Expert witnesses
Patent lost profits or reasonable royalty: which damages model does the expert build, and what must it prove?
Section 284 of the Patent Act sets a floor and leaves the method open: damages adequate to compensate for the infringement, but in no event less than a reasonable royalty. A patent owner that competes with the infringer can claim the profits on sales it lost, if it proves it would have made them. A patent owner that cannot prove those sales recovers a royalty, and the expert's model follows that proof.

What does the Patent Act let a patent owner recover?
Damages adequate to compensate for the infringement, never less than a reasonable royalty for the infringer's use, with interest and costs. The court may increase damages up to three times and may hear expert testimony on damages.
Section 284 of title 35 of the U.S. Code reads: "Upon finding for the claimant the court shall award the claimant damages adequate to compensate for the infringement, but in no event less than a reasonable royalty for the use made of the invention by the infringer, together with interest and costs as fixed by the court."
The second paragraph adds: "In either event the court may increase the damages up to three times the amount found or assessed." The third names the expert's role: "The court may receive expert testimony as an aid to the determination of damages or of what royalty would be reasonable under the circumstances."
The statute does not name lost profits. The decisions below apply section 284 to both measures, and the royalty works as the minimum when the patent owner cannot prove more. The choice between them decides what the damages expert has to collect: the patent owner's own sales, capacity and costs for lost profits, or licensing evidence and the value of the patented feature for a royalty.
What is the difference between lost profits and a reasonable royalty?
Lost profits measure what the patent owner itself lost: sales, and the profit on them, it would have made without the infringement. A reasonable royalty compensates for the infringer's use of the invention and is the statutory minimum.
For lost profits the Federal Circuit requires causation. In Rite-Hite Corp. v. Kelley Co. (1995), the en banc court wrote that the patent owner "must show a reasonable probability that, 'but for' the infringement, it would have made the sales" that the infringer made. The expert therefore reconstructs a market without the infringing product and asks which buyers would have bought from the patent owner.
A royalty does not depend on lost sales. It compensates for the infringer's use of the invention, and section 284 makes it the minimum award. In Grain Processing, discussed below, the district court denied lost profits and awarded a 3% royalty. Among the reasons for that rate, the court cited the 2.3% higher cost of the infringer's noninfringing process.
Standing limits who may claim. In Rite-Hite the independent sales organizations sold Rite-Hite's products in their territories and sued for their lost retail profits. Their agreements did not grant them "any right to exclude others under the patent," and the court remanded "for the court to dismiss the ISOs as plaintiffs and recalculate damages to Rite-Hite."
What are the Panduit factors for patent lost profits?
Demand for the patented product, absence of acceptable noninfringing substitutes, the patent owner's manufacturing and marketing capability to exploit the demand, and the amount of profit it would have made. Each element needs its own evidence.
The test takes its name from Panduit Corp. v. Stahlin Bros. Fibre Works, a 1978 decision of the Sixth Circuit (575 F.2d 1152). In Rite-Hite the en banc Federal Circuit wrote that Panduit "articulated a four-factor test that has since been accepted as a useful, but non-exclusive, way for a patentee to prove entitlement to lost profits damages."
The four factors are demand for the patented product, absence of acceptable non-infringing substitutes, manufacturing and marketing capability to exploit the demand, and the amount of the profit the patent owner would have made.
Proof of the four factors shifts the burden. Under Rite-Hite, a Panduit showing "permits a court to reasonably infer that the lost profits claimed were in fact caused by the infringing sales, thus establishing a patentee's prima facie case with respect to 'but for' causation." The infringer may then show that the inference is unreasonable for some or all of the lost sales.
The four elements map onto the expert's file: market data on demand, an analysis of substitutes, the patent owner's production and sales capacity during the damages period, and a profit calculation that separates incremental revenue and costs.
Can a patent owner recover profits on a product the patent does not cover?
Yes, if the loss was reasonably foreseeable. In Rite-Hite (1995) the Federal Circuit allowed lost profits on a competing product outside the patent, but not on dock levelers, which did not function together with the restraints.
