Letter review

Foreign medical degree (MBBS or MD) for USCIS: when is it an advanced degree, and what must the evaluation show?

A U.S. medical degree is an advanced degree for USCIS because U.S. medical schools admit students after a bachelor's. Many foreign schools admit them after secondary school and award a Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery. The USCIS Policy Manual still lets such a degree count as an advanced degree for EB-2 if two conditions are met when the labor certification is filed. A credential evaluation is one of three ways to meet the first.

Hands hold a burgundy diploma booklet beside a blank sheet, a stethoscope and a white coat

Does USCIS treat an MBBS as an advanced degree?

It can. The Policy Manual says a foreign medical degree may qualify as the equivalent of a U.S. medical degree and therefore an advanced degree, including degrees named Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery.

Under 8 CFR 204.5(k)(2), an advanced degree means "any United States academic or professional degree or a foreign equivalent degree above that of baccalaureate." The title of the foreign degree does not decide the question. What counts is whether the degree is equivalent to a U.S. degree above the bachelor's level.

The USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 6 addresses physicians directly. It states that "a U.S. medical degree is considered to be an advanced degree" and that "a foreign medical degree may qualify as the equivalent of a U.S. medical degree and therefore an advanced degree." It also notes that "in some countries, the name of the degree is Bachelor of Medicine, Bachelor of Surgery."

The difficulty comes from the admission route. A U.S. medical school admits students who already hold a bachelor's, so the M.D. sits above the baccalaureate. A five- or six-year MBBS that starts after secondary school does not follow a bachelor's. The Policy Manual answers this with two conditions instead of a rule based on years of study.

What is the first condition for a foreign medical degree?

The beneficiary must meet one of three options: a school that requires a bachelor's-equivalent degree for admission, a credential evaluation showing equivalence to a U.S. medical degree, or a passed NBME examination or equivalent such as USMLE.

Under the first option, the degree is from "a medical school that requires applicants to obtain a degree equivalent to a U.S. bachelor's degree" before admission. A graduate-entry program meets this option on its own.

Under the second option, the petition contains "a foreign education credential evaluation that credibly describes how the foreign medical degree is equivalent" to a U.S. medical degree from an accredited school. The word credibly matters. The evaluation has to explain the equivalence, course content and length included. A one-line conclusion does not meet that word.

Under the third option, the beneficiary has passed the National Board of Medical Examiners Examination "or an equivalent examination, such as the USMLE, Steps 1, 2, and 3." The Policy Manual names all three Steps for this option. A beneficiary who has passed Steps 1 and 2 and not Step 3 has the school's admission rule or the evaluation left for the first condition.

What is the second condition?

The beneficiary must have been fully eligible for the position on the labor certification when it was filed and must hold, or have a degree that qualifies for, a full and unrestricted license in the place of employment.

The second condition has two parts. First, the beneficiary "was fully eligible for the position described on the permanent labor certification application." Second, he or she either "had a full and unrestricted license to practice medicine in the place of intended employment" and continues to hold it, or holds a degree that meets the medical degree requirements for a full and unrestricted license there.

The Policy Manual adds that "approximately 75 percent of the U.S. states require foreign medical school graduates" to complete additional post-graduate training before they receive a full license. A degree that meets a state medical board's degree requirement does not mean the beneficiary already holds a license, and the petition has to say which part of the condition it relies on.

Licensing rules that turn on immigration status are set aside: under the Policy Manual, state criteria that depend on the applicant's U.S. immigration status are not relevant to the decision on the petition.

On which date must the conditions be met?

Both conditions are measured at the time the labor certification is filed with the Department of Labor. Officers also check the education, training and experience on the labor certification as of that filing date.

The Policy Manual ties both conditions to the filing of the permanent labor certification. In Section A.1 it states that officers check whether the physician met the minimum education, training and experience requirements of the labor certification as of the date it was filed with the Department of Labor.

