RFE responses

NIW denied after an RFE: appeal, motion or a new petition?

After an EB-2 NIW denial, the petitioner has 30 days to file an appeal to the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) or a motion on Form I-290B, and 33 days if USCIS mailed the decision. A motion to reopen brings new facts backed by documents. A motion to reconsider argues that the law was misapplied to the existing record. A new I-140 may rely on achievements after the first filing and receives a new priority date.

A woman by a window reads a letter closely, an opened envelope resting on the table.

What are the options after an NIW denial?

There are four: an appeal to the AAO, a motion to reopen, a motion to reconsider and a new Form I-140. The first three are filed on Form I-290B within 30 days of the decision.

8 CFR 103.3(a)(2)(i) requires the affected party to submit an appeal on Form I-290B with the fee set by 8 CFR 106.2 and to file "the complete appeal including any supporting brief" within 30 days after service of the decision. Under section 103.5(a)(1)(i), a motion to reopen or a motion to reconsider is filed within 30 days of the decision it challenges.

One Form I-290B carries either an appeal or a motion. The Form I-290B page says a separate form is filed for each, at the address USCIS lists for the form, and that the form is not filed directly with the AAO. The two motions can be joined: on January 29, 2025 and February 3, 2025 the AAO decided combined motions to reopen and reconsider in two NIW cases and dismissed both motions each time.

A new petition is a separate filing with its own fee. The USCIS fee schedule lists $715 for Form I-140 plus a $300 Asylum Program Fee for a self-petitioner, and $800 for Form I-290B. The new petition is judged on the record as of its own filing date.

How long do you have to appeal or file a motion?

30 days after service of the decision, or 33 if USCIS mailed it. A late appeal is rejected without a refund. A late motion to reopen may be excused if the delay was reasonable and beyond the petitioner's control.

Under 8 CFR 103.8(b), when a notice is served by mail, 3 days are added to the period, and service by mail is complete upon mailing. The count starts on the mailing date. The Form I-290B page states the result as 30 calendar days, or 33 calendar days for a mailed decision.

An appeal filed out of time "must be rejected as improperly filed," and any fee USCIS accepted is not refunded (103.3(a)(2)(v)(B)(1)). Paragraph (B)(2) contains one exception. If the late appeal meets the requirements of a motion to reopen or a motion to reconsider, USCIS must treat it as a motion and decide the case on the merits.

For motions, 8 CFR 103.5(a)(1)(i) lets USCIS excuse a late motion to reopen when the petitioner proves that the delay was reasonable and beyond the petitioner's control. The text gives no such exception for a motion to reconsider.

The brief is due with the appeal. Under 103.3(a)(2)(vii), the petitioner may make a written request for more time to submit it, and more time may be allowed for good cause. If it is granted, paragraph (viii) requires the brief to be submitted directly to the AAU. That is the name 8 CFR 103.3 and 103.5 give the appellate body; the Form I-290B page and the decisions cited here call it the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO).

What is the difference between a motion to reopen and a motion to reconsider?

A motion to reopen states new facts and attaches affidavits or other documents that prove them. A motion to reconsider argues that the decision misapplied law or USCIS policy to the evidence in the record at the time.

Section 103.5(a)(2) reads: "A motion to reopen must state the new facts to be provided in the reopened proceeding and be supported by affidavits or other documentary evidence." Under 103.5(a)(3), a motion to reconsider must state the reasons for reconsideration, be supported by any pertinent precedent decisions to establish an incorrect application of law or Service policy, and establish that the decision "was incorrect based on the evidence of record at the time of the initial decision."

A motion that does not meet these requirements "shall be dismissed" (103.5(a)(4)). In its decision of February 3, 2025 on a combined motion in an NIW case, the AAO dismissed both motions. It wrote that a petitioner cannot meet the requirements of a motion to reconsider "by broadly disagreeing with our conclusions."

The motion goes to the official who made the latest decision in the case (103.5(a)(1)(ii)). After a service center denial, that is the service center. After the AAO has dismissed an appeal, it is the AAO. In the same 2025 decision the AAO wrote that its review on motion "is limited to reviewing our latest decision."

Under 103.5(a)(6), a field office decision made on a motion may be appealed to the AAU only if the original decision was appealable to the AAU. NIW denials are appealable: the AAO decided appeals from Texas Service Center NIW denials on April 6, 2023, January 12, 2024 and February 6, 2024.

