Expert report review
Low appraisal on a mortgage: how does a reconsideration of value work, and what evidence does the lender accept?
When an appraisal comes in below the contract price, the borrower can ask the lender for a reconsideration of value. Five federal agencies issued guidance on the process in July 2024. Fannie Mae and FHA allow one borrower request per appraisal with up to five alternative comparable sales. A federal law of July 11, 2026 requires the housing agencies to set review procedures for federally backed mortgages.

What is a reconsideration of value?
A request that the lender sends the appraiser asking for a reassessment of the report, based on possible deficiencies or on information that may affect the value conclusion. The borrower starts it by raising concerns with the lender.
The Interagency Guidance on Reconsiderations of Value of Residential Real Estate Valuations was published in the Federal Register on July 26, 2024 and is final as of that date. It was issued by the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, the National Credit Union Administration and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency.
The guidance defines a reconsideration of value as "a request from the financial institution" sent "to the appraiser or other preparer of the valuation report to reassess the report," based on potential deficiencies or other information that may affect the value conclusion. The borrower does not contact the appraiser directly. The request goes through the lender.
The guidance states that it "does not have the force and effect of law or regulation" and "does not impose any new requirements on supervised institutions." The binding rules come from the investor or insurer of the loan, such as Fannie Mae or FHA, from Regulation B and from the requirements that section 704 of the 2026 federal housing act directs the agencies to implement and maintain.
When is the borrower entitled to a copy of the appraisal?
Promptly upon completion, or three business days before closing, whichever is earlier, for a first-lien loan on a dwelling under Regulation B, 12 CFR 1002.14. The lender may not charge for the copy.
Under 12 CFR 1002.14(a)(1), a creditor "shall provide an applicant a copy of all appraisals and other written valuations" developed in connection with an application for a first-lien loan secured by a dwelling, "promptly upon completion, or three business days prior to consummation of the transaction" for closed-end credit, whichever is earlier.
The applicant may waive the timing and receive the copies at or before closing. The waiver generally must be obtained at least three business days before closing, except where the only change since an earlier copy is clerical.
Under 1002.14(a)(2), the creditor sends a written notice of the right to receive copies not later than the third business day after it receives the application. Under 1002.14(a)(3), the creditor "shall not charge an applicant for providing a copy," although it may charge a reasonable fee to reimburse the cost of the appraisal itself unless other law provides otherwise. A "valuation" in the regulation is "any estimate of the value of a dwelling developed in connection with an application for credit."
The copy is the starting point for any request. Without it, the borrower cannot point to a page, a comparable or an adjustment.
What can a reconsideration request be based on?
Errors or omissions in the report, information the appraiser did not have or did not consider, such as comparable sales, and possible prohibited discrimination in the valuation.
The interagency guidance says that "a consumer may provide specific and verifiable information that may not have been available or considered" when the appraisal was prepared. It also lists "errors or omissions" among the deficiencies, and states that "collateral valuations may be deficient due to prohibited discrimination."
Errors are facts in the report that do not match the property: square footage, room count, lot size, condition, a garage or a renovation missing from the description. Omissions are data the report should have considered: a closed sale nearby with similar features, or a feature of the property that the comparables lack.
Each of these documents describes grounds as facts or data. A request that says the value is too low, without a fact or a sale, gives the lender's reviewer nothing to send to the appraiser. Fannie Mae's 2024 update requires the lender to "validate that the request from the borrower contains sufficient supporting evidence prior to sending to the appraiser."
What rules apply to a conventional loan delivered to Fannie Mae?
One borrower-initiated request per appraisal, with up to five comparable sales and their data sources. The lender reviews the appraisal first, and the appraiser returns a revised report whether or not the value changes.
Fannie Mae's Appraiser Update of June 2024 states that "for any appraisal, only one borrower-initiated ROV is permitted." The borrower may provide "up to five comparable sales (and the related data sources)." The lender's communication to the appraiser may include additional data, information or comparable properties "not to exceed the maximum of five."
The update sets the order of steps on the lender's side. Lenders "must complete their appraisal review before initiating the ROV process" and must "designate an underwriter or other appraisal subject matter expert to review any ROV requests." The lender's standardized communication to the appraiser includes the borrower's name, the property address, the effective date of the appraisal, the appraiser's name and the date of the ROV.
The appraiser's duty is stated directly: "Regardless of whether the ROV request results in a change in value or not, a revised appraisal must be provided" within the defined time frame "with a description of the points in dispute and the outcome." The borrower therefore receives a written answer to each point along with the final number.
What rules apply to an FHA-insured loan?
Under Mortgagee Letter 2024-07, as HUD explained in October 2024, one borrower request per appraisal with up to five alternative comparable sales, resolved before closing through the lender's underwriter.
HUD's questions and answers on FHA appraisal review and reconsideration of value, dated October 8, 2024, refer to Mortgagee Letter 2024-07. The document states that "only one Borrower-initiated ROV request is permitted per appraisal" and that the borrower disclosure must include "up to five alternative comparable sales for consideration."
The lender's Direct Endorsement underwriter controls the request. The lender confirms that the borrower's request complies with the general ROV requirements, the underwriter assesses the relevance and appropriateness of the information, and where a request is unclear or deficient the underwriter must remediate it with the borrower. HUD states that "the DE Underwriter is responsible for submitting the request to and communicating with the Appraiser."
FHA requires that "the resolution of the ROV must be completed prior to loan closing." The appraiser answers in a revised appraisal logged in FHA Connection, and "the last version of the appraisal logged in FHAC will be used to establish the appraised value for case processing."
What did the 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act change in 2026?
Section 704 directs USDA, VA, FHA and FHFA to require creditors of federally backed mortgages to provide a review and resolution procedure for consumers who request reconsideration of an appraised value.
