Examinations
Retrospective appraisal: how is property valued as of a past date?
A retrospective appraisal gives a value as of a date that has already passed: the date of death, the day before a shareholder's petition, a date chosen by a divorce judge. The appraiser works with what the market knew on that date and states the assumptions about a property that may have changed since. The date comes from a statute or a court, and the report shows which one.

What is a retrospective appraisal?
An appraisal whose effective date is earlier than the date of the report. USPAP Advisory Opinion 34 addresses retrospective and prospective value opinions, and the effective date sets both the date of value and the period for gathering data.
JoAnn Apostol, MNAA, wrote "Appraising in the Past: A Look at Retrospective Appraisal Assignments" for Appraiser Focus, the magazine of the National Association of Appraisers, in 2023 (pp. 14-17). She writes: "The key to retrospective appraisals is the effective date." And: "That date sets the date of value and the time frame for gathering data." She adds that "Advisory Opinion 34, in USPAP, addresses retrospective and prospective value opinions."
Every retrospective report therefore carries two dates. The effective date is the date of value; the report date is when the appraiser signed. An appraisal ordered after a death is written months later than the date it values, and an appraisal for a shareholder buyout may be written years after the day before the petition.
Tim Andersen, MAI, explained in Working RE which rules govern such work with a hypothetical retrospective appraisal whose effective date, April 15, 1912, lay more than 100 years in the past.
Litigation is where these assignments concentrate. The IAE valuation page lists estate and gift tax disputes, divorce, condemnation and shareholder cases, and in each the value is needed as of a date set by law or by the court.
Which date does the case require?
The one the governing law sets: the date of death or an alternate date for estate tax, the day before the petition in New York and Florida buyouts, and a date the judge chooses in Florida divorces.
Estate tax uses the date of death unless the executor elects the alternate date. Under 26 U.S.C. 2032(a), property disposed of within 6 months after death "shall be valued as of the date of distribution, sale, exchange, or other disposition," and property still held "shall be valued as of the date 6 months after the decedent's death."
Buyouts of minority shareholders look to the day before the petition. New York Business Corporation Law 1118(b), as quoted in Maxon v. Mirror Show Management, sets fair value "as of the day prior to the date on which such petition was filed." Florida section 607.1436(4) uses the day before the petition was filed "or as of such other date as the court deems appropriate under the circumstances."
Appraisal rights after a merger tie the date to the corporate action. Florida section 607.1301(5)(a) values the shares "immediately before the effectiveness of the corporate action to which the shareholder objects."
Florida divorce law leaves the date to the judge. Section 61.075(7) reads: "The date for determining value of assets and the amount of liabilities identified or classified as marital is the date or dates as the judge determines is just and equitable under the circumstances."
Who chooses the effective date, the client or the court?
The statute or the court. In Maxon v. Mirror Show Management a New York court refused to move the statutory valuation date, while a Florida divorce judge may value different assets as of different dates.
In Maxon v. Mirror Show Management (Supreme Court, Monroe County, March 22, 2005), the petitioner asked to move the valuation date to "a date towards the end of 2004," arguing that litigation over disqualifying the respondents' counsel had in effect stayed the case. Justice Kenneth R. Fisher refused and cited Matter of Vetco: "the court has determined that it has no discretion to change the date set forth in the statute for valuation."
Florida gives the judge the opposite power in divorce. The last sentence of section 61.075(7) reads: "Different assets may be valued as of different dates, as, in the judge's discretion, the circumstances require." A business may be valued as of one date and a house or a bank account as of another.
Until the court rules, the parties may ask for different dates, and an appraiser may be asked to value the same property as of each. The engagement letter names the date or dates, and the report repeats them.
Where the parties' appraisals conflict, Federal Rule of Evidence 706(a) lets a federal court appoint its own expert, either one the parties agree on or one of its own choosing, and under Rule 706(c) the expert is entitled to "a reasonable compensation, as set by the court."
Can the appraiser use sales that closed after the effective date?
Only to describe the market as it stood on the effective date, and the report must say so. Apostol excludes later sales that were not active or under contract before that date and sets a logical cutoff for the data.
