EB-2 NIW
Matter of Dhanasar: the three NIW prongs and the evidence for each
Matter of Dhanasar, an AAO precedent of December 27, 2016, sets the test USCIS applies to an EB-2 national interest waiver (NIW). The petitioner proves three prongs: the proposed endeavor has substantial merit and national importance, the person is well positioned to advance it, and on balance a waiver of the job offer and labor certification would benefit the United States. The AAO approved the petition in that case on expert letters, media articles and records of grant-funded projects.

What did Matter of Dhanasar decide?
On December 27, 2016, the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) vacated the 1998 precedent known as NYSDOT and set three prongs for the national interest waiver. The petitioner proves each one by a preponderance of the evidence.
Matter of Dhanasar, 26 I&N Dec. 884 (AAO 2016) began with a denial. The Director of the Texas Service Center found that the petitioner qualified as "a member of the professions holding an advanced degree" but that a waiver of the job offer requirement "would not be in the national interest of the United States." On appeal the AAO accepted the first finding: "We agree that he holds advanced degrees and therefore qualifies under section 203(b)(2)(A)." The dispute was about the waiver.
Until then the governing precedent was Matter of New York State Dep't of Transp., 22 I&N Dec. 215 (Acting Assoc. Comm'r 1998), known as NYSDOT. The AAO listed what had gone wrong with it in practice. In the first prong, "the term 'intrinsic' adds little to the analysis yet is susceptible to unnecessary subjective evaluation." The term "national in scope" was at times "construed too narrowly by focusing primarily on the geographic impact of the benefit." And "NYSDOT's third prong was especially problematic for certain petitioners, such as entrepreneurs and self-employed individuals." The AAO wrote: "Today, we vacate NYSDOT and adopt a new framework."
Under the new framework, USCIS may grant the waiver when the petitioner proves three prongs by a preponderance of the evidence. The framework applies "after eligibility for EB-2 classification has been established."
- The foreign national's proposed endeavor "has both substantial merit and national importance."
- The foreign national "is well positioned to advance the proposed endeavor."
- On balance, "it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification."
What has to be proven before the three prongs?
EB-2 eligibility. Under 8 CFR 204.5(k), the person is a member of the professions holding an advanced degree or has exceptional ability in the sciences, arts or business. The prongs come after that.
Under 8 CFR 204.5(k)(2), an advanced degree is "any United States academic or professional degree or a foreign equivalent degree above that of baccalaureate." A U.S. bachelor's degree or a foreign equivalent "followed by at least five years of progressive experience in the specialty" counts as a master's degree. If the specialty customarily requires a doctorate, the person needs a U.S. doctorate or a foreign equivalent degree.
Exceptional ability means "a degree of expertise significantly above that ordinarily encountered in the sciences, arts, or business." Paragraph (k)(3)(ii) asks for at least three of six types of evidence: an academic record of a degree, diploma or certificate in the area; employer letters showing at least ten years of full-time experience in the occupation; a license or certification; a salary or other remuneration that shows exceptional ability; membership in professional associations; and recognition for achievements and contributions from peers, government entities or professional organizations. Where these standards do not readily apply to the occupation, paragraph (k)(3)(iii) permits comparable evidence.
EB-2 eligibility does not settle the waiver. The USCIS Policy Manual says it "does not automatically mean that the person qualifies for a national interest waiver." A waiver request "does not need to be supported by a job offer; therefore, the person may file as a self-petitioner," and "A waiver of a job offer also includes a waiver of the permanent labor certification requirement." The petitioner still submits "the employee-specific portions of a permanent labor certification" without approval from the Department of Labor. The Policy Manual names Form ETA 750B or Form ETA 9089 for that; 8 CFR 204.5(k)(4)(ii) names Form ETA-750B, Statement of Qualifications of Alien.
What does the first prong require?
A specific proposed endeavor with substantial merit and national importance. The officer looks at what the person will do and at the potential prospective impact of that work. A general description of the occupation is not enough.
In Dhanasar the AAO wrote that the first prong "focuses on the specific endeavor that the foreign national proposes to undertake." Merit can come from "a range of areas such as business, entrepreneurialism, science, technology, culture, health, or education." Evidence of a potential economic impact "may be favorable but is not required," and "endeavors related to research, pure science, and the furtherance of human knowledge may qualify" whether or not they are likely to bring economic benefits to the United States.
