Expert report review
Deficiency judgment after foreclosure: how is fair market value set, and how is the lender's appraisal reviewed?
After a foreclosure sale the lender's claim for the rest of the debt turns on one figure: the fair market value of the property on the sale date. New York's RPAPL 1371 subtracts the higher of that value or the sale price from the debt, and California's CCP 580a caps the deficiency at the debt minus fair market value found by the court. The lender's appraisal sets the starting point, and a review tests it.

Why does fair market value decide the deficiency?
Because these statutes measure the deficiency against market value as well as the bid. New York deducts the higher of fair market value or the sale price; California caps the deficiency at debt minus fair market value.
A foreclosure auction often ends with the lender bidding in the property for less than the debt. If the deficiency were the debt minus the bid, a low bid would leave the borrower owing more and the lender holding the property. The New York and California statutes break that link by tying the deficiency to the property's market value.
Under section 1371 of New York's Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law the deficiency equals the debt with interest, prior liens with interest and the costs and disbursements, including the referee's fee, minus the higher of the market value the court determines or the sale price. Under section 580a of California's Code of Civil Procedure a judgment after a trustee's sale cannot exceed the amount by which the total debt exceeded the fair market value of the property at the time of sale, with interest from that date.
In both states the market value is therefore the contested number. Each dollar the court adds to it comes off the deficiency, and the appraisal on which the lender relies is the main evidence of what that number is.
How does New York set the value under RPAPL 1371?
On a motion made within 90 days after the deed is delivered, the court determines the fair and reasonable market value as of the date the property was bid in at auction, upon affidavit or as it directs.
Section 1371 requires the party seeking a deficiency to move within 90 days after the sale is consummated by delivery of the proper deed of conveyance to the purchaser, and the motion is made together with the motion to confirm the sale. Notice goes to the party against whom judgment is sought, served personally or as the court directs.
The court then determines the fair and reasonable market value of the mortgaged premises as of the date they were bid in at auction, or as of the nearest earlier date on which there was a market value. It decides upon affidavit or otherwise as it directs. The deficiency judgment runs only against a person liable for the debt who was made a defendant and either appeared or was personally served.
The deadline cuts both ways. If no motion is made as the section prescribes, the proceeds of the sale are deemed to be in full satisfaction of the mortgage debt, and no right to recover a deficiency exists. A lender that misses the 90 days loses the deficiency, and a borrower who answers the motion has the same short window to put a competing value before the court.
What evidence of value did the court accept in TrustCo Bank v. DeCaro?
A real estate broker's appraisal based on comparable sales and adjusted for the market decline, updated after an interior inspection. The defendant offered no convincing evidence, and the Third Department affirmed a value of $160,000 in 2011.
In TrustCo Bank v. DeCaro, decided by the Appellate Division, Third Department, on January 27, 2011, the bank had the burden of establishing the value of the property as of the foreclosure sale. It submitted an appraisal by a real estate broker who valued the property at $145,000 to $150,000 as of June 2008. She based the figure on an exterior inspection and on sales of similar nearby properties, and she adjusted for declines in the housing market after the sale.
Before the hearing the broker inspected the interior and, taking further market decline into account, put the value at a little less than $130,000. The defendant offered no convincing evidence of a different value. The appellate court held that the bank's evidence, against the defendant's failure to rebut it, amply supported the trial court's finding of $160,000 as the value on the foreclosure date, and it affirmed a deficiency judgment of $39,635.19.
The case shows the weak points a review looks for and the price of not raising them. The first appraisal rested on an exterior inspection; the value moved after the interior was seen; the adjustments for market decline were the appraiser's own. A borrower with a review that tested each of these would have had evidence to set against the bank's. The borrower in TrustCo had none.
How does California set the value under CCP 580a?
The court must find the fair market value at the time of sale. On either party's application at least 10 days before trial, it appoints a probate referee to appraise the property; the referee may be examined.
Section 580a applies to a money judgment for the balance of a debt secured by a deed of trust or mortgage with a power of sale, after the power has been exercised. The complaint states the total debt at the time of sale, the sale price, the fair market value on the sale date and the date of sale, and the action must be brought within three months of the time of sale.
On the application of either party made at least 10 days before trial, the court appoints a probate referee to appraise the property as of the time of sale; the court may also appoint one on its own motion at any time. The referee files the appraisal with the clerk, takes an oath, and may be called and examined as a witness by any party or by the court. The appraisal is admissible in evidence, and the referee's reasonable compensation may be taxed as costs.
Before rendering any judgment, the court finds the fair market value at the time of sale. The judgment may not exceed the debt minus that value, plus interest from the sale date, and in no event may it exceed the difference between the sale price and the total debt. A party that disagrees with the referee's figure has a witness to examine and a report to answer, which is the task of a review.
