Expert report review
Chain of custody for digital evidence: what does a reviewer check?
The chain of custody for digital evidence is the record of who held a phone, a drive or a forensic image, when, and what was done to it during collection, safeguarding and analysis. In federal court a gap in that record does not by itself keep the evidence out. The reviewer reads the record against the examiner's report and published practice and names every step where the data could have changed without a trace.

What is the chain of custody for digital evidence?
NIST defines it as a process that tracks the movement of evidence through its collection, safeguarding and analysis lifecycle. For digital evidence the record covers the device and every copy made of its data.
The definition is in the glossary of NIST Special Publication 800-101 Revision 1, Guidelines on Mobile Device Forensics (May 2014). The same publication describes preservation as securely maintaining custody of property without altering or changing the contents, and section 4.2 says evidence must be accurately identified and accounted for.
A digital case has more links than a physical one. A phone is seized, isolated, packed and stored; an examiner extracts its data into a file; the file is hashed, loaded into analysis software and exported into a report. Each step creates an object that someone held, and each object can be compared with the one before it.
Section 7 of the publication lists chain of custody documentation among the supporting materials of a mobile forensics report, together with printouts of particular items of evidence and digital copies of evidence.
What standard does a federal court apply to a chain of custody?
Rule 901(a): the proponent must produce evidence sufficient to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims it is. A missing link does not by itself prevent admission.
Federal Rule of Evidence 901 lists ways to meet that standard. Rule 901(b)(1) accepts testimony that an item is what it is claimed to be; Rule 901(b)(4) accepts the appearance, contents, substance, internal patterns or other distinctive characteristics of the item, taken together with all the circumstances; Rule 901(b)(9) accepts evidence describing a process or system and showing that it produces an accurate result.
In United States v. Summers, No. 06-5009, decided on December 16, 2011, the Fourth Circuit upheld the admission of a jacket although no witness accounted for it between its recovery and the FBI laboratory. The court quoted United States v. Ricco: establishing a strict chain of custody is not an iron-clad requirement, and the fact of a missing link does not prevent the admission of real evidence, so long as there is sufficient proof that the evidence is what it purports to be and has not been altered in any material respect (full text).
The Fourth Circuit applied the same rule on November 13, 2018 in United States v. Roberts, an unpublished opinion that is not binding precedent in that circuit, and repeated from United States v. Zhu that it is up to the jury to decide whether evidence is that which the proponent claims.
The rule sets the reviewer's target. The question is whether the record leaves room for a material change in the data, and the rebuttal answers it by naming the step where that room appears.
Does a gap in the chain make digital evidence inadmissible?
Not by itself. In United States v. Pebley the Tenth Circuit treated a gap in an outside vendor's chain of custody for recorded jail calls as a question of weight, because other evidence identified the speaker.
Pebley, No. 20-7022, was decided on February 18, 2021 in an unpublished order and judgment. It concerned three recorded calls from a county jail, stored by an outside vendor and copied to a disk. The court found the foundation sufficient because an FBI agent recognized the defendant's voice and a jail employee described the recording process, and it said deficiencies in the chain of custody generally bear on the weight of the evidence rather than its admissibility.
Pebley turned on evidence outside the chain: a voice identification and a description of how the system recorded calls. A rebuttal that attacks only the paperwork, without showing how the data could have changed, meets the same answer. A rebuttal that points to a concrete change, such as file dates that moved after seizure or a serial number that differs between two records, gives the factfinder a reason to discount the evidence.
Hash values are the usual check between links. The 2017 Committee Note to Rule 902(14) says data copied from electronic devices are ordinarily authenticated by hash value and that, when the values match, it is highly improbable that the original and the copy are not identical. The same note says the opponent remains free to object to admissibility on other grounds.
What should the record show for a seized phone?
When and how the phone was isolated from networks, how it was sealed and stored, and who handled it before extraction. A phone left on a network can receive new data or a remote wipe command after seizure.
Section 4.3 of NIST SP 800-101r1 gives the reasons for isolation: it keeps new traffic, such as SMS messages, from overwriting existing data, and many devices allow a remote lock or remote wipe by sending a command.