The Policy Manual asks for detail. "The term 'endeavor' is more specific than the general occupation." Its example is engineering: the explanation of the endeavor "should describe the specific projects and goals, and the area of engineering in which the person will work, rather than simply listing the duties and responsibilities of an engineer." For national importance, "the officer's analysis focuses on what the person will be doing rather than the specific job title or occupational classification."
National importance is judged by the endeavor's "potential prospective impact." Under Dhanasar, an undertaking may have "national or even global implications within a particular field, such as those resulting from certain improved manufacturing processes or medical advances." Geography does not decide the question: "we do not evaluate prospective impact solely in geographic terms," and "Even ventures and undertakings that have as their focus one geographic area of the United States may properly be considered to have national importance." The AAO gave one more example, an endeavor that "has significant potential to employ U.S. workers or has other substantial positive economic effects, particularly in an economically depressed area."
Dhanasar proposed two activities, research and teaching, and only the research passed this prong. The AAO found that STEM teaching "has substantial merit in relation to U.S. educational interests," but the record did not establish that he "would be engaged in activities that would impact the field of STEM education more broadly." The AAO did not address the other prongs for his teaching. The Policy Manual keeps the rule: classroom teaching "without broader implications for a field or region" generally does not have national importance.
Which evidence supports the first prong?
The Policy Manual says petitioners "should submit a detailed description explaining the proposed endeavor and supporting documentary evidence to establish that the endeavor is of national importance." In Dhanasar the AAO found substantial merit because the research "aims to advance scientific knowledge," and it cited letters on uses of hypersonic flight research for national security. For national importance it relied on "probative expert letters from individuals holding senior positions in academia, government, and industry" and on "media articles and other evidence documenting the interest of the House Committee on Armed Services."
For endeavors in STEM, the Policy Manual tells officers to identify a critical and emerging technology field from governmental, academic and other authoritative sources and from all other evidence the petitioner submits. A footnote defines the term: "Critical and emerging technologies are those that are critical to U.S. national security, including military defense and the economy." Its examples "may include, but are not limited to, certain critical areas of artificial intelligence or quantum information science," and USCIS reviews each proposed endeavor case by case.
What does the second prong require?
Proof that the person is well positioned to advance the endeavor. Dhanasar lists education, skills, knowledge and record of success, a plan for future activities, progress so far and interest from customers, users or investors.
The Policy Manual separates the first two prongs in one sentence: "Unlike the first prong, which focuses on the merit and importance of the proposed endeavor, the second prong centers on the person." In Dhanasar the AAO listed the factors it considers, "including, but not limited to": "the individual's education, skills, knowledge and record of success in related or similar efforts; a model or plan for future activities; any progress towards achieving the proposed endeavor; and the interest of potential customers, users, investors, or other relevant entities or individuals."
The AAO accepted that the success of a future endeavor is hard to forecast. It does not require petitioners to prove that their endeavors are "more likely than not to ultimately succeed." They must still establish, by a preponderance of the evidence, that they are well positioned to advance the endeavor.
The Policy Manual adds two rules on degrees. An advanced degree, "particularly a Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.), in a STEM field tied to the proposed endeavor" and related to work furthering a critical and emerging technology or another STEM area important to U.S. competitiveness or national security, is "an especially positive factor to be considered along with other evidence." A degree on its own, however, "is not a sufficient basis to determine that a person is well positioned."
The chapter then lists evidence for this prong and warns: "This list is not meant to be a checklist or to indicate that any one type of evidence is either required or sufficient to establish eligibility." After the list it adds two conditions. Letters "may be persuasive when they are from experts in the person's field who have first-hand knowledge of the person's achievements, describe those achievements, provide specific examples of how the person is well positioned to advance the person's endeavor, and are supported by other independent evidence." Business plans, "while useful in explaining the person's objectives, should be supported by other independent evidence." The items on the list include the following.
- The person holds degrees, certificates or licenses in the field.
- The person developed patents, trademarks or copyrights.
- Published articles or media reports cover the person's achievements or current work.
- The person's work has a strong citation history.