This has a practical effect on the evaluation. If the USMLE Steps were passed after the labor certification was filed, the third option of the first condition is not available for that petition, and the equivalence has to rest on the school's admission requirement or on the evaluation.

Which examinations must a physician pass for the green card?

Under INA 212(a)(5)(B), a physician coming to practice medicine must have passed Parts I and II of the NBME examination or an equivalent such as USMLE and show competency in oral and written English.

Admissibility is a separate question from the degree. The Policy Manual states that "the physician must provide evidence that he or she has passed parts I and II of the NBMEE." It explains that "the NBMEE, also known as the NBME, ceased to be administered in 1992" and that "the USMLE, which was first administered in 1992, is considered an equivalent examination."

For English, the Policy Manual states that "an Educational Commission for Foreign Medical Graduates (ECFMG) certification showing the physician has passed the English language proficiency test meets this requirement." For a physician national interest waiver, admissibility is documented when the petition is filed. For a petition based on a labor certification, it is established when the labor certification is filed.

A credential evaluation does not replace these examinations. It answers whether the degree is an advanced degree; the examinations answer whether the physician is admissible to practice medicine.

What does an H-1B for a physician require?

Under 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(viii), a state license or authorization, and either a teaching or research role or a passed licensing examination plus English competency or graduation from an accredited school.

Under 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(viii)(A), the physician has a license or other authorization required by the state of intended employment to practice medicine, and has a full and unrestricted license to practice medicine in a foreign state or has graduated from a medical school in the United States or abroad.

Under (h)(4)(viii)(B), the petitioner then shows one of two things. The physician is coming "primarily to teach or conduct research, or both," at a public or nonprofit institution, with patient care only incidental to that work. Or the physician has passed the Federation Licensing Examination or an equivalent examination, or graduated from a U.S. medical school, and has competency in oral and written English shown by the ECFMG English test or is a graduate of a school accredited by a body approved by the Secretary of Education.

Under (h)(4)(viii)(C), a foreign medical graduate "of national or international renown in the field of medicine is exempt" from the requirements of paragraph (B). The H-1B rules for physicians do not depend on whether the MBBS is an advanced degree, which matters only for EB-2.

What if the H-1B job is not a physician position?

Then the general specialty occupation rules apply: a U.S. bachelor's or higher degree, a foreign equivalent degree, an unrestricted license, or equivalent education and experience under 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(iii)(C) and (D).

If the H-1B job is a research, public health, data or administration role, the beneficiary must meet one of the four tests in 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4)(iii)(C): a U.S. bachelor's or higher degree required by the occupation, a foreign degree determined to be equivalent to such a degree, an unrestricted state license, or education, training and experience equivalent to the degree with recognized expertise.

Under (h)(4)(iii)(D)(3), equivalence can be shown by "an evaluation of education by a reliable credentials evaluation service which specializes in evaluating foreign educational credentials." Under (D)(5), USCIS counts three years of specialized training or experience for each year of college-level training the beneficiary lacks. For this kind of petition, the evaluation has to link the medical degree to the specific specialty of the job, for example public health or biostatistics. A statement that the degree equals a U.S. medical degree does not answer that question.

Can a foreign medical graduate file as an EB-3 professional instead?

Yes, if the degree is equivalent to at least a U.S. bachelor's and the occupation requires one. The evidence is an official record showing the date the degree was awarded and the area of study.

Under 8 CFR 204.5(l)(2), a professional is "a qualified alien who holds at least a United States baccalaureate degree or a foreign equivalent degree and who is a member of the professions." Under (l)(3)(ii)(C), the evidence of the degree is "an official college or university record showing the date the baccalaureate degree was awarded and the area of concentration of study."

Under 8 CFR 204.5(k)(2), a profession includes the occupations listed in section 101(a)(32) of the Immigration and Nationality Act and any occupation for which a U.S. bachelor's degree or its foreign equivalent is the minimum requirement for entry. The EB-3 route does not need the two conditions of the Policy Manual. It still needs the admissibility evidence if the job is the practice of medicine.

