Letter review

Indian three-year bachelor's plus two-year master's: does USCIS count it as an advanced degree for EB-2?

In AAO decisions of 2017 and 2019 an Indian master's degree was placed at the level of a U.S. bachelor's degree. In 2017 the AAO cited EDGE. In 2019 the petitioner's own three evaluations said so about a three-year bachelor's and a two-year master's. EB-2 then depends on five years of progressive experience after the degree and on a labor certification that accepts that route. An evaluation that claims a U.S. master's has to explain why the record supports it.

Hands stack a thin diploma cover on a thicker one beside a slim folder in window light

Does USCIS count an Indian three-year bachelor's and two-year master's as a U.S. master's degree?

In two AAO decisions it did not. In 2017 the AAO cited EDGE for the conclusion that an Indian master's degree equals a U.S. bachelor's degree, and in 2019 three evaluations reached the same level.

In Matter of I-V-P- Corp. (June 30, 2017) the Administrative Appeals Office wrote that, in the conclusion of EDGE, an Indian master's degree "is equivalent to a U.S. bachelor's degree." The beneficiary in that case held a postgraduate diploma, and the sentence answered the school's statement that its diploma was recognized as equivalent to an MBA. EDGE is the Electronic Database for Global Education of the American Association of Collegiate Registrars and Admissions Officers, which the decision describes as "a web-based resource for the evaluation of foreign educational credentials."

In Matter of R-LLC (May 9, 2019) the beneficiary held "a three-year bachelor of science" awarded in 2001 and "a two-year master of science in chemistry" awarded in 2004, both in India. The petitioner filed three credential evaluations, "all of which concluded that the Beneficiary's two degrees were, in combination, equivalent to a U.S. bachelor's degree in chemistry."

Both are non-precedent decisions, and each was decided on its own record.

What does EB-2 require of the degree?

A U.S. advanced degree or a foreign equivalent degree above the baccalaureate, or a U.S. bachelor's or foreign equivalent degree followed by at least five years of progressive experience in the specialty.

8 CFR 204.5(k)(2) defines the term: "Advanced degree means any United States academic or professional degree or a foreign equivalent degree above that of baccalaureate." The next sentence of the same paragraph gives the alternative: "A United States baccalaureate degree or a foreign equivalent degree followed by at least five years of progressive experience in the specialty shall be considered the equivalent of a master's degree."

The evidence is listed in paragraph (k)(3)(i). Route (A) is "An official academic record showing that the alien has a United States advanced degree or a foreign equivalent degree." Route (B) is "An official academic record showing that the alien has a United States baccalaureate degree or a foreign equivalent degree, and evidence in the form of letters from current or former employer(s) showing that the alien has at least five years of progressive post-baccalaureate experience in the specialty."

Both routes start with an official academic record of a degree: an advanced degree on route (A), a baccalaureate degree on route (B).

A holder of an Indian three-year bachelor's and two-year master's therefore argues one of two things: the master's is the foreign equivalent of a U.S. master's (route A), or the education equals a U.S. bachelor's and five years of experience followed it (route B).

What happened in Matter of R-LLC?

A pharmaceutical company petitioned for a quality control chemist with a three-year B.Sc. and a two-year M.Sc. from India. The labor certification required a master's degree, and on May 9, 2019 the AAO left the denial in place.

The petitioner, a pharmaceutical research and development company, filed Form I-140 in the EB-2 classification with a priority date of May 25, 2017. The AAO quoted the labor certification: "the minimum requirements for the proffered position are a master's degree in chemistry" or analytical chemistry, or a foreign educational equivalent, plus one year of experience in the job offered.

The Director of the Texas Service Center denied the petition because the beneficiary did not meet the minimum education requirement of the labor certification. The AAO dismissed the appeal, and the petitioner filed a motion to reopen and a motion to reconsider.

The three evaluations placed the two Indian degrees together at the level of a U.S. bachelor's degree in chemistry. They also concluded that the degrees and the beneficiary's later work experience together equalled a U.S. master's degree. The AAO answered with the text of the certification: "The labor certification does not allow for an alternate combination of education and experience."

