For employers

Are personality tests legal in hiring, and when does the ADA treat a personality test as a medical examination?

The ADA bars medical examinations of job applicants before a conditional offer, and a psychological test that can identify a mental disorder is a medical examination. That is the line the EEOC drew in its 1995 guidance and the Seventh Circuit applied in Karraker v. Rent-A-Center (2005) to the MMPI. A test that measures only traits such as honesty, tastes and habits is not medical, but it still falls under the anti-discrimination rules for tests.

A candidate from behind fills a blurred bubble sheet while a medical chart sits unused aside

What does the ADA say about medical examinations before a job offer?

Before an offer, an employer shall not conduct a medical examination or ask whether an applicant has a disability, but may ask about the applicant's ability to perform job-related functions. After a conditional offer, examinations are allowed on conditions.

Under 42 U.S.C. 12112(d)(1), the ADA's ban on discrimination "shall include medical examinations and inquiries." Under (d)(2)(A), a covered entity "shall not conduct a medical examination or make inquiries of a job applicant" as to whether the applicant has a disability or about its nature or severity. Under (d)(2)(B), it "may make preemployment inquiries into the ability of an applicant to perform job-related functions."

The EEOC regulation repeats the permission. Under 29 CFR 1630.14(a), a covered entity "may make pre-employment inquiries into the ability of an applicant to perform job-related functions" and may ask the applicant to describe or show how the applicant will perform them, with or without reasonable accommodation.

After an offer, the rules change. Under 12112(d)(3) an employer may require a medical examination after an offer and before work begins. Section 1630.14(b) puts it this way: an employer may require a medical examination "after making an offer of employment to a job applicant and before the applicant begins" work and may condition the offer on the results, "if all entering employees in the same job category are subjected to such an examination." The results are kept "on separate forms and in separate medical files" and treated as confidential, with disclosure only to supervisors for necessary restrictions, to first aid and safety personnel and to government officials investigating compliance.

For current employees, 12112(d)(4)(A) and 1630.14(c) allow medical examinations and inquiries only when they are "job-related and consistent with business necessity."

When is a psychological test a medical examination?

When it provides evidence that would lead to identifying a mental disorder. The EEOC's 1995 guidance treats tests that measure only honesty, tastes and habits as non-medical, and lists eight factors for deciding whether any test is medical.

The EEOC's "Enforcement Guidance: Preemployment Disability-Related Questions and Medical Examinations" is dated October 10, 1995. It defines a medical examination as "a procedure or test that seeks information about an individual's physical or mental impairments or health."

The guidance lists eight factors. Is the employer trying to determine the applicant's physical or mental health or impairments? Is the test administered by a health care professional or someone trained by one? Are the results interpreted by such a person? Is it designed to reveal an impairment or physical or mental health? Is it invasive, for example requiring blood, urine or breath? Does it measure physiological responses to performing a task? Is it normally given in a medical setting? Is medical equipment used? No single factor is always decisive, and in some cases one factor is enough.

On psychological tests the guidance draws the line in two sentences. "Psychological examinations are medical if they provide evidence that would lead to identifying a mental disorder." And "if a test is designed and used to measure only things such as honesty, tastes, and habits, it is not medical."

A notice on the EEOC page states that the document "was issued prior to enactment of the Americans with Disabilities Act Amendments Act of 2008." Its definitions of medical examinations are the ones the court relied on in Karraker in 2005.

What did the court decide in Karraker v. Rent-A-Center?

On June 14, 2005, the Seventh Circuit held that the MMPI, used in a promotion test battery, is an ADA medical examination because it is designed, at least in part, to reveal mental illness.

Rent-A-Center required employees who sought promotion to upper-level positions to take the APT Management Trainee-Executive Profile. The battery had nine tests measuring math and language skills, interests and personality traits, including 502 questions from the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI). All parts were scored together, and a candidate with more than 12 "weighted deviations" was not considered for promotion.

Judge Evans wrote for a panel with Chief Judge Flaum and Judge Williams. The court held that the MMPI is "designed, at least in part, to reveal mental illness," so its use was a medical examination and violated the ADA. High scores could cost candidates promotions, and that consequence falls on employees with mental disabilities.

The court quoted the EEOC factors, including the statement that "[O]ne factor may be enough to determine that a procedure or test is medical," and noted that psychological tests "designed to identify a mental disorder or impairment" are medical examinations, while tests "that measure personality traits such as honesty, preferences, and habits" are not. It also noted that the EEOC guidance is not controlling.

The disposition was mixed. The court affirmed the judgment on one plaintiff's untimely failure-to-promote claim and on a claim of public disclosure of private facts, and reversed and remanded on the ADA claim "so that summary judgment can be entered in favor of plaintiffs."

Does scoring a clinical test for job traits make it non-medical?

Not under Karraker. The district court found that Rent-A-Center scored the MMPI on a vocational protocol; the Seventh Circuit found the practical effect similar however the test was used or scored.

The district court found that Rent-A-Center used a vocational scoring protocol for the MMPI. The Seventh Circuit did not treat that as decisive: it found that the practical effect of the test was similar regardless of how it was used or scored.

The EEOC factors explain why. One factor asks whether the test is "designed to reveal an impairment or physical or mental health," and one factor may be enough. A clinical instrument keeps its design whatever scoring key the employer chooses.

For an employer the practical test is the instrument itself. A questionnaire written to measure work habits or preferences differs from a clinical inventory that a vendor has relabeled for hiring. The employer reads the vendor's documentation on what the instrument was designed to measure before it uses the test before an offer.

Do the same rules apply to promotion tests for current employees?