What does the AAO review on appeal?

The AAO writes in NIW appeals that it reviews the questions de novo; the burden of proof stays with the petitioner. Before that, the Director who denied the petition has 45 days to treat the appeal as a motion.

Under 8 CFR 103.3(a)(2)(ii) and (iii), the official who made the unfavorable decision reviews the appeal first. In the NIW appeals decided on April 6, 2023, January 12, 2024 and February 6, 2024, that official was the Director of the Texas Service Center. Within 45 days of receipt, the Director may treat the appeal as a motion to reopen or reconsider and take favorable action. Otherwise the official "shall promptly forward the appeal and the related record of proceeding to the AAU in Washington, DC" (paragraph (iv)).

The AAO decisions of April 6, 2023 and January 12, 2024 in NIW appeals both state: "We review the questions in this matter de novo." Both cite Matter of Christo's, Inc., 26 I&N Dec. 537, 537 n.2 (AAO 2015). The April 2023 decision adds that the petitioner bears the burden of proof by a preponderance of the evidence and cites Matter of Chawathe, 25 I&N Dec. 369, 375-76 (AAO 2010).

Of the three NIW appeals named above, the AAO dismissed the one decided on February 6, 2024. In the other two it withdrew the Director's decision and remanded the matter "for the entry of a new decision."

What if the denial relies on a reason the RFE did not raise?

On January 12, 2024, the AAO sent such an NIW case back. When a denial rests on a deficiency of proof the petitioner was not warned about, the AAO remands so the Director can consider the new evidence.

The AAO decision of January 12, 2024 concerned an NIW petition for a civil engineer. The decision lists the first prong of the Dhanasar framework as "The proposed endeavor has both substantial merit and national importance." In its RFE, the Texas Service Center wrote that the record established both the substantial merit and the national importance of the proposed endeavor. The Director then found substantial merit but not national importance and denied the petition under the first prong.

The AAO withdrew the denial and remanded. It wrote: "Where a petition is denied based on a deficiency of proof, and the petitioner was not put on notice of the deficiency with a reasonable opportunity to address it before the denial, then we will remand the matter to allow the Director to consider and address the new evidence or information." The citation is Matter of Soriano, 19 I&N Dec. 764, 766 (BIA 1988).

On appeal, the petitioner filed "further arguments and briefing related to the potential national importance" of the endeavor. The AAO found that the petitioner "was not notified of the deficiencies as to the first prong before the denial."

When is a new I-140 the better route?

When the case depends on facts that arose after the first filing, or when the proposed endeavor has changed. USCIS judges eligibility as of the filing date, so an appeal or a motion cannot add later achievements.

8 CFR 103.2(b)(1) requires the petitioner to establish eligibility "at the time of filing the benefit request" and to remain eligible through adjudication. An article published or a grant awarded after the filing date can be counted only in a new petition. Our guide Answering an RFE with an expert letter, point by point covers the precedent decisions on facts that arose after filing.

A changed endeavor also calls for a new petition. In the AAO decision of April 6, 2023, the petitioner had first described the endeavor as work as a finance director for U.S. oil and gas companies. In the RFE response, the petitioner wrote of creating a company offering finance and accounting consulting services. The AAO cited Matter of Izummi, 22 I&N Dec. 169, 176 (Assoc. Comm'r 1998): "A petitioner may not make material changes to a petition in an effort to make a deficient petition conform to USCIS requirements." After significant, material changes, the decision says, "a petitioner must file a new petition."

The AAO remanded that case with an instruction. The Director had to decide whether the evidence in the RFE response clarified the endeavor as first described or presented a new set of facts material to eligibility, under Matter of Michelin Tire Corp., 17 I&N Dec. 248 (Reg'l Comm'r 1978).

What happens to the priority date after a denial?

A denied petition does not establish a priority date, so a new NIW petition receives the date of its own filing. Under 8 CFR 204.5(e)(1), a later petition takes an earlier date from an approved petition.

For a petition that does not require a labor certification, the priority date is "the date the completed, signed petition (including all initial evidence and the correct fee) is properly filed with USCIS" (8 CFR 204.5(d)). Paragraph (k)(4)(ii) of the same section lets the director exempt aliens of exceptional ability in the sciences, arts or business from the job offer, and thus from the labor certification, if the exemption would be in the national interest.

