Examinations
How do you authenticate social media posts for court, and what does a forensic examiner add when the account is disputed?
A printout of a social media page proves that the page existed. It does not prove who wrote the post. In 2014 the Second Circuit vacated a conviction because the government offered a VK profile with the defendant's name and photo and nothing to show he created it. Courts ask for evidence linking the account to the person: testimony, device data, platform records or the content itself.

What does a party have to show to authenticate a social media post?
Evidence sufficient to support a finding that the post is what the party claims it is. When the claim is that a named person wrote it, the evidence must connect that person to the account and the post.
Rule 901(a) says the proponent "must produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is." The rule does not list social media. It applies to a Facebook post the same way it applies to a letter or a photograph.
The claim decides what must be proven. If a party offers a screenshot to show that a page said something on a date, the person who saw and captured it can testify to that. If the party offers the post to show that the opposing party wrote it, the evidence has to reach authorship.
In United States v. Zhyltsou the Second Circuit repeated that "the bar for authentication of evidence is not particularly high." In the same opinion, the low bar still had to be cleared with evidence about the person, in addition to evidence about the page.
What happened in United States v. Zhyltsou?
The government offered a printout of a VK profile in the defendant's name with his photo. The Second Circuit held there was no evidence he created the page or was responsible for its contents, and ordered a new trial.
Zhyltsou was charged with transferring a false birth certificate. The disputed fact was whether he sent it from an address azmadeuz@gmail.com. A cooperating witness said he did. Near the end of the government's case, a special agent testified about a printout from VK.com, which he called "the Russian equivalent of Facebook." The page showed the defendant's photo, the name "Alexander Zhiltsov" and a Skype name "Azmadeuz."
The agent did not know who created the page. The court held that "there was no evidence that Zhyltsou himself had created the page or was responsible for its contents." It compared the page with a flyer bearing his Skype address, for which the district court "surely would have required some evidence that the flyer did, in fact, emanate from Zhyltsou."
The error was not harmless: the page was the main corroboration on the only disputed point, and the cooperating witness's credibility was weak. The Second Circuit vacated the conviction and remanded for retrial, and it expressed no view on what evidence would have sufficed.
Why do courts worry that a social media account may be fake?
Because anyone can open an account in another person's name, with that person's photo and details. The Maryland Court of Appeals in Griffin v. State held that a photo, a birth date and a location were not enough.
In Griffin v. State, decided on April 28, 2011, the State offered a MySpace profile under the name "Sistasouljah" to show that the defendant's girlfriend threatened a witness. The page carried a photo, a birth date, the town of Port Deposit and the post "JUST REMEMBER SNITCHES GET STITCHES!!" The lead investigator recognized her in the photo. Asked how he knew she sent the post, he answered: "I can't say that."
The court held the pages were not authenticated under Maryland Rule 5-901 and ordered a new trial. It quoted the observation that "anyone can create a fictitious account and masquerade under another person's name" and wrote that a printout from such a site "requires a greater degree of authentication" than the State offered.
The court also listed ways to meet the standard: ask the purported creator whether she created the profile and added the posting, search the computer of the person who allegedly created the profile, and "obtain information directly from the social networking website that links the establishment of the profile" to the person.
Who decides whether the post is authentic, the judge or the jury?
Both, in turn. The judge decides whether there is proof from which a reasonable juror could find the post is what the proponent claims. The jury then decides whether it is.
Four years after Griffin, the same court in Sublet v. State adopted the reasonable juror test from the same Second Circuit appeal, which Sublet cites by its caption, United States v. Vayner (Semyon Vayner was a co-defendant; Zhyltsou was the appellant). The trial judge "must determine that there is proof from which a reasonable juror could find" that the evidence is what the proponent claims it to be.
In the three consolidated cases the court affirmed the exclusion of a four-page Facebook exhibit in Sublet and upheld the admission of Twitter messages in Harris and Facebook messages in Monge-Martinez. The rule did not change between them; the evidence linking each account to the person did.
Once the judge admits the post, the other side can still argue to the jury that someone else wrote it. Authentication is a threshold, and the weight of the post is argued at trial.
Can the content of a post authenticate it?
Yes, together with the circumstances. Rule 901(b)(4) permits authentication by appearance, contents, substance, internal patterns or other distinctive characteristics, taken together with all the circumstances.
Content works when the post contains facts few people would know: a reply to a private message, details of a meeting only the parties attended, a photo taken on the author's phone. In Griffin the State relied on the photo, the birth date and the town, and the court found them insufficient.
Rule 901(b)(1) also permits testimony of a witness with knowledge "that an item is what it is claimed to be." A recipient who exchanged messages with the account and then met the person can testify about that history.
A linguist can compare the writing in the posts with known writing of a candidate author, and Rule 901(b)(3) permits comparison with an authenticated specimen by an expert witness.
Can a party get account records from the platform in a civil case?
Records pertaining to a subscriber, other than the contents of communications, may be disclosed to a person other than a governmental entity. The contents of communications are protected by the Stored Communications Act, with exceptions such as consent.
Under 18 U.S.C. 2702(a)(1) a provider of an electronic communication service to the public "shall not knowingly divulge to any person or entity the contents of a communication while in electronic storage." Subsection (b)(3) permits disclosure "with the lawful consent of the originator or an addressee or intended recipient of such communication."