The ADA restricts medical examinations of current employees to those that are job related and consistent with business necessity. In Karraker the parties agreed that tests required for new positions counted as pre-employment for ADA purposes.

Under 12112(d)(4)(A), an employer may not require a medical examination of an employee or ask whether the employee has a disability "unless such examination or inquiry is shown to be job-related and consistent with business necessity." Section 1630.14(c) states the same rule.

The plaintiffs in Karraker were current employees seeking promotion, not outside applicants. According to the opinion, the parties agreed that the tests counted as pre-employment for ADA purposes because they were required for new positions. The court applied the pre-employment rule and found that the MMPI in the promotion battery violated the ADA.

Can a personality inventory be given after a conditional offer?

A medical examination may be required after an offer and before work begins if every entering employee in the same job category takes it and the results are kept confidential in separate medical files.

The EEOC guidance states that after a conditional offer, an employer may ask disability-related questions and require medical examinations, and that at this stage they "do not have to be related to the job." The condition is uniformity: "all entering employees in the same job category must be subjected to the examination/inquiry."

Under 1630.14(b), information obtained is collected "on separate forms and in separate medical files" and treated as a confidential medical record. Supervisors and managers may be informed only of necessary restrictions and accommodations; first aid and safety personnel may be told when a disability might require emergency treatment; government officials investigating compliance receive the information on request.

The timing rule does not remove the discrimination rule. An employer that withdraws an offer on the basis of a post-offer examination still answers to 12112(b)(6) if the criterion it applies screens out people with disabilities.

Can a personality test that is not medical still be unlawful?

Yes, if it screens out a protected group and the employer cannot show it is job related and consistent with business necessity. Under 12112(b)(6) the ADA applies the same standard to tests that screen out people with disabilities.

Under 42 U.S.C. 12112(b)(6), discrimination includes using qualification standards, employment tests or other selection criteria that "screen out or tend to screen out" an individual with a disability or a class of such individuals, unless the standard or test is shown to be job related for the position and consistent with business necessity.

The EEOC fact sheet describes the parallel rule under Title VII: disparate impact arises when an employer uses "neutral tests or selection procedures that have the effect of disproportionately excluding persons" in a protected group. The employer then shows job relatedness and business necessity, and the challenger may show an equally effective, less discriminatory alternative.

The EEOC's best practices for any test apply to personality inventories as well: administer them without regard to protected characteristics, validate them for the specific jobs and purposes, keep them current, and understand their effectiveness and limits before use. An employer that buys a vendor's test remains responsible for its validity, even when the vendor supplies documentation.

Does the ADA require accommodations for personality and skills tests?

Yes. Under 12112(b)(7) tests are given so that impaired sensory, manual or speaking skills do not distort the result, unless those skills are what the test measures. Employers may ask about accommodation needs.

Section 12112(b)(7) counts as discrimination "failing to select and administer tests" so that, when a test is given to a person with impaired sensory, manual or speaking skills, the results measure the skills or aptitude the test is meant to measure and not the impairment, except where the impaired skills are the factors the test measures.

Under the EEOC's 1995 guidance employers may ask applicants whether they "will need a reasonable accommodation for this process," such as an interview or a timed test. If an applicant asks for an accommodation for showing a job task, the employer either provides a reasonable accommodation that does not create an undue hardship or lets the applicant describe how the applicant would perform the function.

Each request is decided against the skill the test measures: a time limit that is part of the skill differs from a time limit that only adds pressure.

How does a test of job skills differ from a personality inventory under these rules?

A test in which the candidate shows how they perform job-related functions fits the permission in 12112(d)(2)(B) and 1630.14(a). A personality inventory first faces the medical examination question.

The ADA permits pre-offer inquiries into an applicant's ability to perform job-related functions, and 1630.14(a) lets the employer ask the applicant to describe or show how the applicant will perform them. The EEOC guidance treats as non-medical an agility test in which the applicant performs "actual or simulated job tasks."

A written test of job knowledge and job tasks sits on the same side of the line: its questions concern the work, not the candidate's health. It still has to meet the Title VII and ADA rules on screening out and on accommodation.

A personality inventory raises an additional question about its design. If it was built to measure only traits such as honesty, tastes and habits, it is not medical under the guidance; if it can identify a mental disorder, it cannot be given before an offer.

What does the IAE written exam measure, and what does the company see?

The IAE exam is an online written exam of up to 2 hours in the employee's field: 8 tasks scored against the field rubric, one of them about the employee's own project. The company sees scores.

Each of the 8 tasks has its own timer: 10 minutes per question and 25 minutes per case, taken in one sitting. Answers are typed in the exam form with pasting disabled, the system records how each answer was typed, and each candidate receives their own figures and circumstances in the cases. One question concerns a project from the candidate's questionnaire: the decisions taken, the figures and the outcome.

Answers are scored against the rubric of the field, and an examiner with no ties to the employee or the company approves the result within 5 business days. Only the IAE Secretariat sees the questionnaire on experience, education and the project. The company sees in its cabinet the status, the total score, the rubric criterion scores for each task and the certificate PDF if the exam is passed; it does not see the questionnaire, the CV or the reason for refusal.

A company registers through the page for employers and receives a link to the company cabinet within one business day, with no calls or meetings. In the pilot, companies that register by December 31, 2026 test up to 5 employees free of charge. The exam program and terms are published, and under the EEOC's guidance the employer remains responsible for how it uses any test in its own selection process.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Pilot until December 31, 2026

Register your company

Free for up to 5 people. A link to the company cabinet arrives by email within one business day.

Company registration

Received

Cabinet link within one business day

Employees5
FieldSoftware and data
Pilotuntil Dec 31, 2026