Expert report review

How do you challenge an appraisal in a bankruptcy sale or a secured claim valuation?

In a bankruptcy case an appraisal is tested at the hearing where its number is used: a sale of estate property outside the ordinary course under 11 U.S.C. 363(b), a sale free and clear of liens under 363(f), or the valuation of a secured claim under 506(a). Section 506(a) ties value to the purpose of the valuation and the proposed disposition or use of the property, so a review begins with the question the appraisal had to answer.

An appraiser from behind stands in an empty storefront with a tape measure on the floor

Where does an appraisal matter in a bankruptcy case?

At three points: a sale outside the ordinary course, which needs notice and a hearing; a sale free and clear of liens, where the price is measured against the liens; and the valuation of a secured claim under section 506(a).

Section 363(b)(1) of the Bankruptcy Code begins: "The trustee, after notice and a hearing, may use, sell, or lease, other than in the ordinary course of business," property of the estate. The hearing is where a creditor or the debtor challenges the price and the appraisal offered to support it.

Section 363(f) permits a sale "free and clear of any interest in such property of an entity other than the estate, only if" one of its listed conditions is met. Under paragraph (3) the condition is that "such interest is a lien and the price at which such property is to be sold is greater than the aggregate value of all liens on such property." The appraisal of the collateral and the sale price meet in that comparison.

Section 506(a)(1) makes an allowed claim secured by a lien "a secured claim to the extent of the value of such creditor's interest in the estate's interest in such property" and an unsecured claim for the rest. The appraised value of the collateral therefore splits one claim into two parts, and every dollar of difference between two appraisals moves between them.

What does section 506(a) say about how the property is valued?

That value "shall be determined in light of the purpose of the valuation and of the proposed disposition or use of such property," together with any hearing on that disposition or use or on a plan affecting the creditor.

The full sentence of section 506(a)(1) reads: "Such value shall be determined in light of the purpose of the valuation and of the proposed disposition or use of such property, and in conjunction with any hearing on such disposition or use or on a plan affecting such creditor's interest."

The statute gives no single standard of value. It ties the number to what is going to happen to the property. An appraisal written for one purpose, such as a loan file or a quick sale, can answer a different question than the one the bankruptcy court has to decide when the debtor keeps the property under a plan.

A reviewer therefore reads the appraisal's own statement of intended use, the client, the effective date and the type of value before checking any comparable. When the stated purpose and the proposed disposition in the case differ, the review records the difference as the first finding, because the rest of the analysis was built for another question.

Which value applies to an individual debtor's personal property?

Replacement value as of the petition date, without deduction for costs of sale or marketing. For property acquired for personal, family or household purposes it is the price a retail merchant would charge, considering age and condition.

Section 506(a)(2) applies when "the debtor is an individual in a case under chapter 7 or 13." The value of personal property securing an allowed claim "shall be determined based on the replacement value of such property as of the date of the filing of the petition without deduction for costs of sale or marketing."

For household goods and similar property the statute defines the term: "replacement value shall mean the price a retail merchant would charge for property of that kind considering the age and condition of the property at the time value is determined."

Each element gives a check for the review. The date must be the petition date. The figure must not be reduced by sale or marketing costs. For a car or furniture bought for personal use, the comparison is the retail price of a similar item, adjusted for age and condition, and an auction or trade-in figure does not answer that standard.

How is a sale outside the ordinary course approved, and where does the objection go?

The trustee sells only after notice and a hearing under section 363(b)(1). The objecting party brings its evidence of value to that hearing, including a review of the appraisal that supports the proposed price.

The words "after notice and a hearing" in section 363(b)(1) give creditors and the debtor the moment to contest the price. The appraisal the trustee relies on is evidence at that hearing, and so is a review of it.

Section 363(b)(1) also limits sales of personally identifiable information. If the debtor disclosed a privacy policy that prohibited transferring such information and the policy was in effect when the case began, the trustee may not sell it unless the sale is consistent with the policy or the court approves it after appointing a consumer privacy ombudsman and holding a hearing. For a customer database the review of value has to take that limit into account.

The review is most useful when it is ready before the hearing date. It identifies what the appraisal valued, as of which date, under which assumptions about the sale, and which comparables or income figures the appraiser used, with page references that counsel can put to the appraiser.

When can property be sold free and clear of liens, and why does the appraisal matter there?

When one of the conditions of section 363(f) is met. Under paragraph (3) the interest must be a lien and the sale price must exceed the aggregate value of all liens on the property.

Section 363(f)(3) compares two numbers: the price at which the property is to be sold and "the aggregate value of all liens on such property." The appraisal of the property and the amount of the liens feed that comparison, and a dispute over value becomes a dispute over whether the sale may go forward free and clear.

The reviewer checks that the appraisal values the same property the sale covers, at a date close to the proposed sale, and that it uses the sale conditions actually proposed. A going-concern value for a business sold piece by piece, or a value for land with improvements the buyer is not acquiring, measures something other than the sale in front of the court.

Why does an objection to value have to come before the sale is completed?

Because section 363(m) protects a good faith purchaser. Reversal or modification of the sale authorization on appeal does not affect the validity of the sale unless the authorization and the sale were stayed pending appeal.

Section 363(m) provides that the reversal or modification on appeal of an authorization to sell "does not affect the validity of a sale or lease under such authorization" to an entity that purchased in good faith, "unless such authorization and such sale or lease were stayed pending appeal."

In Ready v. Rice, an appeal in the OR Partners bankruptcy decided on September 26, 2006 by Judge Benson Everett Legg in the District of Maryland, an apartment complex in Baltimore called Mt. Pleasant had been sold for $4.75 million on December 21, 2005. Section 363(m), the court wrote, "limits appellate review to the narrow issue of whether the sale was made to a 'good faith purchaser,'" and it dismissed the appeal as moot. On value, the opinion quoted the Fourth Circuit benchmark that "a reliable measure of 'for value' is 75 percent of an asset's appraisal value" and added: "When a property has not been appraised, a properly conducted auction may properly substitute for an appraisal." The price was close to 80 percent of the $6 million scheduled value the appellant proposed.

For a party that disputes the appraisal, the practical window is the hearing in the bankruptcy court. A review served after the sale closes may still matter for other questions in the case, but it does not undo a protected sale.

Must the trustee obtain a certified appraisal before selling estate property?

Not as an absolute rule. In Rose v. Logan (D. Md. 2014) the court declined to read In re Donoway as requiring a certified appraisal and affirmed a sale supported by a realtor's opinion of value.

Rose v. Logan, decided by District Judge Bennett of the District of Maryland on March 25, 2014, was an appeal by a shareholder of the debtor. The Chapter 7 trustee had sold the debtor's only asset, the property at 9843 Wades Point Road in Claiborne, Maryland, under a contract at $1.42 million, the highest offer the trustee had received. The shareholder argued that the trustee never obtained a certified appraisal, that a realtor's opinion was presented as an appraisal, and that a marketing period of 41 days was too short.

The court wrote that it "does not find that In re Donoway establishes an absolute requirement for a certified appraisal" and added that "the two cases that have directly addressed this aspect of the Donoway decision have rejected it." It listed the conditions for approving a section 363(b) sale: "a sound business reason justifying the sale," "adequate and reasonable notice of the sale to all parties," "that the sale has been proposed in good faith" and that "the purchase price is fair and reasonable." The court held that "it was not an abuse of discretion for the Bankruptcy Judge to conclude that the contract price was fair."

For the objecting party the case moves the fight to the price. The absence of a certified appraisal does not by itself defeat a sale, so the objection has to show, with market evidence, that the price is not fair and reasonable. A review of the opinion of value the trustee relied on, with comparables and a recomputation, is that evidence.

Who appraises property for the estate, and must the appraiser be independent?

The trustee may employ appraisers with the court's approval. Under section 327(a) they must not hold or represent an interest adverse to the estate and must be disinterested persons.

Section 327(a) reads in part: "the trustee, with the court's approval, may employ one or more attorneys, accountants, appraisers, auctioneers, or other professional persons, that do not hold or represent an interest adverse to the estate, and that are disinterested persons, to represent or assist the trustee in carrying out the trustee's duties under this title."

The review records who engaged the appraiser and whether the engagement was approved. When the appraisal was commissioned by a prospective buyer or by a secured lender, the report names that client and its intended use, and the reviewer sets them against the question the court must decide.

The same section gives a list of questions for the appraiser's examination: who retained you, when, for what intended use, whether you have done work for the buyer or the lender, and whether your fee depends on the outcome of the sale.

What does Rule 702 require of the appraiser's opinion?

Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence puts the burden on the proponent to show the court that the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data and on reliable principles and methods, reliably applied.

Rule 702 lets a qualified witness testify as an expert if the proponent shows the court that "it is more likely than not" that the expert's knowledge will help the trier of fact, that "the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data," and that "the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods." The fourth condition concerns the application of those methods to the facts of the case.

An appraisal that values the wrong property, uses the wrong date or applies a standard of value that section 506(a)(2) does not allow raises questions under each of these conditions. The review lists the findings in the same order, so counsel can use them on cross-examination or in a motion.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure lists the contents of a retained expert's written report in federal civil litigation: the opinions with their basis and reasons, the facts or data considered, exhibits, qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, testimony from the previous 4 years and compensation. When the bankruptcy court requires such a report, those six items frame the review.

What does a review of the appraisal check in a bankruptcy matter?

The purpose and proposed disposition, the effective date, the standard of value, the property actually appraised, the comparables and income data, and the appraiser's engagement and independence.

The review is written for the hearing at which the value will be used. Each finding carries a page reference to the appraisal and the provision of the Bankruptcy Code it concerns.

  • The reviewer states the purpose of the valuation in the case and compares it with the intended use stated in the appraisal, as section 506(a)(1) ties value to purpose and proposed disposition.
  • The reviewer checks the effective date against the date the case requires, including the petition date for personal property of an individual debtor under section 506(a)(2).
  • The reviewer checks the standard of value, including whether sale or marketing costs were deducted where section 506(a)(2) does not allow it.
  • The reviewer confirms that the property appraised is the property being sold or retained, with the same rights, improvements and condition.
  • The reviewer traces each comparable sale, rent or income figure to a source and recomputes the adjustments.
  • The reviewer records who engaged the appraiser, for whom, and whether the engagement was approved under section 327(a).

What does IAE do when a party disputes an appraisal in a bankruptcy case?

An appraiser from the IAE registry recomputes the opposing valuation step by step and writes a review or a rebuttal report with questions for the appraiser, in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed.

The IAE page for valuation rebuttals is written for attorneys facing the other side's appraisal of a business, an ownership interest or real property. The reviewer recomputes the opposing valuation step by step, writes a rebuttal report and turns the findings into questions for the appraiser's deposition. The page names three formats: a review of the opposing appraisal, a rebuttal valuation report and cross-examination questions.

The IAE valuation page describes a review under USPAP Standards 3 and 4 as an opinion on the quality of another appraiser's work: comparables, adjustments, discount rate, effective date and the support for each conclusion. Before work starts IAE confirms the report under review, the property and the valuation date.

The client sends the appraisal or the case materials and describes the task, and the secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, cost, deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days; cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

The specialist is a member of the public IAE registry who passed the council's attestation under the published Criteria Matrix, and the Member ID or QR code on the document opens the record. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. The review is evidence that the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member