Rite-Hite owned U.S. Patent No. 4,373,847 on a vehicle restraint that holds a truck to a loading dock. Kelley's Truk Stop restraint infringed it. Rite-Hite's MDL-55 restraint embodied the patent; its ADL-100 did not and was covered by other patents. Kelley designed the Truk Stop to compete primarily with the ADL-100. The district court found that, but for the infringement, Rite-Hite would have made about 3,243 more ADL-100 sales, 80 more MDL-55 sales and 1,692 more dock leveler sales.
On June 15, 1995, the en banc Federal Circuit, in an opinion by Judge Lourie, affirmed the ADL-100 award: the losses were "reasonably foreseeable" even though the patent in suit did not cover that product. It vacated the dock leveler award. The levelers and restraints "did not function together to achieve one result," and "These facts do not establish the functional relationship necessary to justify recovery under the entire market value rule."
The vote was split. Judge Nies, joined by Chief Judge Archer, Senior Judge Smith and Judge Mayer, dissented in part, and Judge Newman, joined by Judge Rader, concurred in part and dissented in part.
How do noninfringing substitutes defeat a lost profits claim?
If the infringer could have switched to an acceptable noninfringing alternative, the patent owner cannot show it would have made the sales. In Grain Processing (1999) such a substitute counted even though it was not on the market.
Grain Processing owned U.S. Patent No. 3,849,194, which claimed certain maltodextrins. American Maize sold Lo-Dex 10, a maltodextrin it made by four processes. Lo-Dex 10 from Processes I-III infringed. Process IV added the enzyme glucoamylase, which made the product noninfringing, and American Maize had not used it earlier because glucoamylase cost more. Grain Processing sued on May 12, 1981; American Maize switched to Process IV in April 1991, and the patent expired in November 1991.
The district court found that Process IV cost about 2.3% more to run, that American Maize could have switched within about two weeks and that customers saw no difference in the product. It denied lost profits and awarded a 3% royalty, which it linked to the cost difference.
On August 4, 1999, Judge Rader wrote for a panel with Senior Judge Friedman and Judge Bryson and affirmed. The court wrote that "a substitute need not be openly on sale to exert this influence." The but-for inquiry "requires a reconstruction of the market, as it would have developed absent the infringing product." A court may infer that a substitute not on the market during the accounting period was not available; the infringer then has to prove availability, and "Mere speculation or conclusory assertions will not suffice to overcome the inference."
The findings that decided Grain Processing came from two kinds of evidence: the infringer's cost and time to switch processes, and the customers' view of the product made by the new process.
Do lost profits have to be apportioned to the patented feature?
In Mentor Graphics v. EVE-USA (2017) a Federal Circuit panel held that where the Panduit factors are met, the award accounts for apportionment. The full court declined rehearing, with Judges Dyk and Hughes dissenting.
The jury found that "Intel would not have purchased the [infringing] Synopsys emulator system without the two patented features and that there were no other alternatives available." The panel opinion of March 16, 2017, upheld the lost profits award, and the order of September 1, 2017, denied panel rehearing and rehearing en banc.
Judge Stoll, joined by Judges Newman, Moore, O'Malley, Reyna and Wallach, concurred in the denial. She wrote that the panel "made clear that apportionment is typically necessary in both reasonable royalty and lost profits analyses," and that on these facts the Panduit factors meant the award "properly accounted for apportionment."
Judge Dyk, joined by Judge Hughes, dissented. In his view the panel "improperly holds that when lost profits are awarded for patent infringement, there is no requirement for apportionment," and its approach "equates consumer demand and but-for causation with apportionment." The dissent quotes the panel's statement that "the absence of non-infringing alternatives ties lost profit damages to specific claim limitations." In Mentor Graphics the record behind the award consisted of the jury's findings on Intel's demand for the two patented features and on the absence of alternatives.
Can one award combine lost profits and a royalty, and can it reach sales abroad?
Yes to both in WesternGeco v. ION (2018): the jury awarded $12.5 million in royalties and $93.4 million in lost profits, and the Supreme Court held that lost foreign profits were a permissible domestic application of section 284.
