Expert report review

Defect after the warranty expired: is there still a claim, and what must the expert prove about when it arose?

A defect that first shows up after the warranty period has ended is usually outside the express warranty, even if the cause was there from the start. In Clemens v. DaimlerChrysler (9th Cir. 2008), a head gasket that failed after the 3-year, 36,000-mile warranty gave no express warranty claim. What remains depends on the implied warranty, the limitations period in UCC 2-725 and the evidence of when the defect arose and was discovered.

A torn warranty booklet lies beside a cracked metal part on a warm workbench

Does an express warranty cover a defect that appears after it expires?

Generally no. In Clemens v. DaimlerChrysler the Ninth Circuit applied the rule that an express warranty does not cover repairs made after the applicable time or mileage periods have elapsed.

Clemens v. DaimlerChrysler Corp., No. 06-56410, was decided by the Ninth Circuit on June 19, 2008, in an opinion by Judge Canby for a panel of Circuit Judges Canby and Bybee and District Judge Roger L. Hunt. The court applied California law. On July 24, 2008 the panel amended the opinion, revising two sentences of its section on the implied warranty.

The court took the rule from the California Court of Appeal's decision in Daugherty v. American Honda Motor Co., which in turn quoted the Second Circuit's decision in Abraham v. Volkswagen of America. In the words Clemens quotes from Daugherty: "The general rule is that an express warranty does not cover repairs made after the applicable time or mileage periods have elapsed."

The court answered the argument that the defect was there from the start with this sentence: "Every manufactured item is defective at the time of sale in the sense that it will not last forever." Of the car in the case it wrote: "The product has performed as expressly warranted." What counted was that the part worked through the period the warranty named.

What happened in Clemens v. DaimlerChrysler?

The buyer of a 1998 Dodge Neon with a 3-year, 36,000-mile warranty noticed an oil leak at about 50,000 miles and replaced the head gasket himself. The Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal of his warranty claims.

Clemens bought the car new. Its warranty ran for 36 months or 36,000 miles. He noticed an oil leak at about 50,000 miles, and in September 2002 he replaced the head gasket himself for $70. The court described him as an end consumer who bought from a retailer rather than from the manufacturer, and that point later decided his implied warranty claim.

The court wrote: "The head gasket functioned throughout the 36,000 miles or three years for which it was warranted." And: "The repairs in this case were made after the warranty period expired." It concluded: "Therefore, we affirm the dismissal of the express warranty claims."

The court reached the same result for the warranty claims under the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, which depend on the state law warranty: "Dismissal was therefore appropriate as to both claims under state law and the Magnuson-Moss Act." The opinion ends with one word: "AFFIRMED."

Does it matter that the defect existed at the time of sale?

Not for the express warranty under Clemens. The court treated every product as defective in the sense that it will not last forever, so proof that the cause was present at sale does not extend the warranty term.

Buyers in these cases often argue that the defect was latent: present in the product from the factory and only revealed later. Clemens answered that argument for the express warranty with the sentence quoted above. In the court's analysis the decisive fact was the date of failure and repair, not the date the cause came into being: the gasket worked for the 36,000 miles or three years it was warranted, and the repair came after.

That makes the expert's dating of the defect matter for other claims rather than for the express warranty. When the defect arose and when it could have been discovered bear on the implied warranty, where it is available, and on the limitations period under UCC 2-725.

For a reviewer, the first step is therefore to sort the opposing expert's opinions by the claim they serve. An opinion that the defect existed at delivery answers a different question from an opinion that the failure occurred within the warranty period, and the report should say which one it is answering.

What about the implied warranty?

It depends on state law and the parties. In Clemens the implied warranty claim failed because, under California law, a buyer who purchases from a retailer is not in vertical privity with the manufacturer.

The Ninth Circuit stated the California rule, in the wording of the amended opinion: "a plaintiff asserting breach of warranty claims must stand in vertical contractual privity with the defendant." It continued: "Thus, an end consumer such as Clemens who buys from a retailer is not in privity with a manufacturer."

The court then stated the consequence for the case: "A lack of vertical privity requires the dismissal of Clemens's implied warranty claims." Under California law as Clemens applied it, the claim against the manufacturer failed on privity before the condition of the gasket at delivery could matter, so evidence about when the defect arose did not reach that question.

