Expert witnesses
Biomechanical expert witness: impact forces and the line at medical causation
A biomechanical expert witness applies engineering mechanics to the human body: how large the forces in a crash or fall were, which way they acted, and how the occupant moved. Federal courts in Louisiana and Ohio and the Sixth Circuit have let the engineer testify about those forces and stopped the testimony at medical causation. In Collins v. Benton the court wrote that "a biomechanical engineer is not qualified to provide medical causation testimony."

What does a biomechanical expert witness do?
The engineer estimates the forces and accelerations a body experienced in a crash or fall and explains how those forces act on a human body, using vehicle damage, crash data and published studies.
On August 9, 2017, Wayland Collins was exiting Interstate 10 onto Interstate 510 in Louisiana when his vehicle collided with an 18-wheeler. In the suit that followed, Collins v. Benton, the defendants relied on the report of Dr. Baratta, a biomechanical engineer. He prepared an "injury causation analysis" and a "traffic accident reconstruction," classified the collision as a sideswipe, and calculated "the forces and accelerations exerted on the plaintiffs' bodies." He compared the force on the plaintiffs' spines with "plopping into an office chair, bending over, running, or lifting a small child" and concluded that any structural damage or aggravation was "unlikely a result of the subject accident."
Both sides use these experts. In Parker v. NGM Insurance Co. (E.D. La. 2016), a rear-end collision case, the defendants retained the biomechanical expert Dr. Charles Bain and the plaintiffs retained Dr. David Barczyk as a rebuttal biomechanical expert.
Baratta's file shows the usual inputs: the crash report, more than 80 photographs of the vehicles, dimensional data, deposition transcripts, medical records, repair estimates, body camera footage, an inspection of the plaintiffs' vehicle by an associate after it had been repaired, and about 40 peer-reviewed biomechanical studies.
When the vehicle has an event data recorder, 49 CFR 563.7 requires it to record the longitudinal change in velocity (delta-V) for 0-250 ms after time zero, or until the end of the event plus 30 ms if that is shorter, at 100 samples per second, along with the maximum delta-V and the time it was reached. Vehicle speed, accelerator position and service brake status are recorded for the 20 seconds before the event; vehicles manufactured before September 1, 2031 may, subject to a phase-in that starts on September 1, 2028, record 5 seconds at 2 samples per second. Lateral delta-V is recorded only if the recorder captures it. How a reconstructionist reads those data is covered in the article on accident reconstruction experts.
Can a biomechanical engineer testify that the crash caused the injury?
In Collins, Smelser and Snyder, no. The courts let the engineer describe the forces and their general effect on a human body and left the opinion that this collision caused this plaintiff's injury to a physician.
In Collins, Chief Judge Nannette Jolivette Brown ruled on the plaintiffs' Daubert motion on July 2, 2020. Baratta may testify about "the amount of force he believes was generated" by the collision and "the observed effect of such force on a hypothetical human body in a comparable accident." He "may not testify as to whether the subject collision in fact caused Plaintiffs' injuries" because he is not a medical expert. The court cited Thomas v. Chambers (E.D. La. 2019), Collett v. GEICO Casualty Co. (E.D. La. 2017) and Baxter v. Anderson (M.D. La. 2017) and held that "a biomechanical engineer is not qualified to provide medical causation testimony." The motion was granted to that extent and denied in all other respects.
The Sixth Circuit drew the same line in Smelser v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co. (decided January 27, 1997). Claude Smelser was injured on August 29, 1989, when the company pickup he was driving to a job site was rear-ended by another motorist, who, the opinion says, was "traveling at approximately 45 m.p.h." He sued his employer under the Federal Employers' Liability Act and claimed that a defective shoulder belt caused his back injuries. Biomechanical engineer Ronald Huston testified that the belt, not the collision, caused them. The jury awarded $3.5 million, and the trial court remitted the judgment to $1,668,000. The Sixth Circuit wrote that "Huston is not a medical doctor who had reviewed Smelser's complete medical history" and that "his expertise in biomechanics did not qualify him to testify about the cause of Smelser's specific injuries." It reversed and remanded for entry of judgment as a matter of law for Norfolk Southern.