- The person's work has influenced the field of endeavor, and others use it.
- A plan describes how the person intends to continue the proposed work in the United States.
- Correspondence comes from prospective or potential customers, users, investors or other relevant entities.
- Documents show feasible plans for financial support.
- The person has received investment from U.S. investors such as venture capital firms, or awards, grants or other non-monetary support.
- Contracts, agreements or licenses show the potential impact of the proposed endeavor.
What carried the second prong in Dhanasar?
The AAO pointed to the petitioner's "experience conducting research and developing computational models" and to his work on projects funded by grants from NASA and the Air Force Research Laboratories. A footnote adds that he "initiated or is the primary award contact on several funded grant proposals." The AAO also cited "detailed expert letters describing U.S. Government interest and investment in his research."
The Policy Manual sets the limit for this kind of evidence: "However, unsubstantiated claims would not meet the petitioner's burden of proof."
What changes for an entrepreneur?
The Policy Manual has a part on entrepreneurs. "The petitioner may have an ownership interest in an entity based in the United States" and "may also play an active and central role in the operations of the entity." The chapter notes that "many entrepreneurs do not follow traditional career paths" and discusses accelerators, incubators, outside investment and "Revenue Generation, Growth in Revenue, and Job Creation." An entrepreneur does not have to prove that the venture is more likely than not to succeed.
A business plan answers two items from the lists above: the Dhanasar factor "a model or plan for future activities" and the Policy Manual's item on a plan for continuing the proposed work in the United States. The chapter's condition applies to it: other independent evidence supports the plan. An IAE business plan runs 25-35 pages with a five-year financial model in Excel, and every market figure carries a source with its name, year and link. A registry expert in economics and management checks the plan against 15 points, corrects it and signs it. For NIW the section on the petition covers the entrepreneur's role and the significance of the enterprise as facts, with no legal conclusions. The plan takes 7 business days after payment, 4 in rush mode.
What does the third prong weigh?
Whether, on balance, it would benefit the United States to waive the job offer and the labor certification. Dhanasar names three factors, and the Policy Manual adds considerations of its own, among them economic impact and job creation.
In Dhanasar the AAO wrote that Congress required job offers and labor certification "to protect the domestic labor supply." The third prong weighs that process against the person's contributions. Unlike the NYSDOT test, it does not require a showing of harm to the national interest or a comparison of the person with U.S. workers in the field.
In Dhanasar the AAO named three factors USCIS may evaluate. The first is whether, "in light of the nature of the foreign national's qualifications or proposed endeavor, it would be impractical either for the foreign national to secure a job offer or for the petitioner to obtain a labor certification." The second is whether, "even assuming that other qualified U.S. workers are available, the United States would still benefit from the foreign national's contributions." The third is "whether the national interest in the foreign national's contributions is sufficiently urgent to warrant forgoing the labor certification process." The factors considered "must, taken together, indicate that on balance, it would be beneficial to the United States to waive the requirements of a job offer and thus of a labor certification."
A footnote gives two examples. Labor certification "may prevent a petitioning employer from hiring a foreign national with unique knowledge or skills that are not easily articulated in a labor certification." And "it may be impractical for an entrepreneur or self-employed inventor, when advancing an endeavor on his or her own, to secure a job offer from a U.S. employer."
The Policy Manual repeats the three factors and gives an example of urgency: "a time-sensitive public health or safety benefit offered by the endeavor." Its more specific considerations are whether the endeavor "has the potential to generate considerable economic impact consistent, for example, with economic revitalization" and whether it "may lead to potential job creation." It then notes that "evidence of a national labor shortage in the person's occupation would not, by itself, satisfy this third prong." For STEM it treats one combination of facts as "a strong positive factor": an advanced STEM degree, especially a Ph.D., work furthering a critical and emerging technology or another STEM area important to U.S. competitiveness, and a person well positioned to advance that endeavor.
How did the AAO weigh the third prong in Dhanasar?
The AAO relied on specific facts. The petitioner "holds three graduate degrees in fields tied to the proposed endeavor": two master of science degrees, in mechanical engineering and in applied physics, and a Ph.D. in engineering from North Carolina A&T. He "possesses considerable experience and expertise in a highly specialized field," and research on hypersonic propulsion "holds significant implications for U.S. national security and competitiveness." The research he took part in had been funded repeatedly, and government agencies, including NASA and the DOD, had found his work "promising and useful."