Privity rules differ between states and between consumer and commercial sales, so the expert's work does not decide whether an implied warranty claim exists. Where it does exist, the expert's evidence on the condition of the goods at delivery becomes central.

When does the four-year limitations period under UCC 2-725 start?

When the breach occurs, which for a warranty is at tender of delivery, regardless of the buyer's knowledge. The exception is a warranty that explicitly extends to future performance, where the period runs from discovery.

UCC 2-725(1) provides: "An action for breach of any contract for sale must be commenced within four years after the cause of action has accrued. By the original agreement the parties may reduce the period of limitation to not less than one year but may not extend it."

Section 2-725(2) sets the start: "A cause of action accrues when the breach occurs, regardless of the aggrieved party's lack of knowledge of the breach. A breach of warranty occurs when tender of delivery is made, except that where a warranty explicitly extends to future performance of the goods and discovery of the breach must await the time of such performance the cause of action accrues when the breach is or should have been discovered."

The rule makes two dates important. The date of tender starts the period for most warranties. For a warranty that explicitly extends to future performance, the date on which the breach was or should have been discovered starts it, and the expert's account of when symptoms appeared becomes evidence on that date.

How does the expert help fix the date of discovery?

By tying the symptoms to dates and mileage or hours of use: when the first signs of the defect would have appeared, whether a reasonable user would have noticed them, and what the records show.

In Clemens the record contained the buyer's own dates: an oil leak at about 50,000 miles and a repair in September 2002. Records of that kind, together with service invoices and inspection reports, give the expert a timeline against which to place the physical evidence.

The expert then explains how the defect progresses: what the first signs are, how long they take to become noticeable, and whether the condition of the part fits the timeline the party describes. Where the timeline and the physical evidence disagree, the report says so and explains which is more reliable and why.

Rule 26(a)(2)(B) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure requires the report to state "the facts or data considered by the witness in forming" the opinions, so the timeline and the documents behind each date belong in the report itself. A date the expert took from a party's account should be marked as such.

What does a review of the opposing defect report check in a post-warranty case?

The warranty terms and dates, the claim each opinion serves, the timeline of use and symptoms, the physical evidence of when the defect arose, and whether the method can date the defect at all.

The review starts with the documents: the warranty, its time and mileage limits, the date of delivery, the date the defect was reported and the date of any repair. Each opinion in the opposing report is then marked with the claim it supports: express warranty, implied warranty, limitations or damages.

The second step tests the dating. A conclusion that the defect existed at delivery needs a method that can tell an original defect from wear, misuse or a later repair, and the report should show that method. A conclusion that the failure occurred within the warranty period needs evidence tied to dates or mileage.

Rule 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence requires the proponent to show that the testimony rests on sufficient facts or data and that the method is reliably applied. A dating opinion built on the age of the product alone, without inspection data, is the kind of conclusion the review lists as unsupported.

What does IAE do when the defect appeared after the warranty ended?

IAE prepares a review of the opposing expert's report or an expert report on the client's questions for warranty and supply disputes in US courts, in up to 5 business days.

The review page for goods and product defect reports describes the work for warranty and supply disputes: the review reads the other side's report against Rule 26(a)(2)(B) and Rule 702, lists the tests the expert did not run and the conclusions the data do not support, and checks the valuation under UCC 2-714(2).

The client sends the warranty, the purchase and delivery documents, service records, photographs, the part if it was kept, and the other side's report, and describes what to check. The secretariat confirms receipt the same day. Within one business day IAE confirms the format, the cost, the deadline and the specialist from its registry, and the client approves the candidate and the CV before work starts. Cases with tight deadlines have a 48-hour rush.

Every specialist is a member of the public IAE registry, verified by Member ID or QR code, and confirms in the document that he or she has no interest in the outcome. The court weighs a review together with the other evidence, and neither IAE nor the expert guarantees the outcome. IAE is not a law firm and does not advise on case strategy.

Sources

Read also

All articles

Expert report review

Ready to discuss your case?

Send the materials: the secretariat will confirm the format, cost, deadline and the specialist within one business day.

Expertise request

Received

Cost and timeline estimate

WorkReview of an opinion
TimelineUp to 5 business days
ExpertIAE registry member