"I usually gather sales after the effective date to establish the supply," Apostol writes, "but I eliminate sales that weren't active or under contract before the effective date of the assignment." She continues: "It is up to the appraiser to set a logical cutoff date for the data used in the analysis," because "at some point, the data after that doesn't represent the market conditions as of the effective date."
Her test for later sales is what buyers could have seen: "Using closed sales after that date that weren't exposed to the market at that time is like looking into a crystal ball as of the effective date." She does not forbid them: "It is acceptable to use sales that closed after the effective date, but they must be reported accurately." Her working question is "what would the market have known if it was a current assignment on that date."
She also describes a report written for a court case with an April 2019 effective date that used a sale from July 2019 at its closing price, without analyzing price changes after the effective date. She calls the result misleading under USPAP.
Later records can still matter for other questions. In Maxon the court ordered production of corporate and financial records for 2004 and 2005, after the statutory valuation date, because later events bore on the corporation's ability to pay for the petitioner's shares and on whether a bond should be required.
How is the property's condition on a past date established?
From records made at or near that date, with an extraordinary assumption where the facts are uncertain. Apostol writes that such assumptions are typically needed in retrospective work and must be clearly and conspicuously stated.
A house renovated after a death, a business that changed its product line, land that was rezoned: in each case the appraiser cannot inspect the property as it was. Apostol cites Standards Rule 1-2, under which the appraiser identifies the characteristics of the property using sources the appraiser believes are reliable.
Typical sources are building permits, listing photographs and descriptions, prior appraisals, insurance and tax records, inspection reports, financial statements for a business, and testimony of people who knew the property. Each one carries a date, and the report ties the description to dated records.
Where the record leaves a gap, the appraiser makes an assumption. Apostol writes: "Extraordinary assumptions are also typically needed in a retrospective assignment." They are used when the appraiser relies on uncertain information about physical, legal or economic characteristics, and "it must be clearly and conspicuously stated in the report." USPAP, she notes, does not require the exact words "extraordinary assumption."
Apostol also mentions hypothetical conditions, used "for purposes of reasonable analysis." In litigation the court has to know whether a value rests on an assumption about uncertain facts or on a condition the appraiser knows to be untrue, because the second answers a different question than the court asked.
Which edition of USPAP applies to a retrospective appraisal?
The edition in effect when the appraiser develops and reports the assignment, not the one in force on the effective date. Tim Andersen quotes The Appraisal Foundation: the effective date has no bearing on which edition applies.
Tim Andersen addressed this in "USPAP, Retrospective Appraisals and the Titanic" (Working RE, December 2, 2014). He quotes The Appraisal Foundation: "the effective date of the appraisal has no bearing on which edition of USPAP applies." An appraisal written today with an effective date in 2015 follows today's edition.
Law that sets the date and law that sets the standard are different things. The statute or court order gives the effective date; the standards in force when the work is done govern how the appraiser reaches the value.
What must a retrospective appraisal report state?
The effective date and the report date, the data cutoff, every extraordinary assumption and, in federal litigation, the opinions, their basis and the facts or data considered. Apostol notes that Advisory Opinion 34 suggests the past tense for clarity.
According to Apostol, Advisory Opinion 34 "recommends clear and concise language to eliminate misleading reports" and "also suggests using past tense in the report as it increases clarity." A report that says the house "had" three bedrooms on the effective date leaves no doubt about which date the description covers.
When the appraiser testifies in federal court, Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires a written report with "a complete statement of all opinions the witness will express and the basis and reasons for them," "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them," exhibits, qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, prior testimony from the previous 4 years and "a statement of the compensation to be paid for the study and testimony in the case."
For a retrospective report the list of facts or data considered includes the date each piece of data became available. A comparable sale that closed after the effective date is marked as such, with the reason it was used.
How does a court test a retrospective value opinion?
Under Rule 702 the proponent must show that the opinion more likely than not rests on sufficient facts or data and reliable methods reliably applied. For a past date, the facts are those the market had on that date.
As amended in 2023, Rule 702 requires the proponent to show the court "that it is more likely than not" that "the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data" and "is the product of reliable principles and methods," applied reliably to the facts of the case. Rule 703 lets the expert rely on facts or data that experts in the field "would reasonably rely on."