The AAO concluded that his contributions "would benefit the United States even assuming that other qualified U.S. workers are available." It did not analyze separately whether a labor certification was impractical for him. The order reads: "The appeal is sustained and the petition is approved."
Where does an expert letter fit among the three prongs?
In Dhanasar the AAO relied on expert letters for the first and second prongs, and the Policy Manual says when such letters are persuasive for the second. A letter is one exhibit in the record, and USCIS decides.
The letters in Dhanasar did two separate jobs. For national importance they came from "individuals holding senior positions in academia, government, and industry." For the second prong they were "detailed expert letters describing U.S. Government interest and investment in his research," and the AAO read them together with the grant records. The Policy Manual adds that letters from interested U.S. government agencies or quasi-governmental entities, "for example federally-funded research and development centers," are not required but "can be relevant to all three prongs."
A letter written to this framework follows the order of the prongs. It describes the proposed endeavor in the words of the petition, because the first prong concerns that specific endeavor. It gives dates and sources for the person's record, progress and the interest of users, investors or agencies, because those are the second-prong factors. On the third prong it states facts the expert can confirm, such as funding history or the urgency of the work. The expert does not write that a prong is met, because the officer decides that. How officers weigh expert letters in general is covered in the guide How does USCIS evaluate expert letters in EB-1A, NIW and O-1 cases?
For an IAE expert opinion letter in an EB-2 NIW case, the secretariat prepares a draft from the applicant's documents, and a registry expert in the subject area checks it, makes changes and signs it. The letter runs up to 15 pages, with the analysis set out under the three Dhanasar prongs. The expert's CV and a declaration of independence are attached, and the expert's status can be checked in the public IAE registry by QR code. The draft goes to the applicant and the attorney before signing, with one round of factual edits included. The standard term is 10 business days, or 5 in rush mode, counted from payment and receipt of all materials.
IAE is not a law firm. The letter does not guarantee approval: USCIS weighs it together with the rest of the record and decides the petition.
How can you sort the record by prong before filing?
Check EB-2 eligibility, describe the endeavor in one paragraph, then put every document under the prong it supports. A prong with no dated document behind it is a gap to close before filing.
The sorting takes six steps.
- Check the degree against 8 CFR 204.5(k)(2), or count the types of exceptional ability evidence under (k)(3)(ii), where at least three of six are required.
- Describe the proposed endeavor in one paragraph and name the projects, goals or area of work, as the Policy Manual's engineering example asks.
- Under the first prong, list the documents on the merit of the endeavor and on its implications for a field or region.
- Under the second prong, list the degrees, the record of success, the plan, the progress so far and any interest from customers, users, investors or agencies, each with its date.
- Under the third prong, write which Dhanasar factor applies to the case: a job offer or labor certification is impractical, the United States benefits even if U.S. workers are available, or the work is urgent.
- Mark every claim that no document supports, because under the Policy Manual unsubstantiated claims do not meet the burden of proof.
What if you are not sure the record covers each prong?
The IAE profile audit answers that in writing. An IAE expert checks the record against the three Dhanasar prongs and gives a conclusion and a list of evidence for each prong. The report also contains a criteria map, the gaps, a collection plan and a category recommendation. The audit costs $350 for one category, and the report comes within 5 business days of receiving the materials and payment. The audit is an expert assessment of the profile against published criteria. It gives no legal advice and no forecast of the USCIS decision.
Sources
Read also
All guides
How does USCIS evaluate expert letters in EB-1A, NIW and O-1 cases?
USCIS treats an expert letter as one piece of evidence. Under Matter of Caron International, USCIS may use such a letter as an advisory opinion
The DV-2027 lottery has not opened: which paths remain for professionals in the US?
The State Department postponed registration for the DV-2027 diversity visa lottery in a notice last updated on November 5, 2025, and has notGuides
Case assessment in 1 business day
Tell us the petition category, field and deadline. The Secretariat replies within one business day: which letters make sense, who checks and signs them and what they cost.
Are you an expert thinking about IAE membership? One-minute eligibility check