Does a physician national interest waiver change the degree question?

No. The physician NIW is an EB-2 petition, so the degree must still be an advanced degree or the physician must show exceptional ability. The waiver removes the labor certification in exchange for five years of service.

The Policy Manual describes a waiver for physicians who agree to work full time in primary or specialty care in an area designated as underserved, or at a facility of the Department of Veterans Affairs, for an aggregate of 5 years. A federal agency or state department of public health must have determined that the physician's work there is in the public interest. For petitions filed before November 1, 1998, the service requirement was 3 years.

The regulation is 8 CFR 204.12. The Policy Manual discusses Schneider v. Chertoff, 450 F.3d 944 (9th Cir. 2006), which held that medical practice completed before approval of the petition, other than practice as a J-1 nonimmigrant, counts toward the service requirement. Because there is no labor certification in this route, the Policy Manual requires the admissibility documentation at the time the petition is filed.

What should a credential evaluation of a medical degree contain?

The admission requirement of the school, the length and content of the program with internship, the degree awarded and its date, and a stated basis for the equivalence to an accredited U.S. medical degree.

An evaluation that relies on the second option has to describe how the degree is equivalent. The facts that carry that description are the admission requirement of the medical school, the years of study, the clinical rotations and internship, the title and date of the degree and the official transcript. If the school required a prior degree, that fact alone moves the case to the first option, and the evaluation should say so.

The evaluation also has to match what the petition claims. For EB-2 on a labor certification, it addresses equivalence to a U.S. medical degree. For an H-1B in a non-clinical role, it addresses the specialty of the job. For EB-3, it addresses at least a bachelor's level.

The Policy Manual lists the evaluation as one of three options under the first condition, so a report that states a conclusion without describing the program gives the officer nothing to weigh.

What does a review of the evaluation check before filing?

Whether the evaluation fits the visa category, whether it explains the equivalence rather than asserting it, whether the dates match the labor certification, and whether the admissibility evidence is in the file.

A reviewer reads the evaluation against the conditions that apply to the petition. For EB-2, the questions are whether the first condition is met by the school's admission rule, the evaluation or the USMLE Steps, and whether the second condition is met by a license or by eligibility for one. For H-1B, the question is which paragraph of 8 CFR 214.2(h)(4) the petition relies on.

The reviewer also compares the dates: the date the degree was awarded, the dates of the examinations and the date the labor certification was filed. A USMLE result dated after the labor certification, or an evaluation that describes a different program from the one on the transcript, is a point the officer can raise in a request for evidence.

What does IAE check in an evaluation of a foreign medical degree?

An IAE reviewer checks the evaluation's methodology, the evaluator's authority and the weak points of the degree or experience evaluation, and gives one of three verdicts: file, revise or redo. The standard turnaround is 3 business days, rush 1.

The client sends the evaluation and a short description of the petition. The secretariat confirms the fee, the turnaround and the reviewer within one business day. The reviewer is an IAE registry member in the field of the document, is independent of the provider of the document under review and confirms this in writing.

The review is page by page: every section is checked against the criteria of the visa category and the expectations of USCIS, and for a credential evaluation the reviewer examines the methodology, the evaluator's authority and the weak points of the degree or experience evaluation. The result is a signed review of 3-5 pages with a list of weak points, a recommendation for each and one of three verdicts with reasoning: file, revise or redo. The deadline runs from payment and receipt of all materials.

IAE is not a law firm; strategy questions in the case are for a licensed immigration attorney. The decision on the petition is made by USCIS, and neither IAE nor the reviewer influences it.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert letter review

Check the letter before the officer does

The standard turnaround is 3 business days, the rush option 1 business day. The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials; we confirm the fee, the turnaround and the reviewer within one business day.

Review

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

DocumentExpert letter
Timeline3 business days, rush 1
VerdictFile or revise