In a retrospective assignment the questions follow from the date. Did the appraiser value as of the date the statute or the court set? Were the comparable sales known to the market on that date? Where later data were used, does the report explain why? Are the assumptions about the property's past condition stated and supported?
An appraisal that values the property as of the wrong date answers a question the court did not ask. A business valued as of the filing date in a Florida divorce, where the judge sets the trial date as the valuation date, is one example.
A review ties each answer to a page of the report, so counsel can put that page to the appraiser on cross-examination.
When does one case need values on two dates?
When the law compares values over time: the estate tax alternate valuation election, a premarital business in a Florida divorce, or a Florida appraisal-rights case that excludes appreciation in anticipation of the corporate action.
The alternate valuation date is available only if it lowers both the gross estate and the combined estate and generation-skipping transfer tax (26 U.S.C. 2032(c)). An executor who weighs the election needs one value as of the date of death and one as of six months later or the date of disposition.
In a Florida divorce the enhancement in value of a nonmarital asset, such as a business owned before the marriage, is a marital asset to the extent it results from the efforts of either party during the marriage or from the contribution of marital funds or other marital assets (section 61.075(6)(a)1.b). The appraiser values the business as of the date of the marriage and as of the valuation date, then separates growth caused by the spouses' work from growth caused by the market.
Florida appraisal rights exclude value created by the transaction itself. Section 607.1301(5)(b) excludes "any appreciation or depreciation in anticipation of the corporate action unless exclusion would be inequitable to the corporation and its remaining shareholders." The appraiser has to know the company as it stood before the corporate action was anticipated.
Each of these assignments produces two retrospective values in one report, and each value has its own date, data cutoff and assumptions.
What does IAE do when a case needs a value as of a past date?
An IAE appraiser prepares an expert report as of the date the case needs or a review of the opposing appraisal against USPAP, in up to 5 business days. The property and the valuation date are confirmed first.
The IAE valuation page covers the market value of real property and the fair market value of a business or an ownership interest as of the date the case needs, for estate and gift tax disputes, divorce, condemnation and shareholder cases. For real property the development follows USPAP Standard 1 and each comparable sale and adjustment is traced to its source; for closely held stock the appraiser works from the factors of 26 CFR 20.2031-2(f)(2) with USPAP Standard 9. A review under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 covers comparables, adjustments, the discount rate, the effective date and the support for each conclusion.
IAE confirms the questions, the property and the valuation date with the client before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt of materials the same day and, within one business day, the format, cost, deadline and the appraiser from the registry; the client approves the candidate and the CV. For tight deadlines there is a 48-hour rush.
Appraisers are listed in the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The appraiser confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. IAE is not a law firm, and neither IAE nor the appraiser guarantees the court's decision.
Sources
- JoAnn Apostol, Appraising in the Past: A Look at Retrospective Appraisal Assignments, Appraiser Focus (National Association of Appraisers), 2023, pp. 14-17
- Tim Andersen, USPAP, Retrospective Appraisals and the Titanic, Working RE, December 2, 2014
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 703 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 706 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 26 U.S. Code 2032, Alternate valuation (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Matter of Maxon v. Mirror Show Management, Inc., 2005 NY Slip Op 50601(U) (Sup. Ct. Monroe County, March 22, 2005)
- Florida Statutes 2025, section 607.1436 (Florida Senate)
- Florida Statutes 2025, section 607.1301 (Florida Senate)
- Florida Statutes 2025, section 61.075 (Florida Senate)
Read also
All articles
House owned before the marriage: how is the marital share of its appreciation valued in a Florida divorce?
A house one spouse owned before the wedding is that spouse's nonmarital property in Florida. The marriage can still give the other spouse a claim
Qualified appraisal for a noncash charitable contribution: who may sign it, what must it contain and when is the deduction lost?
A deduction of more than $5,000 for donated property requires a qualified appraisal under section 170(f)(11) of the Internal Revenue Code
Gift tax appraisal: what does adequate disclosure require, and what must the appraisal contain?
The IRS has three years after a gift tax return is filed to assess more tax, but only if the gift was adequately disclosed. If it was not, the periodExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

