Examinations

Debt recharacterization in bankruptcy: which factors turn an insider loan into equity?

On March 1, 2021, Judge Martin Glenn of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York treated a $6,354,900 claim by a member of Live Primary, LLC as equity. The member had made over sixty disbursements without a single promissory note, at 1% interest, repayable only on a liquidity event or a public offering, to a company formed with $1,000 of capital.

A hand moves one sheet from a thin loan file onto a thicker stack beside a wooden gavel

What does it mean when a bankruptcy court recharacterizes debt as equity?

The court finds that money labeled a loan was in substance a capital contribution. The claim is then treated as an equity interest and is paid after creditors instead of sharing with them.

The Sixth Circuit applied the test in Bayer Corp. v. MascoTech, Inc. (In re AutoStyle Plastics, Inc.), decided October 22, 2001. Bayer held a secured claim of $2,915,379.23 against AutoStyle, with a lien second in priority only to the lien of CIT, the company's lender. The defendants, MascoTech, Citicorp Venture Capital and the Michigan State Treasurer for the state retirement systems, were owed approximately $8,435,252 in total through participations in CIT's credit facility. MascoTech had bought one-half of the common stock of AutoStyle's parent and lent AutoStyle another $26.8 million, and Citicorp Venture Capital owned about 35% of the stock of the parent, AutoStyle, Inc. Bayer asked the court to equitably subordinate the defendants' claims to its own and to recharacterize them as equity.

The court located the power to recharacterize in the Bankruptcy Code itself: "The source of the court's general equitable powers is §105 of the Code." It kept recharacterization apart from equitable subordination. Recharacterization asks whether a debt exists at all, and if the claim is recharacterized, "then equitable subordination never comes into play," a line the court quoted from In re Georgetown Bldg. Assocs. The court wrote that the two doctrines "serve different purposes."

Equitable subordination has its own statute. Under 11 U.S.C. 510(c), after notice and a hearing, the court may "under principles of equitable subordination, subordinate for purposes of distribution all or part of an allowed claim," and may order that a lien securing a subordinated claim be transferred to the estate. A subordinated claim stays a claim and is paid later. A recharacterized claim leaves the creditor body.

Fifteen years later the Fourth Circuit wrote in In re Province Grande Olde Liberty, LLC that "Recharacterization is well within the broad powers afforded a bankruptcy court" and that the decision rests on the substance of the transaction involved.

Which factors do courts weigh to decide whether an advance is debt or equity?

Most courts use eleven factors that the Sixth Circuit took from Roth Steel Tube Co. v. Commissioner, a 1986 tax case, and applied in AutoStyle in 2001. No single factor decides the case.

AutoStyle quotes the factors from Roth Steel Tube Co. v. Commissioner, 800 F.2d 625, 630 (6th Cir. 1986). The Fourth Circuit adopted the same eleven in In re Dornier Aviation (North America), Inc., 453 F.3d 225 (2006), and in Province Grande quoted them from AutoStyle, 269 F.3d at 747-48. Restated as questions, the factors read as follows.

  • What names did the parties give the instruments, if any, evidencing the indebtedness?
  • Was there a fixed maturity date and a schedule of payments?
  • Was there a fixed rate of interest, and were interest payments made?
  • What was the source of repayments?
  • Was the company adequately or inadequately capitalized?
  • Was there an identity of interest between the creditor and the stockholder?
  • Did the company give security for the advances?
  • Could the company obtain financing from outside lending institutions?
  • To what extent were the advances subordinated to the claims of outside creditors?
  • To what extent were the advances used to acquire capital assets?
  • Was there a sinking fund to provide repayments?

Weight of each factor

AutoStyle said that "No one factor is controlling or decisive" and that the factors "must be considered within the particular circumstances of each case." On August 25, 2025, in Insight Terminal Solutions, LLC v. Cecelia Financial Management, No. 24-5222, the Sixth Circuit repeated that bankruptcy courts should not treat any of the AutoStyle factors as dispositive, and noted that the test was one "that we first adopted in the tax context."

Several factors can be measured from the company's books and bank records: whether interest was charged and paid, what the capitalization was on each funding date, whether security was granted and recorded, where repayments came from and what the money bought. Those are the parts a forensic accountant documents. The names on the papers and the identity of interest between lender and owner come from the documents and testimony that counsel puts before the court.

How does a forensic accountant test capitalization and access to outside credit?

The accountant measures equity and liabilities on each date money came in, sets them against the funding the business plan required, and lists the outside lenders approached and the terms they offered or refused.

AutoStyle held that "capitalization is not to be assessed only at initial capitalization." The evidence on AutoStyle's capitalization was disputed, and that alone was not enough for Bayer to defeat summary judgment. A capitalization analysis therefore runs date by date: for each advance, a balance sheet as of that date, with total liabilities, owners' equity, cash on hand and the amount of the advance.

In Live Primary the First Operating Agreement recorded that "the aggregate capital contribution for this start up business was only $1,000," of which the member's share was $400. Judge Glenn wrote that it "was obvious from the First Operating Agreement that $6,000,000 was needed," and the debtor had projected that it needed more than $6 million to build out its facilities. Capital on the books set against a funding need written into the company's own documents is the core exhibit of a capitalization analysis.

On outside credit, AutoStyle wrote that "When there is no evidence of other outside financing, the fact that no reasonable creditor would have acted in the same manner is strong evidence that the advances were capital contributions rather than loans." AutoStyle's insiders had funded through participations in a bank facility, and on loans guaranteed by suppliers the court said: "There is no requirement that outside financing come without any involvement of 'interested' parties." That factor weighed toward a loan.

