Expert report review
Appraiser negligence: who can sue the appraiser, and what does the claim have to prove?
An appraiser can be sued by the client who ordered the report and, under the rule of some states, by a third party who relied on it. In Private Mortgage Investment Services v. Hotel & Club Associates the Fourth Circuit held in 2002 that a South Carolina appraiser could be liable to a note buyer. The claim is proved with a second appraiser's review: what a competent appraiser would have done, where the report departed and what the error cost.

Who can sue an appraiser for a negligent appraisal?
The client who hired the appraiser, under the engagement, and in some states a third party who relied on the report. Liability to third parties is often measured by Section 552 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts.
The client's claim rests on the engagement: the appraiser agreed to deliver an appraisal of a stated property, for a stated use and as of a stated date, and the client sues for the loss caused by a report that fell below the standard of the profession. The harder question is a claim by someone who never hired the appraiser: a lender, an investor buying a mortgage note, a buyer of the property.
Section 552 of the Restatement (Second) of Torts, as the Fourth Circuit quoted it, covers one who, in the course of business, supplies false information for the guidance of others in their business transactions and fails to exercise reasonable care or competence. That person is liable for pecuniary loss caused by justifiable reliance, but only to a limited group of persons for whose benefit and guidance he intends to supply the information. In Private Mortgage Investment Services the court applied that section to an appraisal.
The rule is set by each state, because liability for negligent misrepresentation is a matter of state law. Private Mortgage Investment Services reached federal court after the defendants removed it on the basis of diversity jurisdiction under 28 U.S.C. 1332, and the Fourth Circuit had to predict how the South Carolina Supreme Court would rule on a question that court had not decided.
What did the Fourth Circuit decide in Private Mortgage Investment Services v. Hotel & Club Associates?
That under South Carolina law an appraiser may be liable to a third party who justifiably relied on a negligently prepared as-is market value appraisal. The court affirmed a judgment of $28,750 after the jury split fault equally.
The property was a tract of nearly three acres in Darlington County, South Carolina, with a two-story wood frame house built around 1880. On September 5, 1997 Burley Smith, a corporate officer of the seller, Cypress Creek Enterprises, bought it for $389,000, and Cypress Creek took back a purchase-money note and mortgage of $330,650. Cypress Creek hired Hotel and Club Associates, owned by appraiser Andy Hinds, to prepare a limited appraisal to help it sell the note.
The report of September 19, 1997 put the as-is market value at $400,000 as of September 10, 1997, using the income and sales comparison approaches. It assumed use as a bed and breakfast and excluded about $50,000 of needed improvements. In November 1997 Private Mortgage Investment Services bought the note and mortgage for $200,000 plus a $12,000 broker commission, relying heavily on the appraisal and having no local expertise. Smith never paid. Private Mortgage foreclosed, bought the property for $125,000 and sold it in December 1999 for $60,000.
The South Carolina Supreme Court had not decided whether an appraiser owes such a duty, so the Fourth Circuit predicted its answer. In the opinion of July 19, 2002 (296 F.3d 308), written by Senior Circuit Judge Hamilton and joined by Judges Wilkins and Michael, the court held that South Carolina would adopt comment b to Section 552, which applies the section to information about the existence of facts and also to an opinion on facts equally well known to both sides. The court rejected the argument that the reliance was unjustified. The jury had found $57,500 in damages and equal fault, and under South Carolina's comparative fault rule the judgment was reduced to $28,750.
What does a negligence claim against an appraiser have to prove?
A duty to the plaintiff, a standard of care for the assignment, a departure from it, reliance on the report and a loss caused by the error. Each element except the duty is usually proved through another appraiser.
Duty comes first. For the client it follows from the engagement; for a third party it depends on the state's rule, such as Section 552 in Private Mortgage Investment Services. The appraisal itself often answers part of the question, because it names the client, the intended users and the intended use. A report addressed to a lender for a loan decision and a report written to help sell a note to investors name different groups of intended users.
The standard of care is the conduct of a competent appraiser in the same assignment. The plaintiff shows it with the testimony of another appraiser, who explains what such an appraiser would have checked and how. The departure is the distance between that conduct and the report: a comparable that was not comparable, an adjustment without support, an assumption that removed a known cost, as the exclusion of $50,000 of repairs did in Private Mortgage Investment Services.
Reliance and causation close the claim. The plaintiff proves that it used the appraised value in its decision and that the loss came from the difference between that value and the true value at the time, not from a later fall in the market or from its own choices. In Private Mortgage Investment Services the jury found the buyer of the note equally at fault, and the award was cut in half.
Why does the plaintiff need a reviewing appraiser?
Because the standard of care, the departure and the true value are questions of appraisal practice. A reviewing appraiser's testimony must meet Federal Rule of Evidence 702 in federal court, and similar rules apply in state courts.
A jury cannot tell from common experience whether a gross rent multiplier was chosen correctly or whether a 1880 house can be compared with a newer one. The reviewing appraiser supplies that knowledge. In federal court Rule 702, as amended effective December 1, 2023, admits the testimony if the proponent proves to the court that it is more likely than not that the expert's knowledge will help the trier of fact, that the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, that it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and that the opinion is a reliable application of those methods to the facts of the case.