The 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act, H.R. 6644, became Public Law 119-101 on July 11, 2026. Section 704, the Appraisal Modernization Act, requires the Secretary of Agriculture, the Secretary of Veterans Affairs, the Commissioner of the Federal Housing Administration and the Director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency each to implement and maintain a requirement that creditors of federally backed mortgage loans have a "review and resolution procedure for a consumer-initiated reconsideration of value or subsequent appraisal." The term federally backed mortgage loan has the meaning given in section 4022 of the CARES Act, 15 U.S.C. 9056.
The same section orders the Comptroller General to submit to Congress a report on the feasibility of a searchable, downloadable public database of appraisals, not later than 240 days after enactment, which is March 8, 2027. The banking committees of the House and the Senate must each hold a hearing on the report's findings.
Section 403 of the act amends section 202(g)(5) of the National Housing Act: an appraiser for an FHA-insured loan must "be certified or licensed by the State in which the property to be appraised is located." HUD must issue a mortgagee letter or guidance not later than 240 days after enactment, and the amendment takes effect not later than 180 days after that letter or guidance is issued.
What makes a request specific and verifiable?
Each point names a page or field of the report, states the correct fact, and gives a document or a data source for it. Each proposed comparable comes with its sale date, price, features and source.
The documents above use the same test in different words: "specific and verifiable information" in the interagency guidance, "sufficient supporting evidence" for Fannie Mae, a request that is relevant and appropriate for FHA. A request built for that test has a fixed structure.
- The request lists factual errors with the page or field of the report and the document that shows the correct fact, such as a survey, a permit or a tax record.
- The request lists features of the property that the report omitted, with photographs or invoices where the feature is a renovation.
- The request proposes no more than five comparable sales, each with address, sale date, price, size, condition and data source.
- The request explains for each proposed comparable why it is closer to the property than a comparable the appraiser used, by location, size, age or condition.
- The request identifies adjustments in the report that the borrower disputes, with the market data that supports a different adjustment.
What if the borrower believes the valuation was discriminatory?
The interagency guidance lists prohibited discrimination as a ground for a deficient valuation. A lender may handle the allegation through a separate process in addition to the reconsideration.
The guidance states that "ECOA and the FH Act prohibit discrimination on the basis of race and certain other characteristics" in residential real estate valuations. ECOA is the Equal Credit Opportunity Act and FH Act is the Fair Housing Act.
Under the guidance, an institution that receives a complaint alleging discrimination may consider, in addition to processing the reconsideration, separately initiating its own process for responding to allegations of discrimination. The guidance also notes that the appraisal regulations require appraisals in federally related transactions to conform with the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice, which include nondiscrimination requirements.
For the borrower, the factual request and the complaint are two documents. The first reaches the appraiser through the lender and argues the value with data. The second is filed with the lender's complaint process or to a regulator.
What happens if the value does not change?
Under Fannie Mae and FHA rules the borrower has used the one permitted request. The lender's own policy may provide for a second appraisal, and the interagency guidance asks institutions to state when and who pays.
Among the elements the interagency guidance lists for an institution's policy is to "establish guidelines for when a second appraisal could be ordered and who assumes the cost." The guidance does not require a second appraisal in every case.
Under FHA rules, the last version of the appraisal logged in FHA Connection sets the appraised value for case processing. Under Fannie Mae rules, the revised appraisal describes the points in dispute and the outcome, so the borrower can see which points the appraiser accepted and which were rejected and why.
The appraisal can also come back in a later dispute: a claim against the appraiser, a contract dispute between buyer and seller over a financing contingency, or a deficiency claim after foreclosure. In each of these, the revised report and the request become part of the record, and a review of the appraisal under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 tests the same comparables and adjustments again.
What does IAE do when a borrower or an attorney disputes a lender's appraisal?
An appraiser from the IAE registry reviews the appraisal under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 or writes an expert report on market value as of the needed date. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days.
The IAE valuation page covers the market value of real property as of the date the case needs. A review under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 gives an opinion on the quality of the opposing appraisal: comparables, adjustments, discount rate, effective date and the support for each conclusion. The reviewer recomputes the valuation step by step and writes a rebuttal report, with questions for the appraiser's deposition or examination.
The client sends the appraisal or the case materials and describes the task. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The report under review, the property and the valuation date are confirmed before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, and the Member ID or QR code on the document opens the specialist's category, specialization, attestation date and record status. A review is evidence that the lender, the court or the other side weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- Interagency Guidance on Reconsiderations of Value of Residential Real Estate Valuations, 89 Fed. Reg., July 26, 2024 (govinfo.gov)
- 12 CFR 1002.14, Rules on providing appraisals and other valuations (LII, Cornell Law School)
- Fannie Mae, Appraiser Update, June 2024
- HUD, FHA Appraisal Review and Reconsideration of Value (ROV) Updates, Webinar Questions and Answers, 10/8/2024
- Public Law 119-101, 21st Century ROAD to Housing Act, July 11, 2026, sections 403 and 704 (govinfo.gov)
Read also
All articles
Partition action appraisal: how is a co-owner's share valued for a buyout, and how is the court-ordered appraisal challenged?
In a partition action one co-owner asks the court to sell or divide the property, and the others may want to buy that share. Under the partition acts
Deficiency judgment after foreclosure: how is fair market value set, and how is the lender's appraisal reviewed?
After a foreclosure sale the lender's claim for the rest of the debt turns on one figure: the fair market value of the property on the sale date. New
Appraiser negligence: who can sue the appraiser, and what does the claim have to prove?
An appraiser can be sued by the client who ordered the report and, under the rule of some states, by a third party who relied on it. In PrivateExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