In Province Grande the Fourth Circuit pointed to the debtor's "total reliance" on PEM's money for its expenses and its "inability to obtain any other financing." An accountant documents the same point with a schedule of every source of cash the company had during the period, supported by bank correspondence, term sheets and declined applications.

What do the notes, the interest and the payment history show?

Whether the parties acted as lender and borrower: notes signed, a maturity date set, interest charged and paid, security taken. A ledger with accruals and no payments points toward equity.

In AutoStyle the agreements carried a fixed rate and fixed payments, "indicating that the transaction was originally intended to be debt not equity," and the court held that "the deferral of interest payments does not by itself mean that the parties converted a debt transaction to equity." CIT had "a perfected first-priority security interest in all of AutoStyle's assets," so the security factor favored a loan. Repayment depended on the success of AutoStyle's business, which the court said weighed "only slightly in favor of equity," and the liens "obviated any need for a sinking fund." The court concluded that "the other eight factors all weigh toward debt to a greater or lesser extent" and affirmed the judgment for the insiders.

Live Primary went the other way. The member "indirectly made over sixty Disbursements through Waterbridge, without issuance of a single promissory note." The operating agreement set interest at one percent per year, compounded annually, and provided that the loan would "mature and be payable only upon a Liquidity Event" or the company's first underwritten public offering, so it had no fixed maturity date. Of the $6,354,900 stated in the proof of claim, $6,131,148 was principal and $223,752 accrued interest. The court recharacterized that amount as equity.

In Insight Terminal, Cecelia Financial Management had advanced about $5.7 million by 2019 through a series of promissory notes. The fourth amended note carried 6% interest and was due on demand or three years after its date, and "Insight never made a payment to Cecelia on any of these notes." Cecelia filed a proof of claim for over $6 million.

The accountant builds the payment history from bank statements and the general ledger. The notes record what was promised. The statements record each advance, each interest payment and each repayment by date and amount, and the ledger records how the company booked them: as loans payable, as accrued interest, or as contributed capital.

Which records does the forensic accountant need?

The loan documents and company agreements, the general ledger with the accounts for the advances, bank statements for every advance and repayment, financial statements for each funding date, and correspondence with outside lenders.

The accountant asks for the following documents for the whole period of the advances.

  • Promissory notes, loan agreements, amendments, participation agreements and guaranties.
  • Articles, operating or shareholder agreements and the resolutions that approved the funding.
  • The general ledger, with the accounts where advances, accrued interest and repayments were booked.
  • Bank statements of the company and of the insider for each date money moved.
  • Balance sheets and income statements, monthly if they exist.
  • Budgets, business plans and projections that state how much money the business needed.
  • Term sheets, loan applications and refusals from banks and other outside lenders.

Tracing a single repayment

Fitness Holdings turned on one transfer: $11,995,500 of refinancing proceeds paid to the sole shareholder. Tracing it means tying the bank's disbursement to the shareholder's account and to the notes it retired, and then matching those notes against the company's books for the years in which they were issued.

In Live Primary the interest rate, the maturity trigger and the $1,000 of starting capital all came from the operating agreement, which is why the company agreements sit on the list next to the bank records.

What happens to a recharacterized claim and to payments already made?

The claim is treated as equity and is paid only after creditors. Repayments of the supposed loan made before the filing can be pursued as transfers for less than reasonably equivalent value, as in Fitness Holdings.

In Province Grande the debtor had borrowed $6,465,000 from Paragon Commercial Bank and defaulted in 2010. Under a settlement that the debtor's principals negotiated, Paragon sold the loan to PEM Entities LLC for $1,242,000. PEM's three members contributed $300,000, and about $900,000 "was funded by the pledge of security owned by Debtor." The debtor filed in March 2013 and listed PEM's claim at $7,000,000. The bankruptcy court recharacterized the $300,000 portion as an equity investment in the debtor, and the Fourth Circuit affirmed in a per curiam opinion on August 12, 2016.

In Fitness Holdings the remedy sought was recovery of money already paid. If the notes were equity, the $11,995,500 payment did not satisfy a right to payment under state law, and the creditors' committee could pursue it as a constructively fraudulent transfer. The Ninth Circuit sent that claim back to the bankruptcy court.

If the advance survives as debt, the objecting party can still ask for equitable subordination under section 510(c), which keeps the claim but moves all or part of it below other claims for distribution. AutoStyle decided the two requests separately and wrote, on subordination: "Undercapitalization alone is insufficient to justify the subordination of insider claims, however."

What does IAE do in a recharacterization dispute?

A forensic accountant from the IAE registry writes an expert report on the questions agreed with the client, working from the ledgers, bank statements and loan documents in the record. Delivery takes up to 5 business days.

IAE's forensic accountants work on damages, solvency on the date of a transfer and tracing of funds in commercial, bankruptcy and partnership disputes. The expert follows funds from one account into the next through bank statements and ledgers. In a recharacterization dispute the questions cover the company's capitalization on each funding date, the payment history of each note, the source of repayments and the path of the money, and IAE frames them from the ledgers, tax returns and bank statements in the record and confirms them before work starts.

The client sends the materials and describes the task, and the secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. The signed PDF is issued in up to 5 business days after the format and cost are confirmed, and a 48-hour rush is available for cases with tight deadlines.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry and can be verified by Member ID or QR code. The specialist confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome of the case. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy; legal questions are for the client's attorney. A report is evidence that the court weighs with the rest of the record, and neither IAE nor the accountant guarantees the outcome.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert examinations

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member