Letter review

USCIS cited AACRAO EDGE against your credential evaluation: what happens next?

When a credential evaluation and the AACRAO EDGE database disagree, USCIS may follow EDGE. In Viraj v. U.S. Attorney General (11th Cir. 2014) the court called EDGE "a respected source of information" and upheld giving the petitioner's evaluations less weight. In a January 12, 2023 decision the AAO also held that an officer who relies on EDGE must give the petitioner the EDGE report and a chance to respond before denying.

Hands hold a diploma booklet beside a blurred database screen and a face-down letter

What is AACRAO EDGE?

A subscription database of the American Association of Collegiate Registrars and Admissions Officers with country profiles of education systems, credential advice and placement recommendations approved by its International Education Standards Council.

AACRAO describes EDGE, the Electronic Database for Global Education, as a source of "expert-reviewed country profiles, credential guidance, and updates" and of "country-specific education system profiles, credential advice, grading scales". It states that "New placement recommendations are reviewed and approved by the International Education Standards Council (IESC)."

Access is paid. AACRAO publishes annual subscription rates by institution type, membership status and number of users, and notes that "AACRAO Membership and AACRAO EDGE are two separate entities." The users it names are universities and credential evaluators.

For an applicant this means that the officer may have access to a source the applicant's evaluator did not cite, and that the applicant may not be able to read the same entry without a subscription.

Why does USCIS rely on EDGE?

Because courts accept it as a reliable reference. In Viraj v. U.S. Attorney General (11th Cir. 2014) the court held that the agency's reliance on EDGE, "a respected source of information", was not arbitrary.

Viraj, LLC v. U.S. Attorney General, No. 13-13015, was decided on August 25, 2014, in an unpublished per curiam opinion by Chief Judge Ed Carnes and Judges Tjoflat and Fay. Viraj, an IT consulting company, filed an EB-2 advanced degree petition for an employee with a three-year Indian bachelor's degree and a two-year master's degree. USCIS and the AAO denied it on the ground that the degrees did not equal a U.S. advanced degree.

Viraj argued that five years of college were enough. USCIS relied on EDGE and gave less weight to professors' letters and evaluations that Viraj submitted. The district court granted summary judgment to the government, and the Eleventh Circuit affirmed. It held reasonable the conclusion that the three-year bachelor of science degree "was not equivalent to a United States bachelor's degree."

Can USCIS give an evaluation less weight because it differs from EDGE?

Yes. In Viraj the court held that the agency "was entitled to give the letters and evaluations less weight", quoting Matter of Caron International. The AAO cited Viraj for the same point in 2023.

The Viraj court quoted the agency's own precedent, Matter of Caron International: USCIS "may give less weight to that evidence." In Viraj the other evidence was EDGE.

In its January 12, 2023 decision (Matter ID 23661037), the AAO cited Viraj for the proposition that "the AAO is entitled to give letters from professors and academic credentials evaluations less weight" when they differ from EDGE. The rule cuts one way: an evaluation that reaches a different result than EDGE must give its reasons, because the officer may otherwise follow EDGE.

An evaluation is evidence, not a ruling. Its weight depends on its reasons, and an evaluation whose reasons stop at a conclusion gives the officer nothing to set against the database.

What happened with a three-year Indian degree in an EB-3 professional case?

In the AAO's decision of January 12, 2023, EDGE treated the three-year B.Sc. as three years of U.S. study, while two of three evaluations equated it to a four-year degree. The AAO remanded the case.

The labor certification required "a U.S. bachelor's or a foreign equivalent degree in electronics or computer science." The beneficiary had a three-year bachelor of science degree in electronics from an Indian university and submitted the diploma and examination results with three evaluations. One found a U.S. equivalency in mathematics, electronics and computer science. Two found the three-year degree equivalent to a four-year U.S. B.S. of 138 semester hours.

The AAO set out the framework. "USCIS may neither ignore a certification term, nor impose additional requirements", citing Madany v. Smith, 696 F.2d 1008 (D.C. Cir. 1983). "A baccalaureate degree in the United States generally requires four years of academic study", citing Matter of Shah, 17 I&N Dec. 244 (Reg'l Comm'r 1977). And the petitioner must show that the beneficiary met all certified requirements by the priority date, citing Matter of Wing's Tea House, 16 I&N Dec. 158 (Acting Reg'l Comm'r 1977).

On EDGE the AAO wrote that a three-year Indian B.Sc. "is comparable to three years of university study in the United States, not a full bachelor's degree", and that "the Beneficiary has not attained the foreign equivalent of a U.S. bachelor's degree." It nevertheless withdrew the director's decision, because the director had not addressed the three evaluations, and remanded.

Must USCIS show you the EDGE report before it denies?