Non-content records follow a different rule. Section 2702(c)(6) permits a provider to disclose a record or other information pertaining to a subscriber "to any person other than a governmental entity." The introduction to subsection (c) excludes "the contents of communications covered by subsection (a)(1) or (a)(2)."
The statute permits these disclosures; it does not compel them. In Griffin the court named information obtained "directly from the social networking website that links the establishment of the profile" to the person as one way to authenticate a page.
Does Rule 902(14) make a social media capture self-authenticating?
It can make a copy self-authenticating as an exact duplicate, through a certification of a hash value. It does not prove who placed the content on the account.
Rule 902(14) covers "Data copied from an electronic device, storage medium, or file" authenticated by a process of digital identification, as shown by a certification of a qualified person. The proponent must give reasonable written notice before trial and make the record and certification available for inspection.
The 2017 committee note says that identical hash values for the original and copy "reliably attest to the fact that they are exact duplicates." It adds that a certification "can only establish that the proffered item is authentic," and that the opposing party can still challenge whether the information was placed there by the defendant.
The note to Rule 902(13) uses a defamation example: the defendant "remains free to object that the statement on the webpage was not placed there by defendant." A certified capture of a post settles what the page showed. Authorship remains a separate question.
What does a forensic examiner add when the account is disputed?
Evidence from devices and records that ties the account to a person or rules the person out: logins, app data, files and images on a phone or computer, and the platform's records compared with that device data.
On the alleged author's phone or computer, the examiner looks for the app and its account, the cached posts, the images that appear in the posts with their original metadata, and the browser history of visits to the account. Griffin named a search of the computer and its internet history as one way to authenticate.
The platform's records give login times and IP addresses. The examiner compares them with the network logs of the home or office the person used and with location data on the device. A match supports authorship; logins from places the person never was point the other way.
The examiner also checks the capture itself: whether the screenshot or export shows the account identifier, the full post with its date and the page address, and whether a forensic capture with a hash value exists. Each conclusion is tested under Rule 702 on the facts or data the examiner used.
How should a post be captured before it is deleted?
With a capture that records the page address, the account identifier, the date and time, the whole post with its comments, and a hash value of the saved file, made by a person who can testify to the process.
A screenshot made on a phone records only what was on the screen. It may omit the account identifier, the full date and the comments, and it carries no proof that it was not edited afterward. A capture that saves the page source and the media files keeps more of the record.
The person making the capture writes down what was done: the device, the browser and its version, the time zone, the steps taken to reach the page. That person is the Rule 901(b)(1) witness for the capture.
If the post may be deleted, the party also sends a preservation request to the other side. The platform's records about the account, obtained later, show who logged in when the post went up.
What should a client send to an examiner about a disputed post?
The captures and their source files, the account address, the dates of the disputed posts, any platform records already obtained and, where available, the devices or forensic images of the devices of the alleged author.
The client describes the task in writing: whether the account belongs to a named person, whether that person posted a given item, whether a capture is complete and unaltered. The questions decide which data the examiner needs.
If the devices are in the other side's possession, the client's attorney decides whether to seek an inspection under the rules of discovery. The examiner can describe what data would answer each question, so the request is specific.
Captures made by different people at different times are sent separately, each with a note on who made it and how.
What does IAE do when the authorship of a social media post is disputed?
IAE prepares a digital forensics expert report on the client's questions: whether a capture matches the source, who logged in to an account, what a device stored. The signed PDF follows in up to 5 business days.
The examiner answers what a device stored and who logged in, from event logs and browser history, and compares a copy with the original by hash value. IAE frames the questions by the device, the application and the event the case needs to establish, and confirms the questions, the devices and how the data reach the examiner before work starts.
The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. IAE then confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, depending on the volume of data; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; whether to subpoena the platform or seek an inspection is a question for the client's attorney. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the examiner guarantees the outcome.
Sources
- United States v. Zhyltsou, No. 13-803-cr (2d Cir. Oct. 3, 2014) (Justia, PDF)
- Griffin v. State, No. 74, Sept. Term 2010 (Md. Apr. 28, 2011) (Maryland Judiciary, PDF)
- Sublet v. State, Nos. 42, 59, 60, Sept. Term 2014 (Md. Apr. 23, 2015) (Maryland Judiciary, PDF)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 901, Authenticating or Identifying Evidence (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 902, Evidence That Is Self-Authenticating, with Committee Notes (LII)
- 18 U.S.C. 2702, Voluntary disclosure of customer communications or records (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with Committee Notes (LII)
Read also
All articles
Electronic signature disputed: how do you prove who signed, and what does a forensic examiner check?
An electronic signature has legal effect, but the party that relies on it must show that it was the act of the person named. In Fabian v. Renovate
Spyware on a phone: how does a forensic examiner find it, and what can the evidence be used for?
A forensic examination for spyware establishes whether a monitoring app is on the phone, when it appeared, what it collected and where it sent
Forensic image authentication: how does an examiner show that a photo was edited?
A photograph offered in federal court must be shown to be what the party claims it is, under Rule 901(a) of the Federal Rules of Evidence. WhenExpert examinations
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

