Evidence

How does USCIS evaluate expert letters in EB-1A, NIW and O-1 cases?

USCIS treats an expert letter as one piece of evidence. Under Matter of Caron International, USCIS may use such a letter as an advisory opinion and may give it less weight, or decline to accept it, when it conflicts with the record or is "in any way questionable." The Policy Manual expects letter writers' statements to be corroborated by documents in the record. The officer decides.

An expert and an attorney review an expert opinion letter for a petition

What is an expert letter in a USCIS petition?

An expert letter is a signed opinion in which a specialist explains to the USCIS officer what the applicant's work means for the field. The regulations do not list it as a criterion; it supports the criteria.

The officer who reads an EB-1A, NIW or O-1 file is a generalist. An expert letter closes that gap: a person who knows the field reads the record and explains in plain terms what the applicant did and how it compares with ordinary work in that field.

None of the ten EB-1A criteria in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(3) is a letter. The letter works inside a criterion. For original contributions of major significance, the USCIS Policy Manual lists "detailed letters from experts in the field" that explain the nature and significance of a contribution.

The letter explains other evidence in the file to the officer. How much weight it carries depends on a 1988 rule from Matter of Caron International.

What did Matter of Caron International decide?

In 1988 the Commissioner of the Immigration and Naturalization Service held that INS may use expert statements as advisory opinions and may decline them or give them less weight when they conflict with other information or are questionable.

The case, decided on October 28, 1988, was an H-1 petition filed by a yarn manufacturer for its vice-president of manufacturing. To show that the job required a degree, counsel filed three letters from universities and one from the American Yarn Spinners Association. One university letter conceded that doing the job without formal textile education "is definitely possible." Two others said the position was "normally filled" by graduates, which does not mean that a degree is required.

On that record the Commissioner stated the rule. INS may use such statements as advisory opinions, and where an opinion "is not in accord with other information or is in any way questionable," it is not required to accept the opinion or may give it less weight (Matter of Caron International, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791, 795 (Comm'r 1988)).

The letters did not prove that the job was a profession. The petition was approved on another ground: the Commissioner found that the position required a prominent business executive and that the person named in the petition was one. Under this rule the officer reads each letter against the rest of the file, and one sentence that concedes the opposing point can work against the claim the letter was written to support.

How does the Kazarian two-step review treat letters?

Step one asks whether the evidence meets at least three regulatory criteria. Step two weighs the whole record for sustained acclaim. A letter can matter at both steps, and a famous signature does not change what the documents show.

Kazarian, a theoretical physicist, filed Form I-140 as a person of extraordinary ability. The Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) concluded that none of his evidence qualified. In its amended opinion of March 4, 2010, the Ninth Circuit held that the AAO had erred on scholarly articles and on judging, because it had added requirements the regulation does not contain, such as proof that other researchers cited his work (Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F.3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010)).

One reference letter in the record came from Kip Thorne, the Feynman Professor of Theoretical Physics, who wrote that the research was "of the caliber that one would expect from a young professor." Physics professors attested to his contributions; the AAO found them not of major significance, and the court held that finding consistent with the regulation. With two criteria instead of three, the denial stood.

The Policy Manual tells officers to use this two-step analysis and cites Kazarian. At step two the EB-1A question is whether the applicant belongs to the "small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field," the definition in 8 CFR 204.5(h)(2). For O-1A, the O-1 chapter of the Manual says that providing the required evidence "does not, in itself, establish" that the standard is met.

What does the USCIS Policy Manual say about letters?

Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2 says letters of support have weight but should not be the main basis of a claim. What the writers state should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record.

The passage on letters of support starts from an expectation: a person with sustained acclaim would be recognized "well beyond the circle" of personal and professional acquaintances. That expectation is why officers look at who wrote a letter and how the writer knows the applicant.

The rest of the passage reads like a checklist.

  • Letters should explain in specific terms why the writer believes the applicant has extraordinary ability.
  • Letters that repeat USCIS definitions or make general and expansive statements are generally not persuasive.
  • Letters that only describe the applicant as competent and respected are considered but do not necessarily show extraordinary ability.
  • The writers' statements should be corroborated by documentary evidence in the record.

Documents made at the time of the achievement

The chapter on advanced degree and exceptional ability (Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 5) adds a related point: certificates and other documents created at the time of an achievement may carry more weight than letters prepared for the petition. Documents come first, and the letter explains them.

How did expert letters work in Matter of Dhanasar?

In the 2016 NIW precedent, the AAO relied on expert letters for the first two prongs, with media articles for the first and records of grant projects funded by NASA and the Air Force Research Laboratories for the second.

Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016), decided on December 27, 2016, vacated the earlier NYSDOT framework and set three prongs: the proposed endeavor has substantial merit and national importance; the person is well positioned to advance it; on balance, waiving the job offer requirement would benefit the United States. The applicant was an aerospace engineer who proposed research on air and space propulsion systems and also planned to teach.