In the 2023 decision the AAO directed the director to give the petitioner the EDGE report and an opportunity to respond. The rule on derogatory information in 8 CFR 103.2(b)(16)(i) requires disclosure and a chance to rebut.

The remand order in the January 12, 2023 decision did two things. It required the director to address the credential evaluations in the record, and it required the director to provide the EDGE report to the petitioner and allow a response before a new decision.

The general rule is in 8 CFR 103.2(b)(16)(i). If a decision "will be adverse to the applicant or petitioner and is based on derogatory information considered by the Service and of which the applicant or petitioner is unaware, he/she shall be advised of this fact and offered an opportunity to rebut the information and present information in his/her own behalf before the decision is rendered", with listed exceptions.

For the petitioner the response window is the moment to put the evaluation and the EDGE entry side by side: what EDGE says, what the evaluation says, and which documents support the difference.

Can two degrees be combined to meet an EB-3 professional requirement?

Not under the AAO's reading. In a 2005 EB-3 decision the AAO held that the plain meaning of the regulation requires one degree and that a combination of degrees would not qualify the beneficiary as a professional.

The regulation for professionals, 8 CFR 204.5(l)(3)(ii)(C), requires evidence that the beneficiary "holds a United States baccalaureate degree or a foreign equivalent degree", shown by "an official college or university record showing the date the baccalaureate degree was awarded and the area of concentration of study."

In a 2005 decision on a petition by a school in Southern California, the AAO wrote that "the plain meaning of the regulatory language sets forth the requirement that a beneficiary must produce one degree" and that "the beneficiary's combination of degrees would not qualify her as a professional." It found that "neither degree is the equivalent of a U.S. baccalaureate degree" and repeated that "A U.S. baccalaureate degree is generally found to require four years of education."

The same decision noted that one of the beneficiary's programs was a distance learning program of an Indian university. The AAO decided the case on the single-degree rule and on the evaluations, not on the mode of study.

What makes an evaluation hold up against EDGE?

A stated basis: the documents examined, the EDGE entry and the reason for departing from it, and a comparison of course content and hours. In 2005 the AAO rejected evaluations that provided no authoritative basis for their conclusions.

The 2005 decision put the problem in one sentence: "None of the education evaluations provide any authoritative basis for their conclusions". The evaluations stated equivalencies without showing where they came from.

An evaluation that will be read against EDGE should name the EDGE entry for the credential, quote or summarize its placement recommendation, and explain any departure: the length of the program, the credit hours, the level of the courses, the admission requirements, an additional qualification that changes the placement. It should list the documents examined, including transcripts with subjects and hours.

The labor certification matters as much as the degree. Madany and the 2023 decision read the certification's terms as written. If the certification says "a U.S. bachelor's or a foreign equivalent degree", the evaluation has to show one foreign degree equal to a U.S. bachelor's, not a combination of education and experience.

What does a review of the evaluation check before filing?

Whether the evaluation names and addresses the EDGE placement, whether its conclusion rests on documents and course data, whether it matches the labor certification's terms and whether it relies on one degree where the category requires one.

The reviewer starts with the category and the labor certification: which degree, in which field, and whether alternatives or equivalents are allowed. The second step is the evaluation's basis: the documents listed, the course and hour data, the EDGE entry and the reasons for any departure from it.

The third step is consistency. An evaluation that equates a three-year degree to a U.S. bachelor's without addressing EDGE is the profile the AAO addressed in 2023, and an evaluation that adds two credentials together meets the single-degree rule of the 2005 decision.

What does IAE check in an evaluation that EDGE may contradict?

An IAE reviewer checks the evaluation's methodology, the evaluator's authority and the weak points of the degree or experience evaluation, and gives one of three verdicts: file, revise or redo. The standard turnaround is 3 business days, rush 1.

The client sends the evaluation and a short description of the petition. The secretariat confirms the fee, the turnaround and the reviewer within one business day. The reviewer is an IAE registry member in the field of the document, is independent of the provider of the document under review and confirms this in writing.

The review is page by page: every section is checked against the criteria of the visa category and the expectations of USCIS, and for a credential evaluation the reviewer examines the methodology, the evaluator's authority and the weak points of the degree or experience evaluation. The result is a signed review of 3-5 pages with a list of weak points, a recommendation for each and one of three verdicts with reasoning: file, revise or redo. The deadline runs from payment and receipt of all materials.

IAE is not a law firm; strategy questions in the case are for a licensed immigration attorney. The decision on the petition is made by USCIS, and neither IAE nor the reviewer influences it.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert letter review

Check the letter before the officer does

The standard turnaround is 3 business days, the rush option 1 business day. The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials; we confirm the fee, the turnaround and the reviewer within one business day.

Review

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

DocumentExpert letter
Timeline3 business days, rush 1
VerdictFile or revise