In Snyder v. Harrington (N.D. Ohio, November 15, 2010), Chief Judge Solomon Oliver, Jr. applied Smelser to an accident reconstructionist with training in biomechanics and kinematics in a rear-impact case. He may testify about "the significance of the force magnitudes, force directions, and vehicle speeds during a collision," about "general risk factors that a person of Plaintiff's makeup can experience during a collision similar to the incident at issue," and about the "potential mechanism of injury." He "cannot provide his opinion on the cause, existence, or extent of Plaintiff's injuries."
Do state courts draw the same line?
Not always. Delaware admits a biomechanical opinion on whether this plaintiff could have been hurt if it ties the general response of the body to that person; a Vermont court barred injury-likelihood testimony from a reconstructionist.
In Lee v. Holbrook the Delaware Superior Court (Judge Ferris W. Wharton, decided November 22, 2021) heard a renewed motion to exclude the defense biomechanical engineer Garry R. Brock, Jr., Ph.D. Bruce Lee claimed injuries to his neck, back and both shoulders. Brock testified that it would be "inconsistent with medical literature" for Lee to have been injured in this accident. The court applied Eskin v. Carden, 842 A.2d 1222 (Del. 2004), and quoted it: such testimony is admitted only when it "reliably creates a connection between the reaction of the human body generally" and the specific person injured.
Brock had reviewed Lee's medical records and deposition, including his height, weight, body type, seat position and prior medical history, and the pre-existing degenerative condition of his spine described by a neuroradiologist. The court found his opinions "specific to Bruce Lee and not the population as a whole" and denied the motion. It also cited Smith v. Grief (Del. 2015), in which, as Lee describes it, the Delaware Supreme Court rejected the argument that a biomechanical opinion "can never be admitted unless the opinion is seconded by or relied upon by a physician." In Lee a defense orthopedic surgeon did rely on Brock's conclusions.
In McHugh v. Johnson the Vermont Superior Court, Chittenden Unit (Judge Robert A. Mello, May 9, 2017), dealt with a defense accident reconstructionist who had no training in biomechanics. He could give the speed of the defendant's vehicle and compare the estimated forces of 0.87-1.7 g with potholes, sneezing and sitting down. The court wrote that he "will not, however, be allowed to testify as to the likelihood or unlikelihood of injury." The court found a significant risk that jurors would take his numbers as an opinion on injury.
Why do courts exclude biomechanical opinions entirely?
Because the method did not fit the crash: tests on different vehicles or impact types, no inspection of the vehicles, unchecked assumptions about the occupant, and peer review only by colleagues at the expert's own firm.
Parker began on August 21, 2014, in New Orleans: as Parker slowed, "he was rear-ended by the Ford van driven by Rivera." On June 23, 2016, Judge Susie Morgan granted the plaintiffs' motion and excluded the defense biomechanical expert, Dr. Charles Bain, from testifying as an expert at all. The party offering the expert must show reliability and relevance by a preponderance of the evidence, the court wrote, citing Mathis v. Exxon Corp. (5th Cir. 2002).
Bain's speed and force estimates rested on a quasi-static bumper test, while the crash was "a dynamic event, an accident involving two moving vehicles." The published tests he cited used "bumper systems from six different vehicles," collinear impacts, while this collision "involved a 50 percent lateral overlap," and target vehicles that "were stationary while the target vehicle in this case was moving." Bain "did not go to the accident scene, did not inspect the vehicles," and instead viewed still photographs of the 2012 Hyundai Sonata involved in the collision and that car's repair estimates. He made assumptions about whether Parker's seat belt locked, his posture, the position of his hands and contact with the headrest, and conceded he was unsure of several of them. He did not speak with Parker or with his treating physician.
Two more points went against him. His only peer reviewers were "his coworkers at Biodynamic Research Corporation, a for-profit entity" doing litigation consulting, which employs him and of which he is a part owner. He also held medical licenses in Canada and Texas, but he "is not board certified or certified in any medical specialty" and "has not practiced clinical medicine in approximately 13 years," so the court found him unqualified to give the medical causation opinion, which in any case depended on the excluded force analysis. The plaintiffs' rebuttal biomechanical expert was precluded as well, because his only purpose was to rebut Bain.