The motion repeated an argument based on six years of study, "including a three-year bachelor's degree, a one-year postgraduate diploma, and a two-year master's degree in chemistry." The AAO wrote that "USCIS may consider such educational credentials equivalent to a U.S. masters' degree in certain circumstances, depending on the nature of the academic institutions, the quality of the coursework, and the field(s) of study of the respective credentials." The record did not hold them: "Specifically, there is no evidence that the Beneficiary has a one-year postgraduate diploma." The AAO counted five years of study, the three-year bachelor's degree and the two-year master of science, and noted that all three evaluations put that education at a U.S. bachelor's degree in chemistry, "not a U.S. master's degree." The motion to reopen was granted in part, on the employer's ability to pay the wage, and denied on education. The motion to reconsider was denied.

Why did the wording of the labor certification decide the case?

Because the beneficiary must meet the job requirements written in the labor certification as of the priority date. A certification that asks for a master's and offers no alternative leaves no room for a bachelor's equivalent plus experience.

Under 8 CFR 204.5(k)(4)(i) the job offer portion of the labor certification must show that the job requires "a professional holding an advanced degree or the equivalent or an alien of exceptional ability." The priority date under paragraph (d) "shall be the date the labor certification application was accepted for processing by any office of the Department of Labor." Both decisions cite Matter of Wing's Tea House, 16 I&N Dec. 158 (Acting Reg'l Comm'r 1977), for the rule that the beneficiary must meet the requirements of the labor certification as of that date. The 2017 decision words it this way: "a beneficiary must also have all the education, training, and experience specified on the labor certification as of the petition's priority date."

The petitioner in Matter of R-LLC relied on Chintakuntla, et al. v. USINS, No. C 99-5211 MMC (May 4, 2000), which the AAO describes as a federal district court decision recognizing that a bachelor's degree plus five years of qualifying experience is considered equivalent to a U.S. master's degree. The AAO replied: "Nothing in this decision, however, purports to modify the explicit job requirements of a labor certification."

The evaluation and the certification are read together. An evaluation that concludes "U.S. bachelor's" supports an EB-2 petition only where the certified job accepts a bachelor's degree followed by five years of experience.

Does a postgraduate diploma after the bachelor's make a master's?

Not in Matter of I-V-P- Corp. of June 30, 2017. The AAO relied on EDGE, which treats an Indian postgraduate diploma that follows a three-year bachelor's as comparable to a U.S. bachelor's degree.

A software services business petitioned for an associate director-consulting position. The labor certification required a master's degree in business administration, management, management information systems or a related field. The beneficiary held a bachelor's degree in mechanical engineering awarded in India in 2003 and a part-time postgraduate diploma in software enterprise management awarded in 2008. The Nebraska Service Center denied the petition.

Two evaluations were in the record. The first concluded that the bachelor's degree and the postgraduate diploma "together constitute the equivalent of a U.S. master's degree in business administration." The second found them "respectively equivalent to a U.S. bachelor's degree and a U.S. master's degree." Both stated that the diploma program requires a bachelor's degree for admission.

The AAO checked that statement. It quoted EDGE: "[t]he Postgraduate Diploma, following a three-year bachelor's degree, represents attainment of a level of education comparable to a bachelor's degree in the United States." It found that the program was "available to individuals with a three-year bachelor's degree" and that, according to EDGE, such a degree "is comparable to three years of university study in the United States." Its conclusion: "contrary to the two evaluations in the record, admission to the postgraduate diploma program only required the U.S. equivalent of three years of university study."

The AAO added that, by the reasoning of EDGE, the diploma "does not build upon the Beneficiary's four-year bachelor's degree but instead results in a second bachelor's degree," and dismissed the appeal.

Can the bachelor's-plus-five-years route still lead to EB-2?

The regulation provides it: a foreign equivalent of a U.S. bachelor's degree followed by at least five years of progressive experience in the specialty. The experience is counted after the degree, and the labor certification must accept this route.

Route (B) of 8 CFR 204.5(k)(3)(i) asks for "at least five years of progressive post-baccalaureate experience in the specialty," proved by letters. Paragraph (g)(1) gives their form: "Evidence relating to qualifying experience or training shall be in the form of letter(s) from current or former employer(s) or trainer(s) and shall include the name, address, and title of the writer, and a specific description of the duties performed by the alien or of the training received."

The word "post-baccalaureate" places the five years after the baccalaureate degree. Paragraph (g)(1) adds a fallback for the letters: "If such evidence is unavailable, other documentation relating to the alien's experience or training will be considered."

The end point is the priority date. The 2017 decision requires "all the education, training, and experience specified on the labor certification as of the petition's priority date." The 2019 decision did not turn on the beneficiary's years of experience: the certification accepted no alternative to a master's degree.