WesternGeco owned patents on a system for surveying the ocean floor. ION made components in the United States and shipped them abroad, where they were assembled into a system indistinguishable from WesternGeco's. WesternGeco sued under 35 U.S.C. 271(f)(1) and (f)(2), and the jury awarded $12.5 million in royalties and $93.4 million in lost profits.
On June 22, 2018, Justice Thomas wrote for a 7-2 majority. Section 284 is the Patent Act's general damages provision, and its focus is the infringement. Because the claim rested on section 271(f)(2), the focus was the export of components from the United States, and "the conduct in this case that is relevant to the statutory focus clearly occurred in the United States." The overseas events that produced the lost profits were "merely incidental to the infringement." Justice Gorsuch, joined by Justice Breyer, dissented. The Court reversed the Federal Circuit and remanded.
The verdict in WesternGeco contained both measures, royalties and lost profits, and the question before the Supreme Court concerned only the lost profits.
Do marking and notice limit both damages measures?
Yes. If the patent owner sells unmarked patented articles, section 287(a) bars damages for the period before the infringer had notice. Filing suit counts as notice, so the damages period can start late for either model.
Section 287(a) lets a patent owner give notice by fixing the word "patent" or "pat." and the patent number on the article, or by marking "patent" or "pat." with a free, publicly accessible internet address that associates the article with the patent number. Without such marking, "no damages shall be recovered by the patentee in any action for infringement" unless the infringer was notified and continued to infringe, and then only for infringement after the notice. Filing an action for infringement constitutes notice.
The rule speaks of damages generally, so it cuts the period for lost profits and for a royalty alike. For unmarked products, the damages period in the expert's model starts no earlier than the date of notice.
How does IAE find a patent damages expert for lost profits or a royalty?
In the request, choose the case type Intellectual property and describe the damages question, such as lost profits or a reasonable royalty. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and testimony lists.
The IAE page on intellectual property expert witnesses lists 6 specialties and names economists who calculate reasonable royalties under 35 U.S.C. 284 and trade secret damages. The page notes that state courts and the PTAB apply their own rules to expert testimony, so the request names the court or the PTAB. The form also asks for the firm's side, the expert disclosure deadline, the parties and their counsel for the conflict check and a short description of the case, without privileged or sealed information.
Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that field by that deadline. The search costs $2,000 per case, paid in advance. Within 5 business days the firm receives 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years, and each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel.
If no candidate fits, the second search is free. The firm chooses the expert, who bills the firm directly or through IAE under the agency option. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. IAE is not a law firm: case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- 35 U.S.C. 284, Damages (U.S. Code, 2021 edition, govinfo.gov)
- 35 U.S.C. 287, Limitation on damages and other remedies; marking and notice (U.S. Code, 2024 edition, govinfo.gov)
- Rite-Hite Corp. v. Kelley Co., 56 F.3d 1538 (Fed. Cir. 1995) (en banc), text of the opinion (NYU School of Law)
- Grain Processing Corp. v. American Maize-Products Co., 185 F.3d 1341 (Fed. Cir. 1999) (Justia)
- Mentor Graphics Corp. v. EVE-USA, Inc., Nos. 2015-1470, -1554, -1556 (Fed. Cir. Sept. 1, 2017), order denying rehearing with concurring and dissenting opinions (Justia)
- WesternGeco LLC v. ION Geophysical Corp., No. 16-1011 (U.S. June 22, 2018) (Justia)
Read also
All articles
Patent eligibility under section 101: when does an expert declaration change the outcome of an Alice motion?
Whether a patent claims eligible subject matter under 35 U.S.C. 101 is a question of law, and district courts often decide it on a motion to dismiss
Trademark damages expert: how are the defendant's profits and actual damages proved under the Lanham Act?
Under 15 U.S.C. 1117(a), a trademark owner who wins on liability may recover the defendant's profits, its own damages and the costs of the action
FRAND royalty expert witness: how is a rate for standard-essential patents calculated and tested in US courts?
A patent that a standard requires, such as a Wi-Fi or video coding patent, is usually subject to a promise to license on reasonableExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

