Expert report review

Two conflicting appraisals: how does the court choose between them?

When two appraisers put different values on the same property, the judge or jury decides which figure the evidence supports. A court may adopt one appraisal, reject both or reach its own value from the record. New Jersey's Appellate Division rejected a value reached by averaging comparable sales in 2009, and in 2022, in an unpublished opinion, reversed a judge who adopted one appraisal without a statement of reasons.

Two closed appraisal folders of different thickness rest on a judge bench

What can a court do when two appraisals conflict?

Adopt one appraisal, reject both, or reach its own value from all the evidence. Appellate courts in New Jersey and New York have held that expert opinions assist the trier of fact and do not bind it.

State v. Lai-No, 193 N.J. Super. 713, decided by New Jersey's Appellate Division on May 7, 1984, was a condemnation case tried to a judge without a jury. The State's appraiser valued the property before the taking at $145,000 on three comparable sales. The owner's appraiser valued it at $195,000 on six. Both had equal credentials, both used the market value approach, and two sales appeared in both reports. The after-taking value was stipulated at $100,000.

The trial judge adopted $195,000. He reasoned that "one figure or the other must be accepted" and that "There is no satisfactory basis for choosing a value which falls outside of either appraiser's ultimate figure." A figure outside that range, in his view, would mean the court's substitution of its own non-expert judgment.

Judge Furman's opinion for the Appellate Division quoted Port of N.Y. Authority v. Howell: "The office of the testimony of experts is to aid and assist the trier of the facts" and "not to dominate or control him in the decision of the disputed question." Expert opinions "are deductions from the evidence and do not conclude the trier of the facts." The court said the $195,000 award would have been sustainable as an independent judgment, but it reversed because of the judge's "erroneous understanding" that "his fact finding role was limited to choosing between the two conflicting appraisals," and remanded for a new trial.

The record in Lai-No held more than two numbers. The State's expert also gave $160,000 under the cost approach, and the owner's expert gave $157,717 under the income capitalization approach. Those figures were part of the evidence the trier of fact could weigh.

Must the court pick one of the two figures?

No. In Wagner v. State (N.Y. App. Div. 1966) the court held that the trial court "is not bound to choose between these figures" and was justified in rejecting both appraisals; its award fell between them.

In Wagner v. State, 25 A.D.2d 814, decided April 7, 1966, the State permanently appropriated unimproved land. The State's expert treated it as waste land and found total damage of $890. The claimants' expert found $32,000. The Court of Claims found that the highest and best use was residential, "as zoned," and fixed a value higher than the State's figure and lower than the claimants'. The dissent gives the award as $9,550.

The Appellate Division affirmed. It held that "The court is not bound to choose between these figures" and that "the court was justified in rejecting the appraisals of both experts." The award rested on evidence in the record: two nearby residential sales that were not true comparables but could be adjusted, and the trial court's own view of the property.

Justice Bastow dissented. In his view the record had no proof on which a proper decision could be made, and the trial court faced a choice between dismissing the claim for failure of proof and making "a calculated guess as to the amount of damage." He would have ordered a new trial requiring both sides to present proof that conforms to recognized appraisal principles. According to the dissent, the State conceded that its expert had limited familiarity with real estate in the area, and the claimants' expert used none of the recognized appraisal methods.

Can the court average the appraisals?

New Jersey's Appellate Division said no in Pansini (2009): averaging appraisals or comparable sales "is not an appropriate methodology for assessing divergent values," and the fact-finder must weigh the experts' opinions instead.

The property in Pansini Custom Design Associates v. City of Ocean City was 801 Fourth Street in Ocean City, a 13,000-square-foot lot with a house and detached garage, a former U.S. Life Saving Station designated as a historic structure. The owners needed a fair market value to advertise the property for sale under the city's historic preservation ordinance.

Three appraisers testified. Hedden, for the owners, put the value at $1,400,000; Sapio, for the city, at $900,000; Lange, for a citizens' coalition, at $850,000. The trial judge criticized all three. He found that the owners' appraiser had improperly considered development of excess land beyond the current use, and that the comparable sales in the other two reports came from a period when the Ocean City market was "flat at best." He then averaged the three highest and the three lowest comparable sales from the appraisals and declared a value of $1,072,500.

The Appellate Division, in an opinion by Judge Carchman decided May 14, 2009, reversed and remanded for a new trial on valuation. The fact-finder "must weigh and evaluate the experts' opinions, including their credibility," the court wrote, and averaging hands that responsibility "to a simple mathematical formula." It held that "averaging, whether of appraisals or comparable sales, is not an appropriate methodology for assessing divergent values," because there are "sufficient differences that must be weighed and considered by the fact-finder." The court also flagged large adjustments in an appraisal, one of them 166 percent, for review on remand.

Must the judge explain why one appraisal was preferred?

New Jersey's Appellate Division required reasons in Knaust v. Knaust (2022, unpublished). It reversed the part of an order that adopted a court-appointed appraisal of $200,000 because the judge gave no reasons for rejecting the conflicting values.

The record in Knaust v. Knaust, No. A-0346-20, held three values for the marital home: a joint appraisal of September 2016 at $360,000, the wife's appraisal of June 2019 at $300,000 to $325,000, and a December 2019 appraisal by a court-appointed firm at $200,000. In May 2020 the trial court adopted the court-appointed figure. On reconsideration it called the husband's objection "meritless" because he had asked for a neutral court-appointed appraiser.

The Appellate Division, Judges Fisher and Smith, decided the appeal on August 30, 2022. The trial court, it wrote, "failed to consider or appreciate the significance the conflicting proofs on property value in the record," and to the extent it rejected them in favor of the court-appointed appraisal, it "abused its discretion by failing to provide a statement of reasons supporting such a result."

Plenary hearings are required, the court noted, when "a prima facie showing has been made that a genuine issue of fact exists bearing upon a critical question." The values in the record differed by as much as $160,000. The court reversed on the home's value, remanded for a plenary hearing and affirmed the ruling on the husband's pension. The opinion is unpublished. Under New Jersey Court Rule 1:36-3 it does not constitute precedent, and its header states that it is binding only on the parties in the case.

How does the Tax Court treat conflicting valuation experts?

It is not bound by any expert's formula or opinion and may reach its own value from the whole record. In Silverman the Tax Court found $37 per share, above every expert's figure, and the Second Circuit affirmed.

Silverman v. Commissioner, 538 F.2d 927, decided by the Second Circuit on June 21, 1976, concerned gifts of class B common stock. The donors reported $10 per share on their gift tax returns. The Commissioner's notice of deficiency set $48 and was reduced at trial to $25, the figure of the Commissioner's expert. The taxpayers' three experts gave $5 or $6, $12, and $2 to $5.

The Tax Court found $37 per share. It rejected the taxpayers' expert testimony because it considered only the viewpoint of a potential buyer. It took the exchange ratio from a June 1969 reorganization, under which class B shares were worth 65/70ths of class A, and applied it to a class A value of $40.

The Second Circuit affirmed: "The Tax Court is not bound by the formulas or opinions proffered by expert witnesses. It may reach a determination of value based upon its own analysis of all the evidence in the record." For that rule it cited Helvering v. National Grocery Co., 304 U.S. 282, 294 (1938).

The court's figure exceeded the Commissioner's own expert by $12 per share and the highest figure of the taxpayers' experts by $25. Neither side's expert had proposed it.

Can the court appoint its own appraiser to break the tie?

In federal court, yes. Rule 706 of the Federal Rules of Evidence lets the court appoint an expert the parties agree on or one of its own choosing, and any party may depose and cross-examine that expert.

Under Rule 706(a), the court may, on a party's motion or on its own, order the parties to show cause why experts should not be appointed and may ask them to submit nominations. "The court may appoint any expert that the parties agree on and any of its own choosing," but only someone who consents to act.

Under Rule 706(b) the court must inform the expert of the expert's duties, in writing filed with the clerk or orally at a conference where the parties may take part. The expert must advise the parties of any findings, may be deposed by any party, may be called to testify by the court or any party, and may be cross-examined by any party, including the party that called the expert.

In a civil case other than a Fifth Amendment just compensation case, the parties pay the court-set compensation in the proportion and at the time the court directs (Rule 706(c)). The court may tell the jury that it appointed the expert (Rule 706(d)), and the rule does not limit a party in calling its own experts (Rule 706(e)).

A court-appointed value does not end the dispute by itself. In Knaust the trial court adopted the appraisal of the firm it had appointed, and the Appellate Division still reversed because the conflicting appraisals were not weighed and no reasons were given.

Why do two appraisals of the same property differ?

In the cases above the gaps came from the assumed highest and best use, the choice of comparable sales, the size of adjustments and the viewpoint of the sale. A review traces each part of the gap to its source.

In Wagner the gap came from highest and best use. The State's expert valued the land as waste land at $890 and the claimants' expert reached $32,000; the court accepted neither and valued the land for residential use, as zoned.

In Lai-No and Pansini the gap came from comparable sales and adjustments. In Lai-No the appraisers used three and six sales with two in common and ended $50,000 apart. In Pansini the judge found that two appraisers drew their sales from a flat market and that the third counted development of excess land, and the Appellate Division pointed to an adjustment of 166 percent.

In Silverman the Tax Court rejected the taxpayers' experts because they looked only at what a potential buyer would pay, and it took its figure from a ratio the company itself had used in a reorganization.

A reviewer sets the two reports side by side on each of these points: property and rights appraised, valuation date, highest and best use, each comparable sale with its date and source, each adjustment and its support, the weight given to each approach, and the final reconciliation. Where the reports agree, the court has a fixed point. Where they differ, the review states which input the record supports.

When does a rebuttal of the opposing appraisal have to be served?

In federal civil cases, within 30 days after the other side's expert disclosure, unless a stipulation or court order sets another date, under Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B) requires a retained expert's written report to contain a complete statement of all opinions and the basis and reasons for them, the facts or data considered, exhibits, the witness's qualifications with publications from the previous 10 years, a list of cases from the previous 4 years in which the witness testified at trial or by deposition, and the compensation for the study and testimony.

Under Rule 26(a)(2)(D), absent a stipulation or court order, the disclosures are due at least 90 days before the date set for trial. Evidence "intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter" is due within 30 days after the other party's disclosure.

Under Rule 26(b)(4)(A) a party may depose any expert whose opinions may be presented at trial, and when a report is required the deposition may be conducted only after the report is provided. A review of the opposing appraisal gives counsel the questions for that deposition: why these comparables, why these adjustments, why this highest and best use.

The Appellate Division in Pansini required the fact-finder to weigh the experts' opinions, and in Knaust it required a statement of reasons. A rebuttal report that sets out the differences point by point gives the judge reasons to adopt in the decision.

What does IAE do when the other side's appraisal conflicts with yours?

A reviewer recomputes the opposing valuation step by step, writes a rebuttal report under Rule 26 or Tax Court Rule 143 and turns the findings into deposition questions, in up to 5 business days after format and cost are confirmed.

The service is for attorneys facing the other side's appraisal of a business, an ownership interest or real property. IAE confirms the report under review, the property and the valuation date before work starts.

The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case, and materials are not passed to third parties without the client's consent.

IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy. The court weighs a review with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome or influences the decision.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member