Examinations
Ponzi scheme clawbacks: how does a forensic accountant calculate who is a net winner and how much must be returned?
When a Ponzi scheme collapses, the receiver or trustee sues investors who took out more than they put in. The figure in each claim comes from an accounting of the investor's deposits and withdrawals, built from bank records. In Donell v. Kowell, an investor who paid in $22,858.92 had received $73,290.70. This article covers how that netting works, what the courts held and where investors dispute the numbers.

Who is a net winner in a Ponzi scheme?
An investor whose total withdrawals from the scheme exceed the total amount he or she invested. The excess is treated as fictitious profit, paid with money of other investors.
A Ponzi scheme pays earlier investors with the deposits of later investors instead of real returns. The statements investors receive show gains that were never earned. When the scheme ends, some investors have withdrawn less than they paid in and lost money. Others withdrew more than they paid in.
The Ninth Circuit stated the rule in Donell v. Kowell, No. 06-55544, decided July 1, 2008: "Payments in excess of amounts invested are considered fictitious profits." The receiver in that case sued Kowell, an investor, to recover payments he had received from the scheme.
The distinction drives two different proceedings. Net winners face clawback claims. Net losers file claims against the estate or the receivership. In both, the starting figure is the same accounting: cash in, cash out, investor by investor.
How does the netting calculation work?
The accountant adds up all amounts the investor paid into the scheme and all amounts the scheme paid out to the investor, and nets one against the other. A positive balance in the investor's favor is the fictitious profit.
The Ninth Circuit described the method in Donell: "Amounts transferred by the Ponzi scheme perpetrator to the investor are netted against the initial amounts invested." The netting rule "requires disgorgement of only the profits paid to them by the Ponzi scheme" when the investor acted in good faith.
The court's own figures give a worked example. The district court found that Kowell invested $22,858.92 and received $73,290.70, for a net profit of $50,431.78. Kowell's principal, $22,858.92, was not part of the recovery. The claim was limited to the amount he received above it.
In Kowell's case the receiver's figure changed during the litigation. The initial demand letter claimed $69,546.70, and the receiver later conceded that the net gain was $50,431.78. The opinion states that the first letter had "inaccurately informed Kowell that he owed $69,546.70" and that the receiver conceded the lower figure after Kowell sought protection in federal court. The gap between the two figures was $19,114.92.
The calculation is done for each investor. The Ninth Circuit wrote that the trustee "need not match up each investment with each payment made by the debtor and follow the parties characterizations of the transfers," and that the court may presume that the earliest payments the investor received were payments against the investor's claim. In a footnote the court expressed no opinion on the netting rule in more complex cases, such as an investor whose relationship with the scheme changed over time.
Can an investor who acted in good faith keep anything?
Yes, up to the amount invested. Under the netting rule an innocent investor returns only profits above principal, and 11 U.S.C. 548(c) protects a good-faith transferee to the extent he or she gave value.
In Donell the court applied the California Uniform Fraudulent Transfer Act. The good-faith defense "permits an innocent winning investor to retain funds up to the amount of the initial outlay." For constructive fraud, the court held that the receiver may only recover profits above the initial outlay, unless the receiver can prove a lack of good faith.
In bankruptcy, section 548(c) of the Bankruptcy Code gives a similar protection. A transferee who takes for value and in good faith keeps the transfer "to the extent that such transferee or obligee gave value to the debtor in exchange for such transfer or obligation."
If the receiver proves that the investor did not act in good faith, the protection for principal falls away and the claim can reach all payments received. The accountant's schedule therefore shows two numbers for each investor: total payments received and payments above principal. Which number applies is decided by the court on the good-faith question, not by the accountant.
Does the receiver have to prove fraudulent intent for each payment?
No. Courts presume actual intent to defraud from the existence of the Ponzi scheme. The Ninth Circuit held that the mere existence of a Ponzi scheme is sufficient to establish actual intent.
Fraudulent transfer law lets a creditor or trustee avoid a transfer made with actual intent to hinder, delay or defraud creditors. Section 548(a)(1)(A) of the Bankruptcy Code uses the same words: a transfer made "with actual intent to hinder, delay, or defraud any entity."
The Ninth Circuit in Donell wrote that "the mere existence of a Ponzi scheme is sufficient to establish actual intent to defraud." Once the receiver proves that the business was a Ponzi scheme, each payment to an investor is treated as made with that intent.
Proving that the business was a Ponzi scheme is itself an accounting question. The forensic accountant compares the revenue the business actually earned with what it paid investors. If payments to earlier investors were funded by deposits from later investors, the bank records show it. In a 2025 sentencing appeal, United States v. Courtright, the Seventh Circuit noted that an FBI forensic accountant testified that the company would have been unable to meet its obligations without new investors.
Which payments can be recovered, and how far back?
It depends on the statute. Section 548 reaches transfers within 2 years before the bankruptcy petition. Under California's act in Donell, claims had to be brought within four years, or one year after discovery.
Section 548(a)(1) of the Bankruptcy Code covers transfers made "within 2 years before the date of the filing of the petition."
In Donell, the court applied California law. An action for actual fraud must be brought within four years after the transfer, or within one year after the transfer was or could reasonably have been discovered by the claimant. An action for constructive fraud must be brought within four years after the transfer.
The limitation period changed the result in Kowell's case. Kowell had a net profit of $50,431.78 over the life of his investment, but the district court limited his liability to $26,396.10, the payments within the limitations period, plus $5,159.22 in prejudgment interest. For an accountant this means the schedule must give the date of every payment as well as the totals.
