Expert report review

Two forensic audio experts disagree about a recording: how does the court decide, and what does a reviewer compare?

When two forensic audio examiners reach opposite conclusions about the same recording, a federal court does not simply choose between them. The judge first decides whether each opinion meets Rule 702. Opinions that pass go to the jury, which weighs them like other testimony, and the court may appoint its own expert under Rule 706. A reviewer's job is to find where the two reports part ways: the file, the tests or the wording.

Two pairs of headphones face each other across a wood table with one recorder between them

What happens when two forensic audio experts reach opposite conclusions?

The judge decides whether each opinion is admissible under Rule 702. If both are admitted, the jury weighs them. The court may also appoint its own expert under Rule 706, and each party keeps its own expert.

A typical dispute looks like this. One examiner reports that a recording shows signs of editing at a certain point. The other reports that the file is consistent with an original made on the claimed device. Or one examiner attributes the voice to the defendant and the other says the comparison is inconclusive.

Federal law handles this in stages. Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence sets the conditions for each opinion: the expert's knowledge will help the trier of fact, the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data, it is the product of reliable principles and methods, and the opinion is a reliable application of those methods to the facts of the case. The judge applies those conditions to each expert separately.

An opinion that passes the test reaches the jury, and so may an opposing opinion that also passes. A conflict between two admissible opinions is resolved at trial, through cross-examination, the reports and the rest of the evidence.

Does the judge pick the more convincing audio expert?

No. The judge decides admissibility, and since the 2023 amendment the sufficiency of the basis and the application of the method are admissibility questions. Once both opinions pass, any further attack goes to weight.

The 2023 committee note to Rule 702 corrected a line of decisions. It says that "many courts have held that the critical questions of the sufficiency of an expert's basis, and the application of the expert's methodology, are questions of weight and not admissibility. These rulings are an incorrect application of Rules 702 and 104(a)."

The same note sets the limit of the judge's role: "once the court has found it more likely than not that the admissibility requirement has been met, any attack by the opponent will go only to the weight of the evidence." The note also says that "nothing in the amendment requires the court to nitpick an expert's opinion in order to reach a perfect expression of what the basis and methodology can support."

The committee note to the 2000 amendment addressed competing experts directly: "When a trial court, applying this amendment, rules that an expert's testimony is reliable, this does not necessarily mean that contradictory expert testimony is unreliable." It adds that "the trial court's role as gatekeeper is not intended to serve as a replacement for the adversary system." A judge who admits one examiner's authentication opinion can admit the other side's opposite opinion as well.

How does a jury weigh two conflicting audio experts?

Like any other testimony. Model jury instructions tell jurors they may accept or reject an expert opinion and give it the weight they think it deserves, considering the reasons given and all the other evidence.

The Ninth Circuit Manual of Model Civil Jury Instructions, instruction 2.14 on expert opinion testimony as revised in March 2026, tells jurors: "Such opinion testimony should be judged like any other testimony." It continues: "You may accept it or reject it and give it as much weight as you think it deserves", considering among other things "the reasons given for the opinion, and all the other evidence in the case."

The 2000 committee note to Rule 702 quotes the Supreme Court in Daubert on how admissible but contested opinions are tested: "Vigorous cross-examination, presentation of contrary evidence, and careful instruction on the burden of proof are the traditional and appropriate means of attacking shaky but admissible evidence."

For audio evidence that puts the reasons on the table. A juror can follow which file each examiner received, which tests each ran and what each found at a given time code. A list of credentials does not tell the jury which examiner looked at which data. The side whose examiner can show the waveform, the spectrogram and the test recording at the disputed point gives the jury something to compare.

Why do two audio examiners reach different results on the same recording?

Most often because they examined different files, ran different tests, had different exemplar recordings or worded their conclusions differently. Each of those differences can be found in the reports and checked.

The first source of conflict is the file. The SWGDE Best Practices for Digital Audio Authentication, version 1.3 of September 20, 2018, define the original recording as "the first manifestation of sound in a recoverable stored format" and state in section 3.1 that "Transcoded or re-encoded versions of an original recording are not original recordings." An examiner who worked from a converted copy and one who worked from the device may both be right about the file each received.

The second is the set of tests. Section 4.1 says: "Not all tests will be applicable in each case, nor shall any single analysis be relied upon solely." One examiner may have run global analyses of the file structure and local analyses of the signal, the other only critical listening and a spectrogram.

The third is reference material. Section 4.7 provides for test recordings "either from the obtained evidence recorder or from test recorders of the same manufacturer and model". An examiner with test recordings can say what a pause looks like on that device. An examiner without them cannot.

The fourth is wording. Section 5.2 lists three possible results: "Consistent with an original," "Inconclusive," and "Inconsistent with an original," and warns that conclusions "should not be over or understated." Two reports that read as opposite may turn out to differ by one category.

What does a reviewer compare first in two conflicting audio reports?

The file each examiner received: its name, format, size, duration and hash value. If the hash values differ, the examiners did not analyze the same data, and the conflict may end there.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B)(ii) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires a retained expert's report to list "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming them". For an audio report that includes the file. A reviewer sets the two lists side by side.

Hash values settle whether two files are the same. The committee note to the 2017 amendment of Rule 902 explains: "If the hash values for the original and copy are different, then the copy is not identical to the original." If they match, it is "highly improbable" that the files differ. A report that gives no hash leaves open which file was examined, and the reviewer asks for it.

If the files differ, the next questions are which file is closer to the device and how the other one was produced. The answer often explains the conflict without any finding that either examiner made an error.

Did both examiners run the same tests?

The reviewer lists, for each report, the file assessment, critical listening, global and local analyses and test recordings, and marks what each examiner did and documented. A gap in one list often explains the disagreement.