The same section states the limits of common methods. Airplane mode does not prevent the system from using other services such as GPS in all cases. A Faraday container may attenuate the radio signal but not necessarily eliminate it completely, and in the tests reported in section 4.3.1 the shielding devices did not prevent network communication in all cases. The publication says examiners should test their own products to validate that they are working properly before use.
Section 4.4 calls for sealing the device in an appropriate container and labeling it according to agency specifications. The reviewer compares the seal and label described at seizure with those described when the examiner opened the package, and looks in the phone's own logs for network activity between those two dates.
How should a computer drive be imaged?
With as few changes to the source as possible: a write-blocker when one can be used, a documented tool and version, hash values of the acquired data, and the acquisition date and time with time zone.
The Scientific Working Group on Digital Evidence published Best Practices for Computer Forensic Acquisitions, document 17-F-002, version 2.0, on June 15, 2023. Section 6 states the guiding principle: minimize, to the fullest extent possible, changes to the source data. Section 7.1 says hardware or software write-blockers should be used when possible to prevent writing to the original evidence.
Section 9 lists what examiners should document, including the type of acquisition, the imaging tool and version number, the hash values of the acquired data, the acquisition date and time including time zone, and errors encountered during acquisition.
A live acquisition, made while the computer is running, changes the source while copying it. Section 7.4.1 says system and file dates and times may change as a result of live access and that live acquisition may be susceptible to smear; section 7.4.2 describes smear as data modified by the running system during the acquisition, which creates inconsistencies in the acquired data. Where changes to the source cannot be fully prevented, section 4 asks examiners to document the process in enough detail to account for the artifacts. Without that record the reviewer cannot separate the examiner's traces from the user's.
What does a matching hash value prove?
That two sets of data are identical. It ties a copy to the data it was computed from, so it covers only the links after the first hash was taken and says nothing about handling before that moment.
Rule 902(14) makes data copied from an electronic device, storage medium or file self-authenticating when a process of digital identification is shown by a certification of a qualified person and the proponent gives notice under Rule 902(11). A certification under the rule can only establish that the item is authentic.
A hash value carries no record of what happened before it was computed. If a phone stayed connected to a network after seizure, the hash of the extraction file confirms only that the file has not changed since the extraction. The reviewer places the first hash on the timeline and checks every earlier step against seizure records, storage logs and the device's own logs.
SWGDE 17-F-002 adds a technical limit in section 8: the process of verification might not verify all data as read from the subject media, and damaged sectors, Host Protected Areas or Device Configuration Overlays may prevent an acquisition tool from reading those areas. The reviewer checks whether the opposing report says which areas were not read.
What should the examiner's notes and report contain?
Contemporaneous notes kept with the case, a list of items with serial number, make and model, the equipment and steps used, chain of custody documentation and the findings, so that another examiner can re-create the process.
SWGDE 18-F-001, Best Practices for Computer Forensic Examination, version 1.0 of July 11, 2018, says examiners should take contemporaneous notes relevant to their examination and that organizational systems should keep those notes with their case for later review.
Section 7 of NIST SP 800-101r1 lists report contents, among them the identity of the submitter, the date of evidence receipt, a descriptive list of items submitted for examination including serial number, make and model, the equipment and setup used, a brief description of the steps taken, and supporting materials such as chain of custody documentation. The section says proper documentation gives individuals the ability to re-create the process.
Section 5.3 says the version of the tool or device being used should be documented before acquisition and that after an acquisition the forensic specialist should confirm that the contents of the device were captured correctly. The reviewer reads these entries against the chain record. A receipt date later than the extraction date, or a serial number that differs from the seizure record, is a break the rebuttal can name.
Must the person who ran the extraction testify as an expert?
Not always. In United States v. Williams the Fifth Circuit held that an investigator's testimony about a Cellebrite phone extraction was lay testimony under Rule 701, so no expert was required.
Williams, No. 22-10316, was decided on October 13, 2023. The defendant argued that the investigator who ran the extraction had to be qualified under Rule 702. The court disagreed and wrote that "the mere use and understanding of a Cellebrite extract at trial is insufficient to require an expert." It described the investigator as knowing no more than anyone else who runs a program on his computer that he did not write.
The ruling changes what the chain evidence looks like at trial. The witness may describe what he did and what the tool produced without offering an opinion on how the tool works. A rebuttal expert can address what such a witness cannot: whether the extraction was complete, whether the tool version had defects in published testing and whether the phone was isolated before the extraction.
Any witness who offers an opinion based on specialized knowledge still falls under Rule 702. The 2023 Committee Note says that testimony may not be admitted unless the proponent establishes to the court that it is more likely than not that it meets the admissibility requirements of the rule.
How do you obtain the chain records from the other side?
Through expert disclosure and discovery: the list of facts or data considered in the expert report, the expert's deposition after the report, and cross-examination on the underlying facts or data at trial.
Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(ii) requires a retained expert's report to state the facts or data considered. Chain records the expert received belong on that list. Rule 26(b)(4)(A) lets a party depose any person identified as an expert whose opinions may be presented at trial, and when a report is required the deposition may be conducted only after the report is provided.
Under Rule 26(b)(4)(C), communications between the attorney and the expert are protected except those about compensation, facts or data the attorney provided and the expert considered, and assumptions the attorney provided and the expert relied on. An assumption that the phone stayed in airplane mode from the moment of seizure falls under the third exception.
Rule 705 lets an expert state an opinion and give the reasons for it without first testifying to the underlying facts or data, but the expert may be required to disclose those facts or data on cross-examination. A rebuttal report on the same subject is due within 30 days after the other side's disclosure unless a stipulation or court order sets another date (Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii)).
What does IAE do when the handling of digital evidence is disputed?
IAE prepares reviews of the opposing forensic report and expert reports on the client's questions about messages, files, software and device data. The signed document is issued in up to 5 business days.
A review of the opposing report answers whether another examiner could repeat the work from it. The reviewer checks that the image and the source have matching hash values, which tool and version extracted the data, whether timestamps were read in the right time zone and whether each conclusion follows from the data. On device data the examiners work with event logs, browser history and traces of connected USB drives.
IAE frames the questions by the device, the application and the event the case needs to establish, and confirms the questions, the devices and how the data reach the examiner before work starts. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV. The draft is checked for facts, and cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.
Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix; the Member ID or QR code in the document opens the specialist's record. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. Materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent. A review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.
Sources
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 901, Authenticating or Identifying Evidence (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 902, Evidence That Is Self-Authenticating, with Committee Notes (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 702, Testimony by Expert Witnesses, with Committee Notes (LII)
- Federal Rules of Evidence, Rule 705, Disclosing the Facts or Data Underlying an Expert's Opinion (LII)
- Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, Rule 26, Duty to Disclose; General Provisions Governing Discovery (LII)
- United States v. Summers, No. 06-5009 (4th Cir. Dec. 16, 2011) (Justia)
- United States v. Summers, 666 F.3d 192 (4th Cir. 2011), full text (Cetient)
- United States v. Roberts, No. 18-4196 (4th Cir. Nov. 13, 2018), unpublished
- United States v. Pebley, No. 20-7022 (10th Cir. Feb. 18, 2021), unpublished order and judgment (Hall Approved)
- United States v. Williams, No. 22-10316 (5th Cir. Oct. 13, 2023)
- NIST Special Publication 800-101 Revision 1, Guidelines on Mobile Device Forensics, May 2014
- SWGDE, Best Practices for Computer Forensic Acquisitions, 17-F-002, version 2.0, June 15, 2023
- SWGDE, Best Practices for Computer Forensic Examination, 18-F-001, version 1.0, July 11, 2018
Read also
All articles
Cell tower location evidence: how does a reviewer test the other side's cell-site analysis?
A cell-site report plots the towers a phone used and argues that the phone, and its owner, were near a place at a certain time. The records behind
Does an IP address identify a person, and how does a reviewer test the other side's expert who ties an IP address to a defendant?
An IP address identifies a network connection at a moment in time. The internet service provider can name the subscriber who pays for that
Who pays for a review of the opposing digital forensics report, and can the fee be recovered?
The party that retains a reviewer of the opposing digital forensics report pays the reviewer. The other side pays only for the time it spendsExpert report review
Ready to discuss your case?
Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