What about the three-year bachelor's on its own?

The AAO has cited EDGE for the view that a three-year Indian bachelor's is comparable to three years of U.S. university study. In a 2023 EB-3 case it sent the matter back so the petitioner could answer the EDGE report.

In a decision of January 12, 2023 (In Re 23661037) the beneficiary of an EB-3 professional petition held a three-year bachelor of science in electronics from India. The Director had found that the evidence did not establish "a single United States baccalaureate degree or a foreign equivalent degree that requires four (4) years of education."

The AAO quoted EDGE: the degree "comprises three years of tertiary study" and is "comparable to three years of university study in the United States." It cited Matter of Shah for the statement that "A baccalaureate degree in the United States generally requires four years of academic study."

The AAO still withdrew the Director's decision and remanded the case. On remand the Director must address the expert opinions in the record and give the petitioner the EDGE report on a three-year Indian bachelor of science degree, so that the petitioner can respond. The remand decides nothing about equivalence. It gives the petitioner the material used against the evaluation.

How much weight does a credential evaluation carry?

An evaluation is evidence that the officer weighs. In the 2017 decision the AAO wrote that it may reject an expert opinion or give it less evidentiary weight if it conflicts with evidence of record.

The 2017 decision states the rule in a footnote: "We may reject an expert opinion or afford it less evidentiary weight if it conflicts with evidence of record or 'is in any way questionable.'" The citation is Matter of Caron Int'l, Inc., 19 I&N Dec. 791, 795 (Comm'r 1988). The conflict in that case was a fact anyone could check: the AAO opened the institution's website on June 28, 2017 and read the admission requirement of the diploma program there.

The 2023 decision shows the other side of the rule. The AAO withdrew the denial because "The Director did not properly address the expert opinions provided to support this contention," the contention being that the three-year degree equalled a U.S. bachelor of science degree. It instructed: "In any future decision, the Director should sufficiently discuss these assertions and the submitted evidence."

The 2019 evaluations reached a master's level only by adding work experience to the degrees. Route (A) asks for an official academic record of an advanced degree, and experience belongs to route (B).

What should be checked in the evaluation before filing?

Five points drawn from these decisions: the level the evaluation reaches against the level the labor certification requires, each program's admission requirement, proof of every credential named, separation of education and experience, and the EDGE entry.

Each point below failed in one of the decisions described above.

  • The conclusion of the evaluation is compared with the education requirement of the labor certification: in Matter of R-LLC the evaluations reached a bachelor's level and the certification required a master's degree.
  • The admission requirement stated for each program is compared with the program's published rules: in Matter of I-V-P- Corp. the evaluations said a bachelor's degree was required, and the AAO found that a three-year bachelor's degree was enough.
  • Every credential the argument relies on is in the record with its academic record: the AAO found no evidence of the one-year postgraduate diploma named in the 2019 motion.
  • Education and experience are kept apart: an advanced degree is proved by an official academic record, and experience counts only on the five-year route.
  • The equivalency is compared with EDGE, the source the AAO consulted in 2017 and 2023, and any difference is explained by program length, admission requirement and coursework.

What does IAE check in a credential evaluation of Indian degrees?

An IAE reviewer checks the evaluation's methodology, the evaluator's authority and the weak points of the degree or experience evaluation, and gives one of three verdicts: file, revise or redo. The standard turnaround is 3 business days, rush 1.

The expert letter review covers expert letters and credential evaluations prepared by any provider. The client sends the evaluation and a short description of the petition. The secretariat confirms the fee, the turnaround and the reviewer within one business day. The reviewer is an IAE registry member in the field of the document, is independent of the provider of the document under review and confirms this in writing.

The review is page by page: every section is checked against the criteria of the visa category and the expectations of USCIS, and the credentials of the person who signed the document are assessed separately. The result is a signed review of 3-5 pages with a list of weak points, a recommendation for each and one of three verdicts with reasoning: file, revise or redo. The deadline runs after payment and receipt of all materials.

IAE is not a law firm; the wording of the labor certification and the strategy of the case are for a licensed immigration attorney. USCIS decides on the petition, and neither IAE nor the reviewer influences the decision.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert letter review

Check the letter before the officer does

The standard turnaround is 3 business days, the rush option 1 business day. The fee depends on the visa category and the volume of materials; we confirm the fee, the turnaround and the reviewer within one business day.

Review

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

DocumentExpert letter
Timeline3 business days, rush 1
VerdictFile or revise