Smelser shows the same problem on the causation side. Huston's opinion rested on "the assumption that Smelser had no similar neck or back injuries prior to the August 29, 1989 accident," although the record showed earlier treatment, "and therefore cannot be considered reliable." Huston had also concluded that the lap belt worked properly without testing it.
When do criticisms go to weight instead of admissibility?
When the method is accepted and the dispute is over the inputs. In Collins, objections about relying on documents, a 2001 sideswipe study and occupant position were left for cross-examination.
The Collins plaintiffs argued that Baratta worked from documents without his own investigation, did no speed analysis and did not interview the truck driver, relied on a 2001 study of spinal compressive forces in sideswipes, and ignored lateral forces and the occupants' positions at impact. The court held that these points go to the weight of his testimony, for the jury, and quoted Viterbo v. Dow Chemical Co. (5th Cir. 1987): "questions relating to the bases and sources of an expert's opinion affect the weight to be assigned" to it. It found that Baratta was "qualified to testify as an expert biomechanical engineer" and that his "methodologies are reliable under Rule 702."
The text of Rule 702 after the 2023 amendment requires the proponent to show the court that it is more likely than not that the testimony will help the trier of fact, rests on sufficient facts or data, is the product of reliable principles and methods, and applies them reliably to the case. The 2023 committee note adds that "each expert opinion must stay within the bounds of what can be concluded" from a reliable application of the expert's basis and methodology. Parker and Collins sit on the two sides of that test: in Parker the tests did not match the crash, and in Collins the method was accepted and the inputs were disputed.
What qualifications do courts look for in a biomechanical expert?
Degrees in engineering or biomechanics, accident reconstruction training, crash data retrieval certification and published research. A medical license by itself did not make the engineer in Parker a causation witness.
Rule 702 admits a witness "qualified as an expert by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education." In Smelser the Sixth Circuit, quoting its earlier decision in Berry v. City of Detroit, framed the test as "whether those qualifications provide a foundation for a witness to answer a specific question."
Baratta in Collins holds a B.S., an M.S. and a Ph.D. in biomedical engineering from Tulane University, is a Certified Accident Reconstructionist and a Bosch Certified Crash Data Retrieval Technician and Analyst, and is a registered professional engineer in eleven states. The court found him qualified as a biomechanical engineer. Brock in Lee holds a Ph.D. and an M.S. in biomechanics from Cornell and has publications in the field.
Experience in reconstruction alone gives a narrower scope. Henry Lipian in Snyder was accredited by the Accreditation Commission of Traffic Accident Reconstructionists and had more than twenty years of reconstruction work; the court limited him to opinions based on that experience. The reconstructionist in McHugh had no biomechanics training and could not speak to the likelihood of injury. Bain in Parker had a 40-year-old degree in nuclear engineering, reconstruction courses and ACTAR certification, which the court found to be "the minimal qualifications" for his collision analysis, and his medical licenses did not qualify him for causation.
What does the other side receive from a biomechanical expert?
In federal court, a written Rule 26(a)(2)(B) report with every opinion and its basis, the data considered, publications from 10 years and testimony from 4 years, plus any facts, data and assumptions counsel supplied.
Under Rule 26(a)(2)(B) the report contains a complete statement of all opinions and the basis and reasons for them, the facts or data considered, the exhibits, the expert's qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, the cases with testimony in the previous 4 years, and the compensation. Without a stipulation or court order it is due at least 90 days before the date set for trial; a report that only rebuts the other side's expert is due within 30 days after that disclosure.
Drafts of the report are protected under Rule 26(b)(4)(B), and so are communications between counsel and the expert, with three exceptions in Rule 26(b)(4)(C): communications about compensation, facts or data counsel provided that the expert considered, and assumptions counsel provided that the expert relied on. A biomechanical calculation starts from inputs such as impact speed, direction and occupant position. If counsel supplied any of them, that communication is open to discovery.
Under Rule 26(b)(4)(E), unless manifest injustice would result, the party that deposes the expert pays a reasonable fee for the time spent responding to discovery.