These four conditions shape the review. The reviewer works from the appraisal under attack, its workfile, the market data that existed on the effective date and the records of the transaction. He applies the same methods the appraiser should have applied and explains each step, so that the court can test the review the same way the review tests the appraisal.
The review also gives the plaintiff the measure of loss. The true value as of the effective date, set by the reviewer, is the starting point for damages; without it the plaintiff can show that the appraisal was wrong but not by how much.
Can the IRS penalize an appraiser for an incorrect value?
Yes. Under 26 U.S.C. 6695A an appraiser whose appraisal leads to a substantial or gross valuation misstatement pays the lesser of 125 percent of the fee and the greater of $1,000 or 10 percent of the underpayment.
Section 6695A applies to a person who prepares an appraisal and knows, or reasonably should have known, that it will be used in a return or a claim for refund. The penalty is triggered when the value claimed on the basis of the appraisal results in a substantial valuation misstatement under chapter 1 (section 6662(e)), a substantial estate or gift tax valuation understatement (section 6662(g)) or a gross valuation misstatement (section 6662(h)).
The amount is the lesser of two figures: the greater of 10 percent of the underpayment attributable to the misstatement or $1,000, and 125 percent of the gross income the appraiser received for the appraisal. There is no penalty if the appraiser shows the Secretary that the appraised value was more likely than not the proper value.
The regulations put the penalty in front of the appraiser before the report is signed. A qualified appraisal for a charitable deduction must contain a declaration about the penalty under section 6695A and about the three-year bar on practice before the IRS under 31 U.S.C. 330(c) (26 CFR 1.170A-17(a)(3)(vi)). An appraisal fee may not be based on the appraised value (1.170A-17(a)(9)), and an appraisal by someone barred from practice before the IRS during the three years ending on the signing date is disregarded as to value (1.170A-17(a)(11)).
What damages can be recovered from an appraiser?
The loss caused by reliance on the wrong value, reduced by the plaintiff's own share of fault where the state applies comparative fault. In Private Mortgage Investment Services the jury found $57,500, and the judgment was $28,750.
The arithmetic of Private Mortgage Investment Services shows how the loss is built. The buyer paid $200,000 for the note plus a $12,000 commission, bid $125,000 at foreclosure and sold the property for $60,000. The jury did not award the whole difference between what was paid and what was recovered; it found $57,500 in damages and then split fault equally between the buyer and the appraiser.
The court of appeals accepted that the buyer's reliance was justified, noting that the report stated that the as-is value excluded the improvements and that the buyer's president testified to heavy reliance. The equal split of fault was the jury's measure of the buyer's own part in the loss. A defendant appraiser will look for the same elements: what the plaintiff knew, what it could have checked and what part of the loss came from events after the effective date.
What does the reviewing appraiser's report contain in a negligence case?
The assignment as the appraisal defined it, each departure from the standard of care with its document in the record, the value a competent appraiser would have reached on the same date, and the data behind that value.
The review starts with the assignment: client, intended users, intended use, type of value, effective date, extraordinary assumptions. These define what the appraiser undertook, and in a third-party claim they bear directly on whether the plaintiff was within the group the report was meant for.
Then the review goes through the report in its own order. For each comparable it checks the source, the date and the adjustments; for each approach, the inputs and the arithmetic; for each assumption, whether the facts known on the effective date supported it. Each finding is tied to a page of the appraisal and to a document in the record.
The last part is the reviewer's own opinion of value as of the same effective date, with the data that support it. This figure, set against the appraised value, gives the court the size of the error, and the documents of the transaction show whether the plaintiff's loss followed from it.
What does IAE do when a party claims the appraiser was negligent?
An appraiser from the IAE registry reviews the disputed appraisal under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 or writes an expert report on value as of the needed date, in up to 5 business days after format and cost are confirmed.
The IAE valuation page covers the market value of real property and the fair market value of a business or an ownership interest as of the date the case needs. A review under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 gives an opinion on the quality of another appraiser's work: comparables, adjustments, discount rate, effective date and the support for each conclusion. The reviewer recomputes the valuation step by step and writes a rebuttal report under Rule 26 or Tax Court Rule 143, with questions for the appraiser's deposition.
The client sends the appraisal or the case materials and describes the task. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The report under review, the property and the valuation date are confirmed before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, and the Member ID or QR code on the document opens the specialist's category, specialization, attestation date and record status. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- Private Mortgage Investment Services, Inc. v. Hotel and Club Associates, Inc., 296 F.3d 308 (4th Cir. 2002) (Justia)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 26 U.S.C. 6695A, Substantial and gross valuation misstatements attributable to incorrect appraisals (LII, Cornell Law School)
- 26 CFR 1.170A-17, Qualified appraisal and qualified appraiser (LII, Cornell Law School)
Read also
All articles
Partition action appraisal: how is a co-owner's share valued for a buyout, and how is the court-ordered appraisal challenged?
In a partition action one co-owner asks the court to sell or divide the property, and the others may want to buy that share. Under the partition acts
Low appraisal on a mortgage: how does a reconsideration of value work, and what evidence does the lender accept?
When an appraisal comes in below the contract price, the borrower can ask the lender for a reconsideration of value. Five federal agencies issued
Deficiency judgment after foreclosure: how is fair market value set, and how is the lender's appraisal reviewed?
After a foreclosure sale the lender's claim for the rest of the debt turns on one figure: the fair market value of the property on the sale date. NewExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