What happens when the sale price is far below the appraised value?
The court determines fair market value on evidence. In a 1989 Montana case where the $565,000 bid was about 30 percent of the appraised value, the Supreme Court remanded for a finding of value at the sheriff's sale.
In Trustees of the Washington-Idaho-Montana Carpenters-Employers Retirement Trust Fund v. Galleria Partnership, decided on September 20, 1989 by the Supreme Court of Montana, No. 89-29, the court upheld the deficiency judgment against the partnership but sent the case back. The bid at the sheriff's sale was $565,000, about 30 percent of the property's appraised value, and the court required the district court to determine the fair market value at the time of that sale, because that figure would set the amount of the deficiency.
A gap of that size is why the court in Galleria looked past the bid. The appraisal that produced the higher figure, and any appraisal the lender offers for a lower one, are then compared on the same date, the same property and the same market.
What does a review of the lender's appraisal check?
The effective date against the auction date, the inspection the appraiser made, the comparable sales and the adjustments for time and condition, and whether the report supports each figure with data from the market at the sale date.
Date comes first. RPAPL 1371 fixes the value as of the date the property was bid in at auction, and CCP 580a as of the time of sale. An appraisal with another effective date answers a different question; in TrustCo the broker adjusted for market decline after the sale, which is exactly the step a review has to trace and test.
Then the inspection. An exterior inspection leaves the condition of the interior to assumption, and in TrustCo the value fell after the interior was seen. A review notes whether the appraiser entered the property, what condition was assumed and what records, such as photographs, repair estimates or the referee's notes, show the actual condition on the sale date.
Then the comparables and adjustments. For each sale the review checks the date, the distance, the size and condition and whether it was itself a distressed sale. Adjustments for falling or rising prices between the comparable sale and the auction date are checked against the data the appraiser cites. Each departure is listed with its effect on the value, so the court can see how far the figure moves if the point is accepted.
Who has to prove the value, and when should the borrower's evidence be ready?
The lender establishes the value, as the bank did in TrustCo, but a silent borrower leaves the lender's figure unchallenged. The evidence must be ready within the 90-day or 10-days-before-trial windows.
In TrustCo the bank had the burden of establishing the value at the foreclosure sale, and it carried the burden because the defendant offered no convincing evidence against its appraisal. A burden on the lender does not protect a borrower who stays silent: the court decides on the evidence before it.
The timing is short. In New York the lender's motion comes within 90 days after the deed is delivered, together with the motion to confirm the sale, and the court decides on affidavits unless it directs otherwise. In California a party who wants a probate referee's appraisal applies at least 10 days before trial. A review that takes weeks to commission after the motion is served may arrive after the court has ruled.
What does IAE do when a deficiency depends on the lender's appraisal?
An appraiser from the IAE registry reviews the lender's appraisal under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 or writes an expert report on market value as of the sale date. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days.
The IAE valuation page covers the market value of real property as of the date the case needs. A review under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 gives an opinion on the quality of the opposing appraisal: comparables, adjustments, discount rate, effective date and the support for each conclusion. The reviewer recomputes the valuation step by step and writes a rebuttal report, with questions for the appraiser's deposition or examination.
The client sends the appraisal or the case materials and describes the task. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The report under review, the property and the valuation date are confirmed before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, and the Member ID or QR code on the document opens the specialist's category, specialization, attestation date and record status. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- New York Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law section 1371, Deficiency judgment (New York State Senate)
- California Code of Civil Procedure section 580a (California Public Law)
- TrustCo Bank v. DeCaro, 80 AD3d 1094, 2011 NY Slip Op 00452 (App. Div. 3d Dept., January 27, 2011) (New York State Law Reporting Bureau)
- Trustees of the Washington-Idaho-Montana Carpenters-Employers Retirement Trust Fund v. Galleria Partnership, No. 89-29 (Mont. 1989) (Justia)
Read also
All articles
Partition action appraisal: how is a co-owner's share valued for a buyout, and how is the court-ordered appraisal challenged?
In a partition action one co-owner asks the court to sell or divide the property, and the others may want to buy that share. Under the partition acts
Low appraisal on a mortgage: how does a reconsideration of value work, and what evidence does the lender accept?
When an appraisal comes in below the contract price, the borrower can ask the lender for a reconsideration of value. Five federal agencies issued
Appraiser negligence: who can sue the appraiser, and what does the claim have to prove?
An appraiser can be sued by the client who ordered the report and, under the rule of some states, by a third party who relied on it. In PrivateExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