How does a plaintiff answer a defense biomechanical expert?
With a Rule 702 motion aimed at the fit between the tests and the actual crash and at any causation opinion, a physician who testifies on causation, and a rebuttal expert disclosed within the deadline.
The plaintiffs' motions in Collins and Parker followed this pattern and ended differently. In Collins the motion removed only the medical causation opinion. In Parker it removed the expert, and the plaintiffs' own rebuttal biomechanical expert went with him.
Causation itself comes from a physician. In Smelser the Sixth Circuit described the missing qualification as being a medical doctor who had reviewed the plaintiff's complete medical history. On the defense side, the orthopedic surgeon in Lee relied on the biomechanical conclusions, and, as Lee describes Smith v. Grief, Delaware law does not require such reliance for admission.
The questions for a deposition follow from the cases: what crash tests the opinion rests on and how their vehicles and impact configuration compare with this collision; whether the expert inspected the vehicles or worked from photographs; what was assumed about belt use, posture and head restraint contact; whether the plaintiff's height, weight and prior conditions were considered; and who reviewed the method before publication.
How does IAE find a biomechanical expert?
In the IAE request, choose the case type Personal injury, name the specialty, for example biomechanics or accident reconstruction, and give the state and court. Within 5 business days IAE sends 2-3 candidates with CVs.
The personal injury expert witness page lists biomechanics among the specialties IAE searches for, and its accident mechanics card covers accident reconstruction from event data recorder data, carrier records of driver hours and impact biomechanics. The request also asks for your side, the expert disclosure deadline, and the parties and their counsel for the conflict check. Please leave out privileged or sealed information.
Within 1 business day IAE replies whether it can search in that specialty by that deadline. Each candidate confirms in writing that he or she has no ties to the parties or their counsel. For each candidate the firm receives a CV, hourly rates, testimony in the last 4 years and publications in the last 10 years, the lists that Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires.
The search costs $2,000 per case, paid in advance, and candidate names and CVs come after payment. If no candidate fits, the second search is free; if IAE finds no candidates, it refunds the fee. The expert's hourly rate never depends on the outcome of the case or on the content of testimony. Under the agency option, for hours at the expert's rate plus $100 per hour, for fixed fees, minimum charges and surcharges plus 40%, and for expenses at cost, the expert bills the firm through IAE on one invoice, and the search fee is credited to the first invoice.
IAE is not a law firm. Case strategy and the decision to retain an expert stay with the attorney.
Sources
- Collins v. Benton, No. 18-7465, Order and Reasons (E.D. La. July 2, 2020) (govinfo)
- Parker v. NGM Insurance Co., No. 15-2123, R. Doc. 94 (E.D. La. June 23, 2016) (Justia)
- Snyder v. Harrington, No. 1:08 CV 1031, ECF No. 93 (N.D. Ohio Nov. 15, 2010) (Justia)
- Smelser v. Norfolk Southern Railway Co., 105 F.3d 299 (6th Cir. 1997) (Justia)
- Lee v. Holbrook, C.A. No. N17C-12-247 FWW (Del. Super. Ct. Nov. 22, 2021)
- McHugh v. Johnson, No. 686-7-15 Cncv (Vt. Super. Ct. May 9, 2017) (Justia)
- 49 CFR 563.7, Data elements (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702 (LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26 (LII)
Read also
All articles
Dram shop expert witness: what can a toxicologist prove about visible intoxication, and what do courts require of the opinion?
A dram shop claim asks a court to hold a bar or restaurant liable for what an intoxicated patron did after leaving. The crash is usually undisputed
Construction accident expert witness: which safety rules does the expert apply, and when do they decide the case?
A fall from a scaffold, a collapsed trench or a ladder that kicked out ends up in court as a question about safety rules. The construction safety
Traumatic brain injury expert witness: what can a neuropsychologist and brain imaging prove in court?
A mild traumatic brain injury often leaves nothing a standard scan can show, so the case turns on experts: the treating physiciansExpert witnesses
Need an expert witness for your case?
Describe the question, the case type and the court. Within 5 business days you receive 2-3 candidates with CVs, hourly rates and lists of prior testimony.