The AAO described his letters as coming from "individuals who establish their own expertise in aerospace" and who described his research in detail. It called them "probative expert letters" from people in senior positions in academia, government and industry. For the second prong it relied on "detailed expert letters describing U.S. Government interest and investment in his research," next to records of his role in grant-funded projects. The appeal was sustained and the petition approved.

In the same decision the AAO found that he had not shown that his proposed teaching met the national importance element of the first prong.

What changes in O-1 cases?

O-1 petitions need a written consultation under 8 CFR 214.2(o)(5) in the form of an advisory opinion from a peer group or a person with expertise. It is advisory only and does not bind USCIS.

The O-1 rules add a document that EB-1A and NIW petitions do not have. The Policy Manual chapter on O documentation and evidence describes a consultation process that the statute requires for every O petition. For O-1A, the employer or agent who files provides an advisory opinion from a U.S. peer group, which may be a labor organization, or from a person or persons with expertise in the applicant's area of ability.

A favorable opinion describes the applicant's ability and achievements and the nature of the duties, and states whether the position requires a person of extraordinary ability; it may instead state "no objection." A negative opinion must set out the specific facts behind its conclusion. The Manual calls the consultations "advisory in nature only" and says a negative opinion does not automatically lead to denial. If the petitioner shows that no appropriate peer group exists, USCIS decides on the evidence of record.

One more rule from the same chapter applies to every O-1 letter. Affidavits from employers or recognized experts must describe the applicant's recognition and achievements in factual terms, state the author's own expertise and explain how the author obtained the information. IAE issues advisory opinions as an association letter, assessed by at least two members in the applicant's field.

Why do officers give some letters little weight?

The sources above point to four defects: the author is close to the applicant, the letter repeats legal definitions, its claims have no documents behind them, or it contradicts the rest of the file.

Each defect below is tied to a published source.

  • The author is close to the applicant. The Manual expects recognition beyond the applicant's personal and professional acquaintances. Letters from co-authors and supervisors remain evidence, yet they cannot show recognition outside that circle.
  • The letter draws legal conclusions. Letters that repeat USCIS definitions are generally not persuasive. Whether a criterion is met is the officer's call.
  • Claims have no documents behind them. A statement that a method is widely used, with no license data, citations or contracts behind it, asks the officer to take it on trust.
  • The letter conflicts with the file. Under Caron, an opinion that is not in accord with other information may be given less weight. A wrong date, job title or figure creates such a conflict.

What makes an expert letter carry weight?

A letter carries weight when the officer can test it: the author's expertise and independence are shown, every statement points to an exhibit, and the comparison with ordinary work in the field is concrete.

The IAE regulation for expert letters, IAE-EOL-001, turns the requirements for a letter into a checklist that the letter must pass before delivery. The points below come from that check and from the sources above.

  • The author's qualifications in the applicant's field: degrees, positions, years of practice, publications.
  • How the author knows the work: from the documents alone, or through a relationship disclosed in the letter.
  • A dated list of the documents the author reviewed.
  • One section per criterion or prong, under the name the regulation or Dhanasar uses.
  • A source and a date for every number: citations, users, revenue, grant amounts.
  • A comparison with ordinary work in the field, with an example of what counts as the standard.
  • No statement that the applicant meets a criterion or deserves a visa; the author describes facts and what they mean for the field.

Line-by-line check against the CV

Dates, publication titles, employers and job titles in the letter must match the CV and the exhibits. Under Caron, a mismatch is a reason to give the opinion less weight.

How does IAE prepare an expert letter?

The Secretariat prepares the draft from the applicant's documents. A registry member or an external expert under IAE-EOL-001 checks the draft, makes changes and signs it. The expert signs a declaration of independence, and the text passes the IAE checklist.

You receive the expert's CV before payment. The expert's status can be checked in the public IAE registry by record number or QR code. In every letter the expert confirms no personal, financial or professional connection to the applicant; if there is one, the expert declines the order. One expert does not sign two letters for the same petition. The rules are set out in the IAE Impartiality Policy (IAE-GOV-002).

The standard term for an expert letter is 10 business days, or 5 for a rush order. The letter contains no legal conclusions and no predictions about the outcome. It is one piece of evidence in the file, and USCIS decides the petition.

What should you check before ordering letters?

Start from the criteria. For each criterion or prong, list the documents you already have, then mark the facts whose meaning a generalist officer will need an expert to explain.

A table with four columns is enough: criterion, exhibits, gaps, and who can speak to the work. If a criterion has no documents, a letter will not create them, because the Manual expects the writers' statements to be corroborated by the record. If the documents exist and their meaning is not obvious to a non-specialist, that is the job for an expert letter.

If you are not sure which criteria your record supports, the IAE profile audit answers that in writing. A registry expert checks the file against the EB-1A, EB-2 NIW or O-1 criteria and reports what is proven, what is missing and what to collect before filing. The audit costs $350 and takes up to 5 business days.

Sources

Guides

Case assessment in 1 business day

Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.

Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

Case for assessment

Sent

Secretariat reply within one business day

CategoryEB-1A
Letters neededIn the reply
AssessmentFree