How are the claims of net losers measured?
In the Madoff liquidation, by the net investment method: cash deposited less cash withdrawn. The Second Circuit rejected use of the last account statements because the reported positions and profits were fictitious.
In In re Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities LLC, No. 10-2378, decided August 16, 2011, the Second Circuit reviewed the method used by the trustee, Irving H. Picard. The net investment method credits "the amount of cash deposited by the customer into his or her BLMIS account, less any amounts withdrawn from it." Only customers who deposited more than they withdrew had positive net equity.
Objecting customers argued for the last statement method, which would use the market value of securities shown on their final statements. The court found that those statements recorded "nearly $64.8 billion of net investments and related fictitious gains" and that the last statements were not useful for ascertaining net equity. It described the net investment method as relying "solely on unmanipulated withdrawals and deposits."
The court did not hold that a last statement method is impermissible in every case. It noted that such a method may fit more conventional cases where the statements record real positions. The choice of method is argued in court on the facts of each scheme.
What records does the forensic accountant work from?
Bank statements, wire and check records of the scheme's accounts, the scheme's own ledgers and investor files. In Donell, the receiver's CPA based his report on records held by Wells Fargo Bank and by one of the perpetrators.
In Donell the receiver's accounting expert, Samuel Biggs, was a certified public accountant. The opinion states that his declaration and report were based on accounting records held by Wells Fargo Bank and by one of the scheme's perpetrators. The Ninth Circuit held that any error in admitting the declaration was harmless, because Kowell admitted in an interrogatory answer that he had received about $50,000 in net profits.
Bank records come first, because the scheme's own statements are the documents that misreported gains. The accountant traces each deposit from an investor into the scheme's accounts and each payment out to the investor, and records the date, the amount, the account and the instrument: wire, check or transfer.
The result is usually a schedule covering thousands of transactions. Federal Rule of Evidence 1006, as amended effective December 1, 2024, lets the court admit "a summary, chart, or calculation" offered to prove the content of voluminous admissible records that cannot be conveniently examined in court, whether or not the records are in evidence. The proponent must make the originals or duplicates available to the other parties for examination or copying.
Where do investors dispute the receiver's numbers?
In the completeness of deposits credited, the dates of payments against the limitation period, the choice of method, the good-faith question and the prejudgment interest added to the claim.
The investor's accountant checks each point below against the bank records before writing a report. Two of them, the limitation period and the choice of method, changed the result in the decisions discussed above.
- The investor's accountant checks that every deposit the investor made is credited, including deposits through other accounts or entities the investor controlled.
- The accountant checks that every payment counted as received actually reached the investor, by date and by account.
- The accountant separates payments inside the limitation period from payments outside it, as the district court did in Kowell's case.
- The accountant compares the method used for the claim with the method the court has approved, such as the net investment method in the Madoff liquidation.
- The accountant recomputes prejudgment interest on the amount the court can award, not on the full net profit.
Who hires a forensic accountant in a Ponzi clawback case?
The receiver or trustee hires one to build the investor-by-investor accounting. Investors who are sued, and net losers whose claims are disputed, hire their own to test that accounting.
The receiver's accountant reconstructs the scheme as a whole: total money raised, total money paid out, real revenue and the date when the business began paying investors from other investors' deposits. That date matters for the intent question and for the transfers that can be avoided.
An investor's accountant works on one account or a group of related accounts. The work is narrower and often faster: the accountant reconciles the receiver's schedule for that investor with the investor's own bank records and tax returns, and lists each difference with its source document.
In federal court, either expert who is retained to testify must deliver a written report under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, with all opinions, their basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications, prior testimony for 4 years and compensation.
What does IAE do when a case turns on a Ponzi scheme accounting?
An IAE registry forensic accountant writes an expert report on the client's questions, such as tracing an investor's deposits and payments, or reviews the other side's report, in up to 5 business days.
The IAE forensic accounting page lists tracing among the questions the expert answers: the expert traces funds between accounts through bank statements and ledgers, and under Federal Rule of Evidence 1006 a court may admit a summary chart of voluminous records. The questions are framed from the ledgers, tax returns and bank statements in the record.
The client sends the case materials and describes the task. IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed document is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code, and the specialist confirms that he or she has no interest in the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; a report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- Donell v. Kowell, No. 06-55544 (9th Cir. July 1, 2008) (Justia)
- In re Bernard L. Madoff Investment Securities LLC, No. 10-2378 (2d Cir. Aug. 16, 2011) (Justia)
- 11 U.S. Code § 548, Fraudulent transfers and obligations (LII, Cornell Law School)
- United States v. Courtright, No. 24-1115 (7th Cir. Oct. 17, 2025) (FindLaw)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 1006, Summaries to Prove Content (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Preference claim in bankruptcy: how does a forensic accountant test the ordinary course and new value defenses?
A vendor paid in the 90 days before its customer's bankruptcy can be sued for the money under 11 U.S.C. 547. The defenses are arithmetic. In Sparrer
Forensic accountant in a divorce: how are hidden income and assets found under Florida law?
In a Florida divorce each spouse must serve a financial affidavit, three years of tax returns, twelve months of bank and brokerage statements
Forensic accountant expert witness cost: who pays in a lawsuit, a bankruptcy case and a Florida divorce?
The party that retains a forensic accountant pays for the accountant's work, and in a federal lawsuit it usually cannot shift that bill to the loserExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