Paragraph (e) governs retention of the date. Under (e)(1), a petition approved on behalf of an alien under section 203(b)(1), (2) or (3) of the Act gives the alien its priority date for any later petition in those classifications for which the alien may qualify. With several approved petitions, the alien is entitled to the earliest date. Paragraph (e)(3) is one sentence: "A denied petition will not establish a priority date."

An approved petition can lose its date too. Under (e)(2), the date is not retained if USCIS revokes the approval for fraud or a willful misrepresentation of a material fact, for revocation of the labor certification by the Department of Labor, for its invalidation by USCIS or the Department of State, or for a material error in the approval. Paragraph (e)(4) bars transfer of a priority date to another alien.

What does each route cost, and how fast is it?

Form I-290B costs $800. A new self-petitioned I-140 costs $715 plus a $300 Asylum Program Fee, and premium processing adds $2,965 for action within 45 business days.

8 CFR 106.2 sets $800 for Form I-290B in paragraph (a)(16) and $715 for Form I-140 in paragraph (a)(11). Paragraph (c)(13) adds the Asylum Program Fee to an I-140: $600, or $300 for a small employer. The USCIS fee schedule, Form G-1055 (edition 01/17/25), puts a self-petitioner in the $300 group.

Premium processing for any I-140 rose by $160 to $2,965 on March 1, 2026, under the final rule "Adjustment to Premium Processing Fees," published on January 12, 2026 (91 Fed. Reg. 1059). 8 CFR 106.4 now lists $2,965 for every petition under section 203(b) of the Act. For an EB-2 petition with a national interest waiver, 8 CFR 106.4(e)(18) sets the timeframe at 45 business days. It starts when USCIS has received all prerequisites for adjudication, the form and the fees. An RFE or a NOID stops it, and a new timeframe begins on the day USCIS receives the response (106.4(f)(3)).

Under 8 CFR 103.5(a)(1)(iv), unless USCIS directs otherwise, filing a motion to reopen or reconsider, or a subsequent petition, "does not stay the execution of any decision in a case or extend a previously set departure date."

Can a new expert letter support a motion to reopen?

Yes, as the documentary evidence that 8 CFR 103.5(a)(2) requires, if the letter states facts that existed when the petition was filed and answers a ground named in the denial.

Under 103.5(a)(2), the motion states the new facts, and affidavits or other documentary evidence support them. A signed letter from an independent expert in the applicant's field is a document of that kind; a letter that repeats the petition states no new fact.

The facts must date from the filing. Under 103.2(b)(1), the petitioner must have been eligible when the petition was filed and must stay eligible through adjudication, so a letter about the applicant's work as of the filing date can be weighed in the same proceeding. Results achieved after that date can count only in a new petition.

Each ground stated in the denial gets its own section in the letter, with references to the exhibits that answer it.

How does IAE build an expert letter on the officer's findings?

IAE prepares an expert opinion letter around the text of the officer's notice, with a separate section for each finding in the expert's field. The standard turnaround is 5 business days, and the rush option takes 3.

The request on the RFE and NOID response page includes the text of the RFE or NOID, the petition and the supporting file. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day and checks the turnaround against the response deadline. Within one business day IAE confirms the fee, the turnaround and the expert, and the turnaround is confirmed in writing. The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials.

The secretariat prepares the draft from the client's documents. The expert edits the draft and signs it, and revisions before signing are included. Legal points stay with the attorney. When the findings call for different specializations, a second expert joins at the assessment stage. The signed PDF runs up to 15 pages, with the expert's CV and a declaration of independence attached.

RFE and NOID orders go into a priority queue. The 3-day rush term counts from payment and receipt of all materials.

The expert's record is in the public IAE registry and can be checked by Member ID or QR code on the status check page. USCIS evaluates the letter together with the rest of the filing and makes the decision. IAE is not a law firm, and the strategy of the response belongs to a licensed immigration attorney.

Sources

Read also

All articles

RFE and NOID responses

Received an RFE? We count the days with you.

The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials. We confirm the fee, the turnaround and the expert within one business day and check the turnaround against the response deadline.

Quote request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

DocumentRFE or NOID text
Timeline5 business days, rush 3
AuthorFrom the IAE registry