Examinations

Minority shareholder buyout valuation: which value does the court set, and are discounts applied?

When a company or the majority buys out a minority owner under a statute, the court sets fair value, a figure the Eleventh Circuit has said is not synonymous with fair market value. In Cox Enterprises v. News-Journal Corp., that court affirmed a $129.2 million value for a 47.5% stake under Florida law. The company's expert, who applied a 20% marketability discount, had put the same stake at $29.4 million.

Three people lean over a printed financial model and a company charter folder in a meeting room, faces out of frame

When can a court order the buyout of a minority shareholder in Florida?

After a shareholder petitions to dissolve the corporation under section 607.1430(1)(b). Within 90 days the corporation, or other shareholders if it does not, may elect to buy the petitioner's shares at fair value under section 607.1436.

Section 607.1430(1)(b) of the Florida Statutes lets a shareholder petition for dissolution on four grounds: the directors are deadlocked and the shareholders cannot break the deadlock, with irreparable injury threatened or the business no longer conducted to the advantage of the shareholders generally; the shareholders are deadlocked in voting power and have failed to elect successor directors; corporate assets are being misapplied or wasted, causing material injury to the corporation; or the directors or those in control have acted, are acting or are reasonably expected to act in a manner that is illegal or fraudulent.

Under section 607.1430(2), those grounds are not available to a corporation whose shares on the filing date are a covered security under section 18(b)(1)(A) or (B) of the Securities Act of 1933, or are held by at least 300 shareholders and have a market value of at least $20 million. The buyout procedure is a remedy for closely held companies.

Under section 607.1436(1) the corporation may elect to purchase all shares owned by the petitioning shareholder at fair value, and if it fails to elect, one or more shareholders may do so. The election may be filed at any time within 90 days after the petition, or later with the court's permission. Once an election is filed, the proceeding may not be discontinued or settled unless the court finds that equitable. If the parties agree on fair value and terms within 60 days after the first election, the court orders the purchase on the agreed terms.

If they do not agree, the court determines fair value itself. When it orders the purchase, the court dismisses the dissolution petition, and the petitioning shareholder no longer has any rights or status as a shareholder, except the right to receive the amounts the court awards. In Cox, after the corporation elected to buy, the district court held a bench trial on fair value, and each side presented a valuation expert.

Is fair value the same as fair market value?

No. Tax regulations define fair market value as a price between a willing buyer and a willing seller. Florida courts start fair value there, but the Eleventh Circuit said the two terms are not synonymous.

For federal estate tax, 26 CFR 20.2031-1(b) defines fair market value as "the price at which the property would change hands between a willing buyer and a willing seller, neither being under any compulsion to buy or to sell and both having reasonable knowledge of relevant facts." The same regulation says the value "is not to be determined by a forced sale price."

In Cox Enterprises, Inc. v. News-Journal Corp., No. 06-16190, decided on December 21, 2007, the Eleventh Circuit decided an appeal over a buyout under section 607.1436. It noted that Florida courts hold that fair value "rests on determining what a willing purchaser in an arm's length transaction would offer," and added: "This is not to say that 'fair value' is synonymous with 'fair market value.'"

The court also approved a definition of a going concern as a business that "will be managed in a reasonably prudent manner going forward." That definition changes the arithmetic. If the controlling owner has run the company below the results a prudent manager would reach, a value built on prudent management is higher than a value built on the company's own history. In Cox the district court normalized the company's operating margin to the margins of independent comparable companies, and the Eleventh Circuit found no abuse of discretion in that step.

Are minority and marketability discounts applied in a buyout?

Florida's appraisal-rights definition of fair value bars discounts for lack of marketability or minority status. Section 607.1436 itself does not mention discounts, and in Cox the court valued the 47.5% stake without one.

Section 607.1301(5), which defines fair value for appraisal rights in Florida, says the value is determined immediately before the corporate action the shareholder objects to, "using customary and current valuation concepts and techniques generally employed for similar businesses in the context of the transaction requiring appraisal," and "without discounting for lack of marketability or minority status."

Section 607.1436 uses the term fair value but does not address discounts, and the Cox opinion did not expressly decide whether they apply under it. The figures in the case show the size of the question. The company's expert used a discounted cash flow analysis and applied a 20% lack-of-marketability discount, which gave a company value of $61,909,000 and $29,410,000 for Cox's 47.5%. Cox's expert put the stake at $145,350,000. The district court found a total value of $272 million by comparable sales and set fair value at $129,200,000, which is 47.5% of that total with no discount, and the Eleventh Circuit affirmed.

Delaware reached the same point through case law. In Cavalier Oil Corp. v. Harnett, decided on September 5, 1989, the Delaware Supreme Court said the Court of Chancery's task in that appraisal was to value what had been taken from the shareholder, "viz. his proportionate interest in a going concern." The Vice Chancellor had rejected a minority or marketability discount, concluding that the objective of a section 262 appraisal is "to value the corporation itself, as distinguished from a specific fraction of its shares as they may exist in the hands of a particular shareholder." The Supreme Court called this "a valid distinction" and affirmed.

Which valuation date applies in a Florida buyout or a Delaware appraisal?

Under section 607.1436(4), as of the day before the petition was filed, or another date the court considers appropriate under the circumstances. In Cox the shares were valued as of May 10, 2004.

Section 607.1436(4) directs the court to determine the fair value of the petitioner's shares as of the day before the petition was filed "or as of such other date as the court deems appropriate under the circumstances." The statute names no test for choosing another date, so a party that wants one asks the court and explains why the default date does not fit the case.

In appraisal cases the date is tied to the corporate action. Section 607.1301(5)(a) values the shares "immediately before the effectiveness of the corporate action to which the shareholder objects," and section 607.1301(5)(b) excludes "any appreciation or depreciation in anticipation of the corporate action unless exclusion would be inequitable to the corporation and its remaining shareholders." In Delaware, 8 Del. C. § 262(h) has the Court of Chancery determine "the fair value of the shares exclusive of any element of value arising from the accomplishment or expectation of the merger."

The date fixes the record the expert may use. The report names the valuation date, the financial statements and projections that existed on that date and the market data used for comparable companies or transactions. If the expert relies on anything that became known later, the report says what it is and why it bears on the value as of the date.

Which valuation methods did the experts use in Cox, and what did the court accept?

Cox's expert used comparable sales with a discounted cash flow check; the company's expert used discounted cash flow with a 20% marketability discount. The court adopted comparable sales and normalized the operating margin.

Cox owned 47.5% of News-Journal Corporation, a closely held Florida corporation with 4,000 common shares outstanding, and had acquired its stake in 1969. A company controlled by an estate held the other 52.5%. After Cox sued for fraud, waste and mismanagement, the corporation elected under section 607.1436 to buy Cox's shares at fair value, and the district court held a bench trial on the value as of May 10, 2004.

Cox's expert valued the News-Journal newspaper at $270 million and the Pennysaver at $36 million by comparable sales, $306 million in all, and ran a discounted cash flow check that gave $289 million. The company's expert relied on discounted cash flow, reached $77,386,000 and then applied a 20% lack-of-marketability discount. The district court adopted the comparable sales method but normalized the newspaper's operating margin to 24.8%, the average of the similarly situated papers among Cox's expert's comparables, where Cox's expert had used 28.3%, the average of eleven publicly traded newspaper companies. That lowered the newspaper to $236 million and the total to $272 million, and Cox's fair value became $129,200,000.

On appeal the Eleventh Circuit found no abuse of discretion in the method, the going-concern definition, the margin normalization or the refusal to add Cox's pro-rata share of about $31.7 million in waste, which the margin normalization already accounted for. It also affirmed the denial of prejudgment interest; Cox had received $2.8 million in dividends between the valuation date and the judgment.

Delaware's statute leaves the method open. Under 8 Del. C. § 262(h), "In determining such fair value, the Court shall take into account all relevant factors." A report written for either state explains why the chosen method fits the company, which comparable companies or transactions were used and why, and how the result compares with the other methods the expert ran.

Who pays interest and expert fees in a Florida buyout?

The court may allow interest at an equitable rate, order payment in installments with security, and award the petitioner expenses, including fees of counsel and experts, if the petitioner had probable grounds for relief.

Section 607.1436(5) lets the purchase order include payment of the price in installments "when necessary in the interests of equity," with "provision for security to assure payment of the purchase price" and of any additional costs, fees and expenses awarded. Interest may be allowed at the rate and from the date the court considers equitable. If the petitioning shareholder's refusal to accept an offer of payment was "arbitrary or otherwise not in good faith," no interest is allowed.

If the court finds that the petitioning shareholder "had probable grounds for relief under s. 607.1430(1)(b)," it may award expenses to that shareholder, "including reasonable fees and expenses of counsel and of any experts employed by petitioner." The award is discretionary. In Cox the Eleventh Circuit affirmed the denial of prejudgment interest.

Delaware sets a default rate. Under section 262(h), unless the Court of Chancery determines otherwise for good cause, interest runs from the effective date of the merger through the date of payment of the judgment, compounded quarterly, at 5% over the Federal Reserve discount rate, including any surcharge. The surviving entity may pay each holder an amount in cash before judgment; after that, interest accrues only on any shortfall between that payment and the fair value the court sets, plus interest already accrued.

When does a Delaware appraisal claim for listed shares go forward?

For shares listed on a national securities exchange, the Court of Chancery dismisses the proceeding unless the shares seeking appraisal exceed 1% of the outstanding shares, the merger consideration for them exceeds $1 million, or a listed exception applies.

Section 262(g) sets the threshold. The court must dismiss the appraisal proceedings for those holders unless "the total number of shares entitled to appraisal exceeds 1% of the outstanding shares," or the value of the consideration provided in the merger for those shares exceeds $1 million, or the merger was approved under section 253 or section 267.

The threshold applies to listed shares. A holder of shares in a closely held Delaware corporation with appraisal rights is not subject to it, and in that setting the valuation expert works without a market price for the shares, as in a Florida buyout.

What does IAE do when a buyout case needs a valuation?

An appraiser from the IAE registry prepares an expert report on the value of a business or an ownership interest as of the date and under the standard of value the case needs. Delivery takes up to 5 business days.

IAE values real property, businesses and ownership interests for estate and gift tax disputes, divorce, condemnation and shareholder cases. For a buyout the questions name the company, the block of shares, the valuation date and the standard of value the statute uses, and IAE confirms the questions, the property and the valuation date with the client before work starts.

The client sends the materials and describes the task, and the secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and a 48-hour rush is available for cases with tight deadlines.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; legal questions are for the client's attorney. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the appraiser guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member