Membership
Association membership as an EB-1A and O-1 criterion: which memberships count?
EB-1A and O-1A petitions both list membership in associations among the evidentiary criteria. The criterion is narrow. The association has to require outstanding achievements of its members, and recognized national or international experts have to judge them. The USCIS Policy Manual lists membership based solely on education, years of experience, a fee or an employment requirement as a sign that the criterion is not met.

What does the membership criterion require?
The association must work in the applicant's field and require outstanding achievements of its members, and recognized national or international experts must judge whether a candidate has them.
In EB-1A the criterion is 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3)(ii), one of ten. The petition has to meet at least three of them unless the applicant has a one-time achievement, a major, internationally recognized award (USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2).
The O-1A rule, 8 CFR 214.2(o)(3)(iii)(B)(2), uses the same words: documentation of membership "in associations in the field for which classification is sought, which require outstanding achievements of their members, as judged by recognized national or international experts in their disciplines or fields" (Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 4). An O-1A petition needs a qualifying award or at least three alternate forms of evidence.
For outstanding professors and researchers (EB-1B) the criterion covers associations in the academic field that require outstanding achievements of their members. It is one of six criteria, and the petition needs at least two of them (Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 3).
Current membership is not required. A footnote in the EB-1A chapter adds that if the petition has no recent evidence, the time since membership may be considered in the final merits determination, when the officer decides whether the acclaim is sustained.
Which memberships does USCIS not count?
Membership based solely on a level of education or years of experience, on paying a fee or subscribing to publications, or on a requirement for employment, such as a union.
Both chapters give the same factors. Under the EB-1A chapter they may lead to a conclusion that the membership was not based on outstanding achievements in the field if it was based solely on them, by themselves or in the aggregate:
- a level of education or years of experience in a particular field;
- the payment of a fee or a subscription to an association's publications;
- a requirement, compulsory or otherwise, for employment in certain occupations, as with union membership or guild affiliation for actors.
Does a degree requirement disqualify an association?
No. The Manual speaks of membership based solely on these factors. An association may require a degree and ten years of work and still qualify if it also requires outstanding achievements and experts judge each candidate. Membership open to any holder of the right diploma or to anyone who pays the dues does not meet the criterion, whatever the association is called.
What if the association has several membership levels?
USCIS looks at the level the applicant holds. To grant that level, recognized national or international experts must have judged the applicant as having outstanding achievements in the field.
The EB-1A chapter says that associations may have multiple levels of membership and that the level afforded to the person must show that experts judged the person as having attained outstanding achievements. As a possible example, general membership in an international organization for engineering and technology professionals may not meet the criterion. The fellow level of the same organization may qualify if a nominee needs accomplishments that contributed importantly to engineering, science and technology and a council of experts and a committee of current fellows judge the nominations.
The O-1 chapter names the organization. Membership in the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) at the fellow level requires, in part, "accomplishments that have contributed importantly to the advancement or application of engineering, science and technology, bringing the realization of significant value to society," and nominations are judged by an IEEE council of experts and a committee of current IEEE fellows.
The second example is a fellow of a scientific society dedicated to artificial intelligence. The O-1 chapter names it: the Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence (AAAI), whose fellows are recognized for significant, sustained contributions and selected by a panel of current fellows.
Does IEEE Senior Member meet the criterion?
The Policy Manual does not name the Senior Member grade. The petition has to show that ten years of practice, five years of significant performance and three references amount to outstanding achievements judged by experts.
According to the IEEE Professional Communication Society, a candidate for Senior Member must have been in professional practice for at least ten years and must have shown significant performance over at least five of those years. The candidate supplies three references from current IEEE members who hold the grade of Fellow, Senior Member or Honorary Member. The same page says that 10% of the 400,000 IEEE members are Senior Members (IEEE PCS, Become an IEEE Senior Member).
Years of experience are on the Manual's list of factors that do not qualify by themselves. The open question in each case is the rest of the grade: whether significant performance reviewed by IEEE amounts to outstanding achievements, and whether the people who review it are recognized national or international experts. The IEEE example in the Manual is the fellow grade.
A petition that claims Senior Member under this criterion needs the IEEE rules for the grade on the date of elevation, the applicant's elevation record with the references and evidence of who made the decision. Without them the officer sees a grade name and ten years of experience.
What documents prove the criterion?
Proof of the membership, the association's admission rules for the level held, evidence of who judges candidates, and the applicant's own admission file showing the achievements that were assessed.
The petitioner must show that membership requires outstanding achievements in the field, as judged by recognized national or international experts. A membership card or a certificate shows only that the applicant is a member. A set for one association usually includes:
- the certificate or letter of admission with the date and the level;
- the bylaws or admission rules for that level in force on the admission date, with the page address and the date it was saved;
- a description of who reviews candidates: the committee or panel, its members and their positions in the field;
- the applicant's nomination or application and the decision, if the association issues one;
- evidence that the association works in the applicant's field, such as its mission statement or the subjects of its journals;
- for an old membership, a document confirming the current status.
Does membership help an EB-2 NIW petition?
Only through exceptional ability. Membership in professional associations of any caliber satisfies one of six criteria at the first step, and the officer weighs its level later, in the final merits determination.
An EB-2 applicant qualifies with an advanced degree or with exceptional ability. Exceptional ability needs at least three of six types of initial evidence under 8 CFR 204.5(k)(3)(ii), and one of them is evidence of membership in professional associations (Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5). This criterion does not ask for outstanding achievements.
The chapter uses membership as its example: being a member of professional associations alone, regardless of the caliber, should satisfy one of the three required criteria. The officer then evaluates, as part of the final merits determination, whether the membership indicates a degree of expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered in the field.
The national interest waiver itself is decided under the three prongs of Matter of Dhanasar, and membership is not one of them.
What if no association in your field selects members by achievement?
The petitioner may offer comparable evidence after explaining why the criterion does not readily apply to the occupation. A general assertion that it does not apply is not probative.
In EB-1A, under 8 CFR 204.5(h)(4), a petitioner may submit comparable evidence when the standards do not readily apply to the person's occupation. The officer considers whether the criterion is readily applicable and, if not, whether the evidence is truly comparable. A detailed, specific and credible statement by the petitioner can be enough to show that a criterion does not readily apply. General claims that USCIS should accept witness letters as comparable evidence are not persuasive.
In O-1A the petitioner does not have to show that all or most of the criteria do not apply. It has to explain why the particular criterion is not readily applicable and why the submitted evidence is comparable to it, and the petition still needs at least three criteria.
Where does IAE membership fit?
IAE Senior Member is granted on experience and education, so it is not designed for this criterion. Whether CIE or F.IAE meets it in a particular case is for the attorney and USCIS to decide.
IAE grades follow the IAE Criteria Matrix. Senior Member requires at least 3 years of documented experience and an education document, and the decision is made on the documents. These are the factors that the Policy Manual treats as insufficient on their own.
Certified International Expert requires at least 4 of 6 points for experience, publications, patents and methods, expert practice and recognition. Two Council members score the application independently, and the decision is taken by vote and issued in writing with an assessment against each criterion. F.IAE has no application: the Council confers it on current SM and CIE members for documented outstanding achievements, at least two of four indicators, and the designation cannot be bought or requested. Until the Superior Credentialing Council is formed, these decisions are taken by the IAE Board of Directors.
IAE designations are not an immigration decision, and IAE does not promise that any grade satisfies a USCIS criterion. A petition that relies on a CIE or F.IAE record has to document the matrix, the decision makers and the written decision, as for any other association. The written assessment against each criterion and the public registry record with a QR code are the documents IAE issues for that.
Requirements for each grade and a one-minute self-check are on the eligibility page. If you are not sure which criteria your record already meets, the IAE profile audit checks it against the criteria of one category.
Sources
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Extraordinary Ability
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 2, Part M, Chapter 4, O-1 Beneficiaries
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 3, Outstanding Professor or Researcher
- USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5, Advanced Degree or Exceptional Ability
- IEEE Professional Communication Society, Become an IEEE Senior Member
Read also
All guides
The Kazarian two-step review: why three EB-1A criteria are not enough
In Kazarian v. USCIS, decided on March 4, 2010, the Ninth Circuit separated two questions in an EB-1A case: whether the evidence meets at least three
How do you test an EB-1A, NIW or O-1 profile before filing?
Before filing, a profile can be checked against the rules the USCIS officer applies: ten EB-1A criteria in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3), three Dhanasar prongs
The O-1 advisory opinion under 8 CFR 214.2(o)(5): who can write it?
Under 8 CFR 214.2(o)(5), the advisory opinion in an O-1A petition may come from a U.S. peer group, which may be a labor organization, or fromMembership
Ready to apply for membership?
The Secretariat confirms receipt within one business day.

