which memberships USCIS does not count and how a society with several membership levels is assessed.

Does IAE require recommendations from current members?

Yes, for Senior Member. The IAE Bylaws require endorsement by two active IAE members, and a transitional rule lets first applicants be admitted after enhanced document review without the two endorsements.

Section 4.1 of the IAE Bylaws defines Senior Member (SM) as an application-based category for professionals with documented experience in a recognized field, "endorsed by two (2) active IAE members and approved by the Credentialing Council." The membership guide describes the two recommendations as confirming "the applicant's professional standing."

The same section contains an inaugural transitional rule. Until IAE has enough active members to give endorsements, the Credentialing Council, or the Board of Directors before the Council is formed, may admit Senior Members on heightened documentary review without the two endorsements.

Step 3 of the online application asks for the member IDs of two current IAE members in the IAE-YYYY-XXXXX format. First participants may leave the fields empty, and the application is then reviewed with enhanced document verification. A Certified International Expert (CIE) application goes through independent review by two Council members and a Council vote.

The Secretariat confirms receipt of an application within one business day. The Council usually decides within 3 business days of receiving the complete set of documents. The Bylaws set a target of 30 calendar days for the credentialing cycle and pause it while the records are incomplete.

How does an IAE member recommend a colleague?

Through the recommendation form. The Secretariat matches the member's record number and name with the public registry and sends the colleague one invitation, naming the recommending member, within one business day.

The recommendation page asks the member for the IAE registry number, name and email, and for the colleague's name, email and field. The member confirms knowing the colleague personally and agrees that the invitation will show the member's name and record number. A short note about the colleague is optional and goes into the email. The invitation is sent in English or Russian.

The colleague receives an email from the IAE Secretariat with the recommending member's name, grade, a link to that member's registry record and a link to the application. Each colleague receives one invitation, and the Secretariat sends no follow-ups for it.

The Council reviews the colleague's application under the same criteria as any other. If the colleague is admitted and pays the annual dues, the recommending member's membership is extended by 3 months, and extensions for several colleagues add up. The self-check has six questions and names the grade a colleague can apply for.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Membership

Ready to apply for membership?

The Secretariat confirms receipt of the application within one business day. The Council usually decides within 3 business days of receiving the complete set of documents, and no later than 30 days under the Charter.

Membership application

Received

Confirmation within one business day

CategorySenior Member
Documents7 files
Council decisionup to 3 business days