SWGDE describes the steps. Section 4.2 covers the technical characteristics of the file, including container format, encoding, bit rate, sample rate, duration and encoded date and time. Section 4.3 calls for "Critical aural review of the submitted recording, without applying any processing". Section 4.4 lists global analyses, among them file format, file structure, DC offset, long-term spectral analysis, compression level analysis and electric network frequency. Section 4.5 lists local analyses: waveform, signal power, spectrographic analysis and butt-splice detection.

Appendix A of the document shows how the steps fit together. In its sample case one party said a recording was continuous and the other said the recorder had been paused. The examiner decoded the start, stop and pause fields from the file header, found a pause and restart in the waveform, spectrogram and power analyses, and made test recordings on the same recorder model, continuous, paused and edited. The conclusion was that the file was consistent with an original from that model and contained a pause and restart at about 2.7 seconds.

A reviewer who finds that one report contains those steps and the other relies on listening alone has a concrete point for the rebuttal report and for cross-examination.

Does each conclusion stay within what the tests support?

The reviewer checks the wording of each conclusion against the tests behind it. SWGDE says no forensic result has absolute certainty, and the Rule 702 note tells forensic experts to avoid claims of one hundred percent certainty.

SWGDE section 5.2.1 states: "No scientific inquiry, including those in forensics, produce a result of absolute certainty." It adds that language implying 100 percent certainty should be avoided unless the examiner is speaking about known alterations or deletions.

The 2023 committee note to Rule 702 says the same for court testimony: "Forensic experts should avoid assertions of absolute or one hundred percent certainty", and it extends the caution to claims of a reasonable degree of scientific certainty where the methodology is subjective and thus potentially subject to error.

A conclusion that a recording "was definitely edited" resting on one spectrogram, or that a voice "is" the defendant's resting on a short sample, goes beyond the tests. A reviewer can show that the opposing examiner's own data support only an inconclusive result, which narrows the conflict to a question the jury can follow.

Can the court appoint its own audio expert when two experts disagree?

Yes. Under Rule 706 the court may appoint an expert who consents to serve, on its own motion or a party's. That expert shares findings with the parties, may be deposed and cross-examined, and is paid as the court directs.

Rule 706(a) lets the court act on its own or on a party's motion and ask the parties to submit nominations. The court "may only appoint someone who consents to act." Under Rule 706(b) the court informs the expert of the duties, and the expert "must advise the parties of any findings the expert makes". Any party may depose the expert, the court or any party may call the expert to testify, and any party may cross-examine, including the party that called the expert.

In most civil cases the expert is paid "by the parties in the proportion and at the time that the court directs", Rule 706(c). Under Rule 706(d) the court may allow the jury to be told that the court appointed the expert. Rule 706(e) keeps the parties' own experts in the case: "This rule does not limit a party in calling its own experts."

The original advisory committee note explains the purpose of the rule: "The ever-present possibility that the judge may appoint an expert in a given case must inevitably exert a sobering effect on the expert witness of a party."

When should the other side's audio expert be excluded rather than weighed?

When the proponent cannot show it is more likely than not that the opinion rests on sufficient facts or data and a reliable method reliably applied. A conflict between experts is not a ground by itself.

A motion under Rule 702 attacks the opinion, not the disagreement. The grounds come from the rule: the examiner did not have sufficient facts or data, for example worked from a transcoded copy when the question was whether the original was edited; the method was not reliable; or the method was not reliably applied, for example a conclusion of editing with no test recordings from the claimed device.

After the 2023 amendment the court decides those points before trial, and the proponent carries the burden. If the opposing opinion survives, the reviewer's findings move to cross-examination and to the rebuttal report, and the jury weighs them.

How does a review of conflicting audio reports reach the court?

Through a rebuttal report served within 30 days of the other side's disclosure absent a stipulation or order, a deposition of the opposing examiner, a Rule 702 motion, or the reviewer's testimony at trial.

Rule 26(a)(2)(D)(ii) sets the deadline for evidence "intended solely to contradict or rebut evidence on the same subject matter": within 30 days after the other party's disclosure, unless the court orders or the parties stipulate otherwise.

Under Rule 26(b)(4)(A) a party may depose any expert whose opinions may be presented at trial, after the report is provided. Under Rule 26(b)(4)(C), communications between the attorney and the opposing examiner are protected, except those that relate to compensation, identify facts or data the attorney provided and the examiner considered, or identify assumptions the attorney provided and the examiner relied on. Those exceptions show what each examiner was told about the recording before the work started.

Under Rule 26(b)(4)(E), the party seeking the deposition pays the expert a reasonable fee for the time spent responding, unless manifest injustice would result.

What does IAE do when two audio reports conflict?

An IAE examiner reviews the opposing audio report: which file was received and hashed, which tests were run and documented, and whether each conclusion stays within the method. Up to 5 business days.

The IAE review of the opposing forensic audio report is for a party facing the other side's examiner on whether a recording was edited, whose voice is on it or what was said. The reviewer checks which file the examiner received, which tests were run and documented, whether the voice exemplars were comparable and whether the conclusion stays within the method. Each point in the review is tied to a page of the opposing report and to a rule, a standard or a court decision.

The document can take the form of a review of the opposing report, a rebuttal report or a statement of grounds for a Rule 702 motion. The client sends the reports and the case materials and describes what to check. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day, and within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry. The client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and a 48-hour rush is available for tight deadlines.

Specialists are members of the public IAE registry, and the Member ID or QR code in the document opens the specialist's record. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. A review is evidence the court weighs with the other materials; neither IAE nor the reviewer guarantees the outcome, and IAE is not